The People's Hammer

Interview with an Edmonton Roofer – By Jackson M.

, ,


Q. What are the wages like for roofing workers in Edmonton?

A. For the company I work for, they are pretty good, they have been pretty decent for the last ten or so years, although there haven’t been any increases, but right now it’s essentially $25 per bundle, and since we do re-roofing there is a bit more labour involved so the amount we make per contract is a bit more than, lets say, new construction roofers, who don’t have as much labour in there. But yeah we don’t have hourly wages we do contract work. I can only speak for my company, and for now it seems to be good I guess.

Q. Generally what are working conditions like, do people get enough hours, are they overworked?

A. It’s good, the tricky thing with roofing is that our company is seasonal, so we have seven-eight good months of roofing to get done, so there are moments where we’ll put ourselves out there, if it’s gusting wind we’ll just kind of deal with it because we all have bills to pay, if its 33 degrees we’ll still try to get something done because it’ll help make the next day quicker. Logistically we will push ourselves into not the greatest situations to capitalize on a shorter season. Work has been coming in but it has been slowing down in the last three-four years, we had an interesting Covid boom and then from that, year after year, there’s been less jobs. Not many people know about their roofs, and not many people wanna spend the money to get their roof redone, when they hear it’s gonna be $6000, $7000, $8000 or more depending on the size of the roof, but typically with a lot of the homes in Edmonton it will be $7000-$8000 and when people hear that they’re like “nope, we’re good, we’re gonna put a bucket on the floor and deal with it, or patch it” you know. So in terms of work coming in its been fine. We have a running joke in my crew that it seems like our office is slowly trying to dissolve itself, they think it’s ok not getting work in, so there could be some back-end things that our management could do to help bring stuff in. It’s a family owned business, one of the smaller companies in Edmonton, and the managers will sometimes turn away work that they don’t find pleasant, and it’s like, you’re not the one doing the work, what do you mean we’re not doing this job? You’re not up there, we need the work, so that’s kind of weird. And given that everyone’s kind of related, you can’t really say “hey you’re fired” or “we’re finding a new manager” type of thing, so family politics do make it interesting.

Q. has there been any problems with the family aspect of the business, as in have they tried taking advantage of workers saying “we’re just small business”?

A. It’s funny because they’ll essentially take advantage of their step-brother, it seems, I don’t know if it’s intentional or if it’s just sub conscious at this point. Often times we will be doing a job and the home owner will call the office with a complaint, it’s not a valid complaint, like something to do with the soffit, and apparently it’s now our fault and we have to deal with it. And instead of management protecting us and backing us up, they’ll get our crew leader, their step brother to just go there and deal with it, because they can. I don’t think it’s fair for him to be in that position even though they are all very very pro capitalist, but even they don’t respect his part in it. The manager our “head honcho”, them being paid salary, them getting a specific amount each year, doesn’t make him as hungry to get new jobs, where as all the crews are subcontractors, we make as much as we do in a year, or in a season rather. So there’s a few hierarchical things that do develop intentions, but for the most part they know they can’t survive without us, and they kind of recognize that. Our wages are determined by bundles for now,, the office just goes off of the market, but there’s things like them not having our backs when homeowners go crazy and try to demand something that we’re not responsible for, that does get annoying. I understand there’s customer service, you’re trying to get your ratings up, but they’re giving us a bad name. We’re subcontractors, we’re doing work for their office, but we are our own entity at this point.

Q. When work is slow have you and other coworkers talked about difficulties with cost of living?

A. Oh yeah, we talk politics quite a bit, we’ve actually stopped because there’s been so much disagreement, and it was getting quite heated and personal, even though we’re just discussing ideas. I guess it’s more so the solutions that do drive wedges between all of us, not all of us, between me and the older roofers. It’s tough because gas is obviously now an issue, it hasn’t really been in the past. Before the Iran war started it was 1.10, sometimes I’d drive by and it’d be 1.04 and I’m like Oh my God, all of a sudden one day it’s like 1.36 and I’m like no way. There’s one guy, maybe two that drive diesel and I feel really bad for them. Sometimes we’re working an hour, hour and a half outside of the city, you can’t not fill up. So gas is getting up there. We also talk about rising food prices, but there are ways to combat that, don’t get skip, don’t get things delivered, make it yourself. With things getting more expensive, you have to start thinking differently about how you’re exchanging commodities. We do talk about those things, what’s frustrating is that there’s almost a generational gap now where they’re still operating on the old-school mindset that if you work, keep your head down, make ends meet, you can buy a house later, buy more than one property, own multiple houses, be a landlord soon, and it’s like that’s just a dream, that doesn’t exist. It’s really tough explaining to them the conditions of young adults, the market we’re getting tossed into, rising interest rates, housing shortages, housing crisis now for crying out loud, its like if everything was as good and easy as you said it was then why are we dealing with all these crises? There’s a lot of frustration between the generations. They were all teens in the 90s, and its weird they experienced war, 9/11, all these things and its like “nah its fine” actually if you move back to the 80s, 70s, it was even better, we actually had it rough, its like if they had it rough then we have it rougher.

