The People's Hammer

Interview with Sudbury Workers Education & Advocacy Centre – By Scott Florence and The People’s Hammer

,


The following interview was conducted by our editorial board with Scott Florence, the executive director of the Sudbury Workers Education & Advocacy Centre.

Economic Questions

Historically, the mining industry has been an extremely important part of the Sudbury economy. Is this still the case today?

    Mining and mining related industry (suppliers, etc) make up just under 1/3 of Sudbury’s economy. Just under 1/3 is government, we have a large federal force of CRA [Canada Revenue Agency] and Service Canada employees. Much of that work is seasonal, many of those workers are on short term contracts, many of which get renewed, and the hope that many of those workers have is that they will eventually become full time workers. The final almost 1/3 of the economy is healthcare and education. Just over 10% of the economy is in other industries.

    Mining still has a large cultural impact and presence in Sudbury. We still think of ourselves as a ‘mining town’ when we could just as easily think of ourselves as a government town, or a health and education town.

    Why do you think politicians in Sudbury have been trying to diversify the regional economy away from mining?

      The reality is that mining is never going to be the labour intensive operation that it used to be. Machines and automation do big chunks of the work. In addition, there are mines and possible mines throughout Northern Ontario that have great potential. Sudbury will gain some employment and economic advantage from the proposed Ring of Fire, but it won’t be the sole beneficiary. Sudbury styles itself as “the Gateway to the North.” Those in larger centres will scoff, but there are many people from across northern Ontario who consider Sudbury to be ‘the big city.’ When you come from a community of 1000 people or less, a city of 180,000 that has two universities and two colleges, two malls, and a Costco, well, that’s a big city. Many people credit that they only reason they got a university or college degree was because they could do it in Sudbury.

      Beyond the need to diversify the economy and the desire to build a bigger city in the north, there is also a cultural factor. Northerners are proud of being northern. They don’t want to have to travel to the south to get something. Their was and remains a fierce desire to build and maintain post-secondary education here to serve the people in the north, to train people in the north who will stay in the north.

      Social Questions

      Sudbury has one of the largest Francophone populations outside of Quebec. On the day-to-day, do the Francophone workers of Sudbury have access to all the social services they need in French? How has Doug Ford’s cuts o Francophone services in 2018 affected this?

        There is a strong and engaged Francophone population in Sudbury, who are well organized and integrated and are able to mobilize quickly and efficiently at threats, or perceived threats, to Francophone language, culture, and identity. As a recent example, when Laurentian University was undergoing the CCAA [Companies’ Creditors Arrangement Act] process and unilaterally ripped up the contracts that kept the federated universities together, they completely angered the Francophone community, who were serviced through the University of Sudbury. The community rallied and the University of Sudbury has just accepted its first students this year. The two other federated universities are still doing nothing at this time.

        Sudbury has a very large poverty rate compared to the national average while its unemployment rate is around the national average. Why do you think this is and what can be done to resolve it?

          Sudbury provides health and mental health services for communities across the north, which of course means that there are more people with needs who end up in Sudbury. Costs in the north are higher than in denser, urban areas. The ‘northern tax’ is the extra costs for food, fuel, and many goods because of the additional costs of transportation to remote communities. For many years, Sudbury was a ‘company town’ which meant that the mines also provided housing to the workers; you know they didn’t keep those prices low. Even though housing is now ‘free market’, housing in Sudbury is costlier than you would expect for a city of our size. There is a grassroots movement to create more inclusive and communal economies in the north. The real answer is better wages. The unions have shrunk in size and power. When there are larger infrastructure jobs, there are no protections that would ensure local workers are hired first for the job, which results in many workers being trucked in to do work while local workers sit idle.

          Organisational Questions

          Are the workers of Sudbury well organised in terms of both unions and other working-class organisations?

            Despite a proud history of strong unions, I would not describe the unions of today as being [strong].

            Following from the last question, have there been many major worker struggles such as strikes in recent years?

              The workers of Vale, formerly INCO, were on strike in this last decade. Vale is known internationally to be a hard bargainer and to work to strip as many rights as possible from the workers. Vale tried to put in place a two-tiered pension and health benefit system in place, as well as other tactics that would ultimately divide the workers. The union negotiating team recommended the workers accept the offer, fearing they would not get any better offers, and having managed to get concessions around wages. The workers categorically rejected the offer and sent the bargaining team back to the table, where they were able to negotiate a fair package for all workers.

              In the pandemic CRA strike, there was great solidarity with the unions here in town.

              However, overall, you seem the relatively same small group of faces out at labour events, and there does not always seem to be a unified voice or vision.

              What does the Sudbury Workers Centre do for the workers in the city? Do many workers participate in the organisation themselves or, are most of its members students and officials of local charities and unions

                We provide public legal information and education to workers, community support and client navigation to support workers who need to make claims, and we bring workers together to learn and share with each other. We have a particular focus on the needs of newcomers to Sudbury, as well as other communities that are generally overrepresented in low waged, precarious employment.