The following is an interview with Red Flag (Steagul Roșu). More of their writing can be found here.
The positions put forward in the text do not reflect our line. We are publishing this document with the intention of both bettering the understanding of the international communist movement among workers in Canada and to promote two-line struggle internationally.
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
Romanian Society
1. What was the mode of production in Romania before the revolution? How was it transformed by the revolution?
The mode of production before the revolution was capitalism, or to be more precise bureaucratic capitalism, semi-feudal and semi-colonial. There exited a quite obvious industry and proletariat, most of the industry and banking being linked with German or French imperialists, there was a significant amount of petty-bourgeois manufacturing and crafts. Most of the population was made up of peasants, some working their own plots, but the majority were under a sharecropping system and brutally exploited by landlords; this system is sometimes called in our literature “neoiobăgie.” Political power was shared between both the bourgeoisie and the landlord class, the term “bourgeois-landlord regime” was usually used to describe it. This system, having been formed after the incomplete burgeois-democratic revolutions of 1848, became in the 20th century more and more integrated into the imperialist system especially through the oil industry owned by the German imperialists.
After the long battles waged to remove from power, first the fascist legionaries through the 23rd of August 1944 Armed Uprising, and afterwards to eliminate the king’s acolytes through a long struggle spanning from February to March 1945, the Democratic phase of the Revolution begun, and the first democratic government was established on March 6. Soon after, measures were taken to eliminate the most major exploiters, this manifested itself in the expropriation of property belonging to the German imperialists, war criminals and landlords. Over 1.1 million hectares of land was redistributed to the poor peasants trough the agrarian reform begun on March 23. Further, after the attempt to sabotage the revolution after March 6, the government took measures to regulate prices, the circulation of goods and wages.
In the years 1947-1948, the revolution passed into its socialist phase, and so, the state started taking the form of the dictatorship of the proletariat more and more, and the programme of the United Workers’ Party was adopted. The socialist economy was structured upon the collectivization of goods through Collective Agricultural Associations (TOZ), monetary reforms to secure the workers’ economic safety against the attempts of reactionaries, and a planned economy, which helped develop industry, transport and the electrical grid of the country. This process also, by 1960, eliminated the last exploiter, the kulaks and by 1962 collectivization also reached its end. By the time of the 1965 restoration, Romania already has become a socialist society.
2. Since restoration, what has been the Romanian mode of production?
Since restoration, Romania’s mode of production has been capitalist. It is uncertain where Romania stood within the international imperialist system after the restoration, but in the present the country is certainly a semi-colonial one. It’s debatable exactly when Romania became a semi-colony again after the restoration, but it is for sure that it has been one from at least 2007 onward.
During the revisionist period (1965-1989), Romania was a heavily industrialized country, with most of production being focused on export, especially near its end. The policy here is quite similar to China’s in the 2000s: mass produced commodities at a cheap price. But as for its place within the imperialist system, it’s hard to tell since on one side it became heavily indebted in the ’70s and in the ’80s it started to give out loans to Arab and Middle Eastern countries within a plan not that different to what China has been doing in recent years. In any case after the December 1989, when Ceaușescu’s reign ended, a process of privatization started, which resulted in the closing down of many industrial enterprises and the breaking up of collective farms. The nature of some of the governments of the ’90s and early 2000s is debatable regarding their relations with the imperialists.
Today, we are clearly back at the point of being a semi-colonial, bureaucratic capitalist country. Our economy has been described as a subcontractor economy, most enterprises producing parts or offering some services to international monopolies. Agriculture is split mainly between a capitalist agriculture with landlords, capitalist farmers and agricultural workers and a private plot subsistence farming, with the rural population involved in these, doubling as a supply for seasonal labor in imperialist countries in the West; there exist some forms of sharecropping but they are marginal.
3. Which imperialist powers are most prevalent in Romania?
The most prevalent imperialist powers in Romania are Germany and France, with noticeable monopolies in the retail sector, along with banking and energy companies as well. Other less major but still significant imperialists include Austria and the Netherlands, mainly in the banking and energy sectors and of course, due to the European Single Market, all imperialist powers of Europe are, on some level, present in the Romanian economy.
