In 1945, workers unionized under the United Auto Workers led a strike at a Windsor Ford factory. This strike saw Windsor residents forming a car blockade around the factory, which forced Ford to submit to arbitration. The court ruling that resulted from this strike ended up being called the “Rand Formula” after the judge who oversaw the case. The “Formula” granted unions their demand for automatic union dues to be deducted through the employer. This was seen as a major win to the unions since they didn’t need to solicit dues directly as most people paid and few others did not. However, this ruling also granted the demands of Ford which made it such that it would be illegal for unions to strike between agreements.
I will reference the article titled Rand Cuffed by Aalya Ahmad on OurTimes1 and recommend reading it for more background. The article lays out how the unionization rate has been declining in Canada and notes several strikes where lockouts and back-to-work legislation was used to put down strikes. Since this article was published, Port of Montreal workers were sent back to work in 2021,2 the Canada National Railway (CN) and Canadian Pacific Kansas City (CPKC) workers under Teamsters were sent back to work in 2024.3 The postal workers under CUPW were sent back to work in December of 2024 with a year extension on their expired contract.4 DHL workers unionized under Unifor are currently experiencing a lockout after refusing to accept a loss in pay and job security.5 Clearly, this is increasing in frequency to put down any labour action. The point of this article is to show the further impacts of the Rand Formula and provide a few case examples of the complicity of those employed by unions in the perpetuation of the disorganization of workers.
The Rand Formula killed union militancy and the union bureaucrats buried it. Ahmad notes in her article that “top-down strikes” have never gotten the goods for union members. By limiting unions to work stoppages and only after their contracts have expired, they effectively are not prepared to mobilize their membership.
This leads to a point of discussing how well organized union membership is in general. Limiting themselves to work only when the contract expires, unions have disconnected themselves from their membership’s concerns. In doing so, they operate outside of the workers’ daily lives. Many unions pride themselves for not going to strike. UFCW which organized Save-on-Foods workers across BC and the Yukon has in its contract that the two regions can never go on strike at the same time.6 Their agreement also says that a new store cannot go on strike within ten years of opening up even if it’s between contracts.7 Rather than having the possibility of waging such an intense strike, UFCW now tells its union membership that they’re limited in what they can do because its harder to take something out of the contract once it’s in there.
Another example comes from when I was a member of CUPE while on contract work for a public institution and the union held it’s annual general meeting. At the meeting, the union told it’s members to express their concerns that they want addressed in the next round of bargaining since the last contract was expiring. They then followed up by saying they can address anything but wages because they will accept whatever raises the government provides all public institutions provincially. The local union president said the union cannot go up against the government in asking for more because of all the “backlog” of other institutions also negotiating at the same time. Once again, you would think that the union that has most of the public sector workers unionized under them would be more willing to leverage the weight of its membership to negotiate against government. However, due to the lack of active work keeping its membership engaged outside of negotiations the union could not even start to imagine the work required to do so and would rather take the road of least resistance in negotiations. The outcome becomes that the union bureaucrats who are paid by dues have no regard for the rank-and-file workers who are increasingly being squeezed by the union’s acceptance of lower wages and worse working conditions.
The next point that Ahmad makes is the class difference between representatives and rank and file. Many representatives are not hired from the rank and file, and are instead university graduates. Others may have started as rank and file workers who rose up the ranks but have not worked on the shop floor and have occupied a bureaucratic position long enough that their class position has changed. One way this manifests is with the prevalent support of union bureaucrats to the NDP despite the NDP not doing anything for the workers. Even though the NDP was in a minority coalition while the past few back to work orders happened, the NDP maintained its coalition with the Liberals and did not put forward any real opposition to the strikes being put down. Yet, many union bureaucrats canvas for the NDP, urge its membership to vote for the NDP, and officially endorse the NDP.
Another way the class difference manifests itself is how union bureaucrats take action. If we take Ahmad’s claim to be true that historically top down strikes have not been as effective as wild cat strikes, job action on the shop floor, and member driven strikes, we can see how debilitating the labour bureauracy has been. That is, labour bureaucrats always prefer to follow the legal path which maintains the laws laid down by the capitalist class, and often will slow down or remove elements of dissent among rank and file. Labour bureaucrats are always the first to advocate for the workers to follow the law and when back to work legislation occurs, the bureaucrats try to convince their membership that it cannot be counted as a loss because they will appeal the decision in court. Any worker who has been cheated out of their hours or pay by their employer will know how ridiculous it is to try and win back anything in court when you stand against the employer with endless money for appeals and lawyers. The legal system is the way of the capitalist class. Many union bureaucrats will tell you to be a “perfect little worker” during strikes and when forming a union so that you are in line to the legal expectations, even as you are bombarded by threats from your employer for exercising your membership in a union. Practically, the legal path has slowly become the only path for labour action and membership driven actions and member mobilization that has the most impact has been taken off the union table.
As Ahmad puts it, “when all workers must pay dues no matter what union officials do, officials have less reason to respond to workers’ concerns.” Functionally, not only do union bureaucrats prefer different actions that maintain the respect of the union by following legal paths, but they also treat union negotiations as a bureaucratic process because at the end of the day the new contract is negligible to their salary as it’s guaranteed regardless of whether the rank and file’s lives improve because they will still have to pay dues.
Ahmad makes a very clear point that “Canadian labour law was designed to stymie effective actions. It was constructed to channel these less effective tactics into legal realm where they were the sole option.” We can understand from the Rand Formula court case that labour mobilization and disruption of industry was becoming an issue for the capitalist economy so the capitalists started creating laws to limit strikes. Alongside the bureaucracy formed within unions, this combination led to labour unions becoming more complicit in abiding by the capitalist law system. Increasingly, unions promise to their union members that strikes are very unlikely and are only a “last resort”.
Given all of the above, we can start to see how unions are not trying to combat the back to work legislation because workers are not in control of their unions. What we must do as workers is unite with others in our industry, unionized and un-unionized, to push against union bureaucrats by capping their salary to that of an average union member’s. We must also regain control of our unions by agitating our union members about the need to take job action and strike out when we feel it’s necessary to not only defend our right to strike but also push for greater militancy to win our demands.
1 https://ourtimes.ca/article/randcuffed
2 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/back-to-work-legislation-port-strike-1.6003547
3 https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/cirb-decision-railway-dispute-1.7304194
4 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/06/20/canada-post-purolator-and-liquidation-in-the-public-sector-by-hank/
5 https://www.cbc.ca/news/dhl-express-locks-out-workers-1.7555672
6 This information has come to me through discussions with UFCW workers at Save-on-Foods on Vancouver Island
7 This information has come through discussions with former UFCW bureaucrats
Response to “We’ve Gotta Find Our Way… Back to the Strike! – by Bessy”
[…] The following poem was written by the wife of a striker during the Windsor Ford strike in 1945. The strike was the most important one in Canadian history due to its outcome: the Rand Formula which continues to govern all union-bourgeoisie relations in the country today. We have previously published an article on the Rand Formula: We’ve Gotta Find Our Way… Back to the Strike! […]
LikeLike