The People's Hammer

Manitoba Wildfires: Climate Change and Class Relations – By Gordon C.

, , ,


There is no doubt that wildfires have been a persistent issue across Canada for the last three years. Certainly, climate change is the principal contributing factor towards the extreme dryness which transforms Canada’s cold climate boreal forests into tinderboxes ready to erupt at the first sign of heat, but reporting on the matter often ends there. Climate change is not some kind of looming force of the Earth itself which stirs up environmental problems sporadically and randomly. Climate change is the direct result of the largest producers in the world using unsustainable methods which directly cause environmental shifts that impact the regular, working people of the world. In my last article, I covered the droughts in Alberta which were directly related to the profit motivated practices of the Canadian agricultural monopolists who seek to drive out small farmers.1 To further demonstrate the shortsighted thinking of the bourgeoisie and to understand the development of this unyielding wildfire problem, let us look to the history of unsustainable farming practices and their largest consequence in North America: the Dust Bowl.

The Dust Bowl was a period of major drought, dust storms, and topsoil erosion in the prairies and the great plains region of the United States during the 1930s. Climatologists have analysed droughts of similar severity to those of the Dust Bowl, but so far never one that is also as far spanning geographically.2 Chance undoubtedly played a role in the severity and vastness of the Dust Bowl droughts, such as sea surface temperatures impacting atmospheric circulation, but factors such as this are far less direct than the human errors which amplified these unfortunate conditions.2

In 1936, The Great Plains Committee (a body established by the US government to investigate the droughts) created a report analysing the human-caused factors which directly contributed to the terrible agricultural conditions of the recent years.3 Below is a table summarising some of their key findings:

There are two key factors present across these findings which still apply to North American agriculture today: chasing cash crops causing crises of overproduction and disorganised small-scale farming.

The solutions proposed by the Committee encourage a path towards fascistic control of agriculture, no doubt a popular idea among US state-funded boards at the time due to Franklin D. Roosevelt’s presidency. Government control over industry is certainly appealing to the members of the bourgeoisie who have a direct path to government involvement, but for workers these “solutions” mean that the value they generate is now going right into the hands of the state which can more easily oppress, exploit, and control them from within their workplace. Calls for fascism are still common today when environmental issues are spiking. Take for example “The Nordic Resistance Movement” present in the Scandinavian nations. The group emerged in 2016 as a neo-Nazi environmentalist group which preys on people’s fear of climate change in hopes of securing a corporativist state.4 Their history reveals clearly that they have no interest in upholding any kind of policy that would combat climate change effectively as they operate entirely within reaction to the labour movement. Their origin is in the “White Aryan Resistance” and the subsequent “Swedish Resistance Movement,” a group responsible for the murder of a union member fighting for industrial unionism after he tipped off a newspaper about the involvement of one of his coworkers in a fascist terrorist organisation.5 How could a group whose goal is to eliminate any form of worker control over industry possibly care about the environmental practices which affect those workers? They are nothing more than fear mongering opportunists who seek to lie and manipulate as many frustrated, scared, and tired people as possible into supporting their destructive and entirely self-interested movement.

If fascism is not a suitable solution to these human-caused problems, then what is? We must analyse carefully what is required to correct overproduction and disorganisation. First: overproduction occurs in agriculture due to the chasing of cash crops, attempting to maximise profits of a given harvest growing only what is cheapest to produce and most valuable on the market. This flaw is caused by the market-based economy. Capitalism necessitates a degree of anarchy in determining production due to its decentralisation. Cash crops are never usually what is the most logical crop to grow to maintain the soil and thus, large amounts of fertilizers are a necessity, creating costs that otherwise would not be necessary if the goal was to grow whichever crop fed the most people and kept the soil healthy. The solution here is the transition from the capitalist market economy to the socialist needs based economy. Fascists would have people believe they can create this economy, but it is because they encourage people to ignore the political differences of the classes and hide their bourgeois positions so that the masses are fooled into believing they represent workers. This political aspect is principal over the economic aspect, as a bourgeois-controlled economy can only ever meet the needs of the exploiting class who secures their existence through stealing from the working masses. This is why the needs-based economy must be centrally-planned by a proletarian state which can suppress bourgeois political influences. A republic of workers seeks not individual gain, but collective abundance through and for the proletarian class. This leads directly to the solution for the second factor: organisation of farmers.

