The People's Hammer

A Shattered Mirror: The Disintegration of Canada’s Construction Unions and the Need for Industrial Organisation – By Workers’ United Front

,


The following article is a repost from the Workers’ United Front website. The original can be found here.

– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer

The Structure Cracks

Once, Canada’s construction workers were the backbone of industrial power. The unions once built the skylines, set wage standards across provinces, and shut down entire cities when provoked. Their strikes could freeze cranes mid-air. But in 2025, the towers rise while the conditions and organisation of workers collapses. The craft unions dominating the trades are shadows of former union history in this country. They are bureaucratic, fragmented, and territorially obsessed. All the while often more concerned with fighting each other for jurisdiction and which workers in which union get to take which job, more than how workers can be organised to take control of the industry they run. The bosses have no fear for the construction trades because the trades do not fight as one.

Statistics Canada shows union coverage falling from 37.6% in 1981 to roughly 30% today.1 In the private sector (where the majority of construction happens) it’s about 14%.2 The BC Construction Association admits that nine out of ten employers have fewer than ten workers, and nearly all are non-union.3

Across Canada, the pattern repeats. Ontario’s construction coverage hovers near 26%,4 Alberta’s just 25%.5 Only Quebec’s sector-wide bargaining laws keep it higher, around 39%. The rest of the country has quietly become an open-shop frontier, a scattering of union islands in a non-union sea.

One Industry, One Class, One Hundred Divisions

Walk any job site and the contradiction is visible in steel and concrete. Many of the electricians, pipefitters, and elevator constructors on one side of the floor enjoy union contracts, health plans, and pensions. On the next floor, the flooring installers, painters, and siding crews are on piece rates, with no benefits and no security. And where these workers are unionised, they often are out of work as they reppresent a tiny minority in the industry. The work is collective; the reward is not.

This is not an accident. The general contractors and developers have spent decades perfecting fragmentation as a strategy to fight against organised labour in the industry.6 Each job is broken into layers of subcontracting, separating trades into legal and logistical silos. A carpenter might work for a subcontractor who works for another subcontractor, who bills the general contractor — and each layer blames the next for the wages, safety, and deadlines. And who is made to pay the price? The result is an industry designed to isolate workers, to turn solidarity into competition. This issue is also compounded when considering that increasingly, the bosses in the industry are attempting to divide workers by nationality, legal status, and whichever trade is deemed to be more valuable.

The Bureaucracy That Will Not Fight

The building-trades bureaucracy tells workers that this is the price of “jurisdictional harmony.” They claim that defending craft boundaries protects jobs and allows unions to best address the issues of each trade. In practice, it protects only their select trades. This also discounts that regardless of trade, every one on site is facing the same issues of safety, work hours, and the constant rushing of general contractors.

While the Independent Contractors and Businesses Association (ICBA) brags that 85% of BC construction workers are in open-shop firms (and that open-shop companies train 80% of apprentices)7 the official building trades celebrate “partnership with industry.” The bosses centralize. The unions specialize. The result is a labour movement that has forgotten how to organize the unorganized.

Each trade bargains alone. Each strike is isolated. When electricians picket, drywallers cross; when labourers strike, the flooring crews keep pouring. Fragmentation has become policy. The old “stability” of craft unionism has curdled into paralysis. And this paralysis is very willing. It is common for these unions to willingly cede the biggest weapon their workers have, the strike. Some unions, such as the United Association Local 516 have even gone as far as including “No-Strike” clauses in their collective agreements to “guarentee work” for their employees!

The Material Roots of Decline

The consequences are measurable. Real wages in construction have stagnated behind inflation for nearly a decade.8 Safety violations rise fastest in non-union sectors.9 The share of apprentices entering through open-shop programs has exploded.10

This is not just the natural ebb of history — it is the logical result of a model that refuses to see construction as a single, industrial process. Every high-rise, refinery, and hospital is built by dozens of trades working in sequence, their labour interlocked. To organize that production with twenty separate unions, each guarding its turf, is to surrender the fight before it begins. It is an open divide and conquer tactic that the leadership of the unions is willingly embracing.

The employers already act as a single class: general contractors, financiers, developers, and open-shop associations move in coordination. The workers are the only ones still told to “stay in their lane.”

