The basic role of communists is to lead the proletariat to seize state power and build communism. This role cannot be fulfilled without independence for the proletariat. This applies on all levels. Ideologically, this is through the independent proletarian ideology, in our case the guiding thought of the Canadian revolution. Politically, this is through the independent party, today being built by the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) [CPC(RF)]. It also applies on an organisational level seen in financial questions such as how proletarian organisations fund themselves.
Any organisation that claims to act in opposition to a particular state or government can only do so effectively if it is independent. However, if the organisation is dependent on its enemy, then its opposition is pointless. It is effectively a controlled opposition group. This was seen very concretely in the past few years when the state-backed Vancouver Area Network of Drug Users (VANDU) lost much of its state-funding. As a result, they pulled back from the protests they were leading against Mayor Ken Sim’s push to clear the Downtown Eastside of homeless camps out of fear of further funding cuts.
The absolute independence of the revolutionary movement from the state has long been a principle upheld by Canadian communists particularly given the strong corporatist positions of the Quebecois bourgeoisie. Despite this, many modern “communist” organisations have grafted themselves into the state through their mass organisations. This can be seen among many revisionist organisations, but the most obvious modern example is the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” which is little more than a coordinating group for a handful of NGOs and affinity groups.1
The State, Neoliberalism, Non-Profits, and NGOs
Communists understand the state to basically be armed force (military, police, etc.) surrounded by a bureaucratic apparatus. With the transition from free-market capitalism to imperialism, the state has transformed in two major ways. First, capital and state-power have merged producing state-monopoly capitalism. The CPC(RF) has explained this as follows:
“The era of imperialism has led to a qualitative shift in the nature of the bourgeois state. Monopoly capital has been united with state power yielding state-monopoly capitalism. This does not mean that all entreprises have been transformed into crown corporations. It means that the big bourgeoisie utilise the state to secure their interests and further centralise capital. This holds whether an entreprise is ‘publicly’ or privately held.”2
The second major development, which is an extension of the first, has been the expansion of the state through the penetration and integration of all other bourgeois institutions into itself. This was explained in Bukharin’s Toward a Theory of the Imperialist State:
“The general pattern of the state’s development is therefore as follows: in the beginning the state is the sole organization of the ruling class. Then other organizations begin to spring up, their numbers multiplying especially in the epoch of finance capitalism. The state is transformed from the sole organization of the ruling class into one of its organizations, its distinction being that it has the most general character of all such organizations. Finally, the third stage arrives, in which the state swallows up these organizations and once more becomes the sole universal organization of the ruling class, with an internal, technical division of labor. The once-independent organizational groupings become the divisions of a gigantic state mechanism, which pounces upon the visible and internal enemy with crushing force. Thus emerges the finished type of the contemporary imperialist robber state, the iron organization, which with its tenacious, raking claws embraces the living body of society. This is the New Leviathan, beside which the fantasy of Thomas Hobbes looks like a child’s toy. For the time being there is no force on earth that might be its equal – ‘Non est potestas super terram quae comparetur ei [There is no power on earth to be compared to him].’”3
What Bukharin describes has led to all bourgeois institutions being integrated into the state in some way. Universities, hospitals, charitable organisations, etc. – under imperialism these are all arms of the state.
In the 1990s, the USA formed a united front with other imperialist powers and reactionary classes aimed at 1) preventing revolution and 2) defending imperialism. To achieve these goals, this united front initiated a general counter-revolutionary offensive whose economic base was neoliberalism.4 This economic policy is basically one that aims to return to the period of liberalism (free-market capitalism) that existed before imperialism. This means a reduction of the role of the state and large-scale privatisation.
Whatever the aim of the imperialists, it is impossible to move backward. Free-markets cannot be imposed in the era of monopoly capitalism. While there has been much privatisation, the state has not shrunk. In fact, it has only grown a thousand times larger in the past few decades. This can be seen through joint public-private ventures and for the purpose of this article through the penetration of non-governmental organisations (NGOs), non-profits, and self-declared “mutual aid” groups. These organisations previously operated outside of the state, but are today almost universally integrated into the state through legal and financial ties that are required for their continued operation.
The workers must recognise that these organisations are not potential friends, they are arms of the state no matter how much they profess their opposition.
The “(N)CPC’s” Ties with the State
The “(N)CPC” maintains a number of mass organisations, many of which have been integrated into the state, principally by financial and regulatory means.
