The following is a interview with New Hegemony, an italian editorial collective. More of their writings can be found here. The positions put forward in the text do not reflect our line. We are publishing this document with the intention of both bettering the understanding of the international communist movement among workers in Canada and to promote two-line struggle internationally.
ITALIAN SOCIETY
How would you describe the history and characteristics of the current mode of production in Italy?
Under the supervision and with the support of the military bureaucracy of the Savoy monarchy, the liberal bourgeoisie – representing the major merchants, bankers and capitalist landowners of northern Italy, chiefly the north-west – largely brought about the unification in 1861 of a series of small states which, at that time, occupied what was subsequently defined as the ‘Italian nation’.
From the perspective of class relations, unification was achieved on the basis of an alliance between the liberal bourgeoisie of the North and the feudal landowners, mainly from the South and the Islands (Sicily and Sardinia), but also present in Veneto, which, in 1866, in turn became part of the ‘Italian nation’. The feudal landowners, who were particularly influential and even dominant in a number of small states, were in turn surrounded by a bureaucratic-feudal, commercial and financial bourgeoisie, which prospered on feudal agricultural rents. Frightened by the constant uprisings of peasants and small farmers, these landowners and the bureaucratic and parasitic bourgeoisie that supported them often wanted the unification of Italy more than the reactionary liberal bourgeoisie of the North and, for example, of Tuscany. Unification was seen as the only way to pacify the broad masses of peasants and smallholders through the repression of a centralised bureaucratic-military state.
For decades, right up until the end of the 19th century, and thanks in part to the active and direct involvement of major foreign banks – initially French and later, above all, German – manufacturing developed first, followed by industry proper, in northern Italy. With the departure of the major banks from the country – which had, in any case, already shaped the industrial structure of Northern Italy to serve the economic interests of German capitalist industries – the first industrial and financial monopolies were established in Italy, and the unification of the national market was achieved, bringing about the full subordination of agricultural production and trade in Southern Italy and the islands to the interests of Northern Italy’s industrial and financial capital. Thus the foundations were laid for the emergence of Italian imperialism in the early 20th century. This was a marginal form of imperialism compared to that of the major European countries, dependent on German industries, lacking in capital and therefore characterised by a significant role for the state as a lever for accumulation in the service of the industrial development of the North. Imperialism in Italy arose already intertwined with the state and was thus marked by a bureaucratic and parasitic character, characterised by public intervention in support of the interests of industry and the big banks. The state, as the lever of capitalist development in the North, through repression became the guarantor, on the one hand, of the extraction of maximum surplus value from the proletariat of the North and, on the other, of a semi-colonial domination of the South and the Islands which, in practice, translated into the coexistence and superimposition of this feudal rent for the super-exploitation of the vast masses of peasants and smallholders. Thus a dominant bloc emerged, at once bureaucratic, industrial and feudal, held together by a common interest in preventing the workers’ and peasants’ revolution. Whilst the major European countries had witnessed liberal revolutions, agrarian reforms, the rise of free competition and the establishment of forms of bourgeois democracy, Italy, due to the ferocity of the class struggle and the consequent need to safeguard the interests of the various reactionary factions and classes, in order to avoid the emergence of dangerous contradictions within the dominant bloc, never experienced either a genuine liberal revolution, nor, as regards the South and the Islands, a genuine agrarian reform.
On the basis of the large monopolistic and financial capital of Northern Italy and the vast feudal landholdings, the Italian bureaucratic-reactionary liberal state, after the First World War and faced with the revolutionary upheaval of the ‘Biennio Rosso’ of 1919–1920, the occupation of factories and the birth of the Communist Party of Italy [PCd’I], chose the path of fascism. A path which, as Antonio Gramsci, the greatest Italian Marxist-Leninist and founder of the PCd’I, emphasised, had been determined not by a break with the liberal regime but, on the contrary, in full continuity with its specific bureaucratic-reactionary character.
Mussolini’s fascism, which held sway in Italy from 1923 until July 1943, gave a significant boost to the development of Italian imperialism and, in particular, state monopoly capitalism, but all this without altering in any way its bureaucratic structure and its marginal character. Thus, it did nothing to overcome the backwardness of the productive structure and the Italian capitalist economy, which, on the contrary, were fully perpetuated. Fascism, particularly through land reclamation and public works projects, initiated the penetration of state-monopolistic capitalism into the countryside and urban centres of the South and the Islands. A new class of landowners emerged from this process. These were agricultural landowners who went on to invest in urban rents and secured profits and privileges bestowed by state-monopoly capital. On this basis, new banks and new enterprises also developed. In the South and the Islands, all this took place under the influence of the landowners who, in this way, also began to give rise to semi-feudalism.
The Italian imperialist bourgeoisie, terrified by the turning point in the course of the Second World War represented by the Red Army’s offensive, by the development of the wars of liberation from Nazi-fascism underway in Eastern Europe and the Balkans, and by the expansion of the clandestine Italian Communist Party’s initiative in factories and various urban centres, chose to abandon German Nazism and align itself with Anglo-American imperialism. The fascist-monarchist regime recognised this need and decreed in July 1943 the formal transfer of powers to the monarchy, obviously without thereby relinquishing its own positions of power within the state. Only a minority within the regime, including Mussolini himself, chose to remain with Nazism and concentrated in those areas of the country still occupied by German forces.
The Great Anti-Fascist Resistance, which in Italy began later than the partisan wars in Europe and the Balkans, was progressively neutralised following the Salerno Turn initiated by Togliatti during the early months of 1944, with the PCI’s entry into the reactionary bourgeois government of national unity.