The USA is also a very influential imperialist power in the country, but it isn’t very noticeable on the economic side. It mainly holds influence over military and foreign affairs mainly through NATO, thanks to an extremely servile attitude from the bourgeois parties, which are happy to follow the US no matter the government or how mad its policies might seem.
4. What is the stage of the revolution in Romania today?
The masses have been more or less in a state of revolt for some years. The principal contradiction is the contradiction between imperialism and the semi-colonial nation. There is a great anti-imperialist sentiment which could potentially serve as the basis for a new revolutionary situation and the capacity of the state apparatus of the ruling classes to maintain the current state of affairs is weak. However, this state of revolt manifests itself in a disorganized form. Much of the working class is not organized and the communists themselves aren’t organized within a communist party.
We don’t have a great percentage of trade union membership and among the unions that do exist, a great number would be best described as yellow unions. None of this is by chance – it is the result of changes made in the labour law around the year 2011, with the result of restricting the right of unions to negotiate the collective agreement (it being one of the main, if not the main reason to join a union) by requiring that all of them be represented by a single union, which fits within some parameters. In such conditions, of course, union membership would fall and yellow unions would be favored.
That being said, the objective conditions are favorable for revolution, as both the revolt of the masses is high and we have quite a weak state. But the subjective conditions haven’t yet reached a point where it could lead the revolution. The success of the revolution depends on when these problems can be surpassed.
5. In the Canadian press, the most recent Romanian presidential election was portrayed as a defeat of fascism by liberal-democracy. How accurate is this assessment and how would you describe the current organization of the Romanian state?
This assessment is inaccurate; it was a narrative preferred within specific liberal circles, mostly from outside the country. In reality, George Simion, the so-called far-right candidate, is not truly a fascist. Before him, there was Călin Georgescu, who was the surprise independent candidate who made it into the second round of the 2024 presidential elections. Georgescu was a reactionary but nothing close to a fascist, advocating for a more open and tolerant policy toward Russia. The 2024 elections were annulled by the Constitutional Court for supposed Russian intervention and that got us to the 2025 presidential elections, where the second round candidates were George Simion and Nicușor Dan. Both were representatives of some comprador clique, the bureaucrat candidate having lost in the first round, with Simion more oriented toward US imperialists, while Dan toward French imperialists. The mainstream media presented this as a pro-Russia vs pro-EU battle, but the reality is Simion is in no way a real threat to EU membership or even to the European imperialists.
It is true that both Simion and Georgescu have expressed sympathies towards interwar fascists, the legionaries. But Nicușor Dan himself does seem to have some of his own sympathies for legionary groups, for example, he decorated a former soldier who took part in the war against the USSR, has expressed publicly that he admires the anti-communist fascist groups that were active in the 50s and 60s in his native region of Făgăraș, he has opposed laws criminalizing fascist propaganda and it is rumoured that even his son is named after a church with symbolic importance for legionaries. Both Dan and Simion are equally “fascist.” Despite these facts, the mainstream press hasn’t really accused Dan, of being a fascist, and they generally don’t view his questionable sympathies as a negative thing.
If we are to take the more prevalent narrative of this election being a battle between Russia and EU, the current state apparatus is fully integrated with EU institutions and the presence of Russian imperialism is almost non-existent here, especially after the start of the war in Ukraine, when most economic ties with Russia have been cut as part of international sanctions. But even before that Russian presence here was very limited.
6. What are the fundamental forms of opportunism in the Romanian workers movement?
Generally speaking, those would be reformism and trade-unionism. But more particular forms of these could be called “imperialist realism,” “comprador tailism” and “signal based trade-unionism.” The first two fall under reformism and the last under trade-unionism, and all are quite interlinked.
