Introduction
The People’s Hammer recently published an article on the right-opportunist perversion of the mass line: the Social Investigation and Class Analysis (SICA) line.1 This article addressed mainly the view of the “Communist Party of the Philippines” and the “(New) Communist Party of Canada” [“(N)CPC”]. While SICA raises the importance of social investigation and class analysis, in practice this line is an excuse to do nothing other than tail the union bureaucracy.
Out of the SICA line, we have seen a superficially opposite error arise. This is the complete brushing off of the importance of class. Ironically, despite their insistence on SICA, the worst perpetrator of this is the “(New) Communist Party of Canada”. This organisation, which disregards class entirely, takes pains to assure you how working-class they are. However, their understanding of what a worker is is almost as broad as ILWU president and former NDP leadership candidate Rob Ashton’s:
“When I talk about the working class, I talk about people who are not the rich and powerful. The working class are people who go to work every day as well as people who want to work but can’t find stable jobs or who have been pushed out of the workforce. This includes people who are marginalized, Indigenous people, LGBTQ+ members.
“If you wake up in the morning and you don’t jump in a car that’s worth a million bucks, if your title isn’t CEO or CFO or something like that, you’re a member of the working class. If you’re a small business owner, you’re working class. That’s how I envision the working class. It’s an all-encompassing term that covers every rank-and-file Canadian.”2
(New) Communist Party of Canada
Halloween Poster Series
Around Halloween 2025, the “(N)CPC” front organisation – United in Struggle (UiS) put up a number of posters showing different monopoly capitalists declaring them to be real monsters. Many of these were their usual targets like Jim Pattison. However, they also decided to put up posters featuring the owner of the Vancouver Canucks, Francesco Aquilini, in a goalie mask with a machete about to attack Trevor Linden. The tagline reads: “If you think the way he treats the fans is bad… wait until you hear about how he treats the workers!”
The clear implication here is that Trevor Linden and NHL players generally are working-class.3 The professional athlete is generally petite-bourgeois. What is the means of work for the athlete? It is their body which they have sole possession over. Even though the athlete has control over their means of work, this does not mean that they have the ability to make a living off of it on its own. In order to put it into effect, they are forced to sign contracts with sport associations that broadcast them displaying their athletic ability. A similar process and relationship is found with musicians and record labels or actors and production agencies. The entertainer meets the middle and big bourgeoisie of their industry as relative equals.
Entertainers such as NHL players, musicians, and actors may become members of the middle and big bourgeoisie when they begin to invest their sizable income and accumulate capital principally through usury, investment, and exploitation rather than entertainment contracts. These larger entertainers may be able to negotiate a cut of the profits or copyright ownership in some way which places them in the position of exploiting the labour-power of workers.
In this Halloween poster series, UiS could have easily chosen to portray Aquilini attacking a concession worker, a maintenance worker, or a security guard (all of whom are genuinely proletarian and exploited by Aquilini). They instead chose to portray him attacking a hockey player, calling them a worker. As will be shown, this poster is not a one-off or a mistake. It is reflective of the dismissive attitude “(N)CPC” has towards class analysis and how they place the petite-bourgeoisie in the vanguard role of the Canadian revolution practically.
Disregard of Class
Despite the all-important SICA slogan of the “(N)CPC”, actual class analysis is disregarded by this organisation. Supporters of The People’s Hammer have met extensively with the rank-and-file of the “(N)CPC” and their fronts across four provinces. In each of these cities, many debates have been had on the need to properly identify class to maintain the independence and initiative of the proletariat. On this question we see two approaches manifested in two different organisations.
First, those that maintain that independence and initiative of the proletariat is essential in building the three instruments and that this requires delineating the different classes in Canadian society. This approach has led to the creation of the Workers United Front of Canada. Its membership is entirely restricted to the proletariat.4 While members of the petite-bourgeoisie are allowed to attend meetings and partake in work, they are not allowed to formally join, vote, or be elected to any post. A small exception is made for progressive union bureaucrats who adhere to the programme in order to keep them under the discipline of the organisation while in office.5
The Workers’ United Front has also made it clear that while it stands for independence and initiative of the class, it does not reject unity with other classes who have an interest in socialist revolution. In the preamble to its programme we find:
“The Workers United Front of Canada aims to fight for the closest possible alliance between the workers and the small farmers. The Workers United Front of Canada will support members of the petite-bourgeoisie, such as the intellectuals and professionals, in retaking control of their professional associations. Through this work with the farmers in the rural areas and petite-bourgeoisie in the cities, the Workers United Front of Canada aims to build a broad anti-imperialist united front and establish a workers’ republic.”6
This position is also found in the Line of the Socialist Revolution of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) which also calls for the united front to be built concentrically starting from the workers’ united front, which will be united with the farmers in a worker-farmer alliance. Around both unity will be built with the petite-bourgeoisie in the form of the people’s front.7
This line does not neglect the need for work among these classes, but recognises the primacy of work among the proletariat and the need for independence of the proletariat in order for them to lead the struggle for communism. Uniting the workers as a class and then in alliance with the farmers is essential to maintaining proletarian hegemony in the united front.
All of this requires understanding class and organisation on a class basis.
Second, there are those who see what the first group’s vision is as ideal and aim to achieve it through shortcuts including a disregard of class. This is the approach of the “(N)CPC” and Workers Alliance (including its Vancouver and Winnipeg branches that operate under the names United in Struggle and 1919 Workers Collective). Workers Alliance is a petite-bourgeois organisation largely composed of students, union bureaucrats, NGO bureaucrats, teachers, professors, and at least one middle capitalist in the construction industry. The “(N)CPC” is far from the only one to conduct the mass line this way, but they are the most opportunist about it.
These groups claim that exact class demarcation is unimportant so long as an individual is “close enough”. The long debates that communists in Canada have had over whether to organise teachers as part of the proletariat or as the petite-bourgeoisie is seen as a waste of time by the opportunists. In effect, this has led to the “(N)CPC” including all social classes up to the middle bourgeoisie in their membership – even in those mass organisations that are meant to be of, by, and, for the workers! Instead of organising on a class basis, they organise on ideological unity alone. If an individual is a middle capitalist in the construction industry, but claims to adhere to the proletarian ideology, they might as well be organised as part of the proletariat. Or, if an individual is a landlord, but claims to be a Maoist, they might as well be put at the forefront of the tenant’s struggle.
From direct communication with the rank-and-file of the “(N)CPC”, we are aware that they have at times realised that this is an issue. In Vancouver, they launched a proletarianisation campaign that largely failed as student-members sought employment in non-proletarian positions or in other cases were quickly fired because they were too undisciplined to work in industries like logistics.8 Despite this, the campaign was deemed to be complete. The “party” seems to have not learned from these mistakes and is going full-steam ahead with another round of implantation in Halifax through the local Workers’ Alliance.9 Surely, it has got to work this time.
Building the Proletarian Party out of the New Bourgeoisie
The communist party is the unification of the advanced workers with the guiding thought of the Canadian revolution in a single militarised political organisation. The communist party is not a number of activists getting together to declare a party, hoping that the advanced workers will join down the line. This latter view of the party was introduced to Canada by the Canadian Communist League (Marxist-Leninist) and taken up by its successors: the Workers Communist Party (Marxist-Leninist) and the “Revolutionary Communist Party”. It is this same attitude that has characterised other “parties” since, most importantly the “(N)CPC” which is a direct successor to these earlier organisations ideologically and organisationally.
The roots of opportunism in the workers movement are the labour aristocracy, union bureaucracy, and the salaried petite-bourgeoisie. This latter group has formed into a large group in the second half of the 20th century and are highly unionised. While this has broadened the camp of the revolution, it has also introduced a new third source of opportunism. These three groups are highly influential and propagate petite-bourgeois ideology in the workers movement.
Stalin, referencing Lenin, explains that there are basically three main sources for the restoration of capitalism:
“Firstly, ‘in the strength of international capital, in the strength and durability of the international connections of the bourgeoisie’ (see Vol. XXV, p. 173).
“Secondly, in the fact that ‘for a long time after the revolution the exploiters inevitably retain a number of great practical advantages: they still have money (it is impossible to abolish money all at once); some moveable property–often fairly considerable; they still have various connections, habits of organisation and management, knowledge of all the ‘secrets’ (customs, methods, means and possibilities) of management, superior education, close connections with the higher technical personnel (who live and think like the bourgeoisie), incomparably greater experience in the art of war (this is very important), and so on, and so forth’ (see Vol. XXIII, p. 354)
“Thirdly, ‘in the force of habit, in the strength of small production. For, unfortunately, small production is still very, very widespread in the world, and small production engenders capitalism and the bourgeoisie continuously, daily, hourly, spontaneously, and on a mass scale’… for ‘the abolition of classes means not only driving out the landlords and capitalists–that we accomplished with comparative ease–it also means abolishing the small commodity producers, and they cannot be driven out, or crushed; we must live in harmony with them, they can (and must) be remoulded and re-educated only by very prolonged, slow, cautious organizational work’ (see Vol. XXV, pp.173 and 189).”
Any of these three sources may be principal in a given situation. The first was principal for example in the overthrow of Democratic Kampuchea. The second was the main source of the White movement in the Russian Revolution. However, it is the third source that has historically been the most important following the consolidation of the proletarian dictatorship and the expropriation of the big and middle bourgeoisie as it provides a real economic base for the restoration of capitalism within the country itself.
In all past socialist and new democratic states, it has been the labour aristocracy and the petite-bourgeoisie (not only the salaried section) that have provided the economic base for the restoration of capitalism. The overthrown bourgeoisie, Stalin’s second source, manifests as the leading force in the restoration of capitalism in the form of the bureaucracy. However, this bureaucracy needs the economic base for restoration in order to act.
Despite all this, the “(N)CPC” have not formed their party on the basis of the most advanced workers. They have formed it on the basis of those who today form the main basis of opportunism (labour aristocrats, union bureaucrats, and the salaried petite-bourgeoisie) and the basis of restoration (the petite-bourgeoisie as a whole and bureaucrats). Specifically, we find in their ranks few workers, but many union bureaucrats, students, teachers, professors, non-profit bureaucrats, and even the middle bourgeoisie in the film and construction industry!
Class Analysis is Not a Morale Issue
Aside from the total disregard of class seen in the “(N)CPC”, there is another major error that arises in class analysis. This is the conflation of class and morality. As the communist movement is expanding to new regions and encouraging real class analysis, it is increasingly coming into contact with this moral outlook. Many on the “left” do not care about class. If they do, it is in terms of 99% vs 1%. When pressed to define the proletariat, it is often reduced to simply having a boss and no one under you. However, this definition opens the door to the Ashton definition given above.
Because of this weak grasp on what class is, members of the progressive petite-bourgeoisie are often deeply offended when told they are not proletarian. They treat it as an accusation that they are immoral. In reality, the fact that a teacher is petite-bourgeois says nothing about this individual’s character. It speaks to the character of their labour. Just because it is petite-bourgeois does not mean that they cannot adopt a proletarian outlook and style of work.
While the proletariat as a class is the sole consistently revolutionary class in society, there are some proletarians who will side with reaction. Similarly, while all other classes are inconsistently revolutionary to outright reactionary, individual deviations occur. So long as they adopt the ideology and style of work of the proletariat, they will be able to contribute to reconstitution as much as any communist worknoter.
Conclusion
Class analysis is a crucial part of the mass line. Without a class analysis, it is impossible for communists to lead the workers in reconstituting their party. It is necessary to delineate the proletariat from the lower petite-bourgeoisie, the semi-proletariat, and the lumpen. When we confuse these classes or treat the differences as unimportant, we forfeit proletarian hegemony in the construction of the party. This approach opens our doors to alien ideologies like postmodernism, liberalism, and revisionism.
Class analysis is also essential for differentiating friends from enemies. Without a proper class analysis, communists can easily wind up the way of the “(N)CPC” where we not only do not fight capitalists, but we invite them to join our party! What is this if not the basis for corporatism?
Ignoring class distinctions and pretending the petite-bourgeoisie are workers does nothing to resolve the contradiction between the proletarian vanguard and the communist movement. Rather than change their style of work for wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda in order to unite with the advanced workers, the “(N)CPC” aims to replace the workers with the petite-bourgeoisie as the leading force of the revolution. This is done mainly through implantation (sending communist students to get jobs) or by recruiting bureaucrats with the hopes that they will bring workers with them. In both cases, the workers are secondary to the role of the petite-bourgeoisie.
In opposition to the “(N)CPC”, we must 1) maintain the independence and initiative of the the proletariat, 2) we must organise the united proletariat as the centre of the united front along strict class lines, 3) We must resolve the contradiction between the advanced workers and the communist movement through wide-spread communist agitation and propaganda with no intermediate stage.
1https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/
2https://jacobin.com/2025/10/canada-ndp-leadership-election-ashton
3The use of Linden is especially bizarre considering he was appointed to an upper management position for the Vancouver Canucks shortly after his retirement as a player nearly two decades ago.
4https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/constitution/
5https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/constitution/
6https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/about/
7https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/10/03/line-of-the-socialist-revolution-by-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
8“While trying to make connections to the workers, these students in fact substitute themselves for the leading role of the workers. In recent years, we have also been able to see a third path taken by the implantationists in addition to those described by In Struggle of adventurism and tailism. This is that many of these student-“workers” are often unable to handle the discipline required for these jobs and just leave to go back to school or find petite-bourgeois employment.” https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/08/29/sica-a-liquidation-of-the-mass-line-by-daniel-h/
Responses to “On Class Analysis – by Daniel H.”
[…] Nota editorului: Publicăm o traducere neoficială a unui articol publicat de The People’s Hammer. Textul original se găsește aici. […]
LikeLike
[…] following document is a translation of On Class Analysis produced by The Red Flag (Romania). We have previously published an interview with them which can […]
LikeLike