The People's Hammer

Criticism of the Programme of the Communist Workers Circle – By WUF

, ,


Preface to Criticism

In the spring of 2025 representatives of the Communist Workers’ Circle (CWC) met with the embryonic Toronto local of the Workers’ United Front of Canada (WUF) at a study session that the emerging local had hosted. Shortly thereafter the CWC presented the WUF with a yet to be published programme for our review. The WUF had drafted a criticism of this document which is below, the introduction of which being slightly revised to reflect the Workers’ United Front of Toronto’s now concretized position with the broader national Worker’s United Front as well our new partnership with The People’s Hammer, and was sent to the CWC in the early summer. We did not receive any official word from the CWC on our request to struggle for unity, despite several attempts to establish contact on this matter. At the same time, the CWC was in the midst of heavy state repression, taking the particular form of a dubious criminal trial of its leadership. Because of these circumstances the WUF felt it was particularly important that opening two-line struggle for unity began in order to advance the struggle of workers more broadly in the region by unifying our efforts where possible.

On two occasions following the delivery of the criticism, the WUF sent representatives to rallies held by the CWC which protested the trial, principally to stress the necessity of opening two-line struggle between our organizations, and secondarily to support the CWC in the midst of this repression. During the second occasion we were fortunate to speak with leadership on these matters. We were informed that, while the CWC did appreciate and admire our efforts to initiate two-line struggle as well as the general work of our organization, they “could not accommodate us at this time,” with respect to struggling for unity. We were later informed that they would not be initiating struggle in any capacity, despite the willingness of the WUF to wait until the circumstances of the trial had completely resolved.

The WUF upholds that our relationship with the CWC is non-antagonistic and, additionally, that we will continue to support them in times of acute crisis and repression. That said, however, our principal task is to struggle for the advancement of the workers’ movement at all times. The principal form of struggle is two-line struggle, and on this basis we maintain that the CWC is incorrect in its position on the matter. Because of this we are publishing this criticism in an open forum in the hopes that the CWC reconsiders its position. We also are hoping that the CWC publish their original document which will allow workers the chance to review it to provide their own criticisms to the benefit of their struggle. The WUF has made clarifications to particular points of criticism put forward in the general document that was sent to CWC, which we now realize may have been unclear. We would gladly accept criticism from the CWC on this matter should they deem it necessary.

Workers’ United Front of Toronto

Criticism of the Programme of the Communist Workers Circle

The Workers’ United Front of Toronto (WUF) would like to begin this document by extending our appreciation to the Communist Workers Circle (CWC) for allowing us to review these yet to be published documents. It is crucial that organizations such as ours engage in honest debate and open struggle in order to move toward the goal of reconstituting a genuine communist party and united front capable of leading the masses of Canada to socialist revolution. Towards this end, we would like to again request that some sort of public discussion between the CWC and the WUF occur. We have a working relationship with The People’s Hammer and would like to offer this as a venue for public discussion. If the CWC would like to put forward alternatives, either in addition to or in substitution of The People’s Hammer, we will co-ordinate accordingly. At times in this document we have quoted passages from general commentaries and the programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction), an emerging organisation also featured on The People’s Hammer with an ideological line we believe to be the most advanced in the country. Attached to this criticism will be the WUF programme for your review. We would like to hear your criticism of our programme in order to promote unity where possible.

1. What is the Communist Workers Circle?

  • This is a bottom-up understanding of building of the party; the Communist Party is principally national and secondarily local, while the inverse is advocated for in this document as the “Party” is being relegated to its reconstruction in Toronto.
  • There is no mention of a United Front or Red Army. Focusing on party alone and discarding concentric construction; additionally no ideological line is presented.
  • Historical materialism and hegemony of the proletariat are listed as pillars of practical activity. This former is idealist as this aspect of ideology does not inform organization at present. If what is meant by “Historical Materialism” as a practical activity is the study of the conditions of the workers, the term social investigation or class analysis should instead be used and their particular form as conducted by the CWC should be expanded upon. The latter is applicable as a precursor to socialism, specifically in the form of a united front which requires proletarian hegemony; however, this application is not advocated for in this document.
  • There is no mention of dialectical materialism.
  • Emphasis on Palestinian activism in particular is slightly misplaced. Canadian communists should focus principally on toppling Canadian imperialism, and this should take the form of the nations that Canada most directly oppresses. This includes, but is not limited to, nations bound by the Indian Act, the Inuit, and Acadians internally; Haiti, Latin American, and African nations externally. Palestine should of course not be ignored; however, Canada is more directly involved in the subjugation of the aforementioned nations and should be understood as the main targets of anti-imperialist struggle in Canada.