Q. Yeah so you bring up the generation divide, another thing I’ve heard in Alberta is that there is a separate wage for youth, does the company you work for employ youth workers or is it mainly young adults and older workers?

A. I can’t speak to the separate youth wage. My crew does have private jobs from time to time, and on those private jobs one of our members will invite a younger cousin or someone who wants to see what it’s like to be on a roof, to dip their toes in the water a bit. Other than that, we don’t hire young teens, the youngest would be 18. back in the day I know a lot of the guys started working at 13-14-15-16, like they’ve been roofers for their whole lives essentially, but that hasn’t happened in a long time. We got a young laborer, he was 19 when he pulled up. It really depends on the crew leader and how much they want to pay a laborer, my crew leader is pretty positive in how he determines your wage, he’ll do a minimum of $20 to start and then depending on how quickly you get it and how efficient you become in your role, he’ll bring it up to $25, and if you get better he’ll bring it up to $33, I think I capped out at $35 before I started making a percentage of the contract. There’s definitely flexibility, there’s not like a set wage for a laborer.

And I’m just speaking for crews at my company, like the subcontractors, so I do know some places pay per hour, we don’t, and I think our incentives and motivations are probably different as a result. We’ll have 12, 13 hour days from like 6-8 trying to get a big roof done so we can just get done as quick as possible. Not that we’re rushing or anything, but we just have long days and if we do this for a month and a half we’ll have a long weekend so we don’t burn ourselves out. Outside of wages there’s probably other things we don’t do, even when it comes to safety. We don’t necessarily tie off all the time too, the mentality is no one’s trying to fall, no one’s trying to push anyone off, everyone’s keeping it safe. When you have four, five, six guys on the roof with ropes behind them, its easy to step on them, to trip up, making it more of a hazard. We’ll go through all the other safety procedures but when it comes to our personal safety, we kind of work faster without that stuff, and if we work faster we can get out of there faster, we can see our families sooner, that type of deal. We really hate safety regulations, not me personally, but I get it, it can get in the way. Knock on wood, no one’s fallen off yet. There have been some scary moments, I won’t lie.

Q. Have there been any accidents on any sites?

A. Actually there has, there was one incident where one crew member, he was part of a different crew, maybe going back five, six years, and they got on a new laborer, and I think on the second week their laborer was walking backwards and kind of trying to check the straightness of the capping. He ends up walking right off the roof. He had no harness on, no rope, no nothing. Luckily he was able to catch his fall, but he was falling backwards and fell where the trailer was, so I think he ended up hitting his head on the hitch. There was police there, fire department was there, ambulance, I think a detective pulled up and was doing an investigation. I think that would be the most major one that I’ve heard of. All the other ones are like the guys kind of breaking through a truss, kind of falling through the shooting, kind of this and that. Our crew leader went to toss a bundle off the roof and slipped and kind of backflipped himself into the trailer, thank God it was only an eight foot drop. I’ve had a fall, wasn’t that bad, I was carrying shakes on my shoulder, I went to go turn the corner, and me not thinking, it was on the left side, so I ended up clipping the corner and the shakes went into me and kind of pushed me off the roof, it was like a ten foot drop. And those shakes have nails in them and stuff you know? So I was like oh my God, so I kind of had to chuck them to the side of me, and thank God there were so many variables that benefited me, I just got really lucky. The ground was a bit wet, so that helped soften my landing, and I know how to fall so I was able to catch myself. There’s just freak stuff that happens that you can’t really control, so there’s always that aspect in the back of your head, even though I said earlier that we don’t wanna fall off the roof. It’s just sometimes you can’t control it. So yeah it would be nice if we did take safety more seriously, to be fair if we’re up two stories and don’t have any grip then we’ll definitely put some anchors in, we’ll get a rope, we’ll get a harness, you know, clip yourself in, its easier that way. Anything where it’s like “where did my balls go?” you’re putting a harness on. There’s still a lot of that old school bravado, which is mostly a joke, but the fact the joke exists speaks to a little bit of the problematic nature of it. A guy I work with, who actually got me the job, he absolutely hates tying off, like putting a rope on or whatever, so there are times where I’m holding onto the rope, holding on his tool belt so he doesn’t fall, which is so sketchy. And it’s like, we’re two stories up on an 812, it’s like oh my God, even I’m getting a little queasy. I mean if wages were a bit better and you were able to make more by working less, I don’t think we’d be doing all this crazy stuff where we put our health on the back burner and kind of just deal with whatever happens to get out of there quicker and make more money.