North Star
North Star is the central organ of the “(N)CPC”. North Star is also a member of Unrigged, a collective of social-democratic news organisations.5 This collective was launched in response to the ban on Canadian news from being circulated on Meta-owned platforms.
Unrigged openly presents that they receive funding from the following non-profits:
- Co-op de Solidarité Pivot. The co-op lists a number of major financial partners (over $10 000) including both the federal and provincial government.6
- Centre for Social Innovation. The centre also lists its financial sources with funding coming from all levels of the state, several private companies, and the largest banks in the country.7
- Inspirit Foundation. This foundation is a “progressive” financing organisation registered as a charity.8
- Solidarity Economy Incubation for Zero Emissions is an organisation that funds mainly “progressive” organisations who are themselves funded mainly by a levy on Concordia University students’ tuition as well as $44 000 in general grant and foundation donations in 2024.9
- McConnell Foundation. The foundation is similar to the Inspirit Foundation.10
With funding from these non-profits, all of whom are direct or indirect branches of the state, and a per-capita from each member organisation (many of which are themselves non-profits receiving direct and indirect state funding), the collective is attempting to maintain readership against the drop caused by the Meta ban. This approach makes sense when an organisation has a bourgeois understanding of the role of the proletarian press as one that must out-compete the bourgeois monopolies. This is the attitude held by the North Star who state that they are “a media outlet that aims to rival the likes of CBC and CTV.”11 However, communists must recognise that our press will never be able to out-compete the bourgeois press under capitalism. It is futile to even try for ideological and financial reasons.
Ideologically, the proletarian press would need to water down its content in order to broaden its appeal. This is the approach that is today taken by North Star which barely says a word about communism or Maoism. It was also the approach of the liquidated Labour-Progressive Party which in 1946 launched the Daily Tribune with the same goal of out-competing the media monopolies.12 Watering down your content may allow it to become digestible to a broader (bourgeois) audience and allow you to receive state funds, but it also requires an abandonment of communism in order to maintain these funds and readers. Financially, no communist organisation will be able to match the capital held by the big media monopolies as we should learn from Daily Tribune’s rapid collapse.
The People’s Hammer has taken the approach of relying on its own forces for funding, contribution, and distribution. This certainly makes for slower growth than joining a state-funded media collective alongside social-democrats, but it ensures that the paper can consistently advocate for the fundamental tasks of the class: reconstitution, people’s war, and proletarian dictatorship.
In 2024, North Star launched a crowdfunding campaign to fund a full-time journalist.13 As they state in their campaign announcement: “every donation you make until we reach our goal will be doubled by the Fond Mille-et-Un, through a partnership with the crowdfunding platform La Ruche.”14
Here, we find very direct state funding to North Star.
La Ruche explains the origins of the Fond Mille-et-Un:
“To make it easier to achieve objectives or enhance projects, in 2017, La Ruche teamed up with organizations from the public, private and para-public sectors to create an innovative new concept: additional funding programs. These programs offer financial contributions in the form of a loan, bursary or grant. They are applicable to projects that fit the criteria and campaign on La Ruche. Two years later, the first large-scale government fund combining participatory financing, corporate contributions and government support was created in collaboration with the Secrétariat de la Jeunesse: the Mille et UN Fund.”15
Fond Mille-et-Un is a joint project between the Quebec Secretariat for Youth and La Ruche that provides additional funding to projects that target the youth (15-29 years old). It does this by matching funds raised up to $100 000. In order to qualify, the project is required to work in concert with the state by addressing one of its strategic aims among the youth.16 This means that the state not only does not regard North Star as a threat, but in fact sees them as serving their ends enough to justify funding them.
Beyond this, the project is required to adhere to the entirety of the Fond Mille-et-Un policy and work closely with La Ruche.17
Despite funding from both corporations and the government, they claim to be independent of both in their call for donations: “We’re not funded by big corporations or by governments, but by you.”18
A final important point is that North Star has registered itself with the state as a non-profit:
“Donations to The North Star are not tax-deductible. The North Star is registered as a non-profit organization but is not recognized by the Canada Revenue Agency as a registered charity or a qualified journalism organization and cannot issue tax receipts. Donors who want confirmation of the transaction may write to tresorerie@etoiledunord.media with their name, email address, date, and donation amount.”19
To obtain and maintain non-profit status with the state, an organisation is bound by many legal requirements. The organisation is required to regularly report on its activity to the state and submit a large amount of information that will inevitably be used against it in times of severe repression. It is for this reason that Canadian communists have always rejected registration of their organisations officially with the state.
