The People's Hammer

Interview with a Vancouver Ironworker – by Daniel H.

, ,


The following interview was conducted with a Vancouver worker who was until recently employed as an ironworker.

Q: Can you describe what an ironworker does?

A: Ironworking is a diverse construction trade that generally involves the placement and installation of structural steel or reinforcing bars in a concrete foundation. It is a very physically demanding trade, and often involves working with cranes (rigging, signaling, etc.), working at heights, and operating work equipment (boom lifts, telehandlers, forklifts, etc.)

Q: What are the wage and conditions like in comparison to other construction workers?

A: Ironworkers tend to have higher wages than other construction workers, though reinforcing ironworkers don’t get paid as much as structural ironworkers or ironworker welders (about 12% difference)

Q: Have you found that safety has been a major concern in ironwork as it is in other construction work?

A: It depends on the site that you’re at considering that ironwork can be both a commercial and an industrial trade. As far as industrial goes, workers are fairly frequently obligated to wear more than enough safety gear when it comes to safety glasses, high-viz, hardhats, respirators – everything you need to get the job done safely. However they do use that as a means to put the cause of any incident on the worker, but that’s a different issue.

When it comes to commercial, it depends from site to site and what company you’re with. Some of them in my experience do provide you with safety glasses, do require you to wear them. However, the general culture/attitude of the workers that you’re with tend to be a lot more lax when it comes to that side of things. I wouldn’t say that it’s an extremely pervasive issue.

There was a major crane incident that occurred I believe in 2021 in Kelowna and three ironworkers lost their lives. I’m not sure about other tradespeople, but that’s something that is currently being investigated as far as I’m aware.1

Q: Some construction sites that we have spoken to people at have mentioned heat being a big issue. Do you find that to be a thing in ironwork? Too cold is probably not that big in BC, but do people ever get heat exhaustion?

A: Absolutely, that is very much an issue that is once again from my experience something where good companies that I have worked for have been fairly good about it. Whether that’s stocking lots of water coolers in easy to access locations or providing some gear that everyone is free to take in the industrial site. Such as visors that you put over your hardhat that provide a decent amont of shade around you and that sort of thing.

I think its more so an issue when it comes to the industrial side of thing when it comes to workers learning to actually take a step back even if they don’t realise that they are in need of water or the need to cool down. A lot of them will just keep on working because that’s the “ironworking way” as it were.

Its not something that I can see being super strictly enforced universally. However, I’m sure there will be cases where certain companies will not necessarily force, but heavily encourage working through the heat.

Q: Is trade school required? Are the costs covered by unions or the company?

A: Ironworking is a Red Seal trade, and as such, schooling is required, however this is specific to the union. From my understanding, ironworkers who work non-union are not required to attend school, though it’s possible some private companies would want a Red Seal ironworker. Regarding the union, they don’t cover any training costs specifically, however, they do set aside a portion of a member’s wages into a training fund that is then withdrawn and used when that member attends schooling.

Q: Is that portion a part of your monthly dues, or is that an additional deduction on top?

A: It’s an additional deduction. It’s nothing to do with monthly dues as far as I’m aware. It’s deductions off of your paycheque whether that’s weekly or biweekly. A portion of your hourly wages will go towards your training fund. As it fills up to a certain amount, that training fund will be withdrawn towards your tuition. After you have successfully completed all years of your training – at BCIT in our case, any funds that are left over will be sent to you via cheque for the remainder.

Q: Is most ironwork in BC union? What unions are involved?

A: From my understanding, the majority of ironwork in BC is non-union. The local 97 ironworkers union is the BC branch of the International.2

Q: In your time in the union, did you ever hear about efforts by the union to change this situation? Did they carry out union campaigns at non-union sites that members were aware of?

A: I never heard about overt campaigns to win over actual non-union workers. It was only hearsay from workers who used to be non-union who tried to convince their old non-union coworkers to come over.

As far as the union itself, the most that they would do in regards to that was to get companies that were union to successfully bid on jobs and get certain jobs ahead of non-union companies.

That’s it as far as I am aware of.

Q: What is the internal life of the union like? Is it combative or does it collaborate with the boss? Is it democratic? Do you have elected stewards?

A: The union has a contradictory culture of work. They try to emphasize values of the benefits that the union provides to workers, and there’s a general motivation between members to be knowledgeable about the current collective bargaining agreement to ensure that you aren’t getting taken advantage of. However, the union culture also emphasizes quality work for the explicit purpose of being good for employers. The leadership seems more concerned with ensuring the reputation of union ironworkers rather than improving or addressing concerns of the workers. It also doesn’t tend to be democratic, with certain positions in the leadership being appointed rather than elected. This can also extend to shopstewards depending on the job. At my previous employment on a large industrial site, the stewards were always appointed by union leadership, with confusion among workers as to why they weren’t being consulted. I was informed that if you were interested in the position, you would be best off approaching the union president. Though on smaller jobs, a shop steward does tend to be elected.

Q: Why do you think the union is more concerned with protecting the reputation of union ironwork instead of fighting for better conditions of those union workers?

