The People's Hammer

Interview with the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia

,


The following is a interview with the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. More of their writings can be found here. The positions put forward in the text do not reflect our line. We are publishing this document with the intention of both bettering the understanding of the international communist movement among workers in Canada and to promote two-line struggle internationally.

Introduction

Dear comrades,

The Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia is grateful for your paper’s interest in the fundamental issues of the upcoming Yugoslav People’s Revolution and the history of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. We must emphasize that your questions are extensive and if we were to say everything we have about each individual question, it would no longer be appropriate for one interview, but our answers would take the form of two or three books. However, we would be making a mistake if we underestimated the significance and gravity of these issues for the International Communist Movement and its understanding of the complex processes that took place in Yugoslavia. Our main task is then to present the basic and essential through our answers, and we leave it to your readers and activists to draw the appropriate lessons themselves. Our responses are intended for and adapted to this goal.

On Society in the Former Yugoslav Societies:

  1. What is the mode of production across the former Yugoslav countries? What differences exist between the economies of these different countries?

The socio-economic formation of all the republics of the erstwhile Yugoslavia is bureaucratic capitalism. What does this mean?

The predominant mode of production in all the countries of the former Yugoslavia is the capitalist mode of production, but not as it developed from the emerging national capitalism of the South Slavic countries, but as it developed from the capital imported by the imperialist bandits. In their invasions of the South Slavic peoples, the imperialist powers did not aim to create independent capitalist republics, but primarily to subordinate the South Slavic peoples to their bloodthirsty rule. Thus, although imperialism did lead to the dissolution of independent feudal societies, it did so in order to turn the South Slavic lands into its semi-colonies and colonies. The capitalism that developed in such circumstances did not follow the national, revolutionary path of development, but developed in close connection with finance capital, in alliance with imperialism and the big landowners. Imperialism, therefore, in all the countries of the former Yugoslavia, suppressed the free development of national capitalism and instead, relying on the reactionary allies of the comprador bourgeoisie and feudal landownership, subordinated all the South Slavic peoples to their rule. This is what allows it to super-exploit labor, appropriate natural resources cheaply, subordinate agriculture to its needs, etc. All in order to make profits from exported capital, and much faster than in the era of free competition.

Thus, the ruling class in all the countries of the former Yugoslavia is the large, comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie. Comprador-bureaucratic because it is made up of two factions: the comprador faction, which develops primarily in banking and commercial sectors and appears as private capital; Bureaucratic, which is concentrated in industrial sectors and appears when monopoly capital merges with the state. This great comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie is central to imperialism, because the imposition of the above-mentioned super-exploitation is its direct responsibility. It is well rewarded for its “services”, and although it is not a monopolistic bourgeoisie in relation to the world market, in relation to its national market it has a monopoly and makes profits that reproduce it as a monopolistic, comprador and bureaucratic bourgeoisie.

It would be entirely correct to say that in all countries of former Yugoslavia, imperialist capitalism prevails over feudalism and national capitalism, but we must emphasize that feudalism also prevails over national capitalism. This state of affairs serves only imperialism, the comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie and feudal landowners. On the other hand, the proletariat, the peasantry and the petty bourgeoisie are exploited, and the middle, that is, the national bourgeoisie, is restricted.

As for the differences between the economies of the South Slavic countries, they do exist, but they do not define the socio-economic formations, nor do they change the semi-feudal and semi-colonial character of these countries. Talking about their differences has a certain value, but not in an interview like this, it is more important for us to point out the danger of overemphasizing national characteristics in the process of the development of bureaucrat capitalism of the South Slavic countries, because this process in our case is intertwined and interlaced between all nations as probably nowhere else in the world.

  1. What was the mode of production in Yugoslavia prior to the revolution?

Same as now, but under different conditions.

  1. How was the Yugoslav economy transformed by the revolution? Was socialist construction underway before the restoration of capitalism?

First of all, it should be pointed out that with the establishment of people’s democracy in Yugoslavia, a series of unprecedented democratic changes were carried out. For the first time, Yugoslavia freed itself from the yoke of imperialism and was transformed into an independent democratic republic, women became full citizens, the Greater Serbian monarchy and national inequality were abolished, the land was confiscated from the majority of large landowners and divided among the poor peasantry. With the fulfillment of anti-imperialist and anti-feudal tasks, the bourgeois-democratic revolution developed into a socialist revolution. This was reflected in the socialist nationalization of large and medium-sized industry, transport, banking, foreign trade, wholesale, etc.

The point is that it was precisely then, when the construction of socialism was on the horizon, that the class struggle became most fierce. The broad masses of the people and the Communist Party of Yugoslavia genuinely wanted to ensure, not a declarative, but a real transition to a socialist society. Under such pressure, the Titoist revisionists were forced to conceal their true intentions, and so any progress towards socialism also contained the germs of future betrayal. Having taken key positions, the Titoist revisionists began a systematic campaign to undermine people’s democracy, primarily by attacking the Communist Party of Yugoslavia itself. Thus, for example, the Titoists gave various capitalists the right to trade with other countries at the expense of the state, effectively liquidating the state’s monopoly on foreign trade. Behind the turbulent and contradictory developments of the Yugoslav economy in the period from 1945 to 1948 lies nothing else but the class struggle between the proletariat and the bourgeoisie. The Titoist revisionists simply could not openly take the bourgeois path of development, because socialism was the true aspiration of the working people, who, incidentally, really saw the Soviet Union as the greatest achievement of progressive humanity.