Q. Have these issues been brought up when talking with coworkers in conversations towards unionizing?

A. My company in particular, a lot of the crews are older, very anti union, Alberta is very very anti union, it’s common to hear, like “the union slows us down, we’re here to get shit done, we can’t make money if we’re not allowed to work, unions are so inefficient”. There’s like all these ideas of what a union is, and I’ve tried to have a few conversations with them, but it’s to no avail. Like they’re kind of stuck in how they perceive them. So that’s kind of why I’ve stopped having those political conversations with them, because there’s very very very strong anti union beliefs at where I work in particular. And again, it all kind of ties into ideas of individualism, work hard, make money you know, play hard, just all these things where it’s like you wouldn’t need to work as hard if things were a bit nicer you know, and if distributors weren’t constantly increasing the price of their materials every year because of some supply chain issue. Materials are essentially pushing roofers out of the market which is kind of crazy.

Q. Does the rising cost of materials impact pay at jobs or does it remain the same?

A. No, all it does is essentially make it more expensive for the homeowner to get the roof done, because the amount we make per job has remained the same, like that formula of how many bundles, this many bundles, okay, X25, that’s kind of that cut, and then is there gonna be any rot there? Do we need to change the metal, what kind of other labour is involved? And that all gets pooled into our takeaway, but you know step flashing has increased in price, the homeowner pays for the materials. Shingles have gone up in price, drip edge, just like the synthetic rolls, the ice and water membrane, everything is going up in price and our wage stays the same. So we’ve been able to deal with inflation probably a little better than most people, which again reinforces a lot of western ideas of capitalism and its benefits and how good it is, like “I’m making this money, I’m working hard, I got what I worked for. So yeah it’s kind of toxic, but Alberta has the long history of being toxic.

Q. Yeah it’s definitely known for that a bit, all provinces definitely have their issues. Kind of on that, your work is very dependent on home owners needing repairs on their roofs. Would you say your job is more repairs or more installing new roofs for new buildings?

A. We actually have a repair guy who goes and does blow offs, or squirrels are getting in and he’ll install squirrel stops, and we have a client list on file so the client can always reach out to us. But the way our office makes money is by doing reroofing, that’s where most of the crews make their money, by reroofing. But its interesting, the quality of the shingles is meant that the roof life cycle has actually increased. There used to be like 17 year periods where everyone is getting their roof done and it’s kind of led to a steady supply of work coming in. but now that they’re going up to 25 to 30 years, it’s kind of lengthening that window, which might push our office to new construction. Edmonton has the tendency to expand outwards so its interesting, the relationship between neighbourhood developments, people’s idea of how things should be developed, needing the economy to keep showing positives. So the easiest way to do that is to keep expanding outwards, keep building more homes so that roofers can get more work, shingles can get made, siders can do their thing, electricians as well. But yeah the increase in quality of the shingle is definitely starting to do weird things.

Q. Sort of an unintended consequence then, of course people want better quality shingles on their roof but there’s also less work to do for roofers.