A: I would hazard that it has to do with wanting more companies to contract union workers over non-union workers as a means of control as well as pride over the industry in our province. At the end of the day, improving the reputation of the union is going to make more waves toward achieving that goal as opposed to improving the working conditions as far as the union is concerned. I also think that it is a very long-set attitude in the union that conditions aren’t necessarily as important to fight for as it is to just do your job the best that you can and be the best worker that you can be. That is what is pushed above all else.3

Q: Do you have any idea how much autonomy the Canadian locals of the union have from the International union in terms of politics or in terms of how much of the dues are kept at home compared to what is sent to the States?

A: Unfortunately, that’s not information that I’m aware of. There were some times at union meetings I attended when a member from the International in the United States did come to deliver a few words. Unfortunately, I can’t recall what those words were.

Ironworking is a very diverse trade, we have welders, we have rebar workers, we have structural steelworkers, and the International was seeking to generalise the trade even more so and that was something the members at that meeting were very unhappy with. It didn’t matter in what way this official attempted to word it, he wasn’t winning over any people.

Q: How do you think we can go about making the ironworkers union more democratic?

A: From within, I would say voice your concerns with other members that you’re close with or that you work with. As well, voice your concerns whenever there’s a monthly meeting because as it stands it was not a practice that seemed to be changing anytime soon. I don’t know how long it was occurring by the time I noticed that it was occurring – where they were being appointed by the union. When they were appointed everyone would be surprised, like “oh, I guess that guy’s the shop steward now. Okay, sure” Only the people that seemed to show interest in wanting to apply for that position seemed disgruntled by it. Its something the members themselves have to make more noise about to see that demand met. It doesn’t seem like enough members are aware of the problem to begin with.

Q: I was doing some research for this interview beforehand and I couldn’t find many recent instances of ironworkers striking in BC. When it is time for contract negotiations, what attitude did the union bureaucracy take towards strikes?

A: In April 2023, the old collective agreement lapsed and that’s when the negotiations were occurring. At the time, the job I was on was an industrial job with a special memorandum of understanding which entailed that we as workers were not permitted to strike – there was a no-strike clause. When it seemed that negotiations weren’t going forward, I believe a strike was almost started in Vancouver, but that never came to pass. The general sort of attitude seemed to be pretty mixed. Everyone was certainly upset at the job I was on that we weren’t able to strike, but it was pretty mixed. Some workers had the attitude of “I’m glad that we’re not affected” and some were upset that they couldn’t take part. It was pretty mixed, but both sides seemed to want the ability to do so.

Q: Following from what you said about how even if not all workers wanted to strike, they all wanted the right to strike, what would you say are some of the advanced and backward ideas that are common in ironwork?

A: It seems to be the more class-conscious ideas seem to be limited to the rights that we as workers have on the job. It doesn’t tend to get much larger than that because there is a very heavy conservative culture in the ironworkers. I know very many of them that would easily lean towards right-wing ideas while still being pro-working conditions in the job. Which is something that is obviously hypocritical, but it is something that I noticed most pervasively.

Q: What would you say are some of the most pressing concerns ironworkers tend to voice? What are their main demands?

A: A very common issue that gets brought up is the requirement on industrial jobs to take drug tests before, and potentially during, employment. This is contentious specifically because companies have the ability to administer these tests upon any variety of safety incident, regardless of the behaviour of the worker. Testing positive for cannabis on a drug test is reason for an instant firing, despite the fact that cannabis can stay in your system for 28 days after use. This inevitably leads to workers who smoke recreationally on weekends to not report injuries out of fear of losing their job. There supposedly is a slow push by unions to address this issue, though aside from general discontent among the workers, there doesn’t seem to be a large movement with this issue at the forefront.

Q: What do you think communists and workers in the construction industry could do to better organise the workers and gain better conditions?

A: They can bring up relevant concerns/issues at their job to coworkers or other union members to form a strong front against poor conditions. If there’s a material problem that’s affecting the morale of the workforce due to an abusive employer or a corrupt union leadership, a communist or any potential organizer should do their best to be supportive and approachable, while also being ready to agitate and educate when the time is right.

Q: Is there anything else you want to add?

A: I would say that while my time in the union was short, there’s a lot of ways in which the labour aristocracy within have sort of muddied what being a part of a union should be about. There’s definitely a small potential within the union to adopt more progressive ideas. It just needs to be more thoroughly given to union members by more union leaders within said union. More communication of those ideas and less focus on just being good workers. Because if that continues to be the case I can only see it going more down hill.

1 Information on the Kelowna crane failure can be found here: https://www.worksafebc.com/en/about-us/news-events/news-releases/2023/May/update-on-kelowna-crane-collapse-investigations-by-kelowna-rcmp-and-worksafebc

2 The international in question is the International Association of Bridge, Structural, Ornamental, and Reinforcing Ironworkers. It is affiliated to the American Federation of Labour – Congress of Industrial Organisations in the USA and the Canadian Labour Congress in Canada

3 A similar attitude has been reported in Ivan D.’s recent article on the Labourers International Union of North America: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/28/liuna-whose-side-are-you-on-by-ivan-d/

Thumbnail Image – Mario Geo—Toronto Star/Getty Images