The Titoist revisionists, therefore, knew that they must first face the advanced, organized detachment of the proletariat, that is, the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, in order to have the ground under their feet to liquidate people’s democracy and regain the “lost empire” of bureaucratic capitalism.

  1. What is the stage of the revolution in the former Yugoslav countries today?

This fundamental question of the upcoming Yugoslav revolution is also the most important. In our program, the following is written:

It is clear from the semi-colonial and semi-feudal character of the present Yugoslav society that the Yugoslav revolution must be divided into two stages, the first of which has the task of radically transforming the semi-colonial and semi-feudal society into an independent democratic society. The democratic Federal Yugoslavia that the Yugoslav peoples have to establish must be a democratic republic under the common dictatorship of a united front of all anti-imperialist and anti-feudal forces headed by the proletariat.

That Yugoslav society is semi-colonial and semi-feudal is something that revisionists of various shades are trying to deny. It is our task to continue to develop and concretize this teaching. In our view, the most dangerous is the variety that considers the countries of the former Yugoslavia to be semi-colonial, but not semi-feudal, as if the former were possible without the latter.

  1. Who were the main beneficiaries of the break up of Yugoslavia?

We often hear that imperialism should be blamed for the dismemberment of Yugoslavia, but this is not entirely true. Of course, in the end, no matter what happened in Yugoslavia, imperialism would try to use it for its own gain. The main responsibility for the dismemberment of Yugoslavia, however, actually belongs to the large, comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie.

The competitive struggle between the bourgeoisie of the different Yugoslav peoples was the main driver of the national struggle. When the internal contradictions of the economic system of Yugoslavia reached such a point that the state could not provide its own bourgeoisie with the same rate of exploitation, a bitter competitive struggle arose, which then inevitably assumed the character of a national struggle. The explanation lies in the fact that it was perfectly acceptable for the Yugoslav bourgeoisie to advocate Yugoslavism and to conceal its class essence with the mask of “Titoism” as long as it was in their favor. But as soon as the intense competition among the great bourgeoisie of all the Yugoslav countries created a desire for “their own field” for exploitation, free from the competitors of other nations, the big bourgeoisie raised its own class interest to the height of national interest, presenting its class ideals as national ideals. Thus, imperialism did not undermine Titoist revisionism, but it was undermined by that class which found in it a temporary support in the struggle against the proletariat in 1948. Hence the nationalist madness that crippled these nations.

  1. What are the main imperialist powers active in the former Yugoslav countries?

The main enemy of the Yugoslav masses is American imperialism. Since the end of the war, it has held the Balkans in its bloody clutches, and through the influence of its own militarism, politically and militarily it ensures the existence of comprador-bureaucratic regimes. American imperialism plays a decisive role in the internal life of these regimes, supplying them with all the necessary means, especially in moments of political instability. However, the broad masses of the people are aware of this role of American imperialism and it causes them resentment and contempt for the American imperialists.

Economically, the most active imperialist powers since the breakup of Yugoslavia have been Austria and Germany. Amid the escalating contradictions between U.S. imperialism and various European imperialists, it is important to point out that German imperialism continues to sell pieces of its sovereignty to U.S. imperialism, because it essentially relies on U.S. hegemony to assert its own hegemony in Europe. Austrian imperialism, on the other hand, loses room for manoeuvre and therefore moves closer to German imperialism for the sake of its own security. Therefore, we point out that in the case of the Balkans, Germany, and to a lesser extent Austria, also rely on American hegemonism.

Apart from these, the Italian, Russian and Chinese imperialists have some influence, but this varies from republic to republic and is always changing.

  1. Since the formal return of capitalism and dissolution of Yugoslavia, how have the bourgeoisie organised their new states? Does it tend more toward fascism, liberalism, or some intermediate system of government?

Since the liquidation of people‘s democracy in 1948, the political conditions necessary for the rule of the comprador-bureaucratic bourgeoisie have been such that, in general, the bourgeoisie has relied on the absolute centralization of state power in the executive branch, whereby the intelligence services and armed forces have not only unleashed the white terror over the communists, but have also exercised constant control over the civilian government. After the breakup of Yugoslavia, reactionary liberal regimes emerged on its ruins, with an inherent tendency towards further fascisation, especially now that their internal crisis is deepening.

  1. What are the fundamental forms of opportunism in the workers’ movement regionally? How does the Committee to Reconstitute the Communist Party of Yugoslavia (CR-CPY) aim to demarcate Maoism from these opportunist trends?

Indeed, it is clear here that opportunist currents can essentially be divided into two twin brothers, on the one hand we have “left” opportunism, on the other hand we have right opportunism. Both have various organizations and tendencies under their umbrella, but we will limit ourselves to mentioning only those that we consider the most important.