2. Definition of Membership

  • “A member… belongs to at least one industrial fraction…” What is meant by industrial fraction? Can non-industrial proletariat (such as service workers) not participate in the CWC? If so, why?
  • “Members conduct themselves in accordance with the most advanced traditions of the labour and socialist movements, as well as the most democratic aspects of bourgeois culture and the communist aspects of Indigenous cultures. In their presentation and sensibilities they meet or exceed the norms for employment in manufacturing.”
    • The first piece makes sense, but why should members conduct themselves according to any bourgeois norms or the non-dialectical understanding of Indigenous communism if they are what we aim to overthrow?
    • The point about meeting or exceeding norms for employment is odd. Is this so that members can secure jobs in these areas? Even if this is the case, communist work will inevitably conflict with this the moment they begin organizing in their workplaces.

3. Principles of the Communist Workers Circle

  • References to imperialism state only “finance” rather than “finance capital” throughout the document. These have a very important distinction. Finance capital, as described by Lenin, is the merger between bank and industrial capital. This is the basis of imperialism: the merger of the two and the exportation of this newly created finance capital. The absence of “finance capital” from the documents appears to create several issues in the understanding of political economy presented. These will be explained in later points.
  • “… the truly human stage of history.” is a humanist claim. There is nothing inhuman about primitive communism, slavery, feudalism, capitalism, or imperialism as these are all human developments. Communism is not to be fought for on a moral basis. It is fought for on a scientific basis.
  • “Communist Workers Circle bases itself on the philosophy of historical materialism.” Why historical materialism and not dialectical materialism? This suggests an incomplete understanding of communist philosophy.
  • The document states that, “the world’s only manufacturing superpower is the People’s Republic of China,” but what is meant by “manufacturing superpower”? There are imperialist nations other than China which dominate various sectors of industry and, globally, US imperialism is still the most dominant force. To ignore the manufacturing of the other imperialist nations and give China the label of the “only manufacturing superpower” is factually incorrect and oversimplifies inter-imperialist competition. To quote from the international line of the CPC(RF): “Today, there is a tendency within the ICM to diffuse the notion of power so broadly that the quality of a superpower disappears. It is reminiscent of how the bourgeoisie label countries an ‘energy superpower’ or a ‘superpower of soft power’. We must oppose this tendency as it obscures the reality of the international situation. This occurs most frequently in discussion of Russia as a ‘military superpower’ in 2023. We must remember that when the PCP first labeled Russia a ‘military superpower’ it was just after the collapse of the USSR. In this period Russia was no longer a superpower but still had much of the military arsenal it had in the last days of the Soviet Union. In this situation it is logical to say the country has the military strength of a superpower without including it as a superpower alongside the US. After 30 years, we cannot claim this is still the case. Russian imperialism has declined since and has not rebuilt itself. Many of the semi-colonies Russia was previously the dominant power within have since become principally Chinese or principally American semi-colonies. It does still have a massive nuclear armament on paper, but these alone do not raise modern Russia to the level of a ‘military superpower,’ nor does it have the military strength characteristic of a superpower. Many factors prevent the use of nuclear weapons by those that possess them. Firstly, the nuclear monopoly has been long broken preventing their use in inter-imperialist war and in several wars against oppressed nations. Secondly, nuclear weapons undermine the purpose of war for the imperialist powers in expansion, occupation, and centralisation of capital. The imperialists want to conquer a greater portion of the world and the wide-spread use of nuclear arms leaves no possibility of exploitation.” This appraisal of China is one of the failings of political economic analysis due to the lack of an understanding of finance capital.