A. Yeah and Apple had that figured out with planned obsolescence. It’s funny because their shingles are getting better but all their other material seems to just suck. A lot of the nails we get don’t shoot as well as they used to or they’re not coming off of the wire, so you just have a giant spool of wire that isn’t coming out with the nail. The ice and water membrane is peel and stick so when you take off the peel and stick it doesn’t like to come off, you know, it comes off in weird chunks. The synthetic is actually the only thing that’s kind of good, but everything else seems to have dropped in quality outside of the shingles, shingles are I guess their main focus. But even then there’s still manufacturing errors, there will be companies like Ruth Mart, Beacon, where our office will order shingles in bulk in their yard, and what’s messed up is we’ve been giving them business, they’ve been giving us business, but they’ve highkey been disrespecting our company by giving us shingles that have been out in the yard, that have been tossed from roofs from previous jobs and saran wrapped, and it’s like, we’re not putting this on a new roof, like no, don’t give us this actual crap, its bizarre.

Q. Yeah that’s weird, do you think there’s more of a reason for that, or is it sort of laziness?

A. I think it’s laziness and I think they know that, well they’re trying to get rid of their stock, and they do it once, we don’t complain, second time, we don’t complain, so they take advantage of that. Our office hasn’t really said anything, but it’s happened quite a bit actually, I think this last season was probably the most amount of messups, in terms of like, we get to the job, they’re not even the right colour of shingles, we get to the job, there’s two different batch numbers, like they’re the same colour but given that they’re a different batch number, they’re still all slightly off, and when you step back and look and look at it you can notice the different patches because they’re not the same colour. They just wanna get rid of their stock so they think “let’s just give it to these guys, they don’t seem to care”. But yeah, again people are paying for a service and we’re trying to do the best we can, but these guys are just dropping the ball. Our crew leader has a decent relationship with some of the distributors, like kind of the warehouse guys who deal with it, but even then it’s still not enough. There was one incident where they dropped off the wrong bundles, and we realized a little too late that they were the wrong bundles, we had everything stripped, all the paper was applied, the underlayment, and then all of a sudden we called them, “hey guys, you need to come back, pick these up, and give us the proper stuff” and they were like “maybe we’ll come by tomorrow”, and like, no, what are you talking about? We can’t do it tomorrow, we need to do it now but they don’t care. We need to get the job done, we’re on a schedule. We need the money to live as well.

Q. Probably what ends up happening if things are delayed or things don’t look right or whatever, then the customer will blame you guys because they don’t see the company.

A. Exactly, and it’s funny to even look at it more broadly, like we’re all part of the same industry, we’re all in the roofing chain, you know? And even then there’s so much miscommunication and mismanagement , people earning their money in different ways whether it’s contract work, wages, and that interfering with the intensity of getting something right. There’s so many variables at play that for some reason, at my company, it kind of plays into the labour aristocracy where they just blame other workers for “being too unionized, if everything was privatized it would be so much better”, because private companies are so much better for some reason. So there’s definitely a lot of tension between us roofers and the delivery drivers, the office workers, the manufacturers or the distribution centres, it’s bizarre.

Q. Yeah even though you’re all workers in the same boat, there’s definitely a lot of that clashing between the management that sort of bleeds over into the workers, which leads to blame being put on other industries.

A. Yeah it sucks, we try to be conscientious of how we do things, so if we’re expecting a delivery we’ll have a certain section already prepped for work, so when they come it’s easier for them to unload and stack stuff and all that. I once worked with this guy that would always get so mad if he saw the previous job wasn’t done well, so he’d also do the same thing to piss off the next guy. And it’s like, what are you doing? You’re only contributing to the same cycle of spite. You can’t just say you hate something and do that exact thing again.

20 years ago, all you needed for roofing were the shingles and poly, and for some reason nothing ever rotted. Now with insurance warranties, we need to put on this extra stuff, adhesive, underlayment paper, there’s all these extra things for protection but the quality has gotten so much worse, there’s more problems and there’s much more material wasted.

Q. Do you think this is just a way that all these companies and suppliers just make more money off of all this material that’s “required” for the roofs and for insurance?

A. It definitely seems that way, definitely plays out that way. If you apply the shingle wrong, it doesn’t matter if there’s paper below it, there’s gonna be leaks now because there’s holes in the roof. It’s very silly. I know IKO essentially controls the supply chain, everything that’s needed to make shingles, they produce on their own as well. I don’t wanna speak too much on it because I haven’t looked into it too much, but knowing the relationship between capital, owners, and policymakers and all that stuff, it definitely seems to scratch that itch, where it’s like “you don’t really need this, but we’re making it necessary because it’s for your safety, for your insurance payout, warranty this, warranty that”, and it’s like, we could just use less material and still have a waterproofed roof. There’s a lot of really weird tech coming out for no real good reason other than just to have it, even though there’s an old way of doing things that was cheaper and easier but now because our manager sat down and had lunch with Beacon and they’re trying to push out this new product, we’re just treated as crash test dummies for these new products.

