Introduction
“SICA! SICA! SICA!”
If you ask any organisation in Canada under the influence of the “Communist Party of the Philippines” (CPPh) or the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” [(N)CPC] what the tasks of communists today are, this will invariably be the answer.
Conveniently, any criticism of the “(N)CPC” can be dismissed as baseless on the grounds of “not having enough SICA.”1
Since the amount of SICA one has done determines if a criticism has merit or not and is the main task of communists today, it needs to be taken seriously. So, what is it?
SICA is an acronym for “social investigation and class analysis”. These should be two positions in what makes up an organisation’s mass line. However, since the late 2010s, it has increasingly been taken as shorthand not only for these positions, but of the mass line itself. Through organisations under the ideological-political leadership of the “CPPh” and “(N)CPC”, like the International League of People’s Struggles (ILPS), SICA has found its way across Canada.
While the SICA line emerged from the mass line of the “CPPh”, the line as applied by the “(N)CPC” is considerably further liquidated. The “CPPh” supporters in Canada have not fully reduced the mass line in practice to SICA. They continue to carry out (nationalist, not communist) mass work, agitate for new democracy in the Philippines, and mobilise the Filipino petite-bourgeoisie.
For the “(N)CPC”, SICA is the mass line even if they give lip service to other components. This blowing up of a single position to the entire mass line has led to an empiricist and economist approach to mass work.
What is the Mass line?2
The mass line is a fundamental piece of a party’s political line. It is the guide to its intervention among the masses. It resolves a number of questions such as which masses to direct work toward: backward or advanced, industrial workers or students, etc. It consists of the party’s understanding of how the party and masses are linked. It also includes the party’s approach to social investigation and class analysis. Most importantly, it explains the relation of mass work to people’s war. The more systematised the mass line, the more questions it will have concrete answers to. The mass line is all of these positions as a whole, but none of these positions in isolation.
The understanding of the mass line as an ideological-political question rather than a question of scientific process is a key point of demarcation between Marxism and defenders of the SICA line.
The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)’s [CPC(RF)] document Gonzalo Thought explains the importance of this understanding:
“At its root, the many errors of [Continuity and Rupture] stem from understanding Marxism not as a scientific ideology and instead as a ideological science. That is the primacy of ideology – philosophy – is denied. This manifests in other ways such as presenting Marxism not as a doctrine but as a system, not as a dialectical process but as a method, not as the result of practice but as a thought experiment.”3
As the application of Marxism to the party’s relation to the masses, this applies to the mass line as well. It cannot be reduced to a scientific method without a rejection of dialectical materialism. The mass line is scientific, but it is above all an application of the party’s ideological line.
What is SICA?
The “CPPh’s” principal document articulating their understanding of SICA, Mass Work, affirms the mass line as principally ideological-political and not as a science:
“The mass line is the basic Marxist-Leninist principle which guides mass work and other tasks of the Party in advancing the revolution. It is based and conforms thoroughly to the historical materialist outlook on society and revolution.”4
Crucially, this understanding of the mass line recognises the importance of the relation between the mass line and the principal component of a party’s political line – its military line.
The open liquidation of the mass line into the SICA line by the “(N)CPC” from this still-revolutionary position of the “CPPh” is seen in their programme. As the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has pointed out in their criticism of this programme, its main failure is that it does not explain its ideological foundation:
“The programme presents no ideological line. From its founding organisations, we can assume that the ‘(N)CPC’ is at least inspired by Maoism, however, there is no declaration of its ideological basis in this programme. Nowhere can the term Maoism be found in their programme. There is also no ideological founding document that has been publicly released that we can gauge the ‘(N)CPC’s’ ideological basis from. A lower basis of unity on Marxism-Leninism is not mentioned either. We must ask then, is the ‘(N)CPC’ based on Marxism-Leninism-Maoism? If not, what is its ideological basis of unity? Ideological demarcation is among the most important steps in the reconstitution of the party and the ‘(N)CPC’ have absolved themselves of this responsibility.”5
Without this ideological basis to the “(N)CPC”, the mass line can only be a science and not an ideological-political line guiding its intervention among the masses. Absent Maoism, opportunism will fill the void in leading this intervention among the masses. Specifically, empiricism has replaced Maoism as the ideology of this “party” and economism has become its politics.