In China’s socialist period (1949-1976) the dictatorship of the proletariat allowed for democratic networks of workers and peasants to collaborate on a large scale. This was achieved through a gradual process of developing the implements and organisation of the peasantry so they could reach a level of industrialised agriculture efficient enough to meet the needs of these networks.6 This growth in production was possible for the agricultural workers of China through land reform and mutual aid.6 In Canada where we have industrialised farmers already, this process of collectivisation will be even easier because our implements are already efficient. Through the formation of co-ops, farmers’ unions, and a farmer-worker alliance, economic and political securement of the interests of the Canadian agricultural workers will be guaranteed. The monopolists will be choked out and their reckless profit driven decision making will be forced to cease, allowing for sustainable, needs based agriculture to flourish. This is the only means of correcting the environmental shifts we see today. It will never be within bourgeois interest to sacrifice personal profit for the well being of the masses.

Now that we understand the relationship of climate change and class relations, we must understand the here and now of what is affecting Canadians today. Wildfires impact agriculture through a number of hazards. The most obvious of these hazards are fires spreading towards farmland and razing land or crops, but secondary and tertiary elements from wildfires are typically what impacts the broadest number of farmers. Smoke not only poses a health risk for farmers and outdoor labourers (as well as their livestock) who are inhaling it as they work, it also blocks sunlight which can impact crop yield and contain harmful toxins depending on what has been caught in the fires. The impact of smoke can be observed in 2023 when the prairies experienced the most destructive wildfires on record.7 This drastically set back harvests, especially canola which flowered far behind schedule due to the obstruction of sunlight.8

The provincial government is urging Manitoban farmers to protect themselves as well as their livestock from smoke inhalation, but offering no assistance in this process.9 Maintaining good barn and field conditions, getting low-dust and dust-free feeds, regularly misting and avoiding strenuous work with livestock are all easy enough for the agricultural monopolists who employ hundreds of workers. For small farmers who may only have five people working their land it is inevitable that they will lose animals, suffer lower yields, and have to make very difficult decisions on where to cut their losses. This is without even mentioning evacuation protocol and how the wildfires could force many small producers out of farming entirely.

Small farmers across Canada currently have no true political representation and it is most clearly demonstrated by the Canadian government offering next to nothing for workers affected by the fires beyond advice. The electoral parties understand that the agricultural big bourgeoisie will be able to make it through this crisis with ease, and because the government only needs to meet their interests in order to maintain political power, there is no reason for them to come to the rescue of smaller producers. In fact, this would be against the monopolists interests because it would allow for competition to persist. As small as some of the farming operations may be in Canada, the bourgeoisie will not rest until they have every acre of fertile soil.

We cannot allow the bourgeoisie to continue to ravage our environment. Farmers of all provinces must organise to combat them. Farm hands and agricultural labourers must organise against their management. The urban and rural workers must band together to fight for their existence. Without agriculture or industry, the bourgeoisie would be defeated instantly. The workers of Canada are the only one’s capable of transforming our conditions.

1: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/18/albertan-agriculture-in-2025-by-gordon-c/

2: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4015056/

3: Great Plains Committee. The future of the Great Plains. Washington DC: Government Printer; 1936.

4: https://www.frihetskamp.no/information-in-english/

5: https://wwwc.aftonbladet-cdn.se/nyheter/0003/01/nazmord.html

6: https://archive.org/details/the-rise-of-chinese-peoples-communes

7: https://www.nesdis.noaa.gov/news/noaa-satellites-monitor-canadian-wildfires-and-smoke

8: https://www.producer.com/news/wildfire-smokes-crop-yield-impact-thought-to-be-minimal/

9: https://www.producer.com/news/wildfire-smoke-poses-health-risks-to-farmers-and-livestock/