The People's Hammer

The State of Construction in B.C. – By Tobias G.

,


On February 21st 2024, Yuridia Flores unnecessarily lost her life due to the negligence of corporate interests. This incident caused outcry among workers and the general populace for improved working conditions, and more justice for those responsible in events like this. While this event was reported as a case of workplace standards not being met, the concrete actions taken since the incident goes to show just how non-existent the consequences are for companies that perpetrate these. In this particular example, after it was reported by Worksafe BC that this incident occurred because “EllisDon failed to ensure that there was adequate planning, co-ordination, hazard identification, risk assessment, training, and supervision for the critical lift and overhead work on the day of the incident,” the company in question was issued a fine1. The amount in question? 515,000 dollars. That is the pitiful slap on the wrist mustered by the state against an offending company that has repeatedly shown to disregard workers safety in the name of efficiency. For clarity, EllisDon is an international company with offices around the world, with an expected yearly revenue of 10 billion dollars2.

This incident wasn’t unforeseeable by any means at this site. Multiple near misses involving cranes on the Oakridge site had occurred in the months leading up this, with one even happening on the same day! With this in mind, we can look at EllisDons commitment to worker safety as a resolution with even more skepticism, as they were clearly being negligent with this particular trend. Speaking more broadly, we can also see that repeated crane incidents in the province leading up to this point (that were at least reported) show a general failure in the efficacy of whatever safety guidelines are in place in the industry as a whole34. A Representative from the local International Union of Operating Engineers (IUOE 115) made statements before the death of Yuridia, calling for more regulation of contractors in the industry and mandatory training for all workers who are involved in the operations pertaining to tower cranes. As of today, these regulations have not been put in place, with seemingly no plans announced for the future. This isn’t surprising, considering the lack of any actual pressure being put on the state to implement these by the relevant unions.

This is an even more gratuitous fact taking into account the Kelowna crane collapse that happened in July 2021. This catastrophe caused 5 fatalities, and preceding this, no changes were made, and the construction industry in B.C. has carried on5. The government is still “investigating” whether or not criminal charges will be made against the contractor responsible, and over 4 years later, they constructed a memorial to honour the victims6. These actions are not just grossly lacking, but also a direct affront to the actual workers who are in construction today. The fact of the matter is that these incidents aren’t something to be avoided, but outcomes that are budgeted for. The lives of workers aren’t relevant to these companies when they can successfully avoid all potential consequences of their negligence. This is very much by design as well, as the government and the bourgeois they are allied with have much to gain from a rapidly developing construction sector. They simply can’t afford for these companies to actually face culpability.

This is a problem that must be addressed from the workers at the bottom, on the field, seeing the job site every day. Unfortunately, relying on unions as they exist now won’t lead us to a path of change. The Workers United Front (WUF), and the Construction Workers Industrial Organisation (CWIO), both have points in their programmes that can concretely address these issues. One point they share is in the need for an elected workplace committee that represents their given workers interests. Not only will this be an imperative way for safety concerns to be heard and eventually addressed, but these workplace committees will be the building blocks for creating a larger united industrial union. Right now, all unions represent certain specific areas of work, however an amalgamated industrial union provides unparalleled ability to organise and take action as a unit. If one had union had the capacity to curtail multiple industries at once, achieving demands like increased consequences for companies will be a non-issue. Once again however, this is an initiative that must come from workers at the ground level. Waiting for your union bureaucrats to solve these problems is not going to lead to any real change. Organising with your fellow workers is our best way forward.

1 https://www.ctvnews.ca/vancouver/article/companies-fined-over-fatal-crane-accident-at-vancouvers-oakridge-park/

2 https://compworth.com/company/ellisdon#revenue

3 https://www.timescolonist.com/bc-news/crane-accidents-a-huge-concern-after-fourth-incident-in-metro-vancouver-8399436

4 https://ca.news.yahoo.com/multiple-near-misses-fatal-crane-120019789.html

5 https://www.vancouverisawesome.com/highlights/vancouver-construction-crane-death-comes-after-calls-to-better-certify-bc-operators-8344444

6 https://globalnews.ca/news/11286589/kelowna-crane-collapse-memorial-open/


Response to “The State of Construction in B.C. – By Tobias G.”

  1. Canadian Mine Monopoly Works with Sinaloa Cartel to Corprativise Union Drive – by Daniel H. – The People's Hammer