Proletarian internationalism has been a foundational principle of Marxism since its creation, and it is something that so-called communists like to boast about putting into practice with every little protest, poster, or speech. This poses a simple yet important question, what is proletarian internationalism? In order for communists in Canada to properly conduct proletarian internationalism, we need to understand what it genuinely looks like in practice beyond a simple slogan, as it is unfortunately used oftentimes. Proletarian internationalism is even invoked while engaging in practices which represent the exact opposite of it, national chauvinism. The principal form of this in Canada’s communist movement is Bundism. In order to understand proletarian internationalism, we must also understand its opposite as well.
What Is Proletarian Internationalism?
The world is divided into hundreds of nations. Does this mean that the workers are also divided along national distinctions? This question has two aspects. Yes, in the sense that different nations have differing conditions and thus require a particular analysis of said conditions. No, in the sense that all proletarians are united by the common aspects of their class. Proletarians are defined by the selling of their labour power to the bourgeoisie and socialised production. This has a universal characteristic.
Which of these two are principal? The answer is clear, the universal nature of the class is principal. No matter where labour power is sold, and under what specific conditions, the contradiction which emerges between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie are the same everywhere. It is for this reason that Marxism is applicable to every place on Earth. Of course, Marxism requires application to the particular conditions of a given country (Guiding Thought, a concept expanded upon elsewhere)1 but the principles of Marxism remain universal across nations.
From this understanding, a necessity to forge international unity among workers across the world exists. This is proletarian internationalism. Communists who do not uphold proletarian internationalism are not communists, plain and simple. The purpose of conducting revolution in any given country is done with the eventual goal of liberating the entire working class and advancing towards communism. This is the proper understanding of international revolution, summarized by the CPC(RF) in their writing on World People’s War.2
Some then may ask the question, what is the responsibility of communists who are living or working abroad? The answer is quite simple, integrate with the workers and communists of the country you find yourself in. If a Canadian worker moves to Germany, should they attempt to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada from Berlin? Of course not! If this hypothetical Canadian is going to be living in Germany for a long period of time, that time is best spent learning and struggling with German workers to reconstitute the Communist Party of Germany. The best way for this Canadian to aid the struggles of Canadian workers is to help make revolution wherever they find themselves. The victory of the proletariat in one country is a victory for the proletariat in every country. Unfortunately, this seemingly simple idea is something that is either forgotten or flat-out ignored.
What Does Proletarian Internationalism Look Like In Practice?
With a proper understanding of proletarian internationalism out of the way, we now must ask ourselves another question. How do we put proletarian internationalism into practice? An activity can be understood as genuine proletarian internationalism if that activity passes one simple criteria; that it advances the cause of the international proletariat. Putting up some graffiti on a wall or delivering a speech which no one is listening to are obviously not proletarian internationalism. Organising a strike in a munitions factory which supplies foreign imperialism obviously is proletarian internationalism.
Simple forms of proletarian internationalism like the aforementioned munitions strike are a good start, but these should all be in service of the principal form of proletarian internationalism. The reconstitution of the Communist International (CI). Just as the proletariat of any nation have their communist party, so too does the international proletariat. Without this vital weapon, the international proletariat will be unable to forge the necessary networks for spreading revolution from one country to the entire world. Ever since the abolishment of the CI in the 1940s, there has been a great difficulty in the ICM (particularly in the realm of two-line struggle between parties).
One of the greatest feats of the CI was the expansion of the communist movement into countries which it either did not exist or existed in an extremely limited capacity. This is not to say that it did not have its flaws, it most certainly did. For example, the CI opted to send thousands of lumber workers from Canada to the Soviet Union, nearly killing communist presence in the industry at the time.3 These errors represent a failure to implement proper proletarian internationalism. We must always strive to be good proletarian internationalists at all times.
What is Bundism?
The term Bundism originates from the Jewish Bund in the Russian communist movement in the late 1800s and early 1900s. The Jewish Bund was a fraction within the Russian Social-Democratic Labour Party (Precursor to the Bolshevik Party) which was based solely on the Jewish proletariat in Russia. On the Bund, Lenin had the following to say: “We thus arrive at the conclusion that neither the logical, nor the historical, nor yet the nationalist arguments of the Bund will stand criticism. The period of disunity, which aggravated waverings among the Russian Social-Democrats and the isolation of the various organisations, had the same effect, to an even more marked degree, in the case of the Bundists. Instead of proclaiming war on this historically evolved isolation (further increased by the general disunity), they elevated it to a principle”.4 Here, Lenin is saying that the proper path for national minorities in the communist movement is to integrate with the rest of the proletariat of the nation. This is in accordance with proletarian internationalism. For the sake of clarity, the term Bundism is used in this article to mean generally the separation of a national minority from the rest of the communist movement in a given country rather than this one historical example.
