The People's Hammer

“The Conditions in the Union are Already So Much Better” – By Daniel H.



When we speak to our co-workers about the need for industrial unionism, workplace committees, a communist party, etc. this is often the response given. It is often true too, a union workplace will likely have better wages and conditions than a non-union workplace.

But, why should we be satisfied with this? No matter what our contract offers us, we are still getting robbed day-in, day-out by the capitalists. They are making millions and even billions by buying our labour for less than the value we create for them. All a union does is negotiate the rate at which we get ripped off. As union workers we may get fucked over less, but still we get fucked over.

Many immigrant workers have the same mentality. They often refuse to even join a union drive because “conditions are so much better here”. Like the union worker, this is true. Many of these immigrant workers are not super-exploited1 like they would be back home. If they are super-exploited, it is at a lower rate. Despite having the exact same rational for not wanting to fight for higher organisational forms, many Canadian union workers will be angry when immigrant workers refuse to fight for a union.

As workers, we need to reject this mentality that if our conditions are better than others, they are good enough. This is decreasingly the case anyway. Today, newly organised workers in low-skill industries can only expect a couple dollars above minimum wage by the end of their contract.

This “good enough” attitude only serves the capitalists. It prevents us from fighting for better conditions under capitalism (union drives, democratisation of the unions, industrial unions, etc.), but more importantly for the capitalists it prevents us from fighting for the instruments necessary do away with capitalism altogether namely a communist party and workers’ councils.

1 This where the ratio of labour-power sold to wages received is higher than for the average worker.