The People's Hammer

Interview with Miguel, an Undocumented Brick Mason – By Toby G. and Ivan D.

, , ,


Across British Columbia’s construction sites, thousands of undocumented workers labour in the shadows, raising towers, pouring concrete, installing the very infrastructures that power daily life; all while living with the constant threat of deportation. Their hands build the province, yet their existence is treated as disposable. In this issue, we bring forward the voice of one such worker, whose story exposes not only the brutal conditions faced by undocumented labourers, but also the broader system that relies on their exploitation.

Through this interview, we look beyond the myths and official narratives, revealing the real experiences of migrant workers in Canada: a higher level of exploitation hidden behind subcontracting chains, unsafe worksites where speaking up means risking both job and status, and bosses who use undocumented status as a weapon to discipline an entire workforce. What emerges is not an individual tragedy, but a picture of a working class divided by design, and the need for collective resistance capable of overcoming those divisions.

Ivan: What were the wages and benefits for the companies you have worked for? How do they compare to legal workers?

Miguel: There is a huge difference. Legal workers get paid sick days and get paid extra for overtime, medical benefits, unemployment insurance. With undocumented workers, we don’t get any of that. There is a bunch of employers who know we need work and money. We are humble workers coming from poor countries like Mexico, Haiti, Colombia, countries in Africa, Asia, and we have necessities. These employers know this and so they know they can offer tiny amounts because if we don’t take it, someone else will. Some guys I know are earning even below minimum wage. That is like slavery in the modern time. We were never even told we have a legal right to things like benefits or paid days off. Companies would shy away from the subject. They would just tell us where we were working, who was in charge, and where to work. Even though so much is unclear, if you are undocumented, you just do it. There are many of us with families back in the countries we came from facing hard financial times, so we will take what we can get. The employers take advantage of this situation. They are greedy and hire undocumented people to make easy money.


Toby: What are the general conditions of safety on the job sites you are on? Is it worse for undocumented workers?

Miguel: It’s so bad. The employers want work done as fast as possible so us bricklayers and labourers are always kept busy. The employers only ever think about square feet – how fast a job is moving. We have to rush and if we aren’t fast enough they will push us and say “you have to move, come on guys let’s go.” You can’t even stop to breathe sometimes. You burn out quick. It is an insane rhythm. They also make you work long hours too. I was often working for 7 days a week. In terms of safety, they just want stuff done. Sometimes we will be putting up scaffold in bad weather and they don’t care if we have adequate rain gear or if we are even using harnesses at heights. People are using machinery they are not ticketed for. Sometimes safety will come by but rarely, and never comment about unsafe things happening. A couple days ago I was cutting bricks with a saw, and the blade was garbage. It was worn out so it kept pulling and catching on the bricks which is very dangerous. I told my employer that I didn’t want to work with the blade because it’s garbage and he just kept telling me that the bricks needed to be cut right now. I told them I have a legal right to refuse unsafe work, and he said if I didn’t want to do it I could just go home and not come back. So I did it. It sucks because they were putting my life at risk. I could have easily gotten an injury. We often also don’t have respirators when cutting bricks which we should have. Another story is that I got sent to a different site and was told it was to be short term so I did not need my stuff. When I got there the first thing I was told was to mix [mortar] for the bricks. I told them I did not have my respirator because mixing generates a lot of silica dust, which is poisonous. They didn’t care. It is often that employers will treat us like this.

Toby: That’s awful. Is that treatment universal for all employers you have had?

Miguel: I have been to over 50 sites. Some employers are worse, some are better, but they are all burning you out and working fast, especially in masonry. Like I said, the companies always prioritise progress so when we don’t reach one of their incredibly high goals, they just view our work as wasting money.

I met this guy who was a labourer. He was new to work and they just started him on a bunch of things. He was supposed to mix cement. He likely didn’t have the training to use all of the tools and machines for him. He ended up cutting off 3 of his fingers. He was given no compensation or help. In fact, as soon as he was treated at the hospital, he was deported immediately.

Ivan: Did employers ever use your undocumented status as a threat? Were you ever threatened with deportation?

Miguel: No, but the companies would always underline that we are to keep our employment between us and them. The biggest companies in masonry always hire subcontractors and these subcontractors very often hire undocumented workers.

Ivan: What state repression have you faced being an undocumented worker? You have mentioned to us that the IRCC [Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada] has seized your passport?

Miguel: In my immigration case, they have seized my passport. It has made things hard. I don’t have any other form of ID and I can’t get one now. I can’t open a bank account. I can’t take a flight, even within the country. It’s a way to push people into going back to your country because they make life harder and harder here. It is a kind of discrimination. They took my passport as a way to prevent me leaving or fleeing to another part of the country and living like a ghost. This way they have a guarentee that I will stay close to them

Toby: is it common for the IRCC to seize passports for people on deportation orders?