  • The classification of the world as “unipolar”, dominated by US imperialism, is an oversimplification. US imperialism is the dominant imperialist force, but it faces competition from other imperialist forces. They do not all happily cooperate to support US domination. We will provide a few more sections from the international line of the CPC(RF) on this question. “From the 1990s onward, the people of the world were faced with a general counter-revolutionary offensive (GCRO). This offensive was based on a counter-revolutionary united front led by US imperialism in alliance with other counter-revolutionary classes and strata. The GCRO was characterised by an anti-Marxist offensive ideologically, fascism and post-modernism on the level of politics, generalised global low-intensity warfare militarily, and a neo-liberal economic policy. Under the GCRO, unity between these forces was primary and struggle secondary. However, this unity was unstable and the counter-revolutionary united front crumbled under its own contradictions aided by armed struggle and people’s war. Today, the GCRO is broken and struggle is again principal in the inter-imperialist contradiction as it is in general. The principal inter-imperialist contradiction today is seen between China and the United States. Russia and China have often partnered to undermine the United States, but the weakening of Russia in the invasion of Ukraine may lead to Chinese domination of Russia in the same way as the US dominates most other imperialist powers. The US wants continued access to the Chinese market, but not the export of Chinese capital. China and the US today are capturing different national movements in the third world to undermine each other. China is looking to capture Afghanistan by providing funding for abandoned NATO projects in the country as well as expanding others. The US is providing extensive aid to Ukraine against the Russian invasion. In the Ukraine War, Chinese eyes are set mainly on Russia looking to dominate the country as it is weakened on the battlefield and by the departure of capital from the US and other imperialist powers. For China, whether the US or Russia become dominant in Ukraine is secondary to the capture of Russia. Other sites of intense inter-imperialist struggle are in the Philippines, Vietnam, and the Middle East. In the latter, Iranian backed armed groups have been actively targeting American military presence. The breaking of the GCRO is only beneficial to the proletariat and the oppressed nations. It means that the united offensive against the proletariat will in part be lifted as the imperialists focus more attention on each other. This presents us with a greater opportunity to reconstitute the communist party and prepare for people’s war. It also provides us with a number of splits in the inter-imperialist contradiction to take advantage of. The GCRO is a tactic that has been carried out at various points in history. The most clear example occurring just after the Paris Commune leading to relative passivity that was not broken definitively until 1917. It is likely that the different imperialist powers will attempt to reforge an international counter-revolutionary united front particularly during a future high tide of world revolution.”
  • “Though the People’s Republic of China and four other socialist states remain, they preside over economies that are mixed rather than socialist.” Claiming they are socialist states but do not have socialist economies is contradictory. Mixed economies do not exist. Following Deng Xiaoping’s leadership from 1976, China became a capitalist state-monopoly and eventually an imperialist power. The other nations mentioned later (Vietnam, Laos, Cuba and the DPRK) have never held socialist economies and all operate under state-monopoly capitalism. All these nations merely use the guise of communism to secure state power over industry. There is nothing socialist about their government structures or economies.
  • “…the subordination by the United States of its imperialist rivals both militarily through NATO and economically through the IMF and what became the EU.” All imperialist nations are not subordinate to the US. America is the principal imperialist power which collaborates or is in contention with other imperialist powers.
  • “At the same time, the American ruling class and its vassals are unable to maintain the standard of living that has been crucial for the preservation of class peace…” Class peace does not exist. Applying this idea to the first world is third-worldism and assumes the proletariat of the first world are not in direct conflict with the owning class outside of times of economic crisis.
  • Deindustrialisation is not a real phenomenon. This error is likely informed by small group mentality focusing entirely on Toronto at this time. Industry over time has changed within and moved out of Toronto, but it has not disappeared from Canada. If the imperialist nations were to undergo deindustrialisation and maintain their economies domestically on purely liquid capital they would collapse in short order.
  • Quebec
    • Of the Upper and Lower Canadian revolutions it was the Upper Canadian revolution that was more advanced and based in an alliance with the workers. The Lower Canadian revolution was much more conservative as evidenced by its leader being a seigneur.
    • North-West Rebellion was not a French-Canadian thing. It was made up of the Métis, other nations, and local farmers.
    • The Quiet Revolution had nothing to do with workers coming to power. It was principally a bourgeois movement.
    • Focus on Quebec ignores other more important events outside of Quebec like the Canadian Labour Revolt, especially the Winnipeg General Strike, the On-To-Ottawa Trek, Communist control of Blairemore, the Solidarity Movement, and some others.
    • The piece on anti-Quebecois racism needs to be substantiated.
  • Calls for self-determination rather than the right to do so. Applying this error towards Quebec seems to be informed principally by a misunderstanding of what constitutes an oppressed nation and imperialism generally.
  • Canada and Quebec are not mentioned anywhere as imperialist nations.

