The formation of the Alliance des États du Sahel (AES, English: Alliance of Sahel States) in West Africa has caused a large amount of confusion among communists and other self-described “anti-imperialists”. This is due to a common misunderstanding that when an oppressed nation rebels against one imperialist power while subordinating themselves to another, this is still anti-imperialist. In the case of the AES, this is the expulsion of French imperialism while welcoming Russian imperialism with open arms.
Background of French Imperialism in West Africa
French capitalists were one of the main beneficiaries of the carving up of Africa in the late 1800s, receiving much of West Africa. Following World War Two, the imperialist powers pursued a policy of “decolonisation” in order to prevent these nations’ liberation.1 French “decolonisation” was especially superficial. These nations were tied up into a net of different cultural, political-military, and economic agreements with French imperialism.
Up to the modern day, France has retained considerable power over these nations. Economically, this is best seen in the continued use of the Central and Western CFA currency whose founding principle is French domination. Agreements around the currencies require 50% of reserves to be held in the French Treasury and another 20% to be set aside for financial liabilities, leaving only 30% in the “independent” nations themselves.2
France also maintained a permanent military presence in its former African colonies. The French military have been deployed as many as 30 times from 1964-1995 in the region.3 In 2023, French imperialism had a military presence of 1000 soldiers in Chad, 1500 in Djibouti, 350 in Gabon, 950 in Ivory Coast, and 400 in Senegal.4 In the past few years, this military presence has been scaled back largely due to rebellions against French imperialism in the region.
Why West African Rebellions Have Failed to Achieve National Liberation
The continued extreme oppression of these nations has led to the masses in these nations rebelling against French imperialism many times. The most significant of these until the formation of the AES was Thomas Sankara’s 1983 coup. However, none of these rebellions have been able to expel imperialism and liberate the nation. This is because they have not been under proletarian leadership.
In the oppressed nations, imperialism has entered an alliance with the local reactionary ruling class (usually slave-holding or landlord). These alliances benefit the local reactionary class by preventing the development of capitalism allowing the old reactionary class to maintain its economic and political position. It also benefits the imperialist powers by preventing the development of a competitor and keeping the nation a source of cheap labour and resources. Because of this, the imperialists, the local reactionary classes, and the big bourgeoisie produced out of this alliance all have a vested interest in preventing and even undoing development in these nations.
While the big bourgeoisie is fully in bed with imperialism, the national bourgeoisie are too weak a class to consistently lead an anti-imperialist revolution to its end. Today, it is only the proletariat that can lead a national revolution against imperialism.
Because they have been bourgeois-led, these rebellions have always capitulated to imperialism by either cutting deals with the former colonial power or by subordinating themselves to another power. The former is best seen in Blaise Compaoré coup against the Sankara government and the latter is being seen today in the AES’ relations with Russian imperialism.
Both of these paths attempt to renegotiate the terms of national oppression instead of ending it. Imperialism will only be abolished in these nations when the workers unite into a communist party, overthrow imperialism, bureaucrat capitalism, and whatever rotten base it is built on.
To maintain their independence, they must industrialise themselves with a priority on developing their heavy industry without neglecting light industry and agriculture. This is the direct opposite method of industrialisation pursued by the states led by non-proletarian classes. These states pursue a capitalist approach to industrialisation focusing on commodity production, which is exemplified in their principal focus on light industry over heavy industry. This leaves these states’ economies dependent on the heavy industry – production of the means of production, of the imperialist countries.
Political-Economy of the AES
The era of French imperialism in the region may be on the decline with the anti-French military governments in Mali, Burkina Faso, and Niger who have since united into the AES. In each of these countries, the military has removed the previous governments in a struggle against French imperialism and its local lackeys. It is crucial for communists to recognise that the same states exist today that existed before the coups. Power has not changed hands between classes, only the factions in control have changed.