What has been called “imperialist realism” is the view, expressed many times very explicitly, that there is no alternative toward the Imperialist World System and that it is better that we are under the influence of the European or American imperialists and more so that there are numerous benefits to being part of the EU and NATO and collaboration within their institutions is of paramount importance. Many of the trade-union federations and confederations have links with or are a part of European opportunist trade-union organizations, and so, opportunist trade-union leaders have a vested interest in praising the EU and obscuring its character as an organization serving the interests of numerous imperialist powers.
“Comprador tailism” is the best name that could be given to the tendency to only struggle against the bureaucratic bourgeoisie and conveniently leave out the compradors, whom they see as allies. As is the slogan of reformists everywhere, “it’s just some bad apples.” This is the practice of most opportunists linked with the bourgeois parties like PNL [National Liberal Party], USR [Save Romania Union] and AUR [Alliance for the Union of Romanians]. In the case of the last party’s representatives within the workers’ movement, it somehow mimics MAGA rhetoric and present themselves as “sovereignists” to capitalize on the broad anti-imperialist sentiments.
Lastly, we do have issues with trade-unionism, generally with unions who’s leaders are linked with the bureaucrat capitalists and generally PSD [Social Democratic Party], the main bureaucrat party. But an even worse form is what we can call “signal based trade-unionism” where not even the economic struggle is done right, where strikes are replaced with protests and symbolic strikes while continuing to work, which are even worse than protests. The “theory” behind such practices are that there is no need for political struggle from the workers, that through economic struggle they are sending signals that politicians will pick up and solve their problems, and lastly, since all that is important is the signal, actual strikes are not even necessary.
If we are to talk about the actions of revisionist groups they are either falling under tailists or sectarians. These express as their classical form: “we just support worker movement, we don’t interfere” and “no need for work among the masses, the workers will eventually come to us.” As you can imagine, they don’t have much influence within the worker’s movement.
7. What are some recent major struggles the workers of Romania have taken up?
To give some context: since 2025 we have embarked on a session of austerity measures dictated by the EU Commission and the IMF, with NATO adding extra pressure through a higher defense spending quota. This materialized itself as cuts of funds from important public sectors, university scholarships, pensions, freezing wages and eliminating important subsidies to the energy sector. The result was a rampant growth of the cost of living. This affected not only the working class, but all classes in some way or another. But it was the working class that has been the most valiant fighters against the austerity measures through protests and strikes, despite the constant sabotage of the opportunist leaders. The focal point were the teachers’ trade unions with 30 thousand marching on the capital on September 8 last year and with a general strike being in planning for about a month now.
We have had some isolated industrial strikes and protests as well, caused either by the freezing of wages or of production due to conflicts between international monopolies. Although these have been isolated from each other and have been more losses than victories, they are an important step, as they show workers within industry and the whole working class the willful incompetence of the yellow unions and the effects of union busting of the early 2010s which we spoke about earlier. As a result, workers are becoming more aware of the need for red unions and trade-union unity across sectors as none of these struggles are over.
Communist Party of Romania/Romanian Communist Party/Romanian Workers Party
- How was the Communist Party of Romania founded?
It was founded on the 8th of May 1921, during its First Congress, when the majority of the members of the old Socialist Party voted in favor of joining the Communist International. But the reality is that the party founded in 1921 wasn’t truly a communist party, a party of the new type, it did not yet have a Marxist-Leninist programme and it still had opportunist and sectarian elements within its ranks. To purge these elements it took about 10 years, things being worsened by the terror of the ruling classes against the newly formed party.
We take the 5th Congress of the Communist Party of Romania to be the point when the Communist Party has been truly constituted as a communist party as it’s the point when all of the right and “left” deviations we’re eliminated and a Marxist-Leninist programme was elaborated. In some way this was how the Romanian Workers’ Party (RWP) also saw the situation, the 5th Congress was always a point of reference for when the party came into it’s own. It is only by the action of the revisionists and anticommunist historians that this has been forgotten to a degree today.
- The Romanian Workers Party is often described internationally as centrist in the 1950s-1970s alongside the parties in Korea and Vietnam. Do you think this assessment is accurate? In this same period, was the party domestically still pursuing socialist construction or was it already restoring capitalism?
