Across North America, a new generation of tenant organizing has emerged in response to skyrocketing rents, displacement, and the consolidation of landlord power. In Vancouver, the Vancouver Tenants Union (VTU) represents the most influential attempts to build such a movement. Its members have organized tenant associations, defended neighbors from eviction, and helped bring housing issues into public debate. Yet despite years of effort, the organization has struggled to translate localized tenant fights into sustained city-wide mobilization. VTU itself partially acknowledges this difficulty. While it has successfully organized building-level tenant groups, it has repeatedly faced challenges mobilizing tenants across the city in unified campaigns. To understand why, it is necessary to look not only at the external conditions tenants face, but also at the internal organizational model the union has adopted. The VTU organizes itself around what it calls the “snowflake model.” According to its own handbook, this model is built around decentralized chapters and working groups that operate semi-independently and coordinate through a steering committee.1 The intention is to create distributed leadership and encourage initiative from the grassroots. On the surface, this appears democratic and participatory. But the snowflake model rests on a flawed premise: that decentralization itself produces effective democratic power. From a Marxist perspective, the opposite is more often the case.
The Question of Leadership in Class Struggle
Marxism has never rejected leadership or organization. Quite the contrary: it insists that the working class must develop collective leadership capable of strategic direction. Workers do not defeat capital through scattered resistance, including in housing struggles. They do so by organizing themselves into structures that can analyze conditions, make decisions, and act in coordinated unity. This principle is particularly important in tenant organizing. The landlords are not decentralized. Real estate capital operates through large property management firms, financial institutions, and coordinated political lobbying. Municipal governments and courts reinforce this through eviction enforcement and regulatory frameworks. Tenants therefore confront a highly organized adversary. To challenge these adversaries, tenants must develop organizational forms that concentrate collective power, not disperse it.
The snowflake model moves in the opposite direction. By emphasizing decentralized initiative as the core structure of the organization, it treats coordination as something that emerges organically and spontaneously, rather than something that must be consciously built and enforced. The result is predictable: strong local organizing but weak strategic cohesion.
Tactical Decentralisation vs Structural Decentralisation
The CPI (Maoist)’s document Urban Perspective2 offers a useful framework for understanding this problem. It describes the need for tactical decentralisation combined with strategic centralism and offers the best method to employ decentralized tactics. In other words, local units should have the flexibility to adapt tactics to their specific conditions, but the overall political direction of the movement must remain unified and centrally coordinated. This distinction is crucial. Tactical decentralisation allows building committees or neighborhood groups to decide how best to organize tenants locally. One building might organize rent strikes. Another might focus on maintenance campaigns or eviction defense. But strategic centralism ensures that these local struggles are connected to a larger political strategy, and that campaigns can stretch beyond individual buildings.The movement as a whole decides its priorities, its targets, and its campaigns. Without that strategic unity, decentralized organizing tends to fragment and allow multiple (and contradicting) lines and goals to emerge.
The snowflake model, however, effectively elevates decentralization to strategy. Each chapter or tenant association operates with significant autonomy, and the central bodies function primarily as coordinators rather than strategic leadership organs. This means that when campaigns beyond a building are attempted, they depend largely on voluntary alignment rather than unified organizational discipline. In practice, this makes sustained mobilization extremely difficult.
Building-Level Organizing and Its Limits
VTU places strong emphasis on organizing tenants building by building. This is a seemingly logical starting point. Tenants experience exploitation at the level of their building: mold, unsafe conditions, harassment, rent hikes, and eviction threats. But building-level organization alone does not create a movement capable of confronting landlords as a section of the highly organised, and state-backed bourgeoisie. Landlords operate across buildings, across neighborhoods, and across entire cities. Large property companies own dozens or hundreds of buildings. Municipal housing policy is decided at the city level. Financial speculation driving rent increases operates at the level of global capital. If tenant organization remains primarily at the level of individual buildings, it risks reproducing fragmentation.
This is exactly the problem that Marxist organizers have historically sought to overcome in the labour movement. Workers initially organized shop by shop, craft by craft, workplace by workplace. But only when those struggles were unified into broader industrial unions and coordinated labor federations did workers gain the ability to challenge capital effectively. Tenant organizing faces the same structural challenge. Without centralized strategy, building-level struggles remain isolated.
Lessons from Militant Tenant Organizing
Examples from the United States illustrate how different organizational approaches affect outcomes.
Organizations like KC Tenants in Kansas City have managed to expand from local building struggles into city-wide campaigns capable of winning policy concessions, including tenants’ rights legislation and eviction defense programs.3 These organizations developed structures capable of coordinating campaigns across large numbers of tenants rather than relying solely on autonomous building associations.
More militant formations such as the United Neighborhood Defense Movement (UNDM) have taken this even further. UNDM and allied tenant groups have mobilized coordinated eviction defenses, protests at courthouses, and solidarity actions across multiple neighborhoods. In Los Angeles, tenant groups affiliated with these networks have mobilized collectively to defend tenants facing landlord retaliation lawsuits and eviction threats.4
These efforts were far from perfect. They faced internal problems and political contradictions. But their capacity to mobilize broader struggles came from the fact that they treated tenant organizing as a political project, not simply a loose network of autonomous tenant associations. Such efforts recognize an essential fact: decentralized local organizing must eventually be integrated into broader strategic structures if tenant movements are to confront the scale of landlord power.
The Problem with Horizontalism
The snowflake model belongs to a broader trend in contemporary activist culture often described as “horizontalism”. Horizontalist organizations attempt to avoid hierarchy by dispersing authority and prioritizing autonomy. While this approach often emerges from a genuine desire to prevent bureaucracy or domination, it tends to produce the opposite effect. When formal leadership structures are weak, informal leadership inevitably fills the gap. Individuals who have more time, experience, or social influence begin to guide decision-making, but without clear mechanisms of accountability. Instead of democratic leadership, organizations end up with opaque influence networks.
Moreover, horizontal structures often struggle to make decisive strategic choices. Because authority is dispersed, campaigns rely on consensus or voluntary coordination rather than collective discipline. In moments of intense struggle such as rent strikes, eviction defense campaigns, city-wide mobilizations, etc. this lack of unified direction becomes a serious obstacle.
Democratic Centralism and Tenant Power
The alternative is not bureaucratic command structures. It is democratic centralism, a principle long associated with Marxist organizing. Democratic centralism combines two elements: First, democracy. Members debate strategy, elect leadership bodies, and hold those leaders accountable. Decisions about political direction are made collectively. Second, centralism. Once decisions are made, the organization acts in a unified manner to carry them out. This structure allows for both participation and effectiveness. Applied to tenant organizing, democratic centralism would mean:
- building-level tenant committees forming the base of the organization
- elected city-wide leadership capable of directing campaigns
- regular democratic assemblies where members determine political priorities
- coordinated mobilization across buildings and neighbourhoods
Under such a model, building committees would not disappear. They would remain the foundation of the tenant. But they would operate as components of a larger collective strategy, not as isolated units linked only loosely through coordination committees. This is what the CPI (Maoist) concept of tactical decentralisation and strategic centralism captures so well. Local initiative remains essential, but it is guided by a unified direction that allows the movement to concentrate its forces.
The central question facing tenant organizers is simple: what kind of movement are we trying to build? If the goal is simply to create independent tenant associations building by building, the snowflake model may suffice. It can produce many small organizations with varying levels of activity. But if the goal is to build a tenant movement capable of confronting landlords at the scale it actually operates, then something more is required.
Tenants must be organized not just as neighbors or building residents but as a class with shared interests. That requires political clarity, strategic unity, and organizational discipline. Decentralized organizing can create sparks of resistance. But only coordinated struggle can turn those sparks into a fire capable of forcing real concessions from capital. The future of tenant organizing depends on recognizing this distinction. The snowflake model disperses energy. A Marxist approach concentrates it into the future conquering of power.
1Vancouver Tenants Union, Member Handbook, describing the “snowflake model” of decentralized chapters and working groups coordinated through a steering committee. https://assets.nationbuilder.com/vancouvertenantsunion/pages/89/attachments/original/1693533739/CURRENT_June_2023_-_VTU_Member_Handbook.pdf?1693533739
2https://www.bannedthought.net/India/CPI-Maoist-Docs/UrbanPerspective.pdf
3https://www.kansascity.com/news/local/article284709646.html
4https://tribuneofthepeoplenews.wordpress.com/2021/03/12/los-angeles-tenants-protest-at-courthouse-against-retaliatory-lawsuit/
Response to “Against the Snowflake Model, for Democratic Centralism – Ivan D.”
[…] 7Ivan D., “Against the Snowflake Model, for Democratic Centralism,” The People’s Hammer, April 3, 2026, https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/04/03/against-the-snowflake-model-for-democratic-centralism…. […]
LikeLike