The People's Hammer

Socialism of the 21st Century, a New Path for Oppressed Nations? – by Beatrix



Author’s note: When referring to “Socialism of the 21st Century,” this article is referring to the ideology championed by István Mészáros, Michael A. Lebowitz, Marta Harnecker, and put in practice by the Chavismo movement.

Introduction

“Socialism of the 21st Century” is an interesting ideology. It is a “New Left” ideology. Broadly, this means it rejects the Soviet socialist experiment entirely and embraces a humanist reading of Marx. These ideologies are commonly associated with academics in the imperialist countries. Yet, “Socialism of the 21st Century” is also supported by a member of the former Soviet bloc, Cuba, and put into practice by another oppressed nation, Venezuela. This makes “Socialism of the 21st Century” unique. It is the only “New Left” ideology that has been succesful in forming a government.

Yet, “Socialism of the 21st Century” is also a tragic ideology. Due to both its internal contradiction, and the contradiction of imperialism, its project, Venezuela, ended up abandoning it completely in a short time-frame.

On December 26 1991, the USSR officially dissolved. This shocked the “left” globally, and put countries like Cuba, a former Soviet bloc member, into a very difficult spot. In response to this, “left” theoreticians that rejected the USSR, or “state socialism”, rose to prominence. One of these ideologies was “Socialism of the 21st Century.”

In What Is Socialism for the Twenty-First Century? Michael A. Lebowitz characterizes the ideology as a “return” to the original Marxist socialism. He characterizes this socialism as:

“the creation of a society that removes all obstacles to the full development of human beings”1

How “Socialism of the 21st Century” is supposed to do that is left unclear.

“To end the rule of capital, it is necessary to take the state away from capital—i.e., to end capital’s ability to use the police, the judiciary, the army, legislative bodies, and its other oppressive mechanisms to enforce its rule.” 1

And on that basis:

“new relation of distribution emerges in which our claim upon the output of society increasingly is as a member of society” so “the instruments of labor are common property and the total labor is co-operatively regulated.”1

How are we to forge this new relationship of distribution and communize the means of production while cooperatively planning our total labour? It is stated further that:

“To subordinate the bourgeois right based upon individual ownership, the associated producers must create new organs that ensure conscious cooperation of activities, determined by communal needs and purposes.”1

And that we should forge a new communal relationship of production:

“a communal production, communality, is presupposed as the basis of production… its presupposed communal character would determine the distribution of products. The communal character of production would make the product into a communal, general product from the outset.”1

These are all fine and good. The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) [CPC(RF)] wholly agrees with these points. In their Programme, CPC(RF) lays out their thoughts on what constitutes communism and the transitional period very clearly. Relevant sections of their programme include:

Distribution of the products of society on the basis of need;

Abolition of private property, transformation of state and collective property into the property of all of society, administration of the economy by and in the interests of the whole of society;

Establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat based on a system of workers’ and farmers’ councils. This system of councils will combine legislative and executive power, include the right to recall representatives, and will be based on industrial not territorial units;

Participation of workers in management and participation of managers, officials, and technicians in production. Overturning of all unnecessary regulations. Management of all worksites by the elected workers’ committees;

Now, we see the first principles reading of Marx in Socialism for the Twenty-First Century and they do not disagree with these principles.

However, Socialism for the Twenty-First Century entirely rejects the USSR. How so? Socialism for the Twenty-First Century sees socialism as a process, not as a separate stage with specific characteristics that distinguishes it from communism.

Socialism for the Twenty-First Century rejects the Soviet model entirely:

“’Real socialism’ refers thus to the Soviet Union and countries which accepted, with variations, the Soviet model.”

“That model appeared attractive (especially in poor countries) because the Soviet Union succeeded in combining its large rural population with state-directed investments to build an industrial base and achieved substantial increases in the standard of living—and all in the context of external hostility.”