4. Three-Point Programme for Workers Republics

  • Worker councils with a basis on housing are an incomplete break with bourgeois representation on locality. It should not be based on unions either. Worker councils must be established based on industrial units.
  • “Incorporation of Indigenous stewardship into economic planning on a modern, scientific basis.” This can be manipulated into concessions for the Indigenous bourgeoisie.
  • A contradiction emerges in this section with earlier statements on self-determination of other nations in prior sections. Here it claims independence for Quebec and the right to self-determination for the other nations.
  • Many Indigenous nations have adopted French or English as their national language through colonisation. We should not push for them to readopt their old language as this is a demand found almost exclusively among the petite-bourgeoisie. These languages should have equality if it is a national language.
  • The “right to bear arms” is qualitatively different from the arming of workers. The right to bear arms is a concept originating in the bourgeois revolutions to protect one’s private property, whereas arming of workers is the first step in the capturing of state power by the class.
  • “… close collaboration with China, Vietnam, Laos, Cuba and the DPRK.” This error is informed by the incorrect conclusion these are socialist nations.
  • “Comprehensive secular and progressive social policy, including full legal rights and recognition for racial and sexual minorities.” “Sexual minorities” requires a concrete definition. Are “full legal rights” informed by the bourgeois legalist understanding? Needs clarification.
  • What is meant by “obligatory labour”? Socialism calls for all who are able to work. There would be no way to make a living without working, so there would be no reason to force work.
  • “Full stipends for athletes and artists.” Why? Professional athletes are not productive members of society. There is no reason for artists to receive stipends for the commodities they produce when they are neither more or less socially necessary than, say, a video-game console, for which there would be no reason to provide a stipend for its production.

General Criticisms

1. Little is mentioned of the conditions of Toronto or Canada.

2. There is no distinction made between a minimal versus maximal programme.

3. Many positions on worker councils and revolution are informed by economism rather than a full understanding of political-economy.

4. There is no mention of the Chinese revolution or the ideological advancements which came from it.

5. The document generally breaks from historical materialism with its failure to analyze the development of the USSR and China as well as its misunderstanding of social-imperialism and socialist political-economy.

6. The document fails to make a concrete definition of the proletariat and narrowly defines them as “property-less wage-earners, especially those concentrated in manufacturing.” This definition focuses on one sector of proletarians without purpose and allows for mechanical insertion of some strata of the petite-bourgeoisie who are propertyless wage-earners to constitute as proletarian despite their non-socialized forms of labour. This error of class analysis could be why a united front is not mentioned anywhere in the document.

7. Socialism is defined only as a “lower stage of communism” and not as the transitional period between capitalism and communism. This misunderstanding of socialism and its potential for capitalist restoration could be what informs the position on China, Vietnam, Laos, Cuba and the DPRK.

8. Use of bourgeois and humanist vocabulary and sentiments throughout the document. Words and phrases such as “rational” “compassionate” and “truly human” are unscientific and break from material analysis. They have no place in an organizational programme.