General
Would you like to introduce yourselves to our readers?
EM – I’m a tenant living in the Grandview Woodlands neighbourhood. I joined the VTU in late 2018. At the time I was feeling very alienated and depressed about the overall shape of politics in Vancouver specifically and the imperial core more broadly, and I’d just been demovicted the year before. I thought to myself that I had a choice to participate in a movement that pushed back against the oppressive forces that dominate our world or to resign myself to feeling lost and alienated for the foreseeable future. I wasn’t sure what kind of organization to join but I ran into someone recruiting for the tenants union at a local music venue and decided to check them out. Seven years later and I’ve contributed a great deal to this organization, helped build it from a loose collection of working groups into an org with 8 active chapters, done a lot of work I’m really proud of, and most importantly my understanding of what it means to contribute to a revolutionary movement has been shaped by practice.
BG – My name is Ben Ger, I live in the Four Sisters Co-op in Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside, and I’m also a member of the Vancouver Tenants Union. We don’t have a formal Chapter in my neighborhood and instead work through a coalition of groups called Our Homes Can’t Wait (OHCW). I spent a few years working through OHCW but ever since I switched jobs and now have a conflict with their meeting time, I’ve been attending the VTU’s East Side Chapter with Evan. I’m also the Union’s Chapter Coordinator, so I bounce around; most often to support our West End & Marpole chapters.
I got involved in the union in 2019, after moving to Vancouver a year earlier. I was initially introduced through activist & rabbi, David Mivasair. He was working with Independent Jewish Voices (IJV), who I reached out to to get involved with when I first got into town. Later, he introduced me to Jean Swanson, the socialist soon-to-be city councillor who was running with the Coalition of Progressive Electors (COPE). I don’t do electoral work anymore but I worked on that campaign in 2018 and learned a lot, including about the existence of the VTU, which also used to do some electoral work but has long-since moved on from that. I went to one training that the Tenants Union was putting on with Dolores Huerta, the founder of the National Farm Workers Association, and I was hooked. It’s been my political home and a large part of my community ever since.
What is the Vancouver Tenants Union and what does it do?
EM – We are a member-run, neighbourhood-based, non-sectarian union of tenants dedicated to fighting for better conditions for ourselves. We have 8 extant neighbourhood chapters in the Metro Vancouver area. In our context, a tenant is anyone who doesn’t own property or have control over their home, which includes our unhoused neighbors. We’re explicitly an organizing union and we take a revolutionary tack in our work, although this wasn’t always the case. We organize at the building, neighbourhood, and municipal level, and largely work to confront landlords directly.
BG – The union puts a heavy emphasis on the concept of autonomy. This means a few things: (1) we are financially autonomous, meaning we are funded by member dues and so are exclusively responsive to the will of our members, (2) we are politically autonomous, meaning we do not ally ourselves with any political party, critique them all, and remain firmly on the side of the people, and (3) have political goals that aim to create more autonomy for the working class in their day to day lives, such as through the abolition of landlords & rent, in favor of a self-managed housing system. You can read more about us in our Basis of Unity.
Your website says you reject the commodification of housing. We generally agree and call for the confiscation of all capital held by the bourgeoisie including in the form of real estate. However, we believe this requires a workers’ state to carry out, administer, and prevent the re-emergence of a market. What does the VTU see as a viable way to “decommodify” housing in the long run and what immediate demands does the VTU fight for?
EM – This is a big question! If I’m answering you personally I also agree that something resembling what we’d call a state is required to defend the confiscation/expropriation of capital and land by the working class. The nature of the state is shaped by the nature of the economic system that surrounds it (and vice versa) and so I feel it’s difficult to say exactly what shape that sort of entity will take in the kind of future we’re imagining in this question. In terms of immediate demands, to me this is one of those questions where the best answer is ‘we’ll see as we go’. I tend to take a more “Cabralist” attitude towards these things where the most important thing is grounding and changing your strategy and tactics based on local conditions. I chose to use Amílcar Cabral as a reference point just now, but you can find this attitude duplicated in many successful socialist movements outside of the imperial core because it’s effective. Concrete analysis of concrete conditions and so on. Win where you can and defend what you can of the wins. Don’t overextend. Hone your analysis as you go.