“Missing from ‘real socialism’ was protagonism of the working class — protagonism in the workplace, protagonism in the community, protagonism throughout society. The result was predictable: alienation in the workplace, low productivity, and the desire for alien products; the result was ‘apathetic, thoughtless, more or less well-fed instruments of production.’ ‘Real socialism’ did not merely fail to produce rich human beings; its second product was a working class with neither the will nor the strength to prevent the restoration of capitalism. That path is a dead end.”1

Not only does it reject the revisionist Soviet model of the 1970s, it also rejects the revolutionary Soviet model of 1917:

“The twentieth-century answer was that development of the productive forces in the socialist stage, supported by material incentives, creates the conditions for abundance. And, in communism as that system of abundance, the labor of people would become ‘so productive that they will voluntarily work according to their ability’ and that this abundance would allow a person to take freely ‘according to his needs.’ New people, in short, emerge as a ‘trickle-down’ effect of the development of the productive forces.

One would search in vain, however, for any suggestion from Marx that it is possible to get to a future stage of abundance by trying to build upon a defect inherited from capitalism. Indeed, the second product characteristic of producing under these conditions points in precisely the opposite direction. Since the owners of the ‘personal condition of production, of labor power’ want as much as possible for their property in an exchange with society, they look upon labor as a means to obtain articles of consumption, and if they do not get what they consider their entitlement (the equivalent), they offer less labor. Alienated labor to obtain alien products, alienation from other members of society, and alienation from the socially owned material conditions of production, and thus potentially their theft as a means of securing more articles of consumption. Could abundance ever be reached under these conditions? If alienated labor leads to constantly growing needs to possess alien products, can there ever be an end to scarcity?

…

“In 1917 Lenin interpreted the distinction that Marx made in his Critique of the Gotha Program between communist society as it initially emerges (its ‘lower phase’) and the ‘higher phase’ once it rests upon its own foundations as indicating the difference between a stage of socialism and an ultimate stage of communism possible only after ‘an enormous development of productive forces.’ Marx’s distinction between two moments in the process in which the new society advances by producing its own premises (thereby tending to become an organic system) accordingly hardened into a difference between two systems: socialism and communism—each with its own strikingly different relations of distribution.” 1

The Soviet Union is of course not without its flaws, but we must recognize that it advanced Marxism significantly. For the “Socialism for the Twenty-First Century” crowd, what they learned from the Soviet Union was the need to completely reject the Soviet Union, which forces them to go back to a first principle reading of Marx. This tendency, while understandable for academics after the immediate aftermath of 1991, ended up biting them in the end, as will be demonstrated.

Socialism of the 21st Century, Venezuela

On 14 April 2002, Hugo Chávez was elected the president of Venezuela. Under him, Venezuela nationalized the sole oil company PDVSA, formed tens of thousands of local communal councils, and implemented extensive redistributive social programs. Chavez championed “Socialism of the 21stcentury”. He proclaimed:

“We must transcend capitalism. But we cannot resort to state capitalism, which would be the same perversion of the Soviet Union. We must reclaim socialism as a thesis, a project and a path, but a new type of socialism, a humanist one, which puts humans and not machines or the state ahead of everything. That’s the debate we must promote around the world, and the WSF [World Social Forum] is a good place to do it.”

During his rule, many theoreticians who formulated “Socialism of the 21st century” served as his direct advisors. Chávez founded the PSUV [United Socialist Party of Venezuela], which became the main instrument for the Chavismo movement.

Yet in 2020, PSUV practically re-privatized the state-owned oil company through a joint venture with Chevron,2 Venezuela is suffering from chronic shortage of essential goods like medicine while inflation has skyrocketted,3 and since 2015, 7 million Venezuelans have fled the country.4 What happened?

Aside from the direct assault from American imperialism in the form of sanctions and the premature death of Hugo Chavez, there have been large, structural reasons behind the failure of the Chavismo movement. Structural reasons which “Socialism of the 21st Century” has no answer for!

Venezuela is an oppressed nation existing in a imperialist world. It, by definition, does not have enough heavy industry to produce all the essential inputs to its economy. For example, 73% of Venezuelan electricity is generated by the Guri Hydroelctric power plant, which was built and maintained by foreign capital.5 The biggest refinery in Venezuela, the Paraguana Refining Center, also requires maintenance from foreign capital.6 Therefore, the Venezuelan economy has a constant need for foreign capital – including foreign currency. This has two big implications.