Miguel: Yes. Every time I go to one of my reporting days there is a huge line of people waiting who are in the same situation as me. For me, it is understandable to keep immigration under control because there is a lot of people who see Canada as a type of promised land, where dreams come true. You want to be safe and make good money, raise your family. That is the promise. But it is way different living here. You have to struggle every day. You get disaffected by it because you either deal with it or go back to your original country which is worse.

Ivan: Can you talk about these reporting days that the IRCC makes you do? How does it affect you?

Miguel: They make you come to their offices for all people with deportation orders by agreement, once a week. They make sure they have your phone number and address every time. It is upsetting because you can never work a full shift. You have to leave site around 12 to make these reporting days otherwise you will get in even more trouble. It is a type of control.

Ivan: Why did you decide to come to Canada to work?

Miguel: The primary thing was safety. I don’t want to live in a country that looks like it is in a civil war with shooting and guns everywhere. It’s pretty risky. Nobody wants to live like that. You want a peaceful place to live. The economy and inflation is also getting worse. That is why I came here. I came to Canada specifically because my brother in-law and my friends were already here and could get me jobs.

Ivan: Are there organisations you are aware of, fighting for the organisation and rights of undocumented workers?

Miguel: I didn’t know too much about organisations like unions. You [the Workers United Front] were the first I had heard of. I don’t even know if organisations like unions know how to organise workers like TFW’s let alone if they would even organise undocumented workers. I hear nothing about organizing us from them.


Ivan: What are your biggest demands as an undocumented worker in this country?

Miguel: Firstly is payment. There has to be equal payment, not employers just paying you what they want. I think the work conditions have to improve. You have to have a proper environment with the proper materials, tools, and equipment like legal workers would get. How are you going to work in an environment that is putting your body, your health, your life at risk? We have to demand these things, not just for legal workers. Undocumented workers are used to accepting whatever they can get for work because they need the money and they have no other options. Vancouver is an expensive city. You have to make money to survive.

Ivan: The Workers United Front believes that if you are a worker in this country, if you are not a citizen you should be offered immediate permanent residency status with the option for full citizenship. Do you agree with this demand?

Miguel: For sure. This is fair. There is a huge list of issues for undocumented construction workers. It’s not just abuses, or unjust conditions, or risk, or exploitation. We are building this country, we deserve it. Another section of workers could also particularly use this, being the many undocumented agricultural workers. We are building and contributing to this country. Do you know about [mass] amnesty?1 It is fair. If you are working and living in a country, supporting a country, you should have the right to it. A bunch of people came here and just took the land in the first place.2 Why can’t we get amnesty for contributing to this country?

Ivan: Some of the main demands you have made are equal pay for equal work, improving conditions in the construction industry for all workers, and permanent residency for all workers in the country. What do you think is the best way to fight for these demands?


Miguel: The first step is getting in touch with these people, which is the hardest part, because most of them are very apathetic or scared of the government looking at them. There needs to be more connecting with them and building a huge organisation to fight for them. And step by step you can fight systematically.

Ivan: Many workers who aren’t even undocumented, but are here as a temporary foreign worker, or as an LMIA are scared to do anything to fight for a better life. What would you tell these workers about fighting for a better life?

Miguel: I think it’s worth it [to fight]. It is that or continue living in the same conditions and one day get injured, die, and continue being exploited in your job. The conditions change when the humans in them fight to change them.

Ivan: Would you like to make any final comments?

Miguel: We should have a program in the province for all undocumented people. Most undocumented people come with a tourism visa and overstay their visa, which is how they become illegal. There needs to be a program because there is a massive amount of people in this situation. It is hard to get something like a work permit to work legally here. If the IRCC creates a program to get these visas for people it would be way better.

Ivan: That sounds great. But I think a barrier to something like that would be that many of the capitalists in this country are happy to continue to have undocumented workers because they can be exploited more and more easily. Do you agree? What are your thoughts?

Miguel: Yes. The bosses do not want to fix things like this in the legal system because for them it would make them lose a bunch of their profits. Which is why I don’t think a program like this will exist for a while. The system, it doesn’t work for the working class. It is designed for the employers because they get a lot of benefits from a system set up like this. The current immigration program in Canada is set up to be a huge program to promise people in other countries a great life, and instead create a huge mass of heavily exploited workers. You can see that in the article written by Daniel from People’s Hammer.3

Ivan: Thank you very much for your time.

1 Mass amnesty refers to a governmental pardon that allows a large group of people, often illegal immigrants, to gain legal status or forgiveness for past offenses related to immigration.

2 Miguel was referencing Canada’s land aquisition via colonialism.

3 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/11/30/the-temporary-foreign-workers-programme-must-be-abolished-by-daniel-h/


Responses to “Interview with Miguel, an Undocumented Brick Mason – By Toby G. and Ivan D.”

  1. Report on Conditions in the Construction Industry – By CWIO – The People's Hammer

    […] Hammer interview with Miguel. […]

    Like

  2. CBSA raids increase – By Bessy – The People's Hammer
  3. Premier Danielle Smith Plans Anti-Immigrant and Constitutional Referendum – Daniel H. – The People's Hammer