Our experience in the early years of the union has taught us that making demands of the liberal democratic state when we can be comfortably ignored is a misuse of our time and energy, because even if we can – for example – get a law passed or changed that purports to help tenants, the city and/or province won’t bother enforcing it in a meaningful way because it doesn’t benefit developers or landlords. So our list of demands could say things like “real rent control” and “landlords can’t forbid pets” or even “tenants can affect their own repairs and then bill landlords for the cost of the repair” or “tenants have a right to coordinate rent strikes” but we know that these things won’t be enforced properly even if they’re written into the law. As a revolutionary union what we’re ultimately demanding and fighting for is direct, democratic control of our buildings and neighbourhoods. That isn’t workable without overturning the existing political economic system. As we try out different strategies and tactics as a group, our understanding of how to approach our goals will keep evolving.
But with respect to your framing above, I’d say within the union there are certainly a variety of opinions on the role of the state in the context of your question, and that currently there isn’t a single unifying understanding of what the most viable path would look like, so I can’t really answer for anyone else, or for the union as a whole. I can say that our shared understanding within the union pins the blame on the overarching capitalist system of private property, on capital’s drive to both recapture the wages of the working class and control access to land through ground rents, and on the system of colonialism and imperialism that built this wretched country in the first place. All these things need to be understood, confronted directly, and ultimately destroyed in order for housing to be de-commodified. That’s my choice of phrasing and terminology, but I think I’m safe in saying that’s in line with our Basis of Unity and in line with our understanding of what is needed long-term.
BG – I largely agree with Evan. The Union is a pluralistic revolutionary organization by design and we welcome a wide range of perspectives. For whatever it’s worth though, I believe many of our disagreements are often more a matter of diction than actual strategy or goals. What is a State? If we are to take Malatesta’s definition of the word, for example, we could observe that a State is made up of 3 composite parts; one military, one bureaucratic and regulatory, and one political and legislative. It is also an organ that claims a monopoly over the only legitimate use of violence. If one was to divest the State from one or more of its composite parts, is it still a State? If the military arm was to be made directly accountable to people’s councils, could both our libertarian and more state-oriented socialist factions agree on a path forward? If the political and legislative arms were to be transformed from representative, liberal-democratic institutions into directly democratic federations of producer and consumer associations, revolutionary groups, and neighborhood councils, would we all find this formation palatable? I’m not so sure of the answer exactly, as I too, like Evan, believe in a more iterative approach. But, like our comrade Q says, I believe that there is a path forward that we can all swallow, given enough time & discussion. This is a hot topic in the VTU though, as various organs of the union have been studying, for example, the Zapatistas and MST for lessons in more autonomous, decolonial, and less denominational approaches.
What are some victories the VTU has won?
EM – We’ve had some big successes keeping tenants from being displaced, or in getting them new homes they can still afford even if they are, or in getting building repairs done and taking control back from landlords and property managers. And prior to reorienting in 2021 we were also instrumental in getting the Tenant Relocation and Protection Policy (a Vancouver City ByLaw) passed. That sort of bylaw change is no longer our primary or even secondary focus for many of the reasons I touched on in my answer to the previous question.