Firstly, Venezuela’s need for foreign currency. It needs to sell commodities on the international market for foreign currency. This fact remains true no matter what form of ideology the Venezuelan state upholds. When it cannot get enough foreign currency to sustain itself, it will suffer a societal breakdown. This is exactly what happened after 2014. After 2014, oil prices dropped below $50 per barrel due to the American fracking boom, yet Venezuela had a break-even point of between $42 per barrel to $56 per barrel for its oil exports.7

The change in oil price drastically reduced Venezuela’s foreign currency income, leading to under maintenance of its important infrastructure. The output of Paraguana Refining Center cratered and Guri Hydroelctric power plant failed in 2019 and 2024, leading to nationwide black-outs.8

This also means, the Venezuelan state cannot enter into their “Socialism of the 21st century.” Because under “Socialism of the 21st century”, producers are to “subordinate the bourgeois right”.

Critical inputs into the Venezuelan economy such as hydro electric generators, specialized refinery equipments, and medicine are made by foreign capital who firmly uphold bourgeois right! This foreign capital is the essential producer for the Venezuelan economy, and yet they have no intention to form “new organs that ensure conscious cooperation of ‘activities, determined by communal needs and purposes.’” At the same time, the Venezuelan state has no power over them. At the end of the day, the Venezuelan state cannot nationalize the factories in Japan.

To build “Socialism of the 21st century,” you cannot have some producers upholding bourgeois right, while others organize based on communal needs. All of the producers necessary for the functioning of your society must renounce bourgeois right together.

One way to address this issue is to recognize that you need to prioritize the “enormous development of productive forces.” The very thing “Socialism of the 21st Century” rejects!

If you manage to develop self-reliance by using a “large rural population with state-directed investments to build an industrial base and achieved substantial increases in the standard of living—and all in the context of external hostility”, then you will have all the production necessary for the functioning of your society within your national borders. This is the necessary precondition to abolishing bourgeois right.

It must be noted that both socialist China and the USSR faced the same problem. The push to industrialization in the early years of the USSR were born out of necessity, not choice!9 Yes, socialist China and the USSR existed in different circumstances. The USSR gained massive foreign capital by pitting American imperialists against British imperialists.10 Socialist China received massive capital transfers from the USSR.11 Yet, both countries needed to pursue five year plans to be truly free from foreign capital. We exist in an imperialist world. Capital is concentrated in the imperialist states, especially capital necessary for heavy industry. If any country still relies on economic inputs from imperialist states, it will remain de facto under the boot of imperialism.

Unfortunately, both the material conditions of Venezuela, the political economy of Venezuela, and the ideology of “Socialism of the 21st Century” made developing a large, independent, and self-sufficient Venezuelan domestic economy impossible.

Venezuela is too close and too economically dependent on the USA. Unlike China or the USSR, who could rely on selling many different commodities to gain foreign currency, Venezuela has to rely on selling low-quality heavy crude.

Hugo Chávez was also still a parliamentarian. He did not come into power through a people’s war. Therefore, he had to deal with a bureaucratic capitalist political economy, where landlords and compradors resisted Chavismo at every step. In a bureaucratic capitalist political economy, the landlords and compradors rejects developing domestic industries. Even if Chavismo had help from the bureaucrat faction of the bourgeoisie who benefited from state-monopoly, Chavismo still had to fight both foreign imperialist and domestic compradors at the same time.12

Ideologically, “Socialism of the 21st Century” explicitly rejected a mass industrializing push like the five year plans of socialist countries.

The proponents of “Socialism of the 21st Century,” especially Cuban scholars like Marta Harnecker, must have understood the limits of “Socialism of the 21st Century” experiment in Venezuela. You cannot directly jump to communism in an oppressed nation.

