The following article is a repost from the Workers United Front website. The original can be found here: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/10/10/dual-unionism-in-canada/
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
Presented here is the first installment of a two-part article on dual unionism.
Central Committee of the Workers United Front of Canada
Almost all on the ‘left’ agree on the need for industrial unions – unions that unite all workers of a common industry as part of a common union. However, they often disagree about the correct strategy to achieve this: dual unionism or boring from within.
What is Dual Unionism
Dual unionism is what occurs when a generally more advanced section of the labour movement separates from the existing labour movement to establish new “pure” unions. This separation is on the basis that the old unions are company unions, reformist, part of corporations, or because they are part of an American international. These dual unions’ approach to the old unions is to destroy them.
Dual Unionism in Canada
Dual unionism has existed in Canada for a long time. Its most prominent forms under communist leadership have been the Socialist Trades and Labour Alliance (STLA), the Industrial Workers of the World (IWW), the One Big Union (OBU), and the first couple years of the Workers Unity League (WUL). Others have existed as well under social-democratic leadership such as the modern Confederation of Canadian Unions.
The majority of dual unions in Canadian history have never been able to get off the ground. This was seen as early as the STLA. This organisation which was led by the Socialist Labour Party was unable to form a presence anywhere in Canada aside from a small group in Vancouver. In more modern times, the Revolutionary Communist Party attempted several times to launch the Revolutionary Workers Movement, but again it was never able to grow into a real force in the workers movement.1 Both of these unions failed to establish themselves for a variety of reasons. First, the communist movement had not fully united with the vanguard of the proletariat. This meant that the communists were not even able to remove the advanced workers from existing unions, only themselves. Second, both were launched in periods of lower class struggle in Canada. This meant that they did not get the temporary boost other communist-led dual unions initially received.
The IWW was initially very strong in Western Canada, but also fell apart rapidly. Like the STLA and the RWM, the IWW was launched when class struggle was at an ebb in Canada. However, it was able to grow for a period in Western Canada while the STLA and RWM did not for two main reasons. First, IWW thrived in the organisation of the unorganised, particularly itinerant workers who were ignored by the big Trades and Labour Congress-American Federation of Labour (TLC-AFL) unions. Second, the IWW’s strength in the west and weakness in the east was due to the fact that the TLC-AFL unions were far less established there, while many communist-led unions such as the Western Federation of Miners were among the first and most active unions in the region. This meant that these unions were coming against the TLC-AFL unions from a position of strength in the west, but one of weakness in the east. Despite these successes, the IWW also collapsed quickly due to their anarcho-syndicalist line, state repression, and their declaration of war on the old unions alienating many rank-and-file TLC-AFL workers.
The OBU was the most successful of the dual union attempts in Canada. Like the IWW it was based on the unity of communism and the vanguard of the proletariat in the west of the country as well as the existence of a revolutionary situation in the country following World War One. Another reason for its initial success was from the many years of work by communists and other class conscious workers in the TLC prior to the split. This allowed the OBU to not only bring over a small set of advanced workers, but also allowed them to transform many intermediate and backward workers into new advanced workers who then also left the TLC. The OBU’s collapse was a result of heavy state repression following the Winnipeg General Strike, the failure to organise the unorganised and instead focus on growth through raids, and their separation from the mass of workers.
The Communist Party of Canada’s WUL also suffered from a period of dual unionism when it was first launched. For the first few years of its existence, the WUL focused all of its attacks on the TLC and All-Canadian Congress of Labour. It would even defy TLC-launched strikes and accuse those who picketed of being scabs while they themselves would scab on the strike. After this initial period, the WUL embraced the strategy of organising the unorganised. Once they switched to this strategy, the WUL grew significantly and was at the forefront of all strikes during the depression.
Why We Oppose Dual Unionism
Dual unionism is a sectarian line in the labour movement. It relies on separating the vanguard of the proletariat from the rest of the class. This leaves the workers in the old unions at the mercy of the bureaucracy and opportunists. We see this clearly in how the OBU split affected the ideological struggle in the TLC. Prior to the split, the TLC was strongly pro-Bolshevik and pro-Spartacist. After the split, the TLC lurched far to the right. When the class conscious workers left, the opportunists filled this leadership vacuum.
Union work for communists is not mainly about building unions. If a union drive fails, but yields more class conscious workers it can still be counted as a partial success. By separating the most advanced workers from the mass of workers, we may be able to unite the advanced, but there is no way for us to bring up the intermediate and backward workers.
The alternative of pursuing a strategy of boring from within the existing unions ensures that communists and advanced workers are constantly among the mass of workers agitating them. We are able to rapidly counter the propaganda of the bureaucrats as it occurs.
Dual unionism is beginning to experience a renaissance as more and more self-described communists are turning their attention to the workplace. It is important to understand the history of dual unionism in this country and the strategy and tactics for organising workers in the workplace developed by the communist movement so that we can avoid the same old errors.
1The RWM’s manifesto can be found here where they clearly state their intention to launch dual unions: https://communistarchivecanada.wordpress.com/2014/08/01/revolutionary-workers-movement-manifesto/