Yves Engler’s most important book is Left, Right: Marching to the Beat of Imperial Canada. The book outlines the open support of imperialism by Canada’s official “left” (social-democratic parties, the unions, and “progressive” think tanks). A very large part of the book is a chapter specifically dedicated to criticism of the New Democratic Party (NDP) and its predecessor, the Cooperative Commonwealth Federation (CCF). Engler details how the NDP has propped up Canadian imperialism by backing imperialist wars, coups, Zionism, among many other examples. In fact, some of the only kind words Engler has to offer the NDP are that:
“While the party has played an important role in mitigating the worst effects of capitalism inside Canada when it has been in power provincially and through pressure from the left federally, it has regularly failed to defend the rights of ordinary people across the planet, particularly the victims of the British and American empires that Canada’s ruling class has aligned with.”1
The People’s Hammer along with many other communist and progressive groups have published articles showing that even the mild props Engler gives to the NDP for mitigating the worst effects of capitalism domestically is false. The most notable example was the invasion of the Wet’suwet’en under the BC NDP government2 and the creation of the secret police unit Community-Industry Response Group, now the Critical Response Unit.3
Engler has seemingly forgotten about this book as he recently announced his bid for NDP leader.4 In the years since it was released, the NDP has only broken more and more with the interests of the working-class, even its upper crust. In my article on the Alberta NDP’s split from the national party, it is explained that “Across the country, the NDP has watered itself down to such a degree that it has officially rejected socialism and has been courting the progressive petite-bourgeoisie at the expense of the union bureaucracy and labour aristocracy who birthed the party.”5
Engler’s run to lead the NDP is simply a reflection of his opportunism. Engler is always willing to denounce imperialism and reaction in the abstract. But, when it comes to a practical struggle it comes down to whether it will boost his career or not. If it will benefit his career he will denounce it, when it will benefit it, he will turn a blind eye. We have seen this before in Engler’s open and knowing collaboration with the “Communist Party of Canada” in the midst of a sexual misconduct crisis.6
Again, Engler’s recognition that the NDP is an integral part of Canadian imperialism has seemingly disappeared when the chance comes for Engler to run for leader. Even though it is highly unlikely the NDP bureaucracy would allow Engler to win a leadership election, he without a doubt understands that the campaign will boost the popularity of his books and bring him more speaking events.
The NDP has nothing to offer the workers. They do not even mitigate the worst effects of imperialism in Canada as Engler claims. They actively fight on the side of imperialism against the workers and the oppressed nations of Canada. We cannot let an opportunist like Engler lure workers back to support of the NDP.
The proletariat’s interests lie with communism and the destruction of all imperialism including its representatives like the NDP. Let us unite and build the party of our class, a fight being led by the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction).
1 Engler, Yves. Left, Right: Marching to the Beat of Imperial Canada. Page 13-14.
2 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/06/21/submission-the-hypocrisy-of-the-bc-ndp/
3 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/05/03/rcmp-attempt-to-rebrand-c-irg-by-daniel-h/
4 yvesforndpleader.ca
5 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/06/13/albertan-ndp-splits-from-national-party-by-daniel-h/
6 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/05/24/yves-engler-would-you-please-respond/
Response to “Left, Right: Yves Engler’s March to the Beat of Imperial Canada – by Daniel H.”
[…] 2 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/22/left-right-yves-englers-march-to-the-beat-of-imperial… […]
LikeLike