Titoism, of course, has enormous historical significance. However, since the breakup of Yugoslavia, this revisionism, which at one point was in the position of state power, has lost its social function and as such has never recovered or achieved a significant position in the Yugoslav workers’ and revolutionary movement. After the breakup of Yugoslavia, the bourgeoisie still used Titoism as a tool to oppose the efforts of Comrade Dapčević to reconstitute the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, but this was immediately after the war. Titoism today still enjoys the important role of spreading historical confusion, but it is not suited to the honorable reactionary role of spreading confusion among the proletariat and the broad masses of the people about the fundamental questions of the upcoming people’s revolution.

Like Tito himself, contemporary revisionists are spreading confusion by borrowing from the Trotskyist arsenal. It seems that it is almost “fashionable” to deny the semi-colonial, semi-feudal position of Yugoslav societies and the new democratic revolution. From the mildest social-chauvinist reformists to the “anti-revisionist” revolutionary phraseologists, the thesis of bureaucratic capitalism is a thorn in the side of opportunists of all shades. We can safely say that this is the point that separates the wheat from the chaff.

Understanding this, it is clear that both the “left” and the right opportunists are essentially the same, with secondary differences in how they express this misunderstanding of Yugoslav societies. The “left” opportunists ignore important national and peasant questions, advocating a socialist revolution to establish a workers’ Yugoslavia. Right-wing opportunists, on the other hand, mostly side with the nationalist forces of their own country, or with one or the other imperialist power, and in some cases do not even believe that socialism is achievable.

We, for our part, have already theoretically successfully separated Maoism from the opportunist currents in this region. Our work in this direction is not over, but it can be said that it is becoming increasingly clear to every worker, every activist and every sympathizer what separates us from, for example, the Partija rada, the Revolutionary Communist League, the Workers’ Front and other garbage that has accumulated in this region. However, we believe that the real success in this direction is measured by how much the broad masses of the people have accepted our politics, and that is a long-term struggle with opportunism that is far from over.

To not give the wrong impression, we must remain modest and emphasize that we still do not have deep connections with the broad masses, and our reach is limited to only a few cells. But time is in our favor.

  1. What are some major struggles the workers of the region have taken up? Has the CR-CPY or its predecessors taken an active role in these struggles?

The South Slavic peoples have glorious traditions in the struggle for justice and freedom. These are traditions that the people cherish and that they can never forget. With the emergence of the proletariat as a class, it took on the best traditions of our peoples, and therefore the Yugoslav proletariat has an extremely rich history of struggle behind it. It is a class that did not know about disbelief and lamentation, a class that selflessly gave its best daughters and sons not only for the sake of victory in the national liberation struggle, but also long before that in various struggles against the class enemy, often and exclusively for the benefit of the proletariat of other countries. More than 30,000 Yugoslavs took part in the Great October Socialist Revolution. In the same spirit, it is common knowledge that our workers, at the invitation of the Communist International, rose up with a two-day general strike in defense of Soviet Hungary and Soviet Russia, forcing the royal government to renounce its participation in the armed intervention against the Hungarian Soviet Republic.

In the period from the Great October Socialist Revolution to the Second World War, our working class shed a sea of blood in innumerable struggles against the bourgeoisie and its henchmen. This is most evident in the immediate aftermath of the October Revolution, when the revolutionary ferment encompassed the entire region, as practically the entire South Slavic proletariat rose to its feet, constantly on strike, waging armed actions in the cities and villages, and in some cases establishing short-lived Soviet republics. After the South Slavic bourgeoisie, with the help of the imperialists of the Entente, temporarily calmed the situation and established the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes, the proletariat rose up against it with the same energy. Yugoslav journalists witnessed the terrific strikes of miners, railroad workers, sailors, factory workers, women and all the exploited, and the communists played a decisive role in these activities.

The monarcho-fascist dictatorship responded to such activities of the broad masses of the people and primarily of the proletariat with beatings, arrests, torture and assassinations, but even this did not stop the militant proletariat. Conscious and confident in its goal, it was ready not only to suffer but also always to respond to every blow of reaction. The best proof of this is that even in prison the Yugoslav proletariat did not become passive, the heroic stories of the communists in Sremska Mitrovica, the protests for the release of political prisoners in Kumanovo, Split and Podgorica are well known.

With such a teaching of 20 heroic years of resistance to the monarcho-fascist dictatorship, the proletariat of the former Yugoslavia could not allow itself to be distracted by the nonsensical ideas of a pact with German imperialism, and was fully prepared for energetic uprisings against the disgusting Hitlerite occupier and his servants, which are now known everywhere in the world.

Heroic partisan resistance, therefore, is not an isolated act, but a continuation of the heroism of the Yugoslav proletariat under the conditions of occupation.

After the liquidation of the People’s Democracy and the Communist Party of Yugoslavia in 1948, the working class resisted the fascist regime of Titoist spies and murderers. From 1948 to 1949, the struggle of the proletariat was primarily about economic demands. According to official data from revisionist Yugoslavia, in 1949 alone, over 400,000 workers were absent from work every day. In response, the Titoist revisionists created a system of business contracts, but until the late 1950s, there was not a single company in which over 50% of the workers actually signed the contract. Workers resisted in all sorts of ways, some actively, for example through strikes and sabotage of railroads destined for the export of raw materials to the United States, some passively by slacking at work.