This is the tragedy of “Socialism of the 21st century.” If somehow, a Chavista American officer took over the USA enjoyed the same level of mass support as Chavez, he could have a real chance at achieving “Socialism of the 21st Century” in America. This is due to the concentration of heavy industry, light industry, and raw material input within the borders of the USA. Yet, it is Venezuela, an oppressed nation in the backyard of the sole superpower, that “Socialism of the 21st Century” was put into practice.

Should we then try to implement “Socialism of the 21st Century” in imperialist countries? Unfortunately, the social forces that allowed for the Chavismo movement simply do not exist in imperialist countries.

First, the military in the imperialist countries select for institutionalists and imperialists. Unlike the military in oppressed nations where their devotion for nationalism clash with the compradors’ betrayal of their civilian government, military in imperialist nations have aligned interests with their civilian government.

Second, the democratic institution in imperialist nations is entrenched and has historically been extremely capable at killing any anti-capitalist parliamentarian movement. From the SDP to the British Labour, from the McGovern Campaign to the Bernie movement, from the CCF to the NDP, the history of parliamentarian socialism in the imperialist country is a history of defeat.

However, it is important to recognize that “Socialism of the 21st Century” did hit on something important. If you only focus on the development of productive forces, without looking at what kind of relations of production you are building with those productive forces, you create the seed for counter-revolution.

The CPC(RF) upholds that we need:

National liberation for the oppressed nations through the right to self-determination and the development of the national economy principally by developing the heavy industry of these nations;

Establishment of the dictatorship of the proletariat based on a system of workers’ and farmers’ councils. This system of councils will combine legislative and executive power, include the right to recall representatives, and will be based on industrial not territorial units;

Participation of workers in management and participation of managers, officials, and technicians in production. Overturning of all unnecessary regulations. Management of all worksites by the elected workers’ committees;

The details of how to develop heavy industry and foster new relationships of production at the same time depends on the particular circumstances of the time. Yet any socialist project needs to prioritize both, especially in an oppressed nation.

In the end, “Socialism of the 21st Century” is not the path toward socialism for the oppressed nations. However, could the socialist experiment play out differently in Venezuela? While we can not say for sure, we demonstrated that MLM-GT could have addressed many shortcomings of the Chavismo movement.

For example, if Venezuelan people went beyond the parliamentarian process and annihilated the comprador forces like landlords within Venezuela, it could have avoided fighting a two-front war against both domestic comparadors and foreign imperialists.

If the Venezuelan people accepted that building socialism in Venezuela required the massive industrialization of the country, and developed industries domestically when it had ample foreign currency through a mixture of importing capitals and domestic substitutions, the current fate of Venezuelan economy might differ drastically.

Failure of “Socialism of the 21st Century” in Venezuela is not the failure of socialism in Venezuela. We must apply scientific socialism and learn from the failure of “Socialism of the 21st Century” in Venezuela.

Notes

1. https://monthlyreview.org/articles/what-is-socialism-for-the-twenty-first-century/

2. https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/08/world/americas/venezuela-oil-maduro.html

3. https://www.newyorker.com/news/news-desk/venezuelas-food-crisis-reaches-a-breaking-point

4. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-63279800

5. https://www.power-technology.com/projects/gurihydroelectric/

6. https://www.eia.gov/international/content/analysis/countries_long/Venezuela/pdf/venezuela_2024.pdf

7. https://oilprice.com/Energy/Crude-Oil/The-Single-Biggest-Threat-To-Venezuelas-Future.html

8. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-latin-america-49079175

9. https://www.bannedthought.net/MLM-Theory/PoliticalEconomyOfSocialism/SovietSocialistPE/TheEconomicOrganizationOfWarCommunism-1918-1921-SilvanaMalle-1985-OCR-sm.pdf

https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1927/12/02.htm

10. https://www.americanheritage.com/how-america-helped-build-soviet-machine

11. https://min.news/en/economy/f9eabcc2789437fe2c81dcdbc2f828ca.html

12. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/


Response to “Socialism of the 21st Century, a New Path for Oppressed Nations? – by Beatrix”

  1. Workers’ United Front of Kelowna Statement on Venezuela – By WUF Kelowna – The People's Hammer