Despite the failure of Sankara’s government to establish socialism, his image is very deeply associated with socialism and anti-imperialism broadly. For this reason, these military governments have made frequent reference to Thomas Sankara to legitimise their now-Russian backed governments. Burkina Faso’s prime minister, Jean Emmanuel Ouédraogo, even spoke of the need to continue Sankara’s work and has described President Ibrahim Traoré as Sankara’s heir.5 This emphasis on Sankara’s legacy is also seen in the other AES countries, but to a much lesser degree.
The AES countries have nationalised some industry,6 put up a universal 0.5% tariff on nations outside the confederation,7 taken moves to weaken French imperialism, and fight Islamists in the North. Each of these actions should be supported by communists. However, while kicking out the French, these nations have brought in Russian imperialism to fill the void. Without overthrowing imperialism and liberating these nations, they have only transformed the way they are organised from a principally French semi-colony into a principally Russian semi-colony and from the comprador bourgeoisie to the bureaucrat bourgeoisie being the principal faction of the big bourgeoisie.8
The AES’ war with the Al-Qaeda affiliated Islamists has also revealed the reactionary character of these regimes. This war has increasingly taken on an ethnic character. The Islamists in the north of the country are based primarily among the Fulani which has led the AES to target the ethnic group as a whole in their war. This was seen in March 2025 when a government militia massacred upwards of 130 Fulani civilians.9 More recently in Mali, the military carried out at least 22 summary executions of Fulani civilians.10
There has been heavy Russian investment into the AES, particularly in the mining industry. In late 2024, Niger revoked French nuclear monopoly Orano’s permit to exploit a uranium mine leading to the company suspending operations altogether.11 Following Orano’s departure, Russian mining monopolies were invited to fill the gap. Also in late 2024, the Russian Yadran Group met with Malian president, General Assimi Goïta to invest in the production of gold refinery, a cotton processing plant, and establishment of a supply of oil from Mali.12 As a final example, Burkina Faso has just recently awarded a gold mining lease to Russian monopoly Nordgold.13
Russian imperialism has filled the gulf left by exiting French troops. Much of this was originally through the state-mercenary force – the Wagner Group, but is increasingly taken up by the Russian army directly through their Africa Corps.14 Beyond the immediate region of the AES, the Wagner Group has an official security pact with the Central African Republic, presence in Libya, and Russia has direct and indirect alliances with both sides of the Sudanese civil war.15 Ibrahim Traoré’s body guards at least as late as Autumn 2023 were also provided by the Wagner Group.16
In July 2024, Director of the Russian Foreign Ministry’s Department for Partnership with Africa, Tatiana Dovgalenko stated:
“Russia, for its part, assists both in strengthening counter-terrorism capabilities and improving the combat effectiveness of national armed forces by sending military specialists and equipment, training military and law enforcement personnel, as well as in the social and economic development of the countries of the region.17”
It is clear to anyone willing to look into the matter, that the AES is neither socialist, nor anti-imperialist. It is a confederation of semi-colonies that have traded one master for another. Despite all the attempts to link the AES to anti-imperialism and socialism by the governments, the juntas have also been clear that these have not been their primary goals. Instead, as Malian foreign minister Abdoulaye Diop has said, “our priority is the fight against terrorism in the three countries.”18
The AES and the Communist Movement of Canada
An anti-imperialist state is one that exists outside of and against the imperialist system. These are countries that are on the road to communism whether new democratic or socialist. Today, these states exist only in an elementary form in the base areas of countries like India.
In Canada, the idea of countries that are 1) anti-imperialist, but also 2) not on the road to communism has been spread by the revisionist “Communist Party of the Philippines” (CPPh)19 and in a less overt way by the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” [(N)CPC].20 These parties refuse to break with the revisionist baggage of “actually existing socialism”. Any country that is not building communism is still firmly in the camp of imperialism and to carry water for these often social-fascist regimes is support of imperialism.