At the beginning of 1950. the struggle of the Yugoslav proletariat against the Titoist fascists began to develop into a struggle for clear political demands, merging with the communists’ demands for the reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. This effort within Yugoslavia itself, however, abruptly collapsed with the usurpation of Lenin’s and Stalin’s parties by revisionism and the unleashing of the White Terror against Marxist-Leninists, including the Yugoslavs.

At present, the struggles of the working class are directed primarily to the struggle for wage increases, and so far we do not have a class struggle in the true sense of the word. However, we have great popular unrests in which the working class plays a big role, and by far the most significant unrest took place in Bosnia and Herzegovina in 2014. It had proved once again that the Yugoslav proletariat, as a proud descendant of its glorious ancestors, with all its rich traditions of struggle, freedom, patriotism and heroism, will certainly not suffer dark desolation for much longer.

On the Communist Party of Yugoslavia (CPY) and the League of Communists of Yugoslavia

  1. Can you describe the process that led to the constitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia in 1919?

Initially, in May 1918. the Yugoslav communist section of the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks) was formed in Russia, composed primarily of prisoners of war. By November 1918. its membership had expanded, and it adopted a statute and was renamed the Communist Party (Bolsheviks) of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes. Yugoslav communist organizations existed in Moscow, Volga region, Siberia, parts of Ukraine and even in Central Asia.

The role of the CP(b)-SCS was originally reduced to publishing newspapers such as Revolucija, Komuna, Jugoslovenski revolucionar, Crveni barjak, whose task was to expose the truth about the events in Soviet Russia to the South Slavic peoples. The CP(b)-SCS also translated several of Lenin’s writings and proclamations into Serbo-Croatian and Slovenian.

The CP(b)-SCS was not a party in the true sense of the word, but it was the first communist organization of the Yugoslav proletariat. It united the Yugoslavs into one organization before the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes was even founded. It gave its relatively numerous members clear tasks when returning to the country and in fact managed to establish cells in several cities, the largest and most important of which was in Zagreb.

The activities of the CP(b)-SCS, together with the return of its members to the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes, significantly helped the communist elements within Yugoslavia to act in unison. By exposing opportunism in the workers’ movement, the communists attracted the left wings of the pre-war social democratic parties, which then broke away from them and, together with the members of the CP(b)-SCS, founded the Socialist Workers’ Party of Yugoslavia (communists) at the Unification Congress on April 20, 1919.

Without completely breaking with the Social-Democratic deviations in the national and peasant question, however, the SWPY(c) still did not have a militant Bolshevik program. The struggle for such a program would become the main task of the communists in the coming years. The first success in this direction was achieved at the Second Congress of the SWPY(c) held in Vukovar on June 20, 1920, when the so-called “radical current” prevailed over the right-wing and centrist elements. The party was officially renamed the Communist Party of Yugoslavia and its position in the Communist International was sealed.

  1. What were the main instances of two-line struggle in the party prior to its ideological-political liquidation?

For us, this is an extremely important issue that we have approached with the greatest care and attention in the study of the history of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. Therefore, we believe that for the sake of your readers it is correct to quote the relevant lines of our program directly. (For the first time in English.)

The Communist Party of Yugoslavia was constituted from the organizations of the former Social Democratic Party as a consequence of the persistent two-line struggle of communist elements against the right and centrist elements and through the Party’s entry into the Communist International at the Vukovar Congress in 1920. In the tumultuous post-war years, the Party led the vast majority of the working class of Yugoslavia, but without completely breaking with its social-democratic deviations in the national and peasant question, it still did not have a militant Bolshevik program, nor was it capable of opposing the persecutions to which the White Terror was subjected.

In the years that followed, in the period leading up to the III. Congress, several successes were achieved in the struggle against the Social-Democratic deviations and centrists, but nevertheless, just when the Party was about to become the headquarters of everything that was alive and capable of fighting among the masses of people of the country against the bourgeois reaction which was preparing the monarcho-fascist dictatorship, it was overwhelmed by fierce factional struggles which paralyzed the Party organizations and turned the Party leadership into a permanent discussion club.

The fatal practice of factionalism must not be confused with ideological struggle, which is a necessary and integral part of the process of Bolshevisation. Factionalism actually meant that the Communist Party of Yugoslavia adopted the decisions and advice of the Comintern in words, but systematically undermined and sabotaged them in action. Thus, for example, the September Plenum of 1926 and the April and November Plenums of 1927 correctly set out the tasks of the Party, gave an accurate criticism of mistakes and shortcomings, but the Party leadership did nothing to actually implement all these decisions of the Plenum. On the contrary, the living questions of the proletarian struggle were pushed into the background, and scholaristic wisdom was highlighted, where the only important thing was to outmanoeuvre the factional opponent.

Although they differed in many terminological and conceptual aspects, both the “left” and right factions were essentially bourgeois. Their unprincipled struggle led to the demoralization of the membership and threatened to disintegrate the Party as well as destroy the prestige it enjoyed within the masses of the people. In order to save the Communist Party of Yugoslavia from collapse, the Comintern in an open letter called on all Party members to resolutely rise up against factionalism and appointed a new workers’ leadership headed by Đuro Đaković. The Party membership resolutely accepted the contents of the Comintern’s open letter, and the new workers’ leadership immediately set about implementing it.

