The People's Hammer

Interview with an Ontario Dollarama Worker – By Daniel H.

, , ,


Q: What are wages like at Dollarama?

A: Most people get paid minimum wage. Although there is a hierarchy where people can get promoted, the amount of raise that they get does not correspond anywhere near the new amount of responsibilities they are taking on. For example if you are being promoted from a regular worker to an assistant team leader your raise is 40¢, despite you having a lot more responsibilities.

Q: Is there anything else of note relating to wages?

A: They seem to be very petty about the hours to the point where sometimes they will deduct periods of less than ten minutes from your paycheque without explanation.

Q: Do you and your coworkers find these wages enough to live on in Toronto?

A: No, most of the workers are either students or children living with their families. Obviously, they cannot afford to live in Toronto on these wages. Generally, they do not complain because in general their impression is that “its a Dollarama job, it doesn’t deserve to be paid more. Blah blah blah.”

Q: So the idea is that if you want to be able to afford rent, you should get a different job?

A: Yes. It is kind of a sentiment that it is a job for young people who do not really need a lot of money.

Q: Do you know if Ontario has a separate youth wage?

A: Yes, there is a lower wage for youth. I do not know if this happens at Dollarama, but it exists.

Q: I know you said most of your coworkers do not see an issue, but have any of them complained to management seeking higher wages?

A: I do not know. In the time I have been there no one has said anything, but I feel like any normal reasonable person would be unhappy with a minimum wage.

Q: Other than wage, do you get any other compensation at Dollarama?

A: Other than the legally required minimum ones, we have a store discount that applies to your store and that’s it. There is also another worker that got a $30 gift card at Dollarama. So, the only benefits you get, you bring back into the store to get more money anyway.

Q: What’s the discount?

A: I actually don’t know actually what the exact number is – it’s not large. For example there was a worker I was cashing out and she saved 80¢ only.

Q: Some other low-wage low-skill jobs in massive monopolies like Starbucks have a much larger set of benefits like provision of some stock and health benefits. But, you do not get anything like that, despite the size of Dollarama even if its not a monopoly on that scale.

A: As far as I know, the benefits are minimal. It’s a Dollarstore that sells items that cost up to $5. Their way of making a profit is by making the working conditions as miserable as possible.

Q: What are the working conditions like? Do people get enough hours? Are they overworked?

A: The distribution of hours is completely nonsensical. For example, there is a hierarchy of workers where some workers have more seniority so they become full-time. Its like a privilege. Then there are the part-timers. Hours are distributed based on seniority so the more seasoned people get more hours and the less seasoned people get less hours. The logic of the upper management doesn’t make sense even to our stores management. For example, they shortened our stores hours in total, but than extended our stores schedule expecting us to work more – longer, but giving us less hours. Hows that supposed to work? Besides that the people who work there complain that they are not getting enough hours then Christmas comes around and instead of giving them more hours, they hire new people. How does that make sense?

I personally work part-time so I should be working 20 hours per week, but in practice I see less than that. Maybe I work two or three times a week. There are people who work two hours a week – or three or four, but they are children so maybe that’s okay.

A lot of people are working more than one job.

Q: Are the people working more than one job the adults?

A: Yes, adults in the sense that they are not high school students. In their twenties. They are principally students and come here on study permits, but their permits allow them to work off campus for some time and that’s what they probably do.

Q: You were talking about some security issues beforehand, do you want to explain those?

A: This store is extremely micro-managerial. It feels more like you are in a jail rather than a workplace. For example, we need to do bag-checks everyday as if we were in a diamond mine and not a dollar store.

Every action requires your fingerprint. For example when you want to clock-in/clock-out you have to use your fingerprint to prove your identity. If you want to void an item – any serious action where you need some trust, you need to prove your identity with your actual fingerprint. It is insane to me. Why do I not have the power to void items? Why do I need to go on the PA and call a manager to get their fingerprint to do a void.

Besides that, they have cameras everywhere and they have people employed full-time who watch your performance. They take screenshots when they notice you doing something wrong then send emails to the store with the picture attached saying “don’t do this.” How petty is that! There are people who got this email with a photo of them having a drink at the cash register, saying “no drinks at the cash register”. Who cares! Someone is getting paid a salary for just watching these cameras all day.

If you appear to not be doing anything, they will also notice this on the camera and take a picture of that and send you an email saying you should work more. For example, if you are a cashier and have no customers, you are expected to go clean up the aisles. For most people they don’t actually do that, but imitate doing it. Its a waste of effort and time pretending to be active.

Q: You also mentioned there is some expectation that you are to do theft prevention.

A: Because times are rough for everyone, much more people are stealing than before. So, we actually closed all of our self check-outs permanently. It wasn’t explicitly stated that we should prevent thefts because that is against store policy, but the manager has implied repeatedly that we as workers are responsible for theft and that we should confront thieves and tell people to not use their personal bags when they come in – nobody does this by the way, we should count every item and make sure they are not hiding items in boxes and whatnot.

No one in the store feels safe doing that. We are not trained to be security guards, it was not in our job description. Why should we be doing that? Frankly, people have simply ignored these orders from the management, but they keep insisting that we do that. We are pretending to be blind.

Q: Is your Dollarama unionised? Do you know if any others in the country are?

A: Mine isn’t and to the best of my knowledge there aren’t any that are unionised in the country. There have been some discussions on the internet about how it would be a good thing, but seemingly no action being taken towards that.

Q: Have your coworkers expressed any interest in a union?

A: There are people who are vocal about their dislike of the job, but they are not politically advanced enough to understand that something can be done about it because this is seen as a job for young people who are just starting out at life, there attitude is that “oh, I’ll just work here for some time and then I’m going to get a better job.” Especially the students who are studying are probably actually going to go get a petite-bourgeois or labour aristocratic position later. So, that’s their attitude mostly.

Q: If there was a campaign to organise Dollarama, what are some of the main demands you think would resonate with your coworkers?

A: I think better pay would be the number one demand. A second one would be reasonable hours and scheduling that is actually full hours and not just part-time hours. The workers would probably demand less scrutiny from upper management over minor infractions that should be irrelevant like again having a drink at the cash register, which is ridiculous.

Another demand would be for workers to actually receive training. Dollarama makes you watch a lot of videos about how your job should actually be done. But at most stores these videos are simply not shown to new workers at all. New workers usually get put on the cash register and they get someone to explain to them how it works. Then they stand and shadow them for thirty minutes before they abandon them to their own devices. If you are new or if this is your first ever job you are going to feel abandoned or thrown to the wolves basically. Often these people get fired because they are not good enough. Well, no shit you didn’t even bother to train them properly. That’s not fair in any way. Also another demand would be to remove the privileges from more senior workers. Because of the way hours are divided in the store is based on seniority. It is unfair and creates division among the workers and unfair advantage to some workers. Not only do senior workers get more hours and more stable hours, but also they get to do comfortable tasks like stocking and cleaning, whereas the new workers need to be on cash and be abused by customers all the time.

Q: Is there anything else you would like our readers to know about?

A: Fun fact: Did you know that Dollarama is an imperialist company? You might wonder which countries does Dollarama operate in? Apparently, Latin America in some countries like Peru and Ecuador there is a company called Dollar City which is identical to Dollarama in their branding and in the products that they sell. This is why if you go to Dollarama and you look at their packaging, it is written in English, French, and Spanish. Why Spanish? Because they ship them to our semi-colonies in Latin America.

Dollarama was established in the 90s in Quebec and the founder is Quebecois. So, not only is it an imperialist company, but it is a Quebecois imperialist company.

Also, nothing costs a dollar there anymore.