Multi-Monde
Multi-Monde is a documentary production and distribution company formed in 1987 by two very important leaders of the International League of Peoples’ Struggles (ILPS): Malcolm Guy and Marie Botti. This company has produced a number of films that have been used by Filipino revisionist organisations and “(N)CPC” front groups for agitation. This has especially been the case for their documentaries on the armed struggle in the Philippines.20
Like North Star, Multi-monde has also developed increasingly close ties to the state. This is best seen in their relationship with Quebec’s Society for Developing Cultural Enterprises (SODEC). Looking at only the past few years, we can see large and increasing contributions from SODEC to Multi-Monde:
- 5000$ in 2021-2022 to celebrate their 30th anniversary;21
- 16000$ in 2022-2023 to fund the distribution of 2012;22
- 18000$ in 2023-2024 to fund the distribution of Produire la menace;23 and
- 22000$ in 2024-2025 to fund the distribution of Eviction.24
While the data has yet to be released for 2025-2026, we can see for the promotional poster for Malcolm Guy’s My Friend the Terrorist that it likely received support from at least three branches of the state: SODEC, the Canadian Council for the Arts, and CALQ.25
Immigrant Workers Centre
The IWC is a non-profit organisation based in Montreal that was a member organisation of ILPS at least as late as their 2020 international assembly.26 The organisation has acted as a front for the “(N)CPC” for many years going at least to the days of “Revolutionary Initiative” (RI-IR) and the “Charles Gagnon Cell” (CCG). Since the period in which it was led by “RI-IR” and the “CCG”, these opportunists have openly called for work in the IWC to be “depoliticised” (read: liberal and reformist) with its work limited to interventions in the economic struggles of the immigrant workers.
The IWC is a major recipient of direct state funding. Their currently listed funders are:
- Emploi et Dévelopment Social Canada (via Immigrant Québec);
- Ville de Montréal, BINAM (Bureau d’intégration des nouveaux arrivants à Montréal);
- Ministère de Immigration, Francisation et Intégration; and
- Emploi Québec27
State funding in 2023-2024 included:
- Emploi Québec;
- Ville de Montréal, BINAM;
- Immigrant Québec; and
- Emploi été des étudiants.28
How much each state branch contributes to the IWC is not publicly available.
It should be noted that not only does the “(N)CPC” solicit funds from the state in general, but specifically from its arms that are most directly involved in enforcing the super-exploitation of these immigrant workers!
League 3329
League 33 is not as open about its finances as other “(N)CPC” front groups. However, they do openly acknowledge their ties to the state:
“Tous les membres de la Ligue 33 sont bénévoles et notre financement vient de deux sources: les dons des citoyens et certaines subventions venant de groupes étudiants, syndicaux et communautaires. Nous ne sommes affiliés à aucun parti politique. Nous sommes un organisme à but non lucratif dûment enregistré.”30
Conclusion
The above is a very brief survey of the most overt ties between the “(N)CPC” and the state mediated on the part of the “(N)CPC” through their front organisations and by the state both directly and indirectly through non-profits. This survey is not exhaustive as many others such as the ties between VANDU to both the state and the “(N)CPC” have been discussed elsewhere.31
Similarly, while the “(N)CPC” is the most egregious in its collaboration with the state, they are far from the only revisionist organisation in Canada to collaborate in this way. These organisations represent a petite-bourgeois trend in the communist movement. Nothing shows this more than these organisation’s use of the preferred petite-bourgeois method of fundraising: grant writing. As we continue the work of reconstituting the Communist Party of Canada, we must reject these petite-bourgeois methods for proletarian ones. While the sum and ease that we can expect from these methods is initially lower, they offer security and do not require us to publicly abandon Gonzalo Thought. As just a few examples, we can collect dues, we can sell buttons, books, and newspapers, and we can solicit donations. In Bangladesh, one of the first military actions of the Proletarian Party of East Bengal was the theft of a printing press for their central organ. There are many options that maintain our independence and increase our ability to fight.
The development of ties to the state by these organisations is likely pursued as a shortcut to achieve a strong, well-funded, influential, communist organisation. Regardless of the intentions, it yields a toothless organisation. While the organisation may receive funding, they are unable to agitate or propagandise along communist lines which is why many of these organisations turn to economistic and social-democratic work as that is the only work they can do to maintain their funding or their status as a registered non-profit.