It was within the context of this turning point that Togliatti’s leadership also decided to proceed with changing the party’s name from the ‘Communist Party of Italy’ [PCd’I] to the ‘Italian Communist Party’ [PCI].
With the Salerno Turn, Togliatti’s leadership worked to prevent the anti-fascist resistance from proceeding, under the direction of the communists, towards a people’s democratic revolution on the path to socialism, whilst simultaneously severing the link between the “anti-fascist resistance” and the development of the agrarian revolution in the South and the Islands. From the spring of 1944 to the summer of 1947, Togliatti’s PCI had a significant presence in the bourgeois governments, which included a large part of the forces that had previously constituted the fascist-monarchist regime, now recycled into the Christian Democrats and other minor parties.
The so-called agrarian reforms of the 1950s, strongly championed by US imperialism, were followed shortly afterwards by land reclamation and agricultural land consolidation schemes, as well as by the establishment of the Cassa del Mezzogiorno to serve the policy of the so-called ‘development hubs’; revived and continued, in forms that had changed only partially (the consortium system, the promotion of cooperatives and the role of Federconsorzi, Confagricoltura and Coldiretti) in the South and the Islands, and often with the same technical and managerial staff as the previous regime, the policy of restructuring semi-feudalism and developing bureaucratic capitalism in the South.
As far as agrarian relations are concerned, this has resulted in the partial fragmentation of the old large estates, which has produced a widespread small-scale peasant ownership lacking sufficient land to give rise to capitalistic-style accumulative farms, and subject to savage exploitation by the monopolistic industrial, financial and large-scale retail enterprises of the North.
The South and the Islands were therefore entirely unable to overcome the agricultural and social crisis that had always plagued them as a constituent part of what Antonio Gramsci termed the Southern Question.
The ‘agrarian reforms’ were followed by a staggering exodus abroad, and partly to the North of the country itself, of millions of farmers and small-scale livestock breeders, whilst at the same time the cities of the South grew, fuelled by a fragmented, marginalised petty bourgeoisie sporadically employed in a backward service sector.
As for the so-called ‘industrial development hubs’, these emerged as a means for industrial monopolies to penetrate the South and the Islands, aimed at plundering their resources, exporting toxic manufacturing processes and overexploiting the workforce, without this translating into capitalist-industrial development in those parts of the country.
The intensification of the general crisis of capitalism in the early 1970s, which in Italy manifested itself in the processes of crisis, restructuring and downsizing of large industries, also led to a crisis in state holdings and the end of development policy, with a consequent opening up to the influx of foreign capital.
The Social Question, relating to capitalist exploitation exacerbated beyond belief by a generally backward industrial production structure, strongly characterised by parasitism and now devoid of large national monopoly enterprises, and the Southern Question are the two main contradictions, from the perspective of the structure of the capitalist mode of production currently in force in Italy, which are driving the situation towards proletarian revolution and which require a people’s democratic revolution on the path to socialism.
How would you describe the current form of the state: as liberal-democratic, fascist, or something else?
The current form of the state in Italy is characterised by an advanced stage of fascistisation. The trend is towards the establishment and consolidation of a fascist regime. The situation is, in many respects, comparable to that of 1923, the year in which Mussolini’s fascism was able to establish itself in government.
However, the current body of laws, which preclude or restrict the political and trade union freedoms of the proletariat and the masses, is even more repressive and restrictive than the system in place at the very beginning of the regime.
In reality, Italy has never witnessed a liberal democratic revolution, neither at the time of its unification nor at the end of the Second World War, when a large part of the state apparatus that had operated in the service of fascism continued to function under the guise of a ‘constitutional parliamentary republic’.
By the end of the Second World War, the form of the state was liberal-corporatist and therefore not even ‘bourgeois-democratic’.
What are the dominant forms of bourgeois influence within the Italian labour movement?
With the rise of imperialism in Italy, an influential labour aristocracy emerged, particularly in the North, which established, consolidated and closely tied all the semi-liberal and reformist forms of organisation within the labour movement – which had been predominant by the end of the nineteenth century – to the reactionary state. The General Confederation of Labour, together with the Italian Socialist Party [PSI], were the main vehicles through which this labour aristocracy expressed itself. They played a decisive role in the defeat of the ‘Red Biennium’ of 1919–1920 and worked to pave the way for the advent of Mussolini’s fascism. Many intellectuals and political and trade union cadres of the PSI defected to fascism, along with a section of the anarcho-syndicalists, and continued to operate through the corporatist structures developed in the 1920s and 1930s by the fascist regime itself.
The Great Anti-Fascist Resistance undermined the influence of the labour aristocracy, but the Togliatti leadership, together with other reactionary ‘constitutional’ bourgeois parties, paved the way for the formation of new trade union structures representing the interests of this social stratum linked to imperialist super-profits.
The development of state-monopoly capitalism has established a more organic relationship with the labour aristocracy. This has occurred in particular through the processes of restructuring semi-feudalism, with the development of the semi-servile system of cooperatives and with the integration of state holdings into the system. In practice, a process has unfolded that has transformed the old social democracy of the 1920s and 1930s into modern revisionism and its associated form of social fascism.
How are Italian workers organised compared to those in other imperialist countries?
In the 1960s, the influence of the reactionary trade unions (CGIL, CISL and UIL) over the working and popular masses gradually eroded, and a series of economic, social and political factors created an unprecedented situation of strong readiness for struggle and mobilisation. The absence of a Marxist-Leninist-Maoist party was the decisive factor, both then and in the subsequent decade of the 1970s, in the process of disintegration and retreat of a social and political situation that had taken on a broadly revolutionary character.