This course of the two-line struggle in the Party was a reflection of world events, primarily and most importantly of the Sixth Congress of the Comintern, which played an important role in achieving the unity of the proletariat against opportunism and the alliance of social democracy with the reactionary authorities.

In October 1928 the Fourth Congress of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia was held in Dresden. The IV. Congress of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia analyzed the economic and political situation in Yugoslavia and in the world and took a position on the most important theoretical and practical questions. Decisions of the IV. Congress gave the Party membership and the entire proletariat a clear and proper organization for future work. The “left” and right factions had to capitulate to the Congress, which encouraged all those numerous communist cadres who, despite the persecution and regardless of the factionalism in the party leadership, boldly carried the flag of struggle for the liberation of the proletariat and other working masses from the capitalist yoke.

It was at the Fourth Congress of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia that the question of the character of the impending revolution in Yugoslavia was raised for the first time. It has been rightly established that the Yugoslav revolution will be a bourgeois-democratic revolution, and that as such it forms an integral part of the world proletarian revolution, which is a complex process of peasant, national-revolutionary, colonial and proletarian movements and uprisings. The Congress also rightly established that the bourgeoisie of the oppressed nations is not and cannot be the driving force of the bourgeois-democratic revolution, but that its victory is conceivable only as a revolutionary victory of the working class and peasantry against the bourgeoisie, with the establishment of a democratic dictatorship of the workers and peasantry on the basis of the Soviets.

The capitulation of the “left” and right factions was an important step forward, but it could not mean the end of the two-line struggle. There was no doubt that there was a group of Trotskyists, Zinovievites, and Bukharinists in the Party, who, in spite of their differences among themselves, participated together in undermining the line of the Open Letter. Thus, apart from the best of the Party’s cadres, a number of people with little or no connection with the Party, who did not grow up in it and who were brought up outside of it were elected to the leadership.

The Fourth Congress gave the Party a new life and in a short time significantly strengthened all its organizations. However, at the beginning of its consolidation after the Fourth Congress, the Party was caught by a coup d’état and the establishment of a bloody monarcho-fascist dictatorship. Thus, the secretary of the Central Committee of the Party, Đuro Đaković, was brutally murdered by the police only a few months after the Congress, on April 25, 1929.

Since its founding at the Vukovar Congress in 1920, the Party has only retreated in the face of the cruel blows inflicted on it by the reaction. The Party was suffocated by the lack of a firm Bolshevik orientation such as the one established with the Fourth Congress. In the case of the rule of terror, the Central Committee of the Party hoped that the regime would outlive itself quickly, without the active interference of the popular and above all proletarian masses, counting exclusively on the struggle within the ruling classes. Thus, the Party was repeatedly decapitated by the class enemy and forced to concentrate its energies and forces on reorganization. Although the IV. Congress was a turning point in the orientation of the Party, that Party which was accustomed to retreat, which always appealed to the working class and the broad masses of the people to avoid a confrontation with the class enemy, could not reorganize itself in the short term on a truly Bolshevik basis.

After the death of Đuro Đaković, the leadership, led by Martinović, fled abroad and adopted the wrong “leftist” line of armed uprising against the monarcho-fascist dictatorship. Without real directives and without the support of the leadership, with work made difficult by provocateurs and spies within the Party, the healthy elements that found themselves in Yugoslavia were decimated by the monarcho-fascist dictatorship. Martinović, as an agent of imperialism and with the support of Trotskyists and Zinovievites in the Party, stepped down from the line of the Open Letter, reviving factional struggles. His “third group” pursued a policy of unprincipled mutual cover-up of mistakes, shortcomings and disagreements, and the true state of the Party was hidden from the Comintern and the membership.

At the end of 1932 the Comintern removed Martinović’s leadership due to factionalism, and a temporary leadership was appointed, headed by Milan Gorkić. Gorkić was a student and personal friend of a well-known revisionist and one of the leaders of the right-wing and Trotskyist bloc together with Krestinsky – Bukharin – on whose personal initiative he rose to prominence. Milan Gorkić presented himself to the Party membership as a return to the path outlined by the Open Letter. In reality, he was a revisionist of the Bukharin type and an accomplice in the opposition-led anti-Soviet conspiracy. Following the example of his mentor, Gorkić‘s philosophy can be explained by revising the essence of the law of contradiction that the one splits into two, arguing that the two antagonistic sides of a contradiction merge into one: the Bolsheviks and the Trotskyists; the rich kulaks and the poor peasants; the bourgeoisie and the proletariat; etc…

At the Fourth National Conference of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia held in Ljubljana on December 24 and 25 1934, a new Politburo was formed. With the exception of Blagoje Parović, whose appointment was supposed to represent “continuity” with the line of comrade Đuro Đaković in front of the Party membership, the entire Politburo of the Party was in the hands of the revisionists. The Party did undergo a certain renewal and consolidation, but this was done primarily through the persistent work of the middle cadre, while the final goal of the Gorkićites was to position the Communist Party of Yugoslavia in an advantageous position after the usurpation of power by the bloc of Rightists and Trotskyites within the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics. From the very beginning, Gorkić and his faction formed a bloc with the Trotskyists and Zinovievists in the Party, protecting them both from their own Party and from the Comintern. Although the middle cadre fought for the revival and consolidation of the Party, the revisionists at the head of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia actively liquidated it, sometimes from the “left”, sometimes from the right.