What Industrial Unionism Means

Industrial unionism is the recognition that in a modern economy, every trade and task within construction is part of one production system. The answer is not more individual union advertising, or employer agreements, but one organization of all construction workers.

A Construction Workers’ Industrial Organisation (CWIO) would unite electricians and framers, pipefitters and painters, union and non-union alike, to push for the formation of a single Construction Workers Industrial Union. A union to be formed through unionising the non-unionised, and amalgamating the existing unions into one. Every site would form its own workers’ committee, representing all trades, not just those with contracts. Strikes and contracts should be one, coordinated across trades; no one would work while another crew fights. Organizing would focus not on defending old jurisdictions but on expanding into the “missing trades”: flooring, siding, landscaping, residential roofing, decorative concrete, and renovation, the sectors left abandoned by traditional unions.

Such an organization would treat solidarity as strategy, not sentiment. When one site is organized, every site gains leverage. Industrial unity is not an ideal; it’s the only viable weapon left for construction workers in a changing industry where instability and the threat of unemployment grows more daily.

The decline of union coverage in construction is not only a matter of wages or contracts, it is a question of life and death. The trades most neglected by the old union apparatus are also those where injury, wage theft, and the exploitation of immigrants and undocumented workers are most rampant.11

Where the Bodies Fall

Government data and investigative journalism have long confirmed what every construction worker already knows: the most dangerous jobs are the least unionized ones.12 A 2023 study from the Canadian Centre for Occupational Health and Safety found that non-union construction sites report 40–50% higher accident rates than union sites.13 Among roofers, framers, and siding installers (the trades least organized) the rate of serious falls and crush injuries is up to three times the national average.14 The reasons are obvious. Without union safety committees or joint labour-management inspections, corners are cut to meet deadlines. Harnesses are missing, scaffolds are unstable, and workers are forced to work long hours in extreme weather conditions. Subcontractors competing for bids slash time and safety budgets alike.

The Exploitation of Immigrant and Undocumented Labour

These same trades (roofing, siding, flooring, framing, and landscaping) are also where Canada’s most exploited workers are concentrated.15 Many are recent immigrants or undocumented labourers, often recruited through informal networks or shady subcontractors. They are routinely paid in cash, denied overtime, and threatened with deportation if they complain. There have been dozens of such cases: workers sleeping on job sites, paid below minimum wage, and forced to work without protective equipment.16 In residential construction, particularly in the GTA, Vancouver, and Calgary, entire crews are composed of undocumented Latin American and South Asian migrants who have no recourse under existing labour law.17 Union bureaucracies have largely turned a blind eye. The building trades, fixated on retaining jurisdiction over industrial projects, have ceded these sectors to open-shop associations and the grey market. As a result, the very workers who build Canada’s homes are treated as disposable.

Why Industrial Unionism Is a Matter of Survival

The neglect of these trades is a strategic failure for the workers movement. The unchecked exploitation of the most vulnerable workers drags the entire class downward. Every dollar stolen from a migrant worker’s paycheque is a dollar that weakens collective bargaining power for all.18 Industrial unionism offers not only organization but protection. It means enforcing one standard of safety and one wage floor across every trade. It means bringing undocumented and precarious workers into the movement, not leaving them in the shadows. As WUF’s program insists, an injury to one trade is an injury to all. Until the flooring installer, the roofer, and the framer have the same rights and protections as the electrician or pipefitter, there can be no unity. Without unity, there can be no power.

CategoryTradesApprox. Unionization Rate (2025)Key Issues
Highly Organized
(40–65%)
Electricians, Plumbers/Pipefitters, Ironworkers, Sheet Metal Workers50–65%Lower injury rates due to safety oversight; stable wages through CBAs.19
Partially Organized
(20–40%)
Carpenters, Labourers30–40%Still experience pressure from non-union competitors; declining apprenticeship standards.20
Weakly Organized
(10–20%)
Painters, Glaziers, Roofers10–20%High rate of falls, respiratory illness, and wage disputes.21
Neglected / Non-Union (Below 10%)Flooring Installers, Siding/Cladding, Landscapers, Residential Framers3–10%Extremely high injury rates, unpaid overtime, rampant misclassification, and widespread use of temporary foreign and undocumented workers.22
The Bosses Have a Plan, So Must We

The employers’ vision is clear. Their open-shop associations lobby for weaker labour laws, subcontract away accountability, and import cheap labour through the Temporary Foreign Worker Program.23 They speak with one voice across provinces. Their plan is not disorganization, it’s their own form of industrial organization against us.

