This article is not a thorough economic analysis of the illegal drug economy or of addiction. The purpose of this article is to establish a stance on the current state of the nonprofit industry and the recent discussions around drug treatment and “compassion clubs” that existed in Vancouver.
It is our stance that the issues of addiction and reducing drug use in general are not systematically possible to resolve without a socialist state. This is principally because under socialism the state could take measures to dismantle the illegal drug trade and economy. The capitalist state is always one step behind the bourgeoisie of this industry in trying to either use police to conduct minor drug busts or introducing minimal social programs to try and mitigate the current opioid death crisis. Second, the nature of socialist production involves the participation of every member of society which will reduce the social alienation experienced from exploitation under capitalism. Alienation which stems from exploitation of the proletariat is what currently often leads individuals to experience isolation from their work and from their peers and towards using drugs to try and deal with these experiences.
The downtown eastside is the focal point of the drug crisis in BC because of the concentration and herding by police of homeless and addicted people there. What has resulted is the formation of an industry around homelessness and addiction through the nonprofits that line the streets of the neighbourhood. Nonprofits compete for public contracts and grants through the city and province. Many, like Atira have a privatized wing for their business which channels clientele from the non profit state funded services to private businesses where profits can be made from the same service.1 All the while these “supportive housing units” have deplorable conditions and poor fire safety leading to several buildings being burnt down.
Grants govern control of the recipient, how it’s given, surveillance over clientele and evaluation of its efficacy. These nonprofits are not neutral- instead they are state controlled and non profits that pose themselves as “oppositional” or “grassroots” are actually controlled through grants financially by the government they are liable to provide evaluation reports back to.
Among these, Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users (VANDU) stands out. From within VANDU developed DULF, the Drug User Liberation Front in 2021. This group started a “compassion club” to distribute uncut and no buff cocaine, heroin, and meth. Then, in 2023 an article from The Economist was published about the activities of DULF and public outrage ensued once it became public knowledge that the program was being paid for by public funds. Deceivingly, the provincial government acted surprised and arrested two lead organizers of DULF for drug charges. However, if we look at the publicly available information, the City of Vancouver, the VPD, and the provincial government were all informed about the activities of DULF.
In a 2019 City of Vancouver report submitted by Paul Mochrie on behalf of Sandra Singh the memo outlines how a paper by BC Centre for Substance Use calls for the creation of “compassion clubs”, how DULF is asking for an exemption from the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act in order to be able to sell drugs legally, how the Vancouver Coastal Health has a letter of support to DULF to do so. Ultimately, the exemption was denied to DULF but they went on to open the “compassion club” anyways using money that was awarded to them through provincial public funds.
A then-City of Vancouver Counselor, Jean Swanson, was documented to attend a joint VANDU and DULF rally where she handed out free drugs. The VPD reported on this rally in a statement where they claim that they are aware of the operations of DULF, supportive of their right to civil disobedience and harm reduction instead of enforcing the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act.2
What we can start to read from this is that DULF is not an independent activist operation suffering from state repression. Instead, they are puppets of the state they were doing research for. The fact that the VPD was aware of and decided to overlook the operations of DULF, plus the VCH’s endorsement and state funding, clearly shows that DULF was an operation for the state to test out a new project. The state funding DULF and establishing organizational ties with them is in order to co-opt the movement for decriminalization and generally the housing movement. The fact that two DULF organizers got arrested for drug charges is simply the response of the provincial government trying to maintain favour when their project was exposed. Acting surprised while funding and forwarding along this project only because a bourgeois paper published coverage of what they were doing.
In a 2023 communique DULF writes: “When it comes to preventing overdoses, the answers are scientific and simple: create drug user groups and safe use spaces in high needs communities, and then regulate the drug supply. All other action is lip service to a mountain of dead.”3
It is worth briefly addressing the actual strategy of DULF. First regarding addiction itself, I will refer readers to an earlier article explaining why even if the supply is clean, cocaine, heroin, meth are all still harmful to the body, addictive, and can lead to overdose.4 Opioids are the the leading cause of the overdose crisis going on right now. Harm reduction activists have pushed through naloxone training, overdose prevention sites, and have increased drug testing for fentanyl. However, there is a jump from testing drugs to deciding to sell drugs yourself like DULF has. First, it is not socially possible to organize all drug users because of how casual the relationship is to using drugs. Even if you provide a clean supply for drug users, on a small scale, as The Economist article opens up there are people who will mix in their own fentanyl. An alternative is much like alcohol, nationalization of the drug industry is a possibility. Second, selling drugs as a small operation promotes the continued use of drugs because it is not coupled with any other social services that can be provided on a national level like treatment options.
BC has decriminalized drugs and then slid back on some of it. The “Portugal Model” is often cited when referring to the BC policy. However, BC lacks a lot of what made the program in Portugal successful. Those components are a commission if someone had more than 10 days of drugs on them to see a mental health specialist on top of increased treatment programs and availability to attend the programs.5 Meanwhile, BC decriminalized drugs up to a certain amount but did not increase treatment options. In this situation there has been no notable change with use of health care resources including opioid treatment, overdose prevention sites, and drug checking.6
To summarize, nationalization of the drug industry alongside increased treatment options are necessary to put a stop to the opioid drug crisis. Chasing after provincial funding to become low level drug dealers is not.
1 https://vancouversun.com/business/local-business/peering-inside-the-atira-b-c-housing-scandal-with-staff-tenants-and-critics
2 https://vancouverpoliceboard.ca/police/policeboard/agenda/2021/1021/SP-5-2-2110C04-Drug-Distributing-Protests.pdf
3 https://dulf.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/02/2023-09-25.pdf
4 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/21/the-ncpc-and-the-drug-trade-by-bessy/
5 https://www.cbc.ca/radio/ideas/how-portugal-tackled-its-addiction-epidemic-to-become-a-world-model-1.5178848
6 https://www.bccdc.ca/health-info/prevention-public-health/decriminalization-in-bc
Responses to “DULF and the Opioid Crisis – By Bessy”
[…] reader inquired about a position expressed in the article Dulf and the Opioid Crisis, asking “Does the nationalization of drugs industry imply promoting selling hard […]
LikeLike
[…] 31 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/21/the-ncpc-and-the-drug-trade-by-bessy/ and https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/10/17/dulf-and-the-opioid-crisis-by-bessy/ […]
LikeLike