It depends on what we mean by centrist. If by centrist we mean in a conventional sense that RWP was somewhere to the right of the Communist Party of China (CPC) and the left of the Communist Party of the Soviet Union (CPSU), that is correct, but to make such a simplification does not answer a more important question: was the RWP revisionist or not? If by centrism we mean a mix of revisionist and communist positions that adds up to RWP being qualitatively a revisionist party, just like Kautsky was a centrist, then the answer is a clear no.
The Romanian Workers’ Party during the debate between the CPC and CPSU saw itself as fighting for the unity of the Communist Movement. Because it never came to see CPSU as a revisionist party, this of course meant fighting for unity with it too, but as RWP’s positions on the key issues discussed, they were much closer to the Chinese communists. RWP never accepted Khrushchev’s revisionist theories of the Three Peacefuls and Two Wholes. RWP’s positions were as follows: (1) Peaceful Transition had no historical precedence and no party should rule out violent means, more should prepare for such an eventuality, (2) As long as Imperialism still stands there is the possibility of war and as such, Peaceful Coexistence should not mean the abandonment of National Liberation or Class War, (3) The National Liberation Movement is an integral part of the Socialist Revolution, (4) The working class is the ruling class of a socialist state and (5) class struggle continues under socialism, primarily in ideological form. These positions, which are in opposition with Khrushchev’s revisionist theses, are to be found either in the Report of the 3rd Congress of the RWP or in the 1964 April Declaration.
Another point of tension between the RWP and CPSU, is of course Khrushchev’s plan for the so-called “Socialist Division of Labor” which in practice was a plan to transform a part of the former socialist camp into the colonies or semi-colonies of the USSR. This was criticized by the RWP but not for being an imperialist project but for violation of national sovereignty. The comparison with imperialists did occur to them, but as we said, they also still believed the USSR to be socialist.
As for RWP’s actions around the year 1964, it sought to end the public polemic between the CPSU and CPC by helping the two come to a common point, but as you can see the RWP’s preferred common point would have been much more in line with the CPC, which is why especially after the March Peking meeting between the two parties they came to have much closer relationships — the explicit goal of RWP’s actions, that of helping the International Communist Movement (ICM) reach greater unity was achieved even if it didn’t realize it.
As to do with internal affairs, here too the RWP continued socialist construction and succeeded in building a socialist country, it developed both a socialist industry and completed the socialist transformation of agriculture by 1962, all while maintaining the class struggle and the dictatorship of the proletariat, having crushed an attempted counterrevolution between 1956 and 1958 and aiding the Hungarian communists in doing the same in their country.
So it would be wrong to consider the Romanian Worker’s Party as a revisionist party. This is not to say that no mistakes were made, some clearly identifiable mistakes exist. Firstly, it obviously failed to recognize the CPSU as a revisionist party, the USSR as imperialist and despite acknowledging the Yugoslav revisionists as what they were, revisionists, it still thought Yugoslavia wasn’t capitalist. Secondly, there is the mistake of thinking that the leadership of the party has somehow “proven” itself and that in it’s midst there could not be revisionists. This latter assumption made it much easier for Ceaușescu, his clique and Maurer to restore capitalism in Romania.
- What were the main instances of two-line struggle in the party during its revolutionary period? How do the many name changes to the party relate to these two-line struggles?
There were many instances of two-line struggle. Firstly, there was the unprincipled fractional struggle that preceded the constitution of the party and was marked by multiple factions trying to push deviationist or revisionist lines trough unprincipled means and just overtake the party leadership, all these were eliminated or corrected by the time of the 5th Party Congress in 1931. The second major struggle, happened during World War II when Ștefan Foriș, from his position as general secretary was pushing a line of defeatism, shutting down all attempts at partisan actions or people’s war. He was opposed by Emil Bodnăraș, Gheorghiu-Dej and Petre Gheorghe whom succeeded in removing Foriș and his acolytes from the party leadership and organizing an armed resistance which was the basis of the August 23rd Armed Uprising.