Protecting his revisionist accomplices, Gorkić blamed the Comintern for the crisis in the Party in the period after the execution of Đuro Đaković. The two-line struggle within the Comintern itself, where the proletarian section led by comrade Stalin clashed with non-proletarian elements and the world anti-Soviet conspiracy in which direction the international opposition was going, had a sometimes harmful, sometimes positive influence on the development of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. But it is not true, as many bourgeois historians believe, that the ultimate cause of the crisis in the Communist Party of Yugoslavia was its subordination to the Comintern.

The Comintern had a primarily positive influence on the development and Bolshevization of the Party. It is impossible to ignore the fact that the Comintern, relying on healthy elements in the wing of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, through its advice and directives, significantly helped the Yugoslav communists to bolshevize, as well as to develop the Party in the direction of seizing power. The Comintern also repeatedly saved the Party from certain disintegration. To deny this would be to deny the enormous historical role of the Comintern and Comrade Stalin as the helm of the International Communist Movement. The main responsibility for numerous crises must be borne by the Yugoslav communists themselves.

After the Seventh Congress of the Comintern, which correctly faced the development of the world situation and which set the basic tasks within the international communist movement, the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, led by Gorkić, thanks to his philosophy that two antagonistic sides merge into one, incorrectly applied the policy of the Popular Front, thus deepening its liquidation at the expense of the middle cadre who suffered the most sacrifices for it.

In Yugoslavia, at the organizational level, only the Penal Committee of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, in which the middle cadre headed by Comrade Petko Miletić was extremely concentrated, was truly opposed to the opportunistic policy of the Gorkićites. Gorkić’s accusations that the Penal Committee opposed the Seventh Congress of the Comintern are not true. The only thing that is true is that they opposed the liquidationist interpretation of Gorkić which threatened to liquidate the entire Party. Gorkić was not able to suppress the influence of Comrade Miletić or to solve the “problem of the Penal Committee”, primarily because the middle cadre was on the side of Comrade Petko Miletić, and finally, because the international anti-Soviet conspiracy itself, which he and his clique of traitors and vermin advocated, was increasingly exposed.

When Gorkić’s involvement came to light, he and the other conspirators at the head of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia were sentenced to death, and the main immediate task of the Party was a general reorganization. Only Josip Broz Tito, despite being a Gorkićite, managed to get out of the previous Politburo alive. Aware of his own role and opportunism, while extensive material was being prepared against him, Tito refused the directives of the Comintern to appear for questioning. Because of his own ambitions, Tito formally distanced himself from the Gorkićites, but his philosophical views were still essentially identical. During this period, Tito surrounded himself with opportunistic trash that resembled himself (Đilas, Kardelj, Ranković, etc…) and already in mid-1937 he began to behave as the general secretary of the Party.

He had no right to do so, and apart from a few renegades he gathered around him, no one in the Party supported his ambition. Every exile of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia in Paris, as well as in prison, knew him well as a notorious opportunist and were against his takeover of the Party.

From the very beginning, Tito pursued a policy of bribing and corrupting people, and he simply destroyed all those hardworking communists who had been educated and elevated in the Party for decades. Among Tito’s first steps were attacks on Ivan Marić and Labud Kusovac as “factionalists” within the Party who prevented its reorganization because they did not submit to his leadership. This was the precursor to the “final” conflict with the left that Tito had after the end of the imprisonment of comrade Petko Miletić, a former member of the Politburo and organizational secretary of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, who had the sincere support of the vast majority of the Party. Comrade Petko Miletić immediately traveled to Moscow at the invitation of the Comintern, where he tried to expose Tito’s treacherous activities and philosophical views.

But Tito did not sit idly by either, and the revisionist eel knew how to get through. Tito, together with other opportunists, at the head of the so-called “Temporary Leadership” on behalf of the entire Party, demanded the arrest of Comrade Miletić, presenting the issue of his arrest as a matter of the fight against espionage and treason. He presented a multitude of falsified evidence and fabricated stories before the Comintern and appealed for his arrest on behalf of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. Tito, of course, had no right to do so. He simply staged a coup d’état in the party and seized power. This sequence of events and the mistakes of the communists in the fight against Titoism in its beginnings deserve to be studied in depth, but it is important to point out the first thing, that the left within the Communist Party of Yugoslavia acted “parliamentarily” and too passively, for them it was important that the issue be resolved through the Statute. The Communists allowed Tito to inflict a few heavy blows on them before Comrade Petko Miletić was even released from prison. Then second, that Tito’s life was saved thanks to his ability to bribe opportunistic scum, most notably Josip Kopinič, a degenerate who spent the rest of his life bragging about how he saved Tito with falsified evidence.

Immediately after the arrest of comrade Petko Miletić, Tito strengthened his position with the purge of the “Petkovites”, that is, all the best communists who, despite all those traitors and pests within the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, had been developing and defending the Party for decades.