I want to focus on a couple campaigns I think are emblematic of our current orientation as a union, and show that the horizon of possibility for tenants under threat from their landlords is wider than we might think it is. The first case is the 1177 Tenants Collective, who organized two successful campaigns against their landlord (Andrzej Kowalski) who planned to convert their 3 story rental home into luxury condos with fewer units than already existed in the building. First, the tenants were told in 2024 that they’d lose their homes, as the redevelopment would completely demolish the building. They used a strategy of directly pressuring Kowalski, trying a variety of tactics to successfully pressure him into abandoning his plan for redevelopment. Building neighborhood support was critical to this process. To that end, initial tactics included holding block parties, and installing a large lawn sign that resembled the city’s redevelopment signs. Once we built a base of supporters, the tenants enlisted the union’s help with a “phone zap campaign”. Supporters called en masse to disrupt Kowalski’s places of business (he owned his own business and also owned a stake in a second one). The end result of this was that he gave up his stake in the second business and dropped his plans to redevelop.
The intense and very public negative attention brought on by the work the tenants did also resulted in increased city government scrutiny for Kowalski’s redevelopment permitting process. The city closed a loophole in their redevelopment rules that allowed him to try to rebuild with fewer units on the property, which forced him into abandoning the project entirely. It was a clear victory and the tenants got to stay.
A few months later though, Kowalski came back with a scheme to evict the oldest and longest term tenant by claiming he needed to move a caretaker into the building. The tenants and the community fought back once again, this time prepared by their first round of struggle. They started with a collective letter saying that the tenants did not want or need a caretaker, followed by a community email campaign directed at the landlord, demanding the eviction be dropped. Again, the tenants won, in this case at the RTB hearing. In both fights, the tenants outplayed the landlord by strategizing and acting together, which left him floundering. Both times he made critical errors in judgement that resulted in his loss and their win. And both fights resulted in more tenants from the building and the community becoming leaders not just within the campaign but in the VTU at large; it grew our movement.
The VTU’s first big fight after redefining ourselves as an organizing union in 2021 was also an anti-eviction fight. An elderly tenant and her family living at Carolina & Broadway were being evicted by a land development company called PortLiving. The legal process had already completed, and there was an enforceable eviction date set. The union developed a strategy with the tenant to do a community bailiff block/picket line and prevent the eviction from taking place, in order to get some leverage for negotiation between the tenant and the developer. Even though the demolition was going to happen eventually, our bailiff block worked, we got a lot of media attention because of a road block we did at the intersection, and in the end the developer didn’t even send anyone to try and enforce the eviction order. They capitulated and started negotiations with the tenant. This was a valuable lesson for the union, which had done individual eviction support before, but spent a large amount of energy on trying to change city policy in tenants’ favour, only to see those policies left unenforced. We began to see the extralegal route to building power and confronting landlords directly without the mediating, deradicalizing forces of the municipal and provincial governments as the only viable strategy towards improving conditions for tenants.
The last fight I’ll talk about is an ongoing campaign to stop an eviction in the Kensington-Cedar Cottage neighbourhood. Abby Leung is a tenant who has rented part of a single family home for over 18 years. In early 2024 her landlord tried to raise her rent by 42%, and when she refused, the landlord first claimed she needed to evict Abby to move a family member into the unit, and then changed her story to say that she needed the unit herself because she’d injured her foot (Abby lives in the ground floor unit of the same house as her landlord). Abby has been fighting hard against her landlord’s bad faith eviction attempt with the help and support of VTU’s East Side Chapter. Though the fight has been difficult, she’s still in her home a year later and we’ve learned a lot about what it means to fight an eviction in a single family home. The union is asking questions like ‘how do you rally the community around just one or two tenants?’ ‘how do you do that in a neighbourhood with few rental apartment buildings, where most renters live in basements and don’t know each other?’ A great deal of Vancouver looks like this, and if we want to become a fighting force for tenants there, we need to hone our strategies and tactics and answer these questions to the best of our ability. Abby’s campaign is active, so interested readers who want to get involved should check out the campaign page and get directly connected, especially if they live in the neighbourhood. https://www.vancouvertenantsunion.ca/defend-abby
BG – I have been involved in a bunch of different winning campaigns, but I’ll stick to highlighting 3 for the sake of this article. First, in Mt Pleasant, there is a building the collectivized with the Union, under the banner of the Prince Edward Renters Collective (PERC). The building unionized after the landlord put the property up for sale, but found out soon after there a lot of them shared serious maintenance issues as well. One woman, the tenant with the longest tenure in the building, revealed that she had not had heating in her unit for 4 years, which prompted two others to confess that the heating in their units had been on-and-off for one. As well, all the tenants identified a general pest problem across all of the units. Through two rounds of struggle, utilising the tactic of a collective letter, signed by a super-majority of residents in the building, tenants were able to pressure their landlord into fully restoring heating to the units & addressing the pest problem.