The closest thing the “(N)CPC” programme provides to a comprehensive understanding of the mass line beyond SICA, are these Maoist “words of affirmation”:
“In its day-to-day work building the instruments of revolution and fulfilling its revolutionary strategy, the mass line is the general principle guiding the actions of the Party. The mass line teaches that ‘the people, and only the people, are the motive force in the making of world history’ (Mao). Following the mass line means relying on and trusting the masses. It means that the revolution can only be the act of the broad masses and must depend on the mobilization of the majority. It implies that communists must swim within the masses as a fish swims in the water, that they must mingle with them, listen to their concerns, consider them as equals. It means that they must unite and struggle with them, share their losses and victories, their pains and their joys.”6
Yes, this is all true, but what does any of it mean practically, concretely, in the here and now of 2025 Canada? The “(N)CPC” has little to offer these important questions. The only portion of the mass line they go into detail of is the process:
“Applying the mass line daily means to follow the principle ‘from the masses, to the masses.’ Therefore, members of the Party root their actions in the permanent conduct of social investigation so as to learn from the conditions of the people and to get acquainted with their state of mind, their grievances and their needs. The communist way to conduct investigation is class analysis: the understanding of social classes and of contradictions between those classes and how these manifest themselves objectively and subjectively. All actions of the Party must be rooted in social investigation and class analysis (SICA), or else the Party cannot gain traction among the masses, and its watchwords will be reduced to disconnected sloganeering separated from the real world.
[The reader should note here that the “(N)CPC”, like the former “Revolutionary Communist Party” does not recognise any need to synthesise the most advanced ideas gathered in light of Marxism.7]
“It is through agitation and propaganda that the (N)CPC can first put to the test of practice the conclusions of its SICA. Agitation addresses specific contradictions in society. It seeks to arouse indignation, to ‘draw blood’ on particular issues. Through it we spread very basic revolutionary ideas among the broadest masses and lead them towards political and economic struggle. Propaganda, on the other hand, addresses complex or numerous contradictions. It seeks to heighten consciousness of a narrower section of the people. Both agitation and propaganda aim to raise the consciousness of the people and further their participation in the revolutionary movement. They can be carried through mediums (tracts, journals, websites, etc.) or carried out orally by activists.
“It is through agitation and propaganda that the Party pursues the mobilization and organization of the masses. The masses are mobilized in immediate economic and political struggles, in actions against the class enemy and through extensive campaigns. Concretely, these can take the form of demonstrations, occupations, strikes, etc., the form of the actions itself being secondary to the political line and the involvement of the broadest masses of the people. Jointly, the Party seeks their organization in the organs of the united front. These can be either organizations created on the impulse of the Party or already existing organizations, such as trade unions. The most advanced and combative sections of the masses are ultimately organized within the communist Party and eventually, the people’s army.
“In sum, the Party applies the mass line through the conduct of SICA, agitation and propaganda, organization and mobilization of the masses, all with the goal of building the instruments of the revolution — the Party, the united front and the people’s army — and following the revolutionary strategy of accumulating forces, building organs of political power and precipitating the revolutionary crisis.”8
Even with the references to other components of what should be part of a mass line, it is clear from the above that it is the method, the “science” that is the heart and soul of their mass line. The philosophical basis of the mass line and its principal question – the relation of the mass line to the seizure of power are ignored or in the case of the latter perverted into a question of a peaceful accumulation of forces.9
The SICA line often presents a stage of social investigation and class analysis as the first stage in a process. This is articulated in different ways, but it is generally made up of three distinct stages of SICA, synthesis, and returning of the ideas.
In the case of the “(N)CPC”, the process begins with communists going among the masses and conducting SICA. When this is deemed to be complete, they carry out agitation and propaganda. Following this, the masses are to be organised into the three instruments and mobilised. After an indefinite period of accumulating forces, revolution is to occur.
The reader may think the laying out of each of these stages as discrete bricks rather a dialectical process where the party conducts multiple tasks at once with one being specified as principal at a given moment is done for simplicity, but it reflects in the practice of the “(N)CPC” where ever it is active.