  1. What strategy did the CPY pursue in the revolution? It is often presented as a people’s war. Do you believe this characterisation is accurate?

Eroded by internal reaction, Yugoslavia was unable to resist the Nazi invasion. The Royal Yugoslav Army immediately experienced a complete breakdown and disintegration, and the remaining Chetnik groups were poorly organized, disunited, without a solid political basis. The leaders of the former political parties of Yugoslavia partly fled abroad, partly went over to the service of the occupiers, partly passively observed events.

Before the war, the Communist Party of Yugoslavia had made enormous efforts to form a united front to defend the country’s endangered independence. When the war had already begun, the party cadres laid down their lives in the front lines on the battlefield, trying to prevent demoralization, but the betrayal was so deep, and the fifth columnism of the fascist elements was so all-encompassing, that almost nothing could be done. After the capitulation of Yugoslavia, the party cadre and many soldiers did not hand over their weapons to the enemy, but hid them so that they could use them later.

The Communist Party of Yugoslavia made every effort to create a united front of all patriotic elements in the fight against the occupiers. Our people could not reconcile themselves to betrayal, and did not recognize the capitulation as the previous rulers wanted, and resolutely responded to the call of the Party and entered the fight. The leadership of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia, despite being in the hands of opportunists, was fully convinced of the final victory of the Soviet Union and the anti-fascist coalition in the war against fascist tyranny. That is why such a leadership followed a consistent program of national liberation, refusing to compromise with the occupier and siding with those invincible historical forces that ensured the defeat and destruction of the camp of the fascist countries.

Although the Yugoslav people’s liberation struggle was sometimes referred to as a people’s war in the international press, this is not an accurate characterization in terms of the military strategy of the proletariat as a class developed by Mao Zedong. In fact, when the Hitlerites declared war on the USSR, the liberation war of all the peoples of the Soviet Union against fascism united with the liberation movements of the oppressed European peoples into one camp. Among them, of course, was the Yugoslav people. On such occasions, its struggle took the form of the “rear” of the Red Army’s front, and thus essentially the main task of the People’s Liberation Army was to lighten the burden borne by the Red Army and the Soviet people at the front. The victory of the Soviet Union was the only guarantee of its freedom.

The People’s Liberation Army launched large-scale uprisings against the occupiers and undertook powerful offensive operations throughout the country. In this way, it tied the hands of fascist countries and destroyed the legitimacy of collaborationist states, creating an awkward situation for German and Italian imperialism, which could not use their troops elsewhere.

  1. When was the CPY liquidated ideologically-politically? Can you describe how the revisionist line became dominant in the party?

The Communist Party of Yugoslavia was liquidated in 1948. but as we have already stated, revisionists had dominated its leadership for a decade before that. The revisionist line became dominant very quickly and expeditiously, with a massive purge of the party by unelected Titoist revisionists in leadership positions. Using their positions, the Titoist revisionists transformed the tools of the dictatorship of the proletariat into the tools of the dictatorship of the bourgeoisie, and purged the party of 250,000 out of 400,000 members. The all-out fascist terror did not escape even the smallest Yugoslav town, the communists were massively persecuted from their positions, and they were replaced primarily by rehabilitated Chetniks and revisionist weaklings.

  1. Was there organised resistance to the liquidation of the CPY and restoration of capitalism? If so, what are some organisations and figures that were involved in this fight?

Of course there was resistance, and fierce resistance, because otherwise the Titoist revisionists would not have had to be as bloodthirsty as they were. The white terror they unleashed was proportional to the resistance they felt. First of all, the majority of the party opposed their policies, which is why they began to attack the party itself. After its liquidation in 1948. there was organized resistance both inside and outside the country. Within the country, underground committees were organized, which initially helped the communists to save themselves from terror and to flee abroad, later in 1950. they took on more functions and began to disseminate literature and organize strikes.


Outside the country, there was a Yugoslav emigration in the Soviet Union that advocated the “Restoration of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia”, but like any emigration, it had problems, certain opportunists and some great people.

At the plenum of May 1955. the CPSU decided to completely change its attitude towards Yugoslavia, and decided to abolish the organization of Yugoslav political emigration and its work in relation to Yugoslavia. Despite this, the excellent communist Vlado Dapčević continued to represent the Marxist-Leninist position in Russia with high-quality political emigration cadres such as Radonja Golubović and Lala Ivanović, in which they were assisted by representatives of the Communist Party of Albania and China.

Vlado Dapčević gathered a large number of political emigrants around him, wrote resolutions that would have hundreds of signatures, held conferences, propagated, etc… his activities were stopped by the Central Committee of the CPSU, telling him that before his arrival they had not had a problem with Yugoslav emigration, but that, since his arrival, a series of conferences had begun, that resolutions were being written, and that it had taken on a large scale. Since his political work was at odds with the political line of the revisionist CPSU, he was forbidden to continue with such activities.