The only counterweight is to build ours. That means forming cross-trade committees, mapping non-union sectors, and creating a national construction workers’ network independent of the old bureaucracy. It means reviving direct action, solidarity strikes, and class-wide bargaining. It means remembering that “industrial unionism” was the method that built the most serious and successful workers’ movements in this country.

When construction workers act together, they can shut down the arteries of capitalism itself. They build and maintain every bridge, every refinery, every high-rise, every military base. They literally hold up the world. The question is whether we will will hold it up for the bosses, or take it back for ourselves.

We Must Rebuild for Ourselves

The decay of the building trades is not inevitable. It is a sign that the we, the working class in the industry, must fight back. Industrial unionism offers not a dream of the past but a path to the future; one rooted in the real conditions of labour today.

If the unions will not adapt, the workers will. Already across Canada, new forms of job-site militancy are emerging: cross-trade solidarity committees, wildcat refusals, safety actions that unite union and non-union workers alike. These are the embryos of something greater.

The WUF calls for construction workers, regardless of trade or affiliation, to form the foundation of a new industrial organization that is democratic, militant, and internationalist. The boss fears not the strongest trade, but the united site.


  1. https://www.statcan.gc.ca/o1/en/plus/7416-state-unions-canada ↩︎
  2. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/14-28-0001/2024001/article/00010-eng.htm ↩︎
  3. https://bccassn.com/news-publications/stat-packs-data/construction-industry-unionization-in-bc-an-overview/ ↩︎
  4. Ibid. ↩︎
  5. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1410012901& ↩︎
  6. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/14-28-0001/2024001/article/00010-eng.htm ↩︎
  7. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1410013201& ↩︎
  8. https://icbaindependent.ca/2025/12/17/icba50-50-growing-with-open-shop/ ↩︎
  9. https://iuoelocal793.org/unionized-construction-firms-are-safer-study/ ↩︎
  10. https://www.iwh.on.ca/newsletters/at-work/103/union-firms-have-lower-lost-time-claim-rates-study-in-ici-construction-confirms ↩︎
  11. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/36-28-0001/2022011/article/00001-eng.htm ↩︎
  12. https://www.ccohs.ca/oshanswers/industries/construction.html ↩︎
  13. https://www.iwh.on.ca/newsletters/at-work/103/union-firms-have-lower-lost-time-claim-rates-study-in-ici-construction-confirms ↩︎
  14. https://awcbc.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/Workplace-Fatalities-by-Industry-2013-2022.pdf ↩︎
  15. https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2025/01/canada-tfwp-abuse-migrant-workers/ ↩︎
  16. https://degroote.mcmaster.ca/articles/in-the-news-4-1-million-fines-for-violations-of-canadas-temporary-foreign-worker-program-are-a-drop-in-the-bucket/?utm_source=chatgpt.com ↩︎
  17. https://nouvelles.umontreal.ca/en/article/2025/03/20/exploited-temporary-foreign-workers-in-canada-are-vulnerable/ ↩︎
  18. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/ ↩︎
  19. https://www.iwh.on.ca/newsletters/at-work/103/union-firms-have-lower-lost-time-claim-rates-study-in-ici-construction-confirms ↩︎
  20. https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=1410032001 ↩︎
  21. https://awcbc.org/en/statistics/ ↩︎
  22. https://bccassn.com/news-publications/stat-packs-data/construction-industry-unionization-in-bc-an-overview/ ↩︎
  23. https://nouvelles.umontreal.ca/en/article/2025/03/20/exploited-temporary-foreign-workers-in-canada-are-vulnerable ↩︎

Response to “A Shattered Mirror: The Disintegration of Canada’s Construction Unions and the Need for Industrial Organisation – By Workers’ United Front”

  1. Is the Issue Striking, or Strike Strategy? – by Ivan D – The People's Hammer

    […] [5] People’s Hammer, various labour movement and class struggle articles emphasizing militancy, anti-concessionary bargaining, and strike action as central working-class tactics.https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/01/16/a-shattered-mirror-the-disintegration-of-canadas-cons… […]

    Like