The “CPPh”, “(N)CPC”, and many of the other defenders of “anti-imperialist” states, governments, or policies as a category confuse hegemony and imperialism. This error has been criticised by the Communist Workers Front (Organising Committee) in 2022 as follows:
“The first of these is principally anti-hegemonic. Today, this trend tends to focus on opposition to war carried out by US and NATO, but will take neutral to supportive positions regarding wars launched by other imperialist powers. This trend will support any movement that opposes US imperialism. It commonly points to other imperialist powers opposed to US hegemony and their semi-colonies and colonies as ‘anti-imperialist’. Examples of these countries will often include China, Russia, Belarus, Nicaragua, Cuba, DPRK, Venezuela, Bolivia, Syria, and Iran. They will also offer their full support to reactionary feudal movements opposed to US hegemony such as Hamas and Hezbollah despite the fact that these movements do not want to liberate their nation, but instead want to reinforce the feudal mode of production. This trend can even be found among many self-acclaimed Maoists who justify this deviation with reference to Deng’s three worlds theory which calls for the unity of the proletariat with the oppressed nations, weaker imperialist powers, and even the weaker superpowers when they exist against the largest superpower. In Russia’s war on Ukraine, this trend continues to see opposition to US hegemony as principal and gloss over the fact that Russia, an imperialist power, is invading a semi-colonial country. This trend is based on an inability to look at these situations concretely, instead bringing a ready-made solution to every situation as is the case with the invasion of Ukraine.21”
Communists should support the expulsion of French imperialism in the AES countries as this was the principal imperialist power in these nations. However, we cannot take an uncritically positive view of these countries and their leaders who hurried Russian imperialism in to take France’s place. Communists must support the masses of these nations in consolidating whatever gains remain from the expulsion of France by developing new democratic revolution.
1 The Communist Workers Front (Organising Committee) produced a document explaining the difference between decolonisation and national liberation: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/11/08/decolonisation-versus-national-liberation/
2 https://hir.harvard.edu/true-sovereignty-the-cfa-franc-and-french-influence-in-west-and-central-africa/
6 https://www.reuters.com/world/africa/burkina-faso-nationalise-more-industrial-mines-prime-minister-says-2025-04-29/
8 The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has published a summary of bureaucrat capitalism and these two factions of the big bourgeoisie in the oppressed nations. The comprador faction is associated with non-state monopoly capitalism while the bureaucrat faction is associated with state-monopoly capitalism https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/
10 https://apnews.com/article/mali-violence-civil-army-human-rights-fulani-2e5cfd5c1d25c1c595ffc139d1b269d9
11 https://www.themoscowtimes.com/2024/11/13/niger-invites-russian-firms-to-mine-uranium-other-resources-a86999
14 https://www.dw.com/en/russia-kremlin-wagner-group-influence-in-central-african-republic-sudan-mali/a-70599853
15 https://www.dw.com/en/russia-kremlin-wagner-group-influence-in-central-african-republic-sudan-mali/a-70599853
16 https://www.dw.com/en/russia-kremlin-wagner-group-influence-in-central-african-republic-sudan-mali/a-70599853
17 https://en.sputniknews.africa/20250220/russia-supports-aes-by-sending-military-specialists-equipment-foreign-ministry-says-1070734897.html
19 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/08/14/support-the-proletarian-line-in-the-armed-struggle-in-the-philippines-down-with-the-revisionist-leadership-of-the-communist-party-of-the-philippines/
20 “In a very small number of cases, exemplified by such countries as Cuba and North Korea, a given state may attempt to pursue an anti-imperialist policy and strive for real independence. These cases warrant special attention and analysis, since such countries may play a special role with regards to revolutionary movements throughout the world. All of them are, however, beholden to one or more imperialist powers in some regards and none are socialist in the way we and our tradition has ever meant.” https://kites-journal.org/2024/01/31/the-political-program-of-the-new-communist-party-of-canada/#sdfootnote3sym