The following article is a repost from the Workers United Front website. The original can be found here: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/17/toronto-criticism-of-membership-of-the-students-and-workers-for-the-liberation-of-palestine/
– Editorial Baord of The People’s Hammer
Preface To Criticism
In August of 2025 the Workers United Front of Toronto (WUF) was made aware of incorrect behavior and comments from one member of the Students and Workers for the Liberation of Palestine (SWLP) which has since transitioned into the Alliance of Workers and Students (AWAS). Upon learning that membership of the then SWLP was engaging in such behavior, the WUF drafted a criticism of these actions to be distributed amongst members of the organization so that two-line struggle could be conducted between both organizations in the hope that these errors would be rectified and that unity would emerge. While this criticism was being drafted, the WUF learned that the SWLP had formally transitioned into AWAS—a positive development—and drafted an addendum to the criticism expressing this very fact and that this provided an additional aspect to the necessity of struggling for unity between AWAS and the WUF. The criticism and addendum will be featured below.
Upon completing the document the WUF sent it to AWAS membership via their Whatsapp chatroom. Leadership of AWAS removed the WUF from their chatroom, citing that there was no need to conduct line struggle between our organizations, nor should the WUF have shared this with their membership at all. The WUF messaged leadership privately and explained that this was the incorrect action for the following reasons: 1) that the criticism concerned membership of AWAS and therefore the most appropriate course of action is to bring the criticism directly to them; 2) that the promotion of criticism in front of everyone is necessary to ensure the progressive development of the workers’ movement from the bottom up and; 3) that conducting meaningful struggle for unity on behalf of workers everywhere is a task that all serious organizations must take up. The WUF also explained to leadership that in spite of these missteps AWAS has taken the WUF is still willing to engage in two-line struggle so long as this incorrect position on line struggle is corrected. The leadership of AWAS has seemingly refused to comment on the matter.
Because the leadership of AWAS are refusing to engage in line struggle on this matter the Workers United Front of Toronto is publishing this criticism in an open forum with the hope that membership of AWAS are made aware of and struggle against this decision made by AWAS leadership. Let it be made clear again that the WUF is still more than happy to conduct line struggle with AWAS and their membership, all they need to do is contact us. The WUF – Toronto would like to end this preface with the following quote from WUF – Vancouver:
“When a group, union, or politician is claiming to fight for your interests, be sure to recognize who is willing to take your criticisms in earnest, and explain their view. Who is willing to embrace skepticism from the public and prove their worth through their actions. At the same time, take note of who runs or becomes aggressive at the slightest questioning or criticism. Who does not seek to unite with all common fighters of the working class through open and broad struggle, but undermines others through backroom attacks. If a group cannot stand up for their ideas for the supposed liberation of the working class, how will they fare when the capitalists seek to crush them with all their power?”1
Criticism of Membership of the Students And Workers For The Liberation Of Palestine
Recently it has come to the attention of the Workers United Front of Toronto (WUF) that membership of the Students & Workers for the Liberation of Palestine (SWLP) have been engaging in unacceptable behavior towards the WUF. This behavior includes deliberately misrepresenting the WUF’s political line on Palestine, rumor-mongering of the WUF on the basis of this misrepresentation, and openly slandering the WUF to non-members of the SWLP.
Specifically, a peripheral non-member associated with the WUF shared a private conversation with us that they had with an SWLP member over an insecure channel of communication. In these messages between the two mentioned, the member stated that the WUF’s “line on Palestine is idiotic.” Their rationale for this statement is caused by a misunderstanding that the WUF does “not support any national liberation struggle that isn’t led by a specifically Gonzaloist party.” The WUF is unaware of how the SWLP member came to this false conclusion. In our brief interaction with the SWLP, occurring at a one-on-one meeting which two of our members attended, the only formal discussion that was had in regards to the WUF’s line on Palestine was an SWLP representative asking one WUF member for the WUF’s position on Israeli workers. Our member stated in response that they did not hold a strong understanding of the conditions of Israeli workers. The WUF is unaware of any direct or indirect remarks made by its members towards a position on Palestine outside of this situation to the SWLP. We will gladly accept concrete evidence that runs counter to this understanding. Additionally the SWLP member took issue with the WUF’s analysis of Hamas and Hezbollah. The member stated mockingly that the WUF “say[s] Hamas and Hezbollah are feudal of all things,” as though this is not a fundamental characteristic of these organizations. If the SWLP member and organization believe otherwise, we ask that you present us with a concrete analysis of these groups.
To be directly clear the WUF is in full support of any and all struggle for national liberation by Palestine and believes wholeheartedly in its right to self-determine as its own nation. We are disappointed that the SWLP member not only holds this incorrect understanding of the political line of the WUF, but that they have allowed these misunderstandings to fester to the point of misrepresentation and outright slander. If the SWLP member wanted to ensure they understood the political line of our organization, they should have requested that the SWLP engage in open two-line struggle with the WUF. To do otherwise is to engage directly in liberalism; particularly, these actions embody Mao’s second type of liberalism as explained in his document Combat Liberalism. The WUF is hopeful this is merely the position of one of its members rather than the ideological-political line of the entire SWLP. Because of this we are sharing the information we have received in honest faith with the SWLP.
Since an SWLP member is engaging in misrepresentation of the WUF’s political line, and engaging in rumor-mongering and slandering of the WUF on these grounds, we request that our organizations meet in an official capacity to thoroughly discuss our ideological-political lines and to dispel these rumors. The WUF maintains that it would like to uphold a professional, working relationship with the SWLP on the basis that it meets with the WUF and engages in two-line struggle. Please let us know a date and time that might be suitable for your membership and we will coordinate accordingly.
Addendum To Criticism
The Workers’ United Front of Toronto is pleased by recent developments within the SWLP to transition into the Alliance of Workers and Students (AWAS). The above document was written and edited before this transition occurred. We believe this is a positive internal development given that the AWAS is suggesting it is now moving away from campus activity in favour of going directly to the proletariat and their workplaces. The WUF would like to use this transitory period of the AWAS as an opportunity to struggle for unity between our organizations. On this matter you may contact us through the aforementioned email address and phone number. We look forward to hearing from you.
Workers’ United Front of Toronto – torontounitedworkers@proton.me | (672) 335-6820
References:
Response to “Criticism of Membership of the Students And Workers For The Liberation Of Palestine – by WUF Toronto”
[…] 1 The Workers United Front of Toronto recently published a criticism of a regional group of this type. However, as the preface states they have since changed their name and are moving towards work among the proletariat: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/09/19/criticism-of-membership-of-the-students-and-workers-f… […]
LikeLike