But the part that is so exciting to me about that group is the move from reactive struggles to proactive outreach into the community & the claiming of new territory within the building. Following the first round of struggle, tenants got together for a visioning session of sorts, where we all answered the question “if you collectively had full control over your building, what would you do with it & what would it look like?” The two things that were identified were (1) that tenants wanted to share resources more collectively, which they envisioned as free shelves in the lobby, and (2) the tenants wanted to build a community garden and common space for themselves & the neighborhood. Tenants agreed that if they asked the landlord for permission to do either, that they would be told no. So the decision was made to do it regardless and defend them if the landlord attempted to retaliate. As was expected, the landlord did in fact try to stomp out their garden, but was met with on multiple occasions by delegations of tenants, who joined together to directly confront the landlord.
Today, the garden at the corner of Prince Edward and 15th is in full bloom, adorned by a large plaque reading “Prince Edward Renters Collective”, a community free store, propaganda box, and art. And the shelves in their lobby are in constant use. The building holds an annual block party for the neighborhood to encourage others to organize their building.
The second fight that comes to mind is the Plan A No Way campaign we ran last year, in Vancouver’s West End neighborhood. Funny enough, the lead came to us via a member of PERC, whose aunt-of-sorts lived in a building that had recently been sold to the infamous landlord, Plan A Real Estate, owned by Anoop Majithia. Marie, the original contact and a key leader in that building, quickly gathered her neighbors to come up with a plan to defend their homes. The first move was for the tenants to send a good-faith letter, introducing themselves as a collective and rejecting the landlord’s illegal demand that tenants sign new leases. The tenants won their demand and retained their original leases, but Plan A did not stop there. The following year was filled with a constant barrage of eviction notices (often new ones being sent as soon as the old one was defeated or, in one case, multiple at the same time), dirty tactics (using registered mail to deliver every single communication and, when it was missed, claiming that the returned mail in every case just happened to be the eviction notice), illegal surveillance (hiding a camera inside a fake smoke detector), and harassment.
In response to the barrage of attacks on tenant & their homes, we held rallies, phone zaps, emails zaps, and more. We doorknocked in buildings owned by Plan A across the city, defeated attempts to withhold keys from tenants’ partners, and turned away tow trucks attempting to remove vehicles from guest parking spots. This campaign was filled with both wins and losses, as some tenants were successfully evicted while others we managed to collectively defend. But the lessons from the campaign & leadership developed amongst tenants in the building remains the most encouraging component. Jonathan Petrov, a tenant leader, comrade and friend from the building, for example, has become a key member of the union’s West End Neighborhood Chapter, and is now helping other tenants organize their buildings too.
Last but not least, I’ll talk briefly about the Portland Tenants Union. PTU is the name of a tenants association located in a building called The Portland Hotel, owned and operated by a Not-Profit called Portland Housing Society (PHS); both of which are located in Vancouver, not Portland. The building is located in the Vancouver’s Downtown Eastside neighborhood and is operated as “Supportive Housing”. In short, this means tenants enjoy considerably less rights, with residents often comparing the experience of living there to prison. After their elevator had been broken for 8 months, and 5 tenants died in the stairwell, the tenants organized with the union to demand immediate repairs. After a single majority-signed letter delivery & protest action, where tenants went to their landlord office accompanied by media, the landlord fixed the elevator within days. I’ll leave it at that for now, as plenty of ink has already been spilled about the campaign (see the Mainlander article, here).