Bundism is blatantly opposed to proletarian internationalism. It sees the interests of this or that national minority as being more important than the liberation of the proletariat through socialist revolution. Marxists understand fundamentally that proletarians are proletarians no matter where you find them. Canadian proletarians have the same fundamental interests as any other proletarian, inside or outside of Canada. Bundists reject this fundamental aspect of Marxism. They will have you believe that the interests of Canadian workers and migrant workers are in some way different. How exactly they go about arguing this will differ depending on the national minority the Bundist organisation in question represents.
What makes Bundism a particularly parasitic form of national chauvinism is the fact that it often uses of guise of proletarian internationalism to sneak in its reactionary rhetoric. When criticizing a Bundist, one may be met with accusations that they themselves are being reactionary. You will hear arguments like “You think that this national group shouldn’t have an organisation which represents them?” or “You must only care about Canadians and not migrants.” These arguments try to paint criticism as racism or xenophobia, they try to discredit the person rather than seriously engage in struggle over the correct political line. This is a deeply anti-Marxist method. At the end of the day, the only true way for all workers in Canada, whether they were born here or not, to conquer state power is to unify under one party regardless of nationality.
Bundism in Canada Historically
In the early 1900s, many migrant groups in Canada formed their own organisations which fell within the orbits of various socialist and communist organisations. The most prominent of such groups were the Ukrainian Labour-Farmer Temple Association (ULFTA),5 the United Jewish People’s Order (UJPO),6 and various Finnish based organisations. These organisations existed well into the life of the Communist Party of Canada. The continued existence of said organisations represents a failure of the Communist Party of Canada to create a wholly unified party. This Bundism was one of the many factors which led to the emergence of the right-opportunist line under Tim Buck, which ultimately killed the party. This is only a superficial analysis, but is mentioned for the sake of portraying that this issue is not a new one in Canada. It in fact has a long history.
Bundism in Canada Now
In a period of time where the principle task of communists is to unite the vanguard of the proletariat to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada, Bundism poses a direct challenge to said task. The principal form of Bundism in Canada comes from the various Filipino National Democratic organisations. These organisations (such as Anakbayan, Migrante, Canada-Philippine Solidarity Organization, etc.) exist in most major Canadian cities and siphon off the Filipino proletariat from the rest of the class. The population of Filipinos in Canada is about 1 million in a country of about 40 million.7 This represents 2.5% of the population of the country. This is a rather sizable portion of the population to be secluded in the sphere of communist organisation. Curiously, many of these organisations are open to non-Filipino membership. One may think that this disqualifies them from the categorization of Bundism, and they would be wrong. The activities of these organisations are dedicated almost exclusively to support of the National Democratic movement back home or the struggles of Filipinos in Canada, so even non-Filipinos are participants in Filipino Bundism.
At the Toronto May Day Rally, and other events in the city such as International Working Women’s Day (IWWD), various other organisations such as the Worker Communist Party of Kurdistan (WCPK) and the Worker Communist Party of Iran (WCPI) have split off their respective national minorities from the Canadian proletariat. It seems as though these groups have completely removed themselves from participation in the Labour May Day Committee as well, opting instead to host their own May Day event. Why they have chosen to do this is unclear. Supporters of People’s Hammer spoke with members of the WCPK at an IWWD event in the city, only to be told that they were only interested in Kurds and the at-the-time struggle of the PKK (which has since been liquidated). How exactly Kurdish Canadians were supposed to aid the armed struggle in Syria was not explained to the supporters.
This brief analysis only covers the main perpetrators of Bundism in Canada generally and Toronto in particular. There are many other minor groups in the country which also engage in the behaviour described above. One thing which must be reiterated on this subject is that the fight against Bundism must not be in service of Canadian national chauvanism. National minorities in Canada certainly face quantitatively harsher conditions in the realm of production, and this is something which communists need to take seriously. Increased exploitation among one strand of the proletariat opens the door for the bourgeoisie to expand this heightened exploitation to the rest of the class. This is precisely why Bundism is so dangerous. If the conditions of only one national minority are improved, they are more likely to be eroded again due to other proletarians not being included in the gains of the Bundists. All proletarians in Canada must unite firmly to counter exploitation, otherwise any gain of the class can be more easily stripped away by the class enemy.
Conclusion
Bundism is one of the many factors which contribute to the disunity of the Canadian proletariat, and in particular its vanguard. This tendency needs to be exposed, criticized, and struggled against whenever and wherever it exists. Canada is a country which is host to workers from all around the world. From Mexico to India, from Jamaica to The Philippines. If we are all split among hundreds of nationally based organisations, we will never succeed in creating socialist revolution. The only way to win is to unite all workers in Canada from all walks of life in the efforts to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada. Without our party, we have nothing!
Citations
3. Finnish-Americans in War and Peace. © Rainer Langstedt. St. Magnus Press 2015.
4. https://www.marxists.org/archive/lenin/works/1903/oct/22a.htm
5. https://archive.org/details/canadian-society-for-ukrainian-labour-research
6. https://archive.org/details/canadian-society-for-ukrainian-labour-research