Q. Are most workers in your experience immigrants or are most of them from Edmonton?

A. At my company, most of the foreigners were German when the company started, we also have some French guys as well. There is a new growing company owned by Indians that seem to be undercutting the general costs per job, underbidding a lot and not paying their workers what a job is worth. So there’s that going on. There’s also been Ukrainian refugees coming in, especially into taping, charging 75 cents per linear foot of tape compared to the average $2. It seems like there’s not enough regulation anywhere, I would say, that stops someone from doing that stuff. And then this breeds resentment towards foreign workers, but it’s not the worker’s fault, it’s the bosses fault for undercutting the other workers and paying their own workers like dirt. So there’s definitely funky stuff going on in construction. Our company tends to stay away from hiring foreigners that aren’t white to put it mildly, its Alberta, there’s a shit ton of racism here. At my company there’s a lot of western supremacist thinking, tying it in with religion and all that, even though they’re not religious themselves, they don’t go to church, they don’t pray, they don’t do the more ritualistic stuff that would classify someone as a Christian, but they definitely do love touting western supremacy and stuff like that.

Q. That’s very interesting, so the boss’s politics are definitely further right wing in that sense?

A. Yeah I wouldn’t necessarily say the bosses, but it’s kind of everyone at the company, like the manager, they themselves don’t go to church or whatever, but they still have inclinations towards it, it’s still viewed as a positive, like “how good it’d be to have the bible back in school”. So we definitely have those conversations, but I’d say it’s more of a person thing, not necessarily a boss thing, kind of everyone has that belief. Very pro-capitalism, pro Western chauvinism, very pro Christian. Not everyone is homophobic, but they definitely use the bible to justify it.

Q. Would you say that most workers hold that view or would it be a loud minority of them?

A. Oh it’s definitely a loud majority, we’ll even be talking to the homeowners and a lot of homeowners are really happy to overhear talk about right wing stuff and get really comfortable. A lot of the people we do are older, so they’ll have their ideas about, you know, “the trans ideology”, or you know that type of shit or you know, the foreign workers pulling up. And there’s tons of jobs we do for crazy conspiracy nuts too. The company itself has an odd bunch, and then again being in Alberta, even in Edmonton, it being much more liberal than even Calgary, you still come across a lot of these weird right wing views that people are too comfortable with sharing. It doesn’t seem to matter how much I try to explain different belief systems to them, it’s just in one ear and out the other, and at that point I can’t change their mind on an individual level, let’s change the system a little so they can see the material changes, maybe that will affect it.

Q. Yeah I think that ultimately gets to the root of it, it’s good to have conversations and try to convince people that way, but for a lot of people that doesn’t work, people like to see material changes. So I think this will lead to wrapping up the interview, so how do you see the Worker’s United Front in all this in trying to bridge the gap between workers of all industries across Edmonton and the surrounding area more broadly?

A. I think the ambition and the goal of uniting all construction workers under one umbrella is definitely needed, there is lots of disconnect between working people who are doing the same thing, the drywaller’s paying bills, the electrician’s also paying bills, everyone has bills to pay. I’ve seen a lot in my conversations and in talking with people, I’ll go to a bar and talk with some of the guys there, and there’s always this weird idea that, you know, if I make more per hour than you then I’m slightly better and it’s like, we’re drinking the same beer, we’re not different, no one’s better than anyone else here. I’m excited for the future, there is a lot of work to be done in Edmonton in terms of uniting construction workers, it is still very very hostile, and yeah a lot of people I’ve talked with, even though they’re in unions, have this idea that it’s taking money from them in a negative way like “this is money I could have in my pocket”, and it’s like, that money is going towards benefits, it’s going to stuff you’d be paying for anyways. Everyone’s disconnected and divided still, punching the wrong people, punching across and downwards instead of up at the bosses screwing everyone else over. The struggle has given rise to the CWIO, the only way from here is up, if we keep going at it, we will win.