  1. How was the national question dealt with in the revolutionary period of Yugoslavia?

The greatest achievement of the national liberation struggle was the realization of the brotherhood of our peoples. While in the Kingdom of Yugoslavia the program of denationalization was carried out against all nationalities by the Greater Serbian bourgeoisie, while fascist collaborators of all shades spread national chauvinism, through the efforts of the Communist Party, all our peoples fought for their freedom and created their national formations, which merged into a single national liberation army, through which the brotherly solidarity and fighting unity of our peoples was manifested. On this basis, the fascist occupier and his nationalist collaborators were defeated. The peoples of Slovenia, Croatia, Macedonia and Montenegro fulfilled their national goals, the creation of a unified Bosnia and Herzegovina created an opportunity for the further development of the Bosniak nation, and the Albanian people in Kosovo were to be given the right to self-determination.

With the liquidation of people’s democracy, the national struggle has come to life again, as we have already explained in previous answers.

On the Committee to Reconstitute the Communist Party of Yugoslavia

  1. How was the CR-CPY founded?

The Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia was established in July 2024. as a result of the fierce two-line struggle of certain Maoist leaders and cadres of Partija rada against the majority of the leadership that had adopted Trotskyist and Kautskyist positions on the fundamental issues of the Yugoslav revolution. Originally, our organization was called Partija rada (red faction), but through further re-examination it was determined that for our circumstances such a name was not scientifically accurate, so several militant like-minded people underwent the process of forming the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. After half a year of persistent work, the founding declaration was written in Mojkovac under the name “Raise the red flag of Maoism in order to fulfill the task of reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia!”. This document was still immature and undeveloped in its content, but its significance consisted in the fact that it for the first time made a call for unification under the banner of Maoism over this region, and that, before our communists in formation, it established the task of reconstituting the Communist Party of Yugoslavia.

  1. What role does the CR-CPY aim to serve in the struggle to reconstitute the party?

In the present circumstances of our struggle, the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia does not have many supporters, but it stands forcefully as a red beacon of Marxism-Leninism-Maoism in the territory of the former Yugoslavia, clearly showing with its bright light the way forward to those who dare to look. Through our work, especially in the previous year, we have already successfully binded quality young people to ourselves, but if we had not dared to fight against revisionism, this would not have been the case. The Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia has a protracted task ahead of it, it must bind to itself the highest quality people from the working class, with the aim of gradually merging the efforts of reconstitution with the broad masses of the people. It is quite clear that it is impossible to do this unless the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia completely breaks with the revisionist and liquidationist currents in the revolutionary movement. Good progress has been made in this regard.

Whether the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia will succeed in its goal or whether it will fail is a question to which history will inevitably give an answer. But our organization has already made such a contribution that, however modest, will never be erased, because with our organization the idea of Maoism made its first steps in the territory of the former Yugoslavia.

  1. Can you describe briefly how the CR-CPY understands Marxism-Leninism-Maoism?

Marxism-Leninism-Maoism is Marxism-Leninism of the era in which imperialism is heading for total defeat and socialism is advancing towards world victory. To be a Marxist-Leninist today is to be a Maoist, because it is only a further development of the same unity established in the Manifesto and developed by the great Lenin. In our agitation and publications we use the term Marxism-Leninism-Maoism, principally Maoism, we emphasize that we do this exclusively tactically in order to emphasize that Maoism is principal, and thus defend our ideology. For the same reason, the main slogan of our agitation is still “Unite under Maoism!”.

  1. Yugoslavia has been divided into Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Kosovo, Montenegro, North Macedonia, Serbia, and Slovenia. Why is the CR-CPY looking to reconstitute a Yugoslav party and not a unique party for each country?

Although the former Yugoslavia comprises several states, the nationalities that encompass it have had such a mixed development that the only solution to the complex Yugoslav national question is their mutual brotherhood and unity. In other words, the destruction of the forcibly erected barriers between us, ensuring complete equality between all South Slavic nations, and clearing the way for their national unification.

Today, when the South Slavic peoples are on their knees, all equally exploited and enslaved by imperialism, comprador-bureaucratic capitalism and feudalism, when they all live equally badly despite insignificant differences, we consider it our task more than ever to fight for the unity and cohesion of these peoples.

The salvation of the South Slavic peoples from universal misery is tangible only as a vast epic in the solemn triumph of the world proletarian revolution, through which our peoples will establish new democracy, peace amongst themselves and socialism!

Concluding Questions

  1. How can the workers in Canada support the communist movement in the former Yugoslav countries?

The most internationalist thing the Canadian proletariat can do is to overthrow the imperialism of its own country.

  1. Do you have anything else you would like to say?

We would like once again to express our gratitude to your paper for its interest in Yugoslav questions. While our answers aren’t as insightful as they should ideally be, we hope they are satisfying to your readers.


Responses to “Interview with the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia”

  1. Intervju za „The People’s Hammer” – The People's Hammer

    […] More of their writings can be found here. The original interview in English can be found here and the original translation can be found here. The positions put forward in the text do not […]

    Like

  2. Интервју за „The People’s Hammer” – The People's Hammer

    […] More of their writings can be found here. The original interview in English can be found here and the original translation can be found here. The positions put forward in the text do not […]

    Like

  3. Programme and Statute – by the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia – The People's Hammer

    […] The following is the basic document of the Committee for the Reconstitution of the Communist Party of Yugoslavia. The original can be found here. We have previously published an interview with the committee which can be found here. […]

    Like


Latest Articles