In the 1970s, the three reactionary trade union confederations were revitalised through the incorporation of various opportunist, pseudo-revolutionary forces (Avanguardia Operaria-DP, Lotta Continua, Trotskyist, Bordigist and anti-Maoist Marxist-Leninist groups, etc.).
In the late 1980s, alternative trade unions emerged (CUB, RdB, Slai Cobas, etc.). These unions, with the exception of Slai-Cobas until around 2007–2010, were never effectively present among the workers. In any case, these were reformist formations made up of members of the old trade union left and opportunist groups which today hinder the formation of a Maoist party and a corresponding red trade union current.
What are some of the most significant struggles that Italian workers are waging at present?
It must be borne in mind that workers, as such, have no trade union rights in Italy (to strike, bargain, organise, etc.) since all rights are granted by law primarily to reactionary trade unions and only to a minimal extent to opportunist ones. Anti-worker and anti-people agreements between reactionary trade unions, governments and employers’ associations become part of current legislation. The trend towards fascistisation and corporatisation is particularly pronounced in factories and workplaces. Consequently, those sectors of the workforce not operating under the hegemony of the confederal and opportunist trade unions are currently a fragmented and passive group.
Alternative trade unions are mostly present in marginal employment sectors or in the public sector and have virtually no following in factories. In some cases, however, there have been severe repressive measures against them, with several hundred workers reported to the authorities and various trade unionists arrested. Furthermore, some companies organise teams of fascists to attack workers. All this is happening mainly in the logistics sector.
In reality, alternative trade unions operate largely on an opportunistic basis, focusing on initiatives outside the workplace and working hours and aimed at influencing public opinion as a means of putting pressure on reactionary governments. These initiatives are combined with legal proceedings before the labour courts, which are conducted by specialist teams of lawyers. These trade unions function like businesses that sustain themselves financially with the money from cases won by workers, from whom they retain a fee for the legal services provided. The system of legal cases also creates a relationship of dependency between workers and trade union organisations. This is one of the various aspects of the problem of corporatism.
To develop class-based trade union work, Marxist-Leninist-Maoist communists must have a sufficient presence in factories and workplaces. Essentially, this requires the formation of a party suited to the tasks and the situation of the class struggle in Italy.
ITALIAN COMMUNIST MOVEMENT
Our readers are probably not very familiar with the history of the Communist Party of Italy. Could you summarise the main stages of its formation and development?
During the last decades of the nineteenth century, various socialist groups were formed which, in 1892, merged into the Italian Workers’ Party; a party which, a few years later, took the name Italian Socialist Party. Within that party, the influence of the revolutionary Marxists was in the minority. During the First World War, the PSI adopted an opportunist, centrist stance, putting forward the slogan ‘neither join nor sabotage’ with regard to the imperialist war. The crisis generated by the First World War, accompanied by the echoes of the Great October Revolution and the struggle led by Lenin for the formation of the Third Communist International, led to the formation of the first communist groups in Italy. The main ones were the Ordine Nuovo group led by Gramsci, active mainly in the large factories of the Turin area, and Bordiga’s group, which was widespread across a number of towns and cities throughout the country.
In January 1921, at the PSI congress in Livorno, a substantial number of communist delegates walked out of the meeting due to the refusal by the PSI majority, including Serrati’s maximalist wing, to adopt the 21 points for admission to the Communist International. Immediately after 21 January, still in Livorno, the communist delegates opened the the founding congress of the PCd’I. In the party’s Central Committee, of the members of the Ordine Nuovo, only Antonio Gramsci was elected. The Bordigists would heavily influence the early years of the PCd’I’s existence and activities, adopting a sectarian and extremist line, which in reality resulted in a passive and right-wing opportunist approach to the party’s initiatives. In particular, they historically opposed work amongst the peasant masses and hindered the involvement of communists within the popular anti-fascist armed resistance movement of the Arditi del Popolo. In the latter case, the Bordigists argued that communists should confine themselves to forming their own armed groups.
The counter-current work carried out within the PCd’I by Antonio Gramsci and the cadres from the Ordine Nuovo, supported by the Third International, and the gradual erosion of the Bordigists’ influence—who were increasingly aligned with the Trotskyists—created the conditions for the complete defeat of Bordigism at the Third Congress of the PCd’I, held clandestinely in Lyon in January 1926. The triumph of Gramsci’s line, following his election as secretary of the PCd’I, gave a strong impetus to the party’s organisation and growth, and, on the whole, it can be argued that Gramsci himself was its true founder.
The Third Congress highlighted the importance of the Southern Question and the centrality of the slogan of a revolutionary workers’ and peasants’ government, signifying the necessary unity between the proletariat—predominantly based in Northern Italy— and the popular masses of peasants and smallholders, who were predominantly found in the South and the Islands. The theme of the proletariat’s hegemony over the popular and peasant masses also entailed a particular focus on the oppression inflicted upon the South and the Islands by the reactionary Italian state, which served the imperialism of the North and the great feudal landowners of the South. In this context, the PCd’I formulated the slogan of a socialist federal state to safeguard and represent the demands for autonomy and self-determination of important regional entities, primarily Sardinia and Sicily.