The tenants movement in Canada is very decentralised often with multiple competing unions in a city like Montreal. Why do you think this is and what prospects are there for transforming the tenants movement into a united national movement?
EM – I think at least part of this answer lies in how fractured ‘the left’ is within Canada. Some of the separate tenant orgs within the same city (Toronto or Montreal come to mind) that I’m thinking of seem to have radically different understandings of how to go about fighting these sorts of fights. I’d say though, that that might not be the primary contradiction here and that the fragmented, alienated society we’re living in is probably the main thing driving how fragmented the tenants movement is. I would also characterize the contemporary tenants movement as being in its infancy. Most higher profile groups are pretty new in political terms. VTU has heard from two or three organizations lately that aim to connect and even support tenants unions across the country, and I do think this a natural progression of the state of things as inequality skyrockets and more isolated groups start asking ‘how can we expand what we’re doing beyond our local context’. These orgs are in their infancy too though, and it remains to be seen what the nature of their political orientation is and how effective they will be. I agree with what Ben points out below, that context is primary here and a more unified movement will still necessarily use different strategies and tactics in different locales. Our goals as a movement I think are naturally converging as more and more people are squeezed into more and more precarious situations, as reflected by recent attempts to connect tenant unions nationally and share information between them.
BG – Ya, agreed on all fronts. Though I would not characterize the decentralized nature of the tenants movement as something that necessarily needs to be done away with in order to transform the tenants movement into a coherent national force. In the union, we have been contending with the question, “how do we become less centralized, but closer together” and I believe this is a question our entire movement could benefit from. Especially in the current political moment, characterized aptly by Evan as being in its infancy, allowing for experimentation, as well as tactical and structural differences in accordance with locale, I believe is crucial. It is true that at the end of the day we are facing off against Real Estate Capitalism regardless of where in Canada we are. But the social & geographic terrain, local histories, and ways in which the State and Capital work together to suppress social movements sometimes differ quite dramatically. In Ontario, for example, the regulatory regime in place allows for considerably more time between an eviction notice and actually being evicted, allowing for different tactics to be exercised. As well, because of the urban geography, (massive apartment buildings concentrated in a single neighborhood) different types of organizational formation can arise and be maintained. In the meantime, I strongly believe groups like the Autonomous Tenant Union Network (ATUN) and the nascent Canada Tenant Power exist to help level the educational gap that exists across regions by creating room for discussion and coordination. We have already seen attempts to target landlords and developers across multiple cities and provinces arise from these initiatives. My dream is that someday in the future, something like a federation can be established amongst tenant & land-based resistance movements, including first nations and unions of the unhoused, where we can debate and establish a coherent program. But we shall see what occurs next.
Politics
Can you explain how the VTU came to the decision to denounce the provincial NDP?
EM – I believe you’re referring to our April 2025 Newsletter, in which our communications working group produced some commentary on the BCNDP’s changes to the notice period required for evictions, reducing it from 4 to 3 months in many cases. The party’s stated justification for this invoked the idea that the eviction process was being streamlined and made more efficient. This is one instance of many where we can see clearly that irrespective of the allegiances or rhetoric of individual rank and file party members or elected officials, the allegiance of the NDP as a whole lies not with the working class but with the developer and landlord class. In other words they align themselves with capital, in this case real estate capital. Presenting this change as efficient and positive shows that ultimately they wish to uphold the system of private property that has killed untold numbers of people through forced homelessness every year since it was formed. I like to remember the phrase ‘the purpose of a system is what it does’ when I think about systems like this, as it helps cut through rhetoric we often hear about “balancing” the desires of one group of people over the needs of another. In this case the purpose of the system that the NDP works within is to “balance” the desire of a landlord to have a freshly vacant property that they can rent at market rate against the human need for shelter. When someone is served a 3 month eviction notice because their landlord concocted some excuse and hopes to have them out so the rent can be raised more than the allowed yearly maximum, that system is working exactly as intended. The NDP happily reproduces this system each day.