In theory, the SICA line reduces the mass line to the scientific process whereby social investigation is followed by synthesis and concluded through returning the gathered ideas to the masses in some form. Practically, the empiricist nature of this line means the second two stages never get off the ground. The SICA adherents are perpetually stuck in their purely theoretical first stage.
How should we decide when we have enough raw data to move to formulating a programme? The “Revolutionary Initiative”,10 a precursor to the “(N)CPC”, was unable to make this jump in the entire period from their founding in 2006 until their dissolution in 2023!
SICA in Practice under the “(N)CPC”
The SICA line hollows out Marxism by simplifying it to a science. The ideological vacuum is filled by bourgeois thought in the form of a mechanical and empiricist outlook leading to largely passive and economist mass work. This section will show outline several concrete examples of this.
Purely Intellectual Approach
The empirical outlook has been noted in discussions between communists and groups that have been influenced by the “(N)CPC’s” approach when asked questions about their mass work. This question is often responded to with something along the lines of “We are in the SICA stage right now”. In other words, there’s big things coming! But, now is not the right time for open communist intervention among the proletariat.
The SICA line has produced among these organisations an inward-looking approach to mass work consisting of data gathering and study groups. This in turn produces dogmatism which has been noted in members of UiS telling service workers facing lay-offs and lawsuits that they do not care since they are not members of the heavy industrial proletariat.
This mass work produced by the SICA line appeals mainly to the petite-bourgeoisie, especially students, academics, and the union bureaucracy, because of this. They do not need to engage in the struggle of building the three instruments in the real world. Instead they can pat themselves on the back for running surveys whose data will never be put into practice and reading the same Maoist texts.
An important outcome of the “(N)CPC’s” lack of an ideological basis is in how they answer the question of “which masses do we go to?” Of course as good self-described communists they claim it is to the heavy industrial proletariat first and foremost. However, in practice this has rarely been the case (some examples are provided below). One of UiS’ big SICA efforts was a Google Forms survey that was sent into as many activist group chats in Vancouver as possible. However, are the heavy industrial proletariat to be found on these group chats? Are they the ones who have mid-day off for the weekly rallies at the Vancouver Art Gallery? No, the activist crowd in Vancouver like in most other cities is made up predominantly of the petite-bourgeoisie. In conducting surveys in this way, the “(N)CPC” fails to even conduct proper social investigation and class analysis.
The form in which this survey was carried out also shows the mechanical separation of each step in the “(N)CPC’s” process outlined above. There was no attempt at agitation, raising class consciousness, or organisation carried out along with the survey. It was purely a collection of data.
Implantation and Reliance on Bureaucracy
Another area where the SICA line has manifested is in implantation and reliance on the union bureaucracy. These two phenomena are closely linked and stem from the same root cause that is a petite-bourgeois set of would-be communists that want to rally the advanced workers.
The communist answer to this question is wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda. To petite-bourgeois socialists the answer is implantation or reliance on the union bureaucracy. Implantation often consists of having students cosplay as workers in steel-toes, high-viz, and a hard hat to work for a period among the proletariat.
The struggle between a Marxist understanding of rallying the advanced workers and the implantation line was a major site of two-line struggle among communists in the first attempts to reconstitute the party. The most advanced effort, In Struggle, championed wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda against the “Canadian Communist League (Marxist-Leninist)” which called for implantation. In Struggle’s No Revolutionary Party Without a Revolutionary Programme summarised the outcome of the implantation line:
“The experience gathered during the past 8 or 9 years has clearly illustrated the erroneous character of this practice which has been elevated to the level of a tactic for the merger of Marxism-Leninism and the workers’ movement. In all known cases of ‘implantation’ in English Canada or in Quebec, it has always been a failure. Either the intellectuals barged into the factories like lions and declared open war against the existing union leadership, and thus were thrown out without having obtained the support of the working masses, or else, conscious of this danger, they reduced their intervention to its lowest level, to the level of immediate economic demands and completely subordinated and even totally abandoned all political work among the working masses. They sought acceptance by the union and sought to make friends with everyone so that later they could talk about communism… without being rejected! In short, they fell into economism and opportunism and didn’t really help the penetration of communism into the workers’ movement go forward.
“Incidentally, the League adopted the implantation line, thus stupidly repeating the errors of the RCT in Quebec and of certain study groups in English Canada. Conceived in this way, implantation is the expression of a political line, a line which says that it is only on the grounds of the immediate economic demands that workers can be won over to communism. This point of view is completely erroneous, because it leads to abandoning political questions and it always leads to radical reformism, anarcho-syndicalism or ‘political unionism’, which carry with them the implicit negation of the absolute necessity of a party, before everything else, to lead the socialist revolution.”11
While trying to make connections to the workers, these students in fact substitute themselves for the leading role of the workers. In recent years, we have also been able to see a third path taken by the implantationists in addition to those described by In Struggle of adventurism and tailism. This is that many of these student-“workers” are often unable to handle the discipline required for these jobs and just leave to go back to school or find petite-bourgeois employment.
Despite being rejected as a strategy by the communist movement in Canada since at least the 1970s, the “(N)CPC” has been noted as applying implantation in a number of locations.
Where no one is willing to make the jump to implantation, these organisations often aim to rally the union bureaucrats already in place. This has also been noted where ever the “(N)CPC” is active, but most clearly in Vancouver.12 An intermediate option between implantation and rallying the bureaucracy has consisted of getting members into union bureaucrat positions locally which has been noted among those adherents of the SICA line.
The embrace of the strategies of implantation and reliance on bureaucracy follows directly from the mechanical view of the mass line outlined above: SICA → agitation and propaganda → organisation and mobilisation. If an organisation understands that there is a discrete stage of SICA before these other discrete stages, then what other options are there? The communist method of wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda is out of the question because the indefinite stage of SICA has not been completed. To get the information necessary to complete the stage, one must either implant students among the workers or recruit vaguely progressive union bureaucrats.
De-politicised Data Gathering
The extreme level of liquidation of the SICA line is best seen in Vancouver in the data-gathering work of UiS.
Through UiS’ black nationalist committee, Pan-Africanist “Unity”,13 this mockery of the mass line has been carried out by going to a black-owned restaurant to ask black people (regardless of class) what is going on in their lives.
Another example was the gathering of some UiS activists to stand in a Langara College hallway without leaflets or any other agitational material to gauge the interest of students in forming a group to support the national liberation of Palestine. There was no attempt to agitate, only to ask questions. Further, this had a disorganising effect as a pro-Palestinian organisation already existed at the school. However, when asked why they felt the need to create a second pro-Palestinian organisation the response by the UiS member was that they did not like its name!
By far, the most extreme example for what is considered SICA is members attending a house party to again just ask people their thoughts on Palestine.
Disconnection from Reality
The “(N)CPC” programme states that:
“All actions of the Party must be rooted in social investigation and class analysis (SICA), or else the Party cannot gain traction among the masses, and its watchwords will be reduced to disconnected sloganeering separated from the real world.”14
They are completely correct when they say this. However, the fruits of the SICA line often lead to them not meeting this standard. On the one hand they act in a dogmatic manner and on the other hand they tail the union bureaucracy. In either case their work often becomes disconnected sloganeering separated from the real world. Both of these errors were seen in the “(N)CPC’s” Amazon campaign.
Another article criticising the Amazon campaign has pointed out how Workers Alliance (French acronym: AO) was following the leadership of the Confederation of National Trade Unions’ (French acronym: CSN) bureaucracy.15 Where they attempted to differentiate themselves from the bureaucracy, it was in a dogmatic manner:
“It must also be pointed out that in AO’s second set of demands is the call for the seizure of Amazon’s property, if they go through with the closures. This demand has two basic errors. The first is that it lacks any kind of call for workers control either in the form of the warehouses being turned over to the workers or nationalisation with workers’ control. The second error is that this demand is completely disconnected from reality. If we cannot force the state to block the closures, how are we going to force them to take the much more aggressive measure of nationalisation (even without workers’ control)? Without the means to actually achieve this much more militant demand, this is nothing more than ‘writing to strike a pose’ – ‘left-’opportunism.”16
The “(N)CPC” Speak for Themselves
What is good SICA and bad SICA? One of the precursors to the “(N)CPC’s” journal Kites has offered us an example of good SICA in the form of Aiyanas Ormond’s Seven Theses on Imperialism and the Drug War.17 The editorial board of Kites stated of this piece that:
“Beyond their specific analysis of the drug war, these theses also provide a model for making specific class analysis—defining who are our friends and who are our enemies—and outlining a program for class struggle based on that analysis.”18
This article has been discussed and its opportunism put on full display in a recent article published in The People’s Hammer.19 As this article shows, what Kites upholds as a pillar of SICA runs cover for the drug bourgeoisie by placing many sections of the proletariat outside the camp of people while treating objective enemies as middle elements. As stated above, when the primacy of ideology in the mass line is not upheld, opportunism takes its place.
Synthesis
The SICA line, particularly as applied by the “(N)CPC” is an open liquidation of the mass line. It does this by abandoning its principally ideological-political character. This degrades the ideological-political line into a pure science free of any ideological baggage (in reality guided by bourgeois philosophy).
It makes the principal component of the mass line social investigation and class analysis. Other components, including what should be principal – the relation of mass work to armed struggle, are given lip-service, but treated as unimportant. The mass line must be understood as the systematisation of a number of positions dealing with the party’s relation to the masses and the relation of its mass work to people’s war.
The process of the mass line often summarised as “from the masses, to the masses”, is dealt with as a linear series of discrete stages instead of dialectical process where several things co-occur with one treated as principal.
The three general stages generally described by communists of going to the masses and gathering their ideas; synthesising the most advanced in light of MLM-GT, the guiding thought of the Canadian Revolution; and returning these ideas to the masses cannot be understood as discrete blocs pursued linearly. At any given point in the party’s mass work, all three of these “stages” are occurring. However, only one will be principal at a time.
As an example, say that a communist cell wants to gain a foothold in a new area. There are two ways to go about this:
1) the cell goes door-to-door, provides questionnaires, speaks to individuals to establish a base of understanding. This continues for some length of time until they feel they have collected enough quantitative data to begin agitating the masses which will sometimes be followed by the stage of synthesis and return the ideas to the masses.
2) the cell begins from what has already been established by the original communist party, reconstitution efforts, and the international communist movement. They do some background research to find the best parts of the area to begin and go there with the communist programme and agitational material. They may hold a rally or simply distribute leaflets. In the process they speak with workers to gather their ideas in order to better understand the conditions, then collect the workers’ contact information, and arrange meetings. At the cell’s meetings the grievances and demands gathered are discussed and synthesised through Marxism. This leads to the production of new agitational material and corrections to previous erroneous understandings.
The former is the necessary application of the SICA line and leads to empiricist and economist practice.
Despite what is claimed by the revisionists, there is no communist party in Canada. To build it, the communist movement must unite with the vanguard of the proletariat. This requires a break with the SICA line. It has only served to stop wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda by turning communists inward into study groups at best or into tails of the bourgeoisie at worst.
1 A real quote by “(N)CPC” supporters in response to the distribution of a criticism outside a United in Struggle meeting.
2 The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction)’s Mass Line has recently been published outlining this topic in more depth: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/07/25/repost-mass-line-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-by-cpcrf/
3 https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2024/08/20/gonzalo-thought-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
9 The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has criticised the “(N)CPC’s” call for the peaceful accumulation of forces in its general criticism of their programme: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/
12 An earlier article from Quebec noted the following: “The Amazon campaign shows AO’s complete political subordination to the union bureaucracy. AO members at their demonstrations will even approach workers to inquire them to ask their union delegate to reach out to them, rather than organizing the worker directly, since the union delegates ‘already have influence over their group of workers.’” https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/28/submission-lessons-of-the-quebec-amazon-campaign-by-quebec-supporters-of-the-peoples-hammer/
13 We have previously published an article addressing the issue of creating paper organisations such as these: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/armchair-revolutionaries-nothing-but-liabilities-by-cliff-z/
15 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/28/submission-lessons-of-the-quebec-amazon-campaign-by-quebec-supporters-of-the-peoples-hammer/
Responses to “SICA: A Liquidation of the Mass Line – by Daniel H.”
[…] 2 We have previously written a criticism of the SICA line in Canada: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 1https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/ ↩︎ […]
LikeLike