Gramsci also developed the military theory of the Italian proletariat on the basis of Marxism-Leninism, synthesising its revolutionary experience. In particular, Gramsci emphasised that the Italian situation could not lead to a form of proletarian revolution immediately characterised by insurrection in the country’s major urban centres. His analysis of the economic and social situation, his examination of the experience of the Arditi del Popolo and, above all, of the endemic uprisings of the peasant and pastoral masses, led him to highlight the importance—albeit only on a tactical level—of guerrilla initiatives and the need for a proletarian revolution spreading simultaneously across the entire territory, characterised only in its final phase by insurrection in the main urban centres. Much of his teaching contributed to the preparation and development of the military activities of the communists within the framework of the anti-fascist resistance.
At the end of 1926, the Fascists imprisoned Gramsci. The arrest took place under dubious circumstances, after a series of previous attempts to help Gramsci go underground had failed due to the emergence of obscure organisational problems. This is a situation that strongly suggests political responsibility and a relative influence of the ‘black line’ within the PCd’I. Gramsci addresses the issue obliquely in his Prison Notebooks in his comments on Dante’s ‘Tenth Canto of Hell’.
Following Gramsci’s arrest, a leadership group headed by Togliatti was formed. Formally, it adopted Marxist-Leninist positions, but in practice it pursued semi-Trotskyist positions, gradually abandoning the issue of the agrarian revolution. Furthermore, under Togliatti, the PCI began to develop, behind the scenes, an interpretation of fascism as Bonapartism, exaggerating and emphasising the mass character of Mussolini’s regime. All this was then still masked by the slogan of a directly socialist revolution as the outcome of the struggle against fascism.
In 1943 and 1944, with the Salerno Turn, these positions emerged, translating into the thesis that a socialist revolution was impossible due to the Anglo-American landing at Salerno in September 1943. From this point, the now openly revisionist thesis began to take shape, arguing for the need for a sort of progressive democracy to be developed within ‘bourgeois democracy’, to the point of introducing ‘elements of socialism’. This line adopted by the PCI, which downplays the party’s political tasks in a reformist sense and attempts to reduce the military struggle of the communist partisans against the alliance between the minority Mussolini faction of fascism and German Nazism to the period before the Second World War, led many grassroots and mid-level partisans to leave the party at the end of the Second World War, whilst some small groups decided to continue the armed struggle even after the establishment of the ‘new’ parliamentary state. In those years, in fact, the left wing of the party, represented by Secchia, acted as a bridge with Togliatti, and thus there was a lack of leadership capable of adequately representing, politically, the revolutionary, proletarian and anti-fascist demands.
Togliatti, having become Minister of Justice in the government of national unity after the Second World War, would enshrine his murky theories of fascism as a mass Bonapartist regime, decreeing an amnesty for imprisoned fascists and simultaneously opening the doors of the Communist Party—now established as a ‘mass reformist party’—to the Gentilian intellectuals of the previous fascist regime.
The Great Anti-Fascist Resistance marked the beginning of a people’s democratic revolution on the path to socialism. The rise of revisionism stifled and halted this process, but the political and economic factors that had driven it continued, albeit in different forms and with different dynamics, to remain active until they erupted once more in the 1960s and 1970s and are beginning to resurface today.
While in prison, before his murder through the deliberate denial of medical care by the fascist regime, Gramsci summarised his immortal thoughts on the proletarian revolution in Italy in his monumental work Prison Notebooks, a work which remains of great importance and relevance today for the work of rebuilding the Communist Party.
What has been its historical role?
The Communist Party of Italy was the only party the Italian proletariat has ever had for the preparation and conduct of the proletarian revolution and for the establishment of socialism. Gramsci’s Thought encapsulates the theoretical foundation necessary for the construction of the PCd’I. It is therefore impossible to build a Marxist-Leninist-Maoist Communist Party that is not at the same time a reconstruction of the PCd’I and a new qualitative development of Gramsci’s Thought itself.
When did the Communist Party of Italy adopt the name Italian Communist Party, and why did this name change take place?
The name ‘Communist Party of Italy’ indicated that the ‘Communist Party’ was the Italian section of the Communist International and that the party represented the unity between workers and peasants, which spanned the entire territory of what had emerged as the ‘Italian nation’.
A nation born in the mid-19th century primarily in the interests of France, which saw the need for an “Italian state” to counterbalance the influence of the Austrian Empire in Europe, and which had grouped together and incorporated—including through colonial conquest—various territorial entities that were economically, politically and culturally disparate, could certainly not be accepted by a communist party as the organic expression of a national and popular liberal revolution. Hence the rejection by the communists of the time of the name ‘Italian Communist Party’.
The change of the party’s name, from PCd’I to PCI, occurred as an expression of the Salerno Turn and the related decision by Togliatti’s leadership to prioritise national unity with the old monarchist-fascist remnants and the reactionary liberal and clerical parties under the direction of Anglo-American imperialism. The change of the party’s name was therefore intended to emphasise a supposed national character of the ‘Communist Party’ and to sanction the scaling back of the Communist Party’s hegemonic role and tasks with regard to the realities of the South and the Islands and, in general, to the Southern Question. This amounted to a renunciation of the pursuit of the path of agrarian revolution and the struggle for the right to self-determination – as the outcome of a victorious people’s democratic revolution – for those regional entities that would have wished to benefit from it within the framework of the formation of a federal state or a federation of people’s democracy states on the road to socialism.
In short, the Communist Party’s change of name was an expression of a revisionist interpretation of the application of the ‘red line’ of the Seventh Congress of the Communist International.
When was the Communist Party of Italy ideologically and politically liquidated? Can you describe the process that led to this liquidation?
The liquidation of the Communist Party of Italy was a protracted process that began, following Gramsci’s arrest, with the clash over the party’s line regarding the prospect of defeating fascism. Whilst Gramsci essentially placed at the centre the line of uninterrupted people’s democratic revolution based on a workers’ and peasants’ bloc under proletarian hegemony, as we have already seen, Togliatti advocated a semi-Trotskyist line of directly socialist revolution. It can be argued that revisionism became irreversibly established within the Communist Party with the Salerno Turn and the entry of the ‘PCI’ into the new bourgeois parliamentary state operating under the supervision of American imperialism.
What role did the Italian Communist Party play in Italian society and in the labour movement following the rise of revisionism within it?
The fundamental issue is to understand that Togliatti’s PCI was no longer a social-democratic party like those of the 1920s and 1930s, but a modern revisionist party, a social-fascist party in that it was by then tied to state-monopoly capitalism (both public and private) and no longer simply to the labour aristocracy. Obviously, one must distinguish this structural nature of the PCI from the forms in which it manifested itself. Forms which, for a whole period, still formally invoked Gramsci and Marxism-Leninism. To understand this, one must look at the political role objectively played by this party in the amnesty for fascists and in its collaboration with the state in the persecution of the very same communist partisans after the Second World War. Alongside this, one must recall the decisive role of the PCI in the defeat of the revolutionary peasant struggle for land after the Second World War. All this took place in constant opposition to anything that might have contributed to the revival of the anti-fascist people’s revolution. It is also well known that the social-fascists within the state, including the so-called left subsequently represented by Cossutta’s group, played a role in the persecution and repression of the organisations of the 1970s that expressed petty-bourgeois revolutionary ideas. With the dissolution of the social-imperialism of the former USSR, the PCI began to change its name, eventually merging with the so-called Christian Democratic left, giving rise to the current PD. This trajectory, to this day, has seen it play a leading role in the most heinous anti-worker and anti-popular measures, in the worst militaristic and warmongering ventures of Italian imperialism, in the promotion of racist laws and, systematically, in the entire policy of fascistisation of the state.
The workers who began to leave the PCI en masse in the 1960s and 1970s continued to do so in the decades that followed. The problem was that there was no Marxist-Leninist-Maoist party ready to represent them.
But the main issue concerns the various revisionist and opportunist groups. It is they who, to this day, have fought bitterly—albeit not openly or head-on—against Maoism, at times even attempting to appropriate the reference to Maoism in order to oppose it more effectively. Their actions have essentially been aimed at the preventive destruction of the subjective, ideological and organisational conditions necessary for the construction of the Maoist party.
When did the struggle to reconstitute the Communist Party of Italy begin?
Actually, following the revisionist transformation of the PCI, the struggle in Italy for the reconstruction of the PCd’I began almost immediately. The problem is that, in order for this struggle to succeed, develop and establish itself, it must be organically grounded in Maoism and thus in a clear demarcation from revisionism and from opportunism. If all this does not happen, we find ourselves faced with a paradoxical situation where it is opportunism that seeks to pollute, exploit and bend the tendency towards the reconstruction of the PCd’I to its own ends. This is what has in fact happened to date.
Apart from the Communist Party of Italy, there have been many other revolutionary organisations in Italy; for various reasons, some of them have had a certain influence on the communist movement in Canada, such as the Red Brigades and, subsequently, organisations claiming to adhere to Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, such as the nPCI and the Maoist Communist Party-Italy, the latter linked to the international website Maoist Road and the international journal ‘Two Lines Struggle’. Could you tell us how New Hegemony assesses these three experiences?
We can limit ourselves to discussing these three organisations: the Red Brigades [BR], the New PCI [nPCI] and the PCm-Italy [originally the Agit-Prop Collective and subsequently Rossoperaio, now also known as Proletari Comunisti]. Obviously, only the Red Brigades are significant from the point of view of the historical experience of the class struggle in Italy; the other two groups are of entirely relative importance, essentially only insofar as they have been dabbling in Marxism-Leninism-Maoism for decades, creating ideological confusion and hindering the reconstruction of the Communist Party.
The BR were a historical phenomenon linked to a political movement that went through various phases and saw the emergence of different political groups. A movement which, from its very inception, never addressed the question of rebuilding the Communist Party.
To put it as simply as possible, we can identify three phases: the initial phase, which ended in early 1975 and was led by the so-called ‘historic core’; the intermediate phase, marked by the kidnapping and murder of Aldo Moro, one of the leading figures of the Christian Democrats; and what we might call the final phase, associated with the acronym ‘BR – Combatant Communist Party’.
The first phase is linked mainly to the role of three figures: Renato Curcio, Margherita Cagol and Renato Franceschini. It concludes with the arrest of Franceschini, who subsequently distanced himself from the Red Brigades’ activities and the use of revolutionary violence; the cold-blooded execution of Margherita Cagol; and the arrest, in 1976, of Curcio, who later adopted positions specifically characterised by references to ‘critical Marxism’ and postmodernism. Central to this phase was the intervention linked to forms of ‘armed propaganda’ directed at the ‘factory front’, conceived as support, stimulus and radicalisation of trade union struggles. This intervention was combined with forms of action directed primarily against the repressive apparatus, including the 1974 kidnapping of Judge Sossi, conceived as a revival and application of the Guevarist experience of the Tupamaros in Uruguay. The kidnapping was aimed at securing the release of nd a number of political prisoners. The judge was released by the Red Brigades after a few weeks, without the government in power at the time having authorised such a release. The second phase focuses on the shift from ‘armed propaganda’ directed at factories to the so-called ‘unfolding civil war’ within society. In this phase, the reference to revisionist theories of attacking the ‘heart of the state’ and dismantling the ‘imperialist state of multinationals’ is further substantiated, both theoretically and in practical-political terms. These theories conceived of the state as an unstable equilibrium defined by economic, political and bureaucratic-repressive forces. An equilibrium that could be broken in order to generate a dynamic of progressive development of conflicts and struggles within the ‘state’ and the ‘ruling class’. It was against this backdrop that Moro was kidnapped, as he was seen as the main architect of the ‘broad coalition’ political project concerning the government of national solidarity between the DC, the main governing party, and the ‘PCI’, the main formal opposition party. Moro’s murder took place amidst the emerging crisis and decline of the social opposition movements of the 1970s and marked the beginning of the very disintegration of the Red Brigades.
The third phase, that of the ‘combatant party’, is characterised by successive splits between factions closer to the themes of workerism [operaismo] and workers’ autonomy [Autonomia Operaia], and others more closely linked to the vision of an armed movement which, through its initiative aimed at striking at the so-called ‘projects’ of economic and institutional restructuring by the main political and institutional forces, would create the conditions for a shift to the left among forces of the reformist political and trade union left and the mass movements. The ‘combatant party’ too saw strategy as spontaneously and mechanically inherent in the initiative of the proletariat and in the movements, and organisation—represented precisely by a ‘combatant party’—and military action as the necessary tactics for the development of a long-term revolutionary process.
In 1980, the book “The Bee and the Communist” [“L’Ape e il comunista”] was published by the “Red Brigades Prisoners’ Collective”. This is the only comprehensive theoretical-political text produced by the BR, to which one might perhaps add a text of lesser significance and impact, entitled “Politics and Revolution”, written by four militant cadres and published in 1983 by the Rapporti Sociali publishing house. “The Bee and the Communist” seeks to put forward a mechanistic conception of the general crisis of capitalism of the ‘collapse’ variety, meaning by this term a view of the crisis as an alternation of periods of expansion and increasingly catastrophic collapses attributable to the law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall, culminating in imperialist world war. These conceptions are similar to those of Paul Mattick’s councilism and the theories of Henryk Grossman, which have been taken up by various Trotskyist and Bordigist tendencies. This is a perspective aimed at providing a theoretical basis for the spontaneousist approach, which presupposes an antagonistic and potentially revolutionary dynamic set in motion by mass movements under the pressure of the ‘crisis-collapse’, and which underlies the theory of the disarticulation of the ‘heart of the state’ and of the “broad coalition government projects” among bourgeois political, institutional and trade union forces.
The early Red Brigades, despite the eclecticism and opportunistic positions that characterised them—including the idea of armed propaganda as the means of gathering, concentrating and forming the organisation—were one of the expressions of a vast proletarian and popular mass movement which, in various forms, practised forms of struggle characterised by revolutionary violence. In this context, the BR were one of hundreds of groups and organisations that, in those years, carried out revolutionary actions, albeit by far the most significant.
In this sense, and viewed within this context, the early Red Brigades were nonetheless an organisation belonging to the proletarian and popular masses. Conversely, the subsequent phases of the Red Brigades were characterised by a marked intellectualism-subjectivism and by petty-bourgeois revolutionary theoretical and political positions.
The New PCI [nPCI] was formed in the early years of the current millennium. In effect, it is the expression of a process of synthesis and of a small group of militants close to the experiences of the BR and other militant groups linked to the radicalisation of the positions of the Workers’ Autonomy [Autonomia Operaia] movement. This gathering, within the framework of the formation of the CARC and the network for the distribution of the journal and publications of the “Rapporti Sociali” publishing house, was distinguished by a critical assessment and self-critical of these experiences. This assessment led this group to theorise a sort of ‘New Synthesis’ between these experiences and Marxism-Leninism-Maoism.
This New Synthesis has developed under the banner of a substantial liquidation of the experience of the Third International, of Gramsci’s Thought and of Maoism, which is formally claimed but considered incapable, in itself, of answering the question of why the socialist revolution has not been able to triumph in the imperialist countries. The outcome of this liquidationist assessment is a particular vision of the ‘protracted people’s war’, according to which this war has already begun in Italy with the formation of the nPCI and a related supposed process of ‘accumulation of forces’. This essentially amounts to the strategy of the ‘people’s bloc government’, also defined as an ‘emergency government’ or ‘government of national liberation’. This strategy is supposed to lead to the establishment, or at least to an advanced process of building, an alternative government involving bourgeois political forces such as, for example, sections of the M5S, the CGIL, the pacifist movement, alternative trade unions and a large part of the opportunist groups. The thesis underlying this strategy is that the state and the hegemonic sectors within the bourgeoisie would be driven to respond to this process with civil war. Which, according to the nPCI, would allow for the launch of a second phase of the “people’s war”.
The nPCI explains the possibility of different forces converging to form a people’s government through the theory of the crisis of absolute overproduction of capital, which would break down the social mediations that guarantee the maintenance of the bourgeoisie’s political and hegemonic rule and which, at the same time, would push the forces of the ‘bourgeois left’ and the ‘opportunists’ further and further to the left. This theory is none other than that of the crisis-collapse, originally proposed by the Red Brigades to explain why a party such as those of the Third International was no longer necessary.
To underpin this argument, the nPCI also refers to F. Engels’ Introduction to the Class Struggles in France, ignoring the fact that Leninism—and, more generally, the subsequent development of the ICM—has moved beyond the positions expressed in that text. The nPCI maintains that, in this text, Engels outlines a model for the revolutionary strategy of capitalist countries characterised by the existence and role of parliamentary activity.
The nPCI and the CARC party, which represents its open political expression, are clearly a form of revisionism centred on the question of the use of the ‘bourgeois parliament’ and the deepening of inter-bourgeois contradictions, whether real or imagined; a form of revisionism that echoes similar theories put forward by opportunist groups of the 1970s (left-wing government, workers’ government, anti-fascist popular front government, etc.).
The underlying problem is that this revisionism masquerades in the form of a group, such as the nPCI, which declares itself clandestine, claims to draw on Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, and invokes the experience and a series of theories of the Red Brigades.
The so-called Maoist Communist Party-Italy, now also known as Proletari Comunisti-PCm, has its roots in the PC(M-L)I-La Voce Operaia of the first half of the 1970s. The PC(M-L)I emerged from the UCI(m-l), which was made up of Trotskyist forces and members from the ‘left’ of the PSI. With the rectification campaign of 1971–1972, it advocated the need to merge ‘Marxism-Leninism-Mao Tse-tung Thought’ with Bordigism and, in particular, with the workerism of Antonio Negri, going so far as to propose to Negri himself a merger with a substantial component of the Autonomia Operaia, in the delusional aim of asserting, as the PC(M-L)I, its own hegemony over the latter movement. Thus it came to pass that, a few years later, this small party dissolved into the far more significant sphere of Autonomia Operaia itself.
The history of the PC(M-L)I is key to understanding the nature of the positions put forward by the PCm-Italia at national and international level. It represents yet another form of liquidation of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, which in 1982–1984 (the year of the RIM’s formation) positioned itself to the ‘far left’ of Avakian himself. A few years earlier, in its newspaper at the time, entitled Agit-Prop, it had openly attacked Marxism-Leninism and Mao himself on account of his alleged nationalism.
PCm-Italia almost never formally sets out its fundamental theoretical and political positions in specific documents. From this perspective, it does not even carry out genuine party work and therefore represents, more than anything else, an attempt to build – through a movement-based approach – a political organisation within the day-to-day struggles associated with social movements and trade union work. It therefore rejects the need to formulate specific theses (apart from the miserably failed attempt in issue no. 0 of its journal) and a specific programme for the revolution in Italy, and promotes, in the realm of daily political initiative, a pragmatic approach and line. In essence, it is an eclectic group.
It has always adopted, both nationally and internationally, the approach of waging a dirty, underground war against Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, whilst at the same time seeking to present itself as the authentic and sole representative of Maoism in Italy and even in Europe, including by promoting various initiatives of so-called ‘solidarity and support for the people’s wars of New Democracy’ for this purpose.
For decades, thanks in part to the contacts established during the era of the PC(M-L)I and subsequently to the support obtained from Avakian, then through the attempt to re-present itself as the interpreter in Italy of the PCP and the Thought of Chairman Gonzalo, and finally by seeking to present itself as a group directly supported by the Indian CPI (Maoist) itself, it has developed a chameleonic policy on an international scale that has secured it various forms of support and approval. Today it is engaged in rallying former Avakianist, centrist and opportunist forces in an attempt to create a new RIM.
About New Hegemony
How does New Hegemony define itself: as an organisation or an editorial group?
New Hegemony is an editorial collective made up of a group of militant intellectuals, which aims to contribute to the application of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism and the universal contributions of Chairman Gonzalo to the Italian context.
What is New Hegemony’s stated aim?
The objective is the formation and unification of a Maoist tendency, with a view to rebuilding Antonio Gramsci’s Communist Party.
Can you briefly describe New Hegemony’s conception of Maoism?
All this is theoretically summarised in the motto: “To resume Gramsci’s Path on the basis of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism and the Universal Contributions of Chairman Gonzalo and to rebuild the Party”.
Why is the communist movement in Italy currently fragmented?
Almost all the parties and political forces that today in Italy define themselves as communist have their roots, directly or indirectly, in the social-fascist PCI and in the opportunist and petty-bourgeois revolutionary groups of the 1960s and 1970s. In particular, a number of forces stem from the Communist Refoundation Party, which, during the 1990s, garnered more than 4% of the total electorate. This party was formed by incorporating elements of the PCI’s left wing with Democrazia Proletaria (semi-Trotskyists and “operaisti” from Avanguardia Operaia), Christians for Socialism, and remnants of Trotskyist and anti-Maoist Marxist-Leninist groups. The parties and groups that define themselves as communist are, on average, the product of a process of fragmentation caused by social-fascism and opportunism, and this precludes them not only from the possibility of building a communist party, but also simply from building a party through their unification, as demonstrated by the endless series of failures of such attempts and by the petty hegemony and sectarianism that characterises their mutual relations.
It is inevitable that these falsely communist forces will face further failures and further reactionary decomposition.
How does New Hegemony intend to address this fragmentation?
In this context, only the revival of Gramsci’s Path on the basis of Maoism has the expansive potential to attract the best subjective forces of the young revolutionaries, the proletariat and the popular masses.
Could you describe what New Hegemony means by ‘Anti-fascist People’s Democratic Revolution on the Path to Socialism’? Why does New Hegemony not regard the socialist revolution in Italy as the immediate phase of the revolution?
This is a very important issue. The basic thesis is that the Great Anti-Fascist Resistance remains the fundamental reference point for the proletarian revolution in Italy and for the prospect of establishing a New State.
This thesis asserts that the Resistance in Italy was moving in the direction of a people’s democratic revolution; it was, in fact, an initial stage of this type of revolution.
In the 1960s, the debate about a New Resistance was reopened; today the same thing is happening again.
There are intermediate sectors of the intellectual petty bourgeoisie and those linked to small property ownership who oppose fascism, but who are not in favour of socialism today.
With these intermediate sectors, it is possible for the proletariat and the most oppressed and exploited sections of the petty bourgeoisie to advance along the path of the people’s democratic and anti-fascist revolution and establish a People’s Democratic State. It is not, however, possible to lead them directly towards socialism.
We must take into account the possibility that there may be intermediate stages between the victorious people’s democratic revolution and socialism. Stages in which the proletariat may be forced to carry out further revolutionary leaps.
In Italy, the issue is made particularly complex by the fact that in the South and the Islands there is no truly developed and widespread capitalist industry. Instead, there is a highly backward, essentially pre-capitalist economy or, in other words, a semi-feudal economy characterised by ‘bureaucratic capitalism’. In the South and on the Islands, this is evident in the countryside (in agriculture and livestock farming), in the construction sector and in commerce. Countless small businesses that are unable to accumulate capital and are perpetually in crisis due to large-scale distribution and intermediation, and due to European Union measures serving all the imperialist countries of Europe, including the imperialism of Northern Italy itself. A structure determined by state-monopoly capitalism and by the industrial and financial monopolies of Northern Italy.
Under these conditions, the North, setting aside the question of fascism, could even move directly towards the prospect of socialism, but this is unthinkable in the South and the Islands. Therefore, the North must place itself at the service of the South and the Islands. However, this is possible only through a victorious proletarian people’s democratic revolution.
The intermediate petty bourgeoisie—intellectual, agrarian, commercial, urban, etc.—of the South and the Islands is not the same as that of the North. It is therefore necessary for the proletariat of the North to take on the task of leading, in addition to the most exploited strata of the petty bourgeoisie of the North and Central Italy itself, the intermediate strata of the petty bourgeoisie of the South. In all this, there is first and foremost the need to break the domination of Northern imperialism and of the bureaucratic and semi-feudal capitalism of the South and the Islands, but also the need to guarantee, on the basis of the victorious people’s democratic revolution within the framework of the uninterrupted revolution on the road to socialism, the right to self-determination for the popular masses of the regional areas of the South, Sicily and Sardinia who demand its application.
Beyond theoretical work, how does New Hegemony view the necessity of mass work?
Although New Hegemony is a recently formed editorial collective, the Editorial Board possesses considerable experience, gained over decades of mass work, in the political, trade union and cultural spheres, as well as in outreach among young people and students.
New Hegemony considers it necessary, for example, to build a red trade union current comprising militant groups operating within both reactionary and alternative trade unions, as well as external organisations dedicated to initiative and struggle in the economic and industrial relations sphere, defending the immediate interests of workers and the exploited strata of the petty bourgeoisie.
Mass organisations are also needed in the fields of anti-imperialism and anti-fascism as an integral part and support for the work of rebuilding the party.
Conclusion
How does New Hegemony assess the situation of the international Marxist-Leninist-Maoist movement?
The question of the prospects for building a New International has become much clearer in recent years. For decades, the situation appeared confused. Obviously, the CoRIM leadership did everything in its power to foster this confusion. The neo-revisionists, the Avakians and the Trotskyists, who presented themselves as Maoists, cultivated a terrain within which they hoped to thrive. Now the situation has changed; there are three camps. The first camp is represented by the forces that have based their unity on Maoism. A second camp consists of Maoist forces that doubt the possibility or usefulness of building a New Communist International. The third camp comprises former Avakianist and semi-Trotskyist forces, who reject the Maoist theory of bureaucratic capitalism and, consequently, the fact that the oppressed peoples represent the main trend of the world proletarian revolution. This faction effectively converges with the Right-Wing Opportunist Line [ROL] present in various countries around the world, which maintains that new democratic revolutions cannot succeed because the strategy to be adopted is instead that of directly socialist revolution, and because the countries where a victorious socialist revolution is most likely are those with ‘advanced capitalism’ (i.e. the imperialist countries). This third faction is working frantically to link various opportunist forces on an international scale, with the aim of reviving a sort of new RIM on opportunist and eclectic grounds. Its true intent is to “raise the banner of Maoism to liquidate Maoism”.
How can workers in Canada support the struggle for the reconstitution of the Communist Party of Italy?
The main obstacle in Italy to the reconstruction of the Communist Party on the basis of Maoism is the presence of forces such as the CARC-nPCI and Proletari Comunisti-PCm. All this is demonstrated by the experience of the last 45–50 years.
These forces seek, in various ways, to present themselves on the international stage as representatives of Maoism in Italy. On the international stage, they seek to promote blocs, alliances and fronts with other opportunist, neo-revisionist and semi-Trotskyist forces. Lenin had already highlighted how opportunism is an international tendency.
It is therefore important that Canadian Maoists also fight against those opportunist forces present in their own country which have ties of ideological affinity and political initiative with these two forces.
by NEW HEGEMONY, April 2026.
Responses to “Interview with New Hegemony (Italy)”
[…] ringraziamo la redazione di The People’s Hammer – Voice of the Workers per averci richiesto quest’intervista. L’intervista può essere quindi letta in inglese sul sito https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/04/17/interview-with-new-hegemony-italy/. […]
LikeLike
[…] The original Italian article can be found here and the original translation can be found here. We have previously published an interview with New Hegemony that can be found here. […]
LikeLike
[…] The following is a public document from New Hegemony. The original can be found here. We have previously published an interview with the which can be found here. […]
LikeLike
[…] The original Italian article can be found here and the original translation can be found here. We have previously published an interview with New Hegemony that can be found here. […]
LikeLike