The third struggle was of a more protracted nature and maybe it would be wrong to even call it a singular struggle. During the whole period of socialist construction, The Clique of Ana Pauker, Teohari Georgescu and Vasile Luca had conducted subversive actions with the purpose of overtaking the party leadership and use it for their personal benefit. During this time they tried pushing a liquidationist line of rapid unchecked growth of the party which would permit careerist and legionary elements to enter the party and to support them, they tried to push a wedge between the CP(B)SU and the RCP by spreading rumors about the RCP being nationalist and Stalin favoring their clique for party leadership, they pushed both “leftist” and rightist positions on collectivization. All these failed and in the end both RWP and Stalin recognized them for what they were and were excluded from the party by 1953.
There was minor case of struggle after the 20th Congress of the CPSU, two Politburo members have been pursuing a khrushchevite line, of attacking Gheorghiu-Dej for his supposed cult of personality. This was rapidly taken care of within the party, the CC taking a correct position, but having had the experience of the Pauker Clique using the prestige of Stalin to hide their mistakes, it did not question the intent of CPSU’s actions until later on. Unfortunately we cannot say that the restoration of capitalism or the Party’s liquidation was preceded by much struggle, the revisionists having hid their true intent before doing it and while doing so well that even today some are fooled by them.
The first name change, namely from the Communist Party of Romania to the Romanian Communist Party, is a bit mysterious. No explicit explanation of it is found in the official party documents, in some way is treated as if this was the name of the party all along. There are some theories that came after about the reason why name change was made, but there is no proof for any of them. It is most likely just a change in form, as in Romanian “din România” and “român” can mean the same thing — technically “Partidul Comunist Român” is much closer to how “Partidul Communist din România” is usually translated into English, as the Communist Party of Romania, while a literal translation would be “the Communist Party from Romania.”
The second name change, from the Romanian Communist Party to the Romanian Workers’ Party was motivated by two-line struggle within the Workers’ Movement, not so much in the Communist Party. The Workers’ Movement was split from the ’20s as a result of the actions of the Right Social-Democrats. Most of the Right Social-Democrats lost relevance or became politically compromised after they were willing to work with the fascist governments of the ’30s and the last Right Social-Democrats under the leadership of Constantin Titel-Petrescu split form the Social-Democratic Party in 1946, but they had no influence on the working class. While the Left and Center Social-Democrats kept on working together with the Communists in the United Front and came to realize the error of the split and after a long process of ideological clarification, they accepted Marxism-Leninism as their ideology and many were admitted in the Communist Party. As a result of the healing of this split and the working class having attained unity, the name was changed. We are aware that similar processes took place in other countries in Eastern Europe, but if these were truly the result of unity under Marxism-Leninism or just some Social-Democratic merger is up to the communists of that country to decide.
The last name change, namely from the Romanian Workers’ Party to the Romanian Communist Party, was the decision of Ceaușescu and his clique, it was motivated by the fact that Romania became a socialist country and the next step was communism, even though during the same congress where the name was changed, a new intermediate stage between Socialism and Communism was defined, Multilaterally Developed Socialism. In reality the change only marked the triumph of counterrevolution and the liquidation of a real Communist Party.
- When did the revisionist line become dominant in the Romanian Workers Party and when did it restore capitalism? What was the process by which these occurred?
We would say the answer to both is the 9th Congress of Romanian Communist Party. This revisionist line did not manifest itself openly before this event, not even in the leading organs of the party, which the revisionists infiltrated, and later rapidly overtook in 1965. During the 4th Congress of the RWP, as it was initially supposed to be called, the revisionists saw a double opportunity as it was the first Congress both after the death of Gheorghe Gheorghiu-Dej, the former leader of the Romanian Workers’ Party, and also was the congress where Romania would’ve been declared a socialist country so they could motivate both changes within the party and the general line.