BG – I would add that our position in this regard, like many of our beliefs, has developed out of practice. As Evan noted at the beginning of this interview, the VTU wasn’t always a revolutionary organisation. In fact, the organization was started in-part by a coalition of folks, some of which were more reformist and electoral minded. However, through hard lessons & internal struggle, we have transformed this Union from below into an organization focused on building organizing, base building, and direct action. But we can touch more on that history later on..
Does the VTU have this same attitude toward the federal NDP? What about toward the regional social-democratic parties like the Coalition of Progressive Electors?
EM – Yes, we do. We don’t support parties that work within the strictures of the existing political economic system for the same reason as we don’t advocate to the ruling governments (municipal or provincial) for changes to laws that we know won’t be enforced. Our rank and file members have reaffirmed this position several times. It wasn’t always the case that VTU maintained this kind of distance from political parties, but our collective experiences since our founding in 2017 have led us to this position. Now I’m departing from official union positions and speaking for myself: If a party has revolutionary potential, its members should understand and base their behaviour on the principle that participation in a liberal democratic system such as our municipal, provincial, or federal government is only useful when it 1) demonstrates clearly how ineffective these systems are at advancing the will of the people, and 2) they are vocal about this fact. Interfacing with that system can only be done effectively if the goal – exposing how said systems are intentionally designed to subvert and ignore the will/needs/desires of working people, and turning their efforts and energy towards building a new system that does – dictates strategies and tactics. I know of no municipal/provincial/federal party which passes that bar.
BG – Agreed. The VTU is an Autonomous tenants union, both financially (we are funded entirely by member dues) and politically (we do not align ourselves with a party). Evan is also right that there are a variety of political beliefs on the role of political parties in general. But regardless of these differences, we all agree that currently no meaningful, popular socialist alternative exists to the ruling neoliberal parties. This goes for the federal NDP too, who have been largely useless at demonstrating the corrupt and enemy character of the colonial government. Instead, they have chosen to collaborate with the deeply unpopular Liberals in order to achieve minor reforms that have bought them no favor with the working class at-large and only served to bolster the rise of the Conservatives. Allying ourselves with them would be the same as tying oneself to the anchor of a sinking ship.
Personally, I have a generally more favorable view of COPE, but the extent to which further collaboration would benefit movement organizations is still up in the air. In our view, the better we do our job the more these organizations will benefit by proxy, but they still need to be able to demonstrate an ability to win at the ballot box & the hearts of the working-class before collaborations could be seen as mutually beneficial rather than extractive.
How does the VTU intend to resolve the housing crisis if not through these parties?
EM – I know that the phrase ‘housing crisis’ is shorthand for the specific conditions we’re experiencing now (skyrocketing rents, loss of social housing stock, rapid inflation) but I’d like to point out to readers that there has been no end to this ‘crisis’ since the capitalist economic system and the post-feudal nation state formed each other in the 16th-17th centuries. If you read Engels’ The Housing Question it’s plain to see that the material conditions that contemporary tenants are subjected to are as much a crisis as they were in the last half of the 19th century. Our situations are broadly identical, only the minor details are different. When I think about how we are to escape this crisis, I think it is clear that more than a strong tenants movement is necessary. But it is also clear that with the overall decline of labour organizing in the imperial core and the movement of a great deal of finance capital from industry to real estate over the last half century, a tenants movement is constitutive to the kind of change that’s necessary to bring an end to our misery. Getting back to the point of your question: I think it is within this context and understanding that the VTU hopes to build a large enough tenant movement with enough power that we can affect control over buildings and neighbourhoods (and even cities) ourselves.
BG – I believe the answer to your question is three-fold. In the immediate, the Union’s role in “resolving” the crisis is by empowering tenants to transform the material conditions under which they live directly, through organizing with their neighbors. Fighting landlords for immediate gains is a deeply politicizing process that, crucially, we know we can win. Each time a building succeeds in stopping an eviction or forcing the landlord to do repairs, we add numbers to our ranks, teach tenants to take ownership over the solution to their problems, and inspire our neighbors to do the same. As more building organize, forming block & neighborhood-wide associations, more will be possible in terms of both tenant defence & self-managed programs. Fighting back deportation, like is being done in LA, planned food production & distribution program like was planned by the Berkley Tenants Union in the 70s (see here), rent reductions or permanent strikes will become possible and tangible ways of addressing the people’s concerns.
In the medium term, State concessions are extracted as the ruling class feels their interests, power, and capital threatened. For an example, we can point to the 1177 Tenants Collectives anti-eviction campaign. Not only did the landlord drop the evictions but, after public outcry, the municipal government closed the loophole that allowed their landlord to apply for redevelopment in the first place. Obviously, this would be easier done with a party that is more sympathetic to our cause, but I believe as our movement & ideas grow in popularity so will the electoralists benefit, as long as they do theirs. Our relationship to them if & when they gain substantive power will need to be determined.
In the long term, revolutionary change has to be on the horizon. Housing must be decommodified and the financialization of our homes must be undone if we are to solve the crisis. This necessitates an end to capitalism and that can only be accomplished when the balance of forces is swung away from the ruling class and towards mass movements of the people. I do not know the exact form this will take of course, but I think we can look internationally to get an idea of what the role tenant & land-based resistance movements can hope to occupy. In Venezuela, neighborhood & commune organizing is a key pillar of socialist construction. Chávez, for example, described the communes as “fundamental cells”. If we are to reorganize society around truly egalitarian and self-managed ideals, the people must have full control of both production and, crucially, re-production. The latter is where we come in. Organized and democratically self-managed buildings and neighborhoods, in the urban context, are the beating heart of where life is reproduced and sustained. In Venezuela, people go so far as to help plan and construct and service apartment buildings, in concert with organized trade union workers.
As LATU says, “Block By Block To a World Without Rent!”
Campaigns and Recent Actions
Can you explain what the Broadway plan is and why the VTU is organising against it?
EM – The Broadway Plan is the City of Vancouver’s mass eviction and redevelopment plan for the Broadway corridor. Broadway is a busy, commercial street that runs East-West through the entire city, and contains roughly 25% of our city’s purpose built rental. The official plan covers an area of a few blocks North and South of Broadway. It largely deals with regulations on rezoning and development permitting within that area, but also has plans for what City Hall would like the area to look like after the plan is completed. In the simplest terms, they want to build a second downtown along a large stretch of the street. To that end they are proposing zoning and permitting changes that will make it easier and less costly for land developers to get in on it. It’s already pretty easy, but the current government wants to make it even easier and more profitable. The whole thing is an attack on the working class, and this is why we’re organizing against it. If they are effected, the plans will cause a massive amount of displacement throughout the area in question, as well as in surrounding neighbourhoods. Thousands upon thousands of tenants will be evicted, and most won’t be able to access any kind of meaningful compensation through “proper channels”. Hundreds of buildings will be demolished, much of it purpose-built rental, but also a large number of single family homes that tenants rent. What’s replacing the existing housing stock will resemble most new housing being built in town already – luxury condo towers, luxury town homes, and a handful of market rental buildings which will be unaffordable to the tenants being displaced by it all. It’s a landlord’s & developer’s wet dream and a working person’s nightmare.
BG – This is part of a larger and renewed push the city is undergoing to try and shed what remains of its working-class and poor population. The Broadway Plan is certainly the most front-and-center, but it has to be viewed in concert with the Rupert & Renfrew Plan, the recently passed ban on new supportive housing development, the city’s decision to not renew land leases with many Temporary Modular Housing units & Co-ops, the provincial government’s decision to force upzoning near Skytrain stations, the stripping of low-income renters’ rights, and more. I also think it’s crucial we understand this moment as the breeding ground of a new ultrawealthy elite in the city. Developers like JTA Developments, spearheaded by James Tod, have accumulated dozens of enormous projects. If they all go through, the wealth amassed by these people will be unbelievable, and both the physical and political landscape of the city will be dramatically transformed.
We are organizing against it for these reasons, but also for something different. Though, like labor, we organize to address material concerns in moments of crisis, the goal is to forge a different idea of what the city could look like if working class & poor people were in the drivers seat.
The VTU appears to have begun organising more against evictions. Can you explain why this is and what tactics the VTU has found to be effective?
EM – I think we focus on evictions because they are the front line where tenants face homelessness, loss of community, loss of ever-increasing proportions of their wages to the landlord/developer class, etc. Broadly speaking, evictions are a mechanism of social alienation and atomization. I think this is reflected in the way we run our campaigns and our union in general. We put a good deal of our energy into building community within the buildings and neighbourhoods we organize because we find that without it, the kinds of fights we’re engaging in are less (or not) sustainable.
Importantly, evictions are also a kind of battlefield where landlords can be confronted directly. If tenants go through the Residential Tenancy Branch to fight an eviction, the liberal democratic state/party act as mediators between tenants and the landlord/developer class, and it’s quite clear that they do so to the benefit of the latter and the detriment of the former, so as tenants we may have more success in extracting concessions if we confront landlords directly as an alternative to that kind of mediation. For example, if the tenants in a building want something, and they set that kind of direct confrontation as their strategy, they can then try to choose a tactic that works best in their context. Tenants in the union have tried all sorts of different tactics, and they’ve all been successful (and not) in different contexts.
One of the simplest is writing a collective letter to the landlord demanding some kind of change. That’s pretty low stakes, and sometimes tenants don’t even sign individually, only as a collective. Escalating, extralegal tactics after sending a letter, in order of risk, could involve mass-calling a landlord’s place of business(es) and disrupting their day-to-day activities, calling a landlord’s financial backers and disrupting their business activities, picketing a landlord’s home or place of business and inviting the media to report on it, making changes to the property (ex. gardens, free shelves, etc) and then guarding them against landlord interference, or the highest risk activity: a coordinated rent strike. The riskier an activity is, the more crucial for the tenants to have a unified understanding of it, which is why we focus so much on making sure tenants in an organized building or neighbourhood know and respect each other.
BG – Evictions are a critical moment of crisis for the union. All struggles we engage in, whether about evictions or repairs, are fundamentally about fighting to stay in our homes. But an eviction is the most literal materialization of this. And, in our experience, the only thing that can keep someone from being evicted is collective power, so it’s quite radicalizing. I don’t think I have too much more to add on why we do this, since I believe Evan and documents like our Basis of Unity have addressed this well, so I can talk about some of the complexities our union is facing in this regard. In recent years we have taken a fairly loose approach to deciding which eviction cases we fight or buildings we organize. But recently we have been discussing more about whether single-family home campaigns are feasible in this regard. Sometimes you get a clearly winnable case, like in the case of Abby Leung & our Moving Is Not An Option campaign, but scaling up these wins is super difficult since they are usually just about a single tenant in isolation. The same goes for condos, where there may be multiple tenants but all with different landlords. In my mind, focusing on building-wide eviction campaigns, or at least eviction campaigns within an apartment building, needs to be our primary focus when we do take this type of campaign on.
Response to “Interview with Vancouver Tenants Union – By VTU & The People’s Hammer”
[…] 3. Read our interview with the VTU. […]
LikeLike