Communists must realise there is no shortcut to the reconstitution of the party. Trying to secure state-funds may yield temporary boosts in quantity, but they require a necessary reduction in quality. Take the North Star. Would North Star qualify for its Quebecois state fund-matching programme if it was a communist newspaper? Of course not! They qualify because they are just another social-democratic rag of no more use than Canadian Dimension. Wherever communists rely on the state, they will be unable to develop a fight against the state. They can only become another social-fascistic arm of it. Alternatively, by registering the information of the leaders of these paper-thinly veiled fronts, when repression intensifies they will be immediately crushed. Either way, reliance on the state means failure.
Most of the “(N)CPC” has its roots in the Revolutionary Communist Party. Because this organisation and its predecessor the Socialist Action Group were confined to Quebec for the majority of their lives, it had to develop a proletarian position on the question of corporatism. This is due to the strong support for corporatism among the Quebecois bourgeoisie who have successfully incorporated many mass organisations into the state itself. Due to this situation, communists in Quebec have always emphasised the importance of independence and initative of the party and the proletariat. Whether disguised as tactical or not, the “(N)CPC” has turned its back on this basic principle.
Financial independence from the state makes the work of building a communist party difficult. You cannot open a directly linked bank account or get enough funds for a full-time organiser out the gate. It also ensures the hegemony of the proletarian line by not offering opportunism a leg up and hiding the political line of the party as is required to continuously secure grants.
1 The CPC(RF) has produced the following general criticism of this organisation: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/
2 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/09/repost-the-international-line-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-by-cpcrf/
3 https://www.marxists.org/archive/bukharin/works/1915/state.htm
4 The CPC(RF) has produced a more in depth explanation of this general counter-revolutionary offensive that can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/10/14/repost-gonzalo-thought-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-part-2/
They have also produced a longer explanation of neoliberalism that can be found here: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/28/repost-gonzalo-thought-parts-6-8-by-cpcrf/
5 https://www.unrigged.ca/about/
6 https://pivot.quebec/financement/
7 https://socialinnovation.org/
8 inspiritfoundation.org
9 solidarityeconomy.ca
10 https://www.mcconnellfoundation.ca/what-we-fund/
11https://thenorthstar.media/donate/
12 Capitalism Unchallenged: A Sketch of Canadian Communism, 1939-1949 – Donald William Muldoon
13 https://thenorthstar.media/2024/07/29/a-first-full-time-journalist-for-north-star-thanks-to-your-donations/
14 https://thenorthstar.media/2024/07/29/a-first-full-time-journalist-for-north-star-thanks-to-your-donations/
15 https://laruchequebec.com/en/about/mission
16 Finadd.laruchequebec.com/EN/m1f
17 Finadd.laruchequebec.com/EN/m1f
18 https://thenorthstar.media/donate/
19 https://thenorthstar.media/terms-and-conditions/
20 For why we do not refer to this as a people’s war: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/08/14/support-the-proletarian-line-in-the-armed-struggle-in-the-philippines-down-with-the-revisionist-leadership-of-the-communist-party-of-the-philippines/
21 https://sodec.gouv.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/rapport-annuel-gestion-2021-2022-sodec.pdf
22 https://sodec.gouv.qc.ca/wp-content/uploads/rapport-annuel-gestion-sodec-2022-2023.pdf
23 https://sodec.gouv.qc.ca/rapport-annuel-de-gestion-2023-2024-de-la-sodec/
24 https://sodec.gouv.qc.ca/rapport-annuel-gestion-2024-2025-sodec/
25 https://multi-monde.ca/en/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/01/Screenshot-2025-01-10-at-1.22.03-PM.jpg
26 https://peoplesstruggle.org/en/list-of-participating-organizations-in-the-6th-international-assembly/
27 https://iwc-cti.ca/current-funders/
28 https://iwc-cti.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/CTTI-Rapport-Annuel-2023-2024.pdf
29 The Communist Workers Front (Organising Committee) published this criticism of the programme of the League: https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2022/09/28/the-league-33s-liberal-democratic-programme/
30 https://ligue33.org/a-propos/
31 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/21/the-ncpc-and-the-drug-trade-by-bessy/ and https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/10/17/dulf-and-the-opioid-crisis-by-bessy/
Response to “The “(N)CPC” and Independence from the State – By Daniel H.”
[…] 1The relationship of the “(N)CPC” and this NGO is discussed in The “(N)CPC” and Independence from the State […]
LikeLike