The main agents of counterrevolution were Ion Gheorghe Maurer and Nicolae Ceaușescu. First they made sure that Ceaușescu would hold the office of First Secretary ad interim until the congress took place, even though Gheorghe Apostol was suppose to occupy this position as for the plans made with Gheorghiu-Dej before his death. Having this office, Ceaușescu and his clique had control over the organization of the congress and the main report. Using these, Ceaușescu and his acolytes made changes in the structure of the Central Committee, adding around 100 new members to the CC and creating the Permanent Presidium as an organ above the Politburo. Even with these changes that made the job of the revisionists easier they still had to rely on abusive methods of raising issues without being on the order of the day and forcing the other members to take quick decisions on problems without considering the full implications.
During the 9th Congress Ceaușescu formulated his Theses: (1) of “Multilaterally Developed Socialism,” (2) of promoting cadres not based on their political outlook but on technical skills, (3) of the end of class struggle and growing the party and (4) development of the productive forces by raising the Accumulation Fund. The second and third were mainly used to liquidate the party by allowing all kinds of careerists not only to easily enter the party but also to replace the good cadres in leading positions. The first and forth were used to restore capitalism and exploitation. During the whole revisionist period the main way the capitalists exploited the workers was trough the Accumulation Fund, which comprised between 33 to 40% of the national income.
To eliminate and discredit the leadership and good cadres of the former RWP, the revisionists mainly used campaigns of rehabilitating the old revisionists. The most notable was the rehabilitation of Lucrețiu Pătrașcanu in 1968, a minor rightist purged in the ’40s and who’s collaboration with the American imperialists got him the capital punishment. The revisionists, being inspired by Khrushchev’s own condemnation of Stalin, had made up a similar story about Gheorghiu-Dej and the CC’s “abuses” against the rehabilitated Pătrășcanu. The purpose of the rehabilitations was to tarnish the prestige of the previous leadership and demote them from any office of power within the party or the state, isolate them and reduce them to silence. Although the rehabilitations were never made very public as to not alert the CPC, with whom the RCP tried to maintain good relations for trade.
After the 10th and 11th Congresses the power of the revisionists was paramount and they felt completely unhindered in their capitalist pursuit, having in 1967 created legal forms for petty-bourgeois agents inspired by the nepmen, in 1970 they begin to negate the principle of remuneration according to work, and cut down the pay of workers to more fixed wages, with the given reason being to incentivize workers to specialize to a higher degree. In the 1970s after the 10th Congress a chase for foreign capital and imperialist credit begins so that Romania surpasses even the Soviet Union in the size of its foreign currency reserve. Between ’71 and ’77 they experimented with a system of self-management not that different from the Yugoslav one with the aim of turning all state enterprises into profitable ventures. So the form was becoming more and more capitalist to fit the content established by the 9th Congress.
The most brutal forms of exploitation were felt in the ’80s, with most of production being directed towards export so as, on one hand, to pay off all of the debt taken in the ’70s from imperialist institutions and, on the other hand, keep on accumulating capital, these harsh conditions being in no way considered a valid argument to decrease the percentage allocated to accumulation. During this time the population was living basically under wartime measures, with food and necessities being rationed to the minimum necessary amount while working to produce mountains of commodities to be sold somewhere else.
- Academics often portray Ceaușescu’s July Theses as having launched a Romanian version of the cultural revolution. Do you believe this characterisation is accurate?
Absolutely not, nowadays even some bourgeois historians in Romania dismiss this as a myth. The confusion seems to stem primarily from the fact that in June of the same year Ceaușescu visited China, so they think there is some link between the two. But the truth is that the July Theses were in the works since February 1970.
There are also some superficial similarities between the two, for example interest in propaganda or involving youth in production. The reason for these two in the case of Romania is that, for one, new bourgeois elements and petty-bourgeois writers were expressing individualistic tendencies more openly in art and movies and this didn’t go well with the facade the RCP wanted to keep. As for the youth involvement in production, this was just motivated by a deficit of workforce in the agricultural sector. The July Thesis were in no way meant to open up any kind of struggle.
More so, we know from internal documents what impression the 1971 visit to China left on Ceaușescu: he was impressed by advances in production made by the Chinese and the artistic output of the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and saw them as confirmation that what they were already planning to do was right, but thought this was made in spite of the Cultural Revolