The People's Hammer

Interview with a B.C. Cannery Worker – by Alice S.

, , ,


Alice: What do you do for a living?
Worker: I work on the filling section for a beer bottling company.
Alice: How are your wages and how do they compare to similar occupations in this industry?
Worker: We have a collective agreement, sort of, where we get a negotiated annual increase tied with inflation. It has a maximum of three per cent growth per year. So if inflation goes very high we are bound by three per cent. But still it’s several dollars over minimum wage, it’s around $22 for the lowest position, and then the highest position within that department is like $25-$26.
Alice: What are your hours?
Worker: There’s two shifts that are allowed: four 10-hour days, or five eight-hour days, and sometimes they ask for weekends, like on a Saturday if they didn’t finish on a Friday. But they ask they don’t force anyone to do it.
Alice: Is this a liveable wage in your area?
Worker: I mean, the way that liveable wage is usually described by the government, is if you can afford
a one-bedroom apartment, but that’s not really the standard of living within Vancouver. So, yes it is
liveable, but it is not up to this artificial standard. I am able to afford rent and food.
Alice: The collective agreement that you speak of, is your place unionised?
Worker: Sort of. We have a company union, its name is literally “[Name of the Company] Employee Association”. If you read our contract, the first line of most contracts talk about how it’s an agreement between the employer and the union, but our union contract actually differentiates between three parties, so it’s an agreement between the employee association, the workers, and the employer. Which reveals the company union policy that it has. We have this because five years after we opened, there was an attempt to form a union by the Service Employees International Union, and the company managed to crush it. Because they held a meeting before the vote and they managed to convince everyone, even the people that launched the campaign, that things would be better. I think they brought in an HR person around that time, and they also told the workers that they won’t be scaling up production, that they would stay at the level of a craft brewery. So the workload won’t be too intensive. In the year since though, it has evolved far beyond that. It’s still technically qualified as a craft brewery, but I’ve spoken to a lot of my more senior coworkers, and they said it’s a difference of like a 1,000 liters a day before we would be considered a regular large-scale brewery. So, and this is because we have been doing co-packing. Like, a lot of the big brands in the Lower Mainland that are not directly
from our company, shit like Meddler or Strait & Narrow, are all ones that we co-pack. So, like, that initial thing that was granted to the workers was overdone with time. Then there were a couple more attempts to form a union, and that ultimately led to the company stepping in and saying: “We are not gonna give you a union, we will give you this”. And it’s really weird, even in interviews they call it a “diet union” and “a kind of union”, even the management will tell you that. So we have this union now, and it’s very undemocratic: I remember my first meeting for the union, which they don’t normally hold. They only held it right now to tell us that negotiations have started. And the reason this came to my mind was, like, we had a representative in our department switch departments, so we are no longer in regular contact with him anymore. And they told us, basically: “It’s fine, he is gonna stay your representative”. And then he [the company union rep] asked the group: “Did we elect you? I can’t remember”. Like it’s not even a constitutional thing that has to happen. We kind of have a union, but it’s just a company union, it was brought in by the company to crush any union drives. They also offer
no benefits really.
Alice: What are your coworkers’ opinions of the company union?
Worker: I think I’ve met only one person that loves the company union. They also love the company. Whenever conversation starts on this, they always say: “You know, most companies don’t have HR, we should be grateful that they give us HR”, and they’ll say the same stuff for the company union. I think that’s just because she’s worked in much worse conditions in the past. This person is the only person I’ve met that’s an avid defender of the company union, and other policies like HR. But most of my coworkers will bring it up on their own, like how stupid the company union is, how they don’t bargain for us for anything important, how they don’t even negotiate wage increases, it just increases to keep up with inflation. So it’s not even moving us forward, it’s just keeping us flat. How there’s no elections, no meetings, nothing. Some coworkers even told me, apparently there’s a familial relationship between
the person who runs the company and the person who runs Canadian Work Strategies, which is the company that manages our union. Basically everyone hates the union, and a lot of people want to switch to a new union, the only thing is they don’t know how to do that.
Alice: How do you think they should do that?
Worker: There is a document from the Communist Workers Front (Organising Committee): “On Company Unions”1. It was focusing mainly on the Christian Labour Association of Canada (CLAC). I think it puts forward a good strategy for fighting company unions: the first thing is to encircle them in that industry. In mine it would be, maybe cannery, I don’t know what the exact industry qualification would be, and like organise that industry so it has nowhere to expand. Organise industrially, so to strengthen the labour movement broadly in that industry. And, organise within the union itself to transform it and bring it into those new industrial organisations. And its easier for mine, because its a union only on, uhh, it’s not like CLAC, which is actually, its a single organisation with bodies across the country. Mine is literally just in my shop, so that one is much easier. Organising inside the union means organising inside my shop to vote to form a real union basically.
Alice: You mentioned that the company union is extremely undemocratic. How would you see the boring-from-within and transforming the union from within process looking like in practice?
Worker: I think a lot of people misunderstand boring-from-within to be working from within the union’s organisational body to try to take them over organisationally. Whereas its mainly a thing of working inside the unions, because there are workers there. And trying to use this as a means to win
workers over to communism. Just because these are the largest mass organisations, doing it within them is the best way to do this. Whereas splitting off and forming a new union leaves you without those workers. In a situation where there is a communist party, and your work in the union is not to reconstitute the communist party, but to prepare for people’s war, this might be something different. Like the utility of that strategy could be different. But within my specific workplace, I think, even though it’s undemocratic, there are certain, like, protections you get from being in the union: like I am able to talk to my coworkers much more openly about labour unions, communism – and not fear too much repression. I’ve been able to speak to a lot of my coworkers about the issues in the union, a lot of them bring them up themselves, and I think boring-from-within this union would basically be working within my workplace, talking to my coworkers, and using those protections to my benefit in organising us into a new union. Like, I don’t know, Teamsters or United Food and Commercial Workers, or something like that.
Alice: What would be the demands of your coworkers in the new union?
Worker: Some of my coworkers have brought up that in the summers, when things get really busy, they introduce a night shift, so on paper you get a one dollar bonus for working the night shift, which is much smaller than you would normally get in a factory for night shifts, so people want to see a change in that. I know from last year some coworkers didnt receive that actual bonus at all, so organising to enforce, not to like put the contract up on a pedestal, but to enforce what we’ve won. Basically we should hold the bosses to what they’ve given away, but we shouldn’t hold ourselves to it necessarily. And I think a lot of coworkers are very upset with the way the wage increases are done. I think the CPI-tie made a lot of people think that it’s really beneficial, but the fact is that, because it puts a cap on it at three per cent, which is not that high above what the government tries to keep it up at anyways, that is something that a lot of workers want to change and get something, like in other contracts, where
they are getting like “a seven dollar raise over the next three years”. As well as that being tied to inflation. But just the inflation tie is not that great. I know safety is a big issue, there’s been a lot of injuries. We work with a lot of dangerous chemicals, so people have accidentally poured caustic materials into their boots and have been out for months. Or like gotten it in their eye, things like that. There’s also the final one I would say, our workplace has
placed an emphasis on getting everyone trained on forklift, but because, like I said the going rate for this is 22 dollars an hour, and there’s no wage difference between people that are certified for forklift and do lots of forklifting duty, versus someone who just stands at one of the machines putting boxes in all day. So a lot of people refuse forklift duty or even refuse to get certified on it, because they don’t see any pay benefit because of it. So that’s something that a lot of people want to see: increasing the pay to match the skill of your work. One thing more, sometimes they ask us to do cross-departmental work, which is usually something that, in a real union context, is completely banned or the company will be kinda punished for it by forcing them to pay a high premium for it. Whereas, for us, if we are asked to do some
warehouse work, we don’t get paid warehouse wages for that, so like we’ll basically be doing what is paid 28-29 dollars an hour to do at 22 dollars an hour. Are there more big ones? Oh, okay, here’s one: this is one I guess anyone who has to wear like a lot of PPE at work has an issue with, which is boot reimbursement. So, we get like a 150 dollar
coupons for a year to pay for boots, but that’s not really enough to cover a full pair of work boots anymore, unless you get lucky. And the thing is too, we work with a lot of chemicals, and the chemicals eat into your boots, you can easily see it when you have a fresh pair, and then a month in you can notice a lot of it being stripped away from just the different high concentration of chemicals being used.
So I think the people have been saying a lot that they need higher boot pay and they need it probably twice a year. So I guess it would be like four times bigger than what the current boot pay reimbursement is to actually keep on top of in this company.
Alice: What are the benefits that you do get?
Worker: There is RRSP-matching and healthcare.
Alice: How many people in your workplace are in the company union?
Worker: It’s all the workers, so I think there’s like a hundred workers or so. There’s like a hundred employees, and I don’t know how many of them are workers, so let’s say about 90% of employees are in the company union. And then there’s a warehouse in Delta and then there’s the actual complex in Vancouver which has the brewery, the cellar, the factory site, the warehouse, and then there is a
restaurant associated as well.
Alice: You told me that there have been several union drives going on. Why is your workplace so militant?
Worker: I think the first part would be, like, it’s a light industrial field, so we are producing
commodities and we can see what is being made and what it’s being sold for very concretely, and what our pay is. It’s part of the reason why industrial workers are generally more militant because they experience the actual theft of surplus value the most directly. And then I think like the number of injuries that occur, the very clear overexploitation in terms of like being asked to do semi-skilled labour at the rate of something unskilled, whereas like a lot of people have worked in other warehouses or
other factories in the past, so they know what the rates should be, and then they come here and they bring it up. Like in that one union that I mentioned earlier [the company union], they brought up what the [negotiations] process would be like: they’re gonna send a survey, they are not gonna make any updates, they are not gonna elect a bargaining committee, they’re just gonna handle it all in house. And it was easy at that meeting to just discuss how in these other organised workplaces there are like these
other ways to do it, like giving regular updates, electing a bargaining committee. Even something like this was someting that had to be fought for: that we be given the draft contract before the day of the vote, so people could talk about it, discuss its pros and cons things like that. I think introducing people with experience from other unions and other fields to this workplace also contributes to building up that militancy. I think those might be the main three reasons.
Alice: Do you know what are some other company unions run by Canadian Work Strategies?
Worker: Not off the top of my head, but I know that there is several within BC, and they’re headquartered in Abbotsford. A lot of the ones in BC are formatted similarly to my own, like: “[The Company Name] Employee Association”, those are very very likely to be run by this organisation. I think a lot of companies though, they go for something like CLAC, the Christian Labour Association of
Canada, because they’ve built quite a good reputation, among employers, obviously.
Alice: Do you know of any notable victories or achievements in the broader food and beverage manufacturing industry?
Worker: I can’t think of many off the top of my head. A lot of in that specific industry there’s a lot of like centralisation where a lot of companies are getting bought out by other companies, like AB InBev, and then those larger international monopolies are imposing their standards on these newly acquired companies. I do know there was a struggle at Molson in Montreal a few years ago, there was also the Coca-Cola bottling company in Delta as well. I don’t think they obtained anything like crazy. From what I’ve seen and read about, a lot of the smaller ones under a thousand people don’t seem to have a union, and it seems like an industry where the workers are particularly on the defensive. Or not even on the defensive, they’re unorganised.
Alice: What are some unions in this country that target this industry?
Worker: I mean, Service Employees International Union (SEIU) is one, but they’re kind of shit. They are probably one of the least democratic unions in the country. I think it’s like local 2 of SEIU covers the entire country, so like how are the members even supposed to participate in the union. UFCW, United Food and Commerical Workers, is another. Teamsters I’m sure would also be involved in that
industry. Probably Unifor.
Alice: Does your workplace employ a lot of foreign and undocumented labour?
Worker: Noone at my workplace is in Canada illegally, but there is a lot of immigrant labour, especially from Mexico. In my department specifically it seems like maybe 50% is from Mexico, 50% is from Canada.
Alice: Do you know if these are permanent or temporary residents?
Worker: Oh they’re all temporary residents on open work permits. I think part of the reason why they hire them is because they don’t know their labour rights, even to the extent that an ordinary Canadian worker might. So earlier some workers didn’t get paid a bonus for working night shifts, and there were two of those who were affected by this and they were Mexican immigrants.
Alice: Do you find that they speak English enough to learn about their rights?
Worker: Oh yeah they’re all fluent in English. I think it’s just like if you’ve lived in Canada and worked for several years, everyone kinda has a basic understanding of their basic work rights, like that they need to be paid more if they work holidays even if they don’t know the exact amount. They know that they get sick days in BC, they know things like this. But if you’ve just come from Mexico, you don’t have experience in the Canadian workforce, you’re not familiar with these. Actually sometimes we even get people from France come to Canada and they go: “What, you want me to work on Saturday? And I’m getting paid the same rate? This is ridiculous!”


Footnotes:
(1) https://communistworkers.wordpress.com/2023/11/20/christian-labour-association-of-canada-and-
company-unionism-in-canada/


Response to “Interview with a B.C. Cannery Worker – by Alice S.”

  1. Canadian Work Strategies: A Fascist Front in the Labour Movement – by Daniel H – The People's Hammer