The People's Hammer

AI and automation use in Programming – By Bessy

, ,


Q: Can you tell me a bit about what you do for work?

A: Yes, I work in programming more specifically making system software that makes hardware run. Almost all programming is interchangeable, my profession is slightly more special but not to the degree where it’s too particular to my job.

Q: Can you tell me a bit about how automation looks like in your job?

A: I feel like there’s already been a lot of automation before the current AI shock. There is a quantitative leap definitely here. Back in the day when programming just got started it was pretty rudimentary and as time goes by we have modern software that aids in the development of programming that can save you a lot of development time. With that you have the transformation of programming from more of a craft to a more proletarian mass assembly type of job. The distinction of AI and previous tools is that in a real sense its not just saving you time, eliminating certain aspects of the work, but it’s creating a new mode where you can increase your output substantially with the amount of capital being put in. There’s a max amount of tools that you can use. But with the current AI boom it changed it from being given a better hammer to actual innovation in production that is making programming into more factory type of work.

Q: You mentioned the craft vs proletarian work, what does this transformation look like? You are not individually working on one thing from start to finish? Can you elaborate on it?

A: Sure. Back in the day programming was more about solving a million different puzzles, each puzzle slightly different from each other. There was also a design aspect which does require a lot of thinking and planning. In proletarian work you can scale production with the amount of people you hire and the amount of capital you can cram into the industry. Craft you can’t really scale production in the same way. You can’t hire a billion potters who can make one fine china with craft technology better or faster. But with AI you can conceive an arrangement where you can scale production significantly if its arranged correctly and if AI continues to develop with the amount of capital you decide to spend into it. That’s the biggest distinction. That’s why back in the day you can justify the high wages of software engineers because they have the characteristic traits to produce better than other engineers. You couldn’t replace one good one with two slightly worse ones. But with AI I think you might see the bifurcation of this work where same as factory split production into engineer and proletariat you might see it split between software architect designing at the top level and lots of lower level software work who just monitor and use AI.

Q: I guess you talked about this a little bit. Where do you see this AI and automation developing into?

A: Its hard to say but we definitely will see the average pay of software engineer or labour hours going into unit amount of software decreasing. We probably will see more software but produced under more industrial type of setting where software engineers don’t get as high pay or the very relaxed labour relationship that they currently enjoy. Instead they will be forced into similar arrangement as any other office worker like an excel guy or data entry clerk. You will probably have more software engineers that are get more bifurcated into the engineering role, more designing more architecting, management and thinking about business. And you will of course have this lower level of engineer because at the end of the day the AI still needs someone to monitor it. Unless software engineers create an industry union if they want. Of course this is all just band aids because the nature of the work is transitioning. Even if you have a union in the current day it will be highly unlikely its an industrial union and more likely it will be a craft union, and we’re all familiar with the limitations of a craft union. But in the long term we will see the profession transform by the innovation in capitalism.

Q: Do you think this is a good or bad thing? Do your coworkers like or dislike the increased use of automation?

A: I mean, in the long term its 100% a good thing. My coworkers are forced by business to use AI but generally hold a low standard view of AI. They like to use it for themselves but they think the technology effects the bottom line, which it will.

Q: So they like to use it but they realize it will change their work?

A: Yes it’s currently not threatening enough to replace our job, but it will.