Introduction
Recently, a trend in the communist movement of Canada has developed of forming regional communist organisations. Ideologically, these organisations often claim to uphold Marxism-Leninism or even Maoism, but have developed a petite-bourgeois approach to questions of politics, organisation, and strategy.
These organisations often begin from a correct premise that there is no communist party in this country and that a party needs to be reconstituted. The less developed of these regional communist organisations have no strategy to bring the communist movement out of its current state to where it needs to be. Instead, they often attach themselves to a particular mass movement such as the Palestinian national liberation movement and hope that with enough participation in these spontaneous struggles, a party will emerge.1
Another set exists that has a developed a plan based on SICA.2 In practice, there is very little difference between these two sets. Both end up tailing mass movements and making economist interventions among the masses.
The final set of regional communist organisations are those that are actively attempting to build a regional communist party as a path to an all-Canadian communist party. While, this set is under the influence of small group mentality and opposed to centralism (practically at least), they support two-line struggle and form the most developed of the regional communist organisations.
Recent History of Regional Communist Organisations
Small groups began to emerge in the late 2010s – 2021 as part of the process of liquidation of the “Revolutionary Communist Party” (“RCP”). The first of these was the split of the Quebec district into the Continuators.3 While the Continuators spoke of rebuilding the party on the national level, they quickly collapsed into a small group in Montreal leading to many other small groups emerging in Quebec such as the former Charles Gagnon Cell.
Other splits led to the formation of the Atlantic Communist Council (different names were in use by this group although they maintained the acronym ACC) out of the PEI “RCP”, another out of the Saskatoon “RCP”, and the “Revolutionary Workers Party” from members of the Southern Ontario “RCP”.
Today, these groups have ceased to exist with some of their members reuniting in the “(New) Communist Party of Canada”4 and a greater number losing interest in communism altogether.
The new set of small communist groups that are emerging are distinct from this earlier set in that they are not a symptom of liquidation. They tend to be made of new communists that are just beginning to get organised. In this sense too, it marks a great step forward from the self-described supporters of Gonzalo Thought who congregate online as these communists, even if not fully broken from individualism, have begun to organise in the real world. It reflects a genuine desire to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada among a growing number of workers and the progressive petite-bourgeoisie. In these ways, the development of new regional communist groups has been a positive development.
Failure on the Part of National Communist Organisations
Before discussing the errors associated with the regional communist parties, it is important to note that part of the reason for their existence is due to the failure of communist organisations that are building themselves nationally. With the exception of Toronto, most of these regional communist organisations have been built in places far from the activity of national communist organisations. For example, there is very little reporting from The People’s Hammer on the Maritimes or the interior of BC. The Gonzalo Thought movement is also far from a truly national force and is unrecognised outside of where its is directly active. Because of these weaknesses it is inevitable that small communist groups would emerge in regions that the communist movement is absent. Why should they try to affiliate themselves with a national communist organisation if they do not even know that it exists?
The fact that the national communist movement is partially to blame for the emergence of small groups is seen in the fact that when contact is made with the more advanced organisations, they are often open to two-line struggle and even organisational unity early on.
Liberalism, Decentralism, and Small-Group Mentality
While the formation of small groups is often a first step taken by communists when they do not properly understand the party and they are unaware of any national communist organisation, the preservation and consolidation of small groups reflects liberalism in the communist movement.
Small group mentality is an extension of individualism even if it superficially seems superior. One of the first hurdles communists need to overcome in reconstituting the party is the unification of all genuine communists in an organisation of struggle for the party. In order to build this organisation, communists need to forgo the consolidation of their small groups, carry out open two-line struggle between one another and among the masses, carry out joint action, and as soon as all fundamental divisions are resolved they must unite into a single organisation. In Canada, this task has now been completed with the formation of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) [CPC(RF)].5
Small-groups are very often opposed to two-line struggle. When one organisation raises a criticism of another, it is often ignored and they will instead rumour about the other organisation’s supposed dogmatism. This has been noted recently among both the “(New) Communist Party of Canada”6 and the Alliance of Workers and Students (Formerly Students and Workers for the Liberation of Palestine).
A correct ideological-political line can only be built through two-line struggle. It is the principal contradiction in the construction of the party, therefore it must be prioritised by all self-described communists in Canada.
A final major reason small group mentality often persists is due to a call for decentralisation. The construction of an all-Canadian party is a daunting task leading to many taking up the more manageable task of building regionally.
A second way decentralism manifests is that when small-groups become aware of a national organisation of struggle for the party such as the CPC(RF) and they agree with its programme and line, they refuse to rally to it.
Small group mentality rejects the struggle for the party in practice. It calls for the small groups to first consolidate themselves before any real struggle for the party can emerge. Oftentimes there are opportunists at the head of these small groups that want to preserve their position rather than lose it by uniting into a national organisation. Very few small groups will voice these as their reasons for placing the future of their group above that of the party, but it is clear that this is their line of construction even if it is unsystematised.
Reconstitution
If we are united on the need to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada, we need to abandon small-group mentality, liberalism, and decentralism. The party is a highly centralised organisation built vertically from the congress down to its cells. It is not possible to go from many regional communist organisations to a vertically constructed party. At best you may form some federation of communists, but it will not be a communist party.
This should be one of the main lessons the communists of today take from the Progressive Workers Movement (PWM) of the 1960s when compared to In Struggle (IS) in the 1970s. Like PWM, IS was originally confined to one city. Unlike PWM, IS set out with the intention of building nationally. Even while confined to a single city, it built itself and behaved as a national organisation carrying out agitation and propaganda on issues concerning workers across the country. Because of this, it was able to establish itself as a genuinely national organisation in only a few years while PWM remained confined to Southwest British Columbia.
Communists must understand that our principal task is ideological struggle among the communist movement and among the workers in order to unite the vanguard of the proletariat with the communism. This requires two-line struggle. Too many organisations in Canada hide away from two-line struggle when criticised. Others claim to recognise its importance, but say they do not have the capacity to carry it out. However, two-line struggle is the heart of the development of the party. It is the principal internal contradiction. Without it, it will be impossible to unite the communist movement in a single organisation. To cite a lack of capacity is simply a call to sustain and consolidate the small organisations so that at some future point we can debate.
To be fully clear, if an organisation is not able to conduct two-line struggle than it should not exist. It only acts as a barrier on the road to communism.
Conclusion
The development of regional organisations is in some sense a development and in another a backward step. If these regional organisations honestly want to reconstitute the party, they should 1) rally to the CPC(RF) if they generally agree with its programme and ideological-political line or 2) abandon the idea of consolidating existing groups and embrace two-line struggle in order to unite in a centralised organisation of struggle for the party.
To prevent the development of new regional communist organisations, it is the responsibility of national communist organisations to broaden their agitation and propaganda to address issues in areas far from where they are currently based. New local organisations under the centralism of the national communist organisations must also be quickly set up in these areas to prevent more unnecessary regional communist organisations from forming.
1 The Workers United Front of Toronto recently published a criticism of a regional group of this type. However, as the preface states they have since changed their name and are moving towards work among the proletariat: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/09/19/criticism-of-membership-of-the-students-and-workers-for-the-liberation-of-palestine-by-wuf-toronto/
2 We have previously written a criticism of the SICA line in Canada: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/
3 https://communistarchivecanada.wordpress.com/2017/03/12/statement-from-the-quebec-district-of-the-revolutionary-communist-party/
4 A criticism of the “(N)CPC” can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/
5 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
6 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/07/18/revolutionaries-struggle-in-the-open-not-hidden-with-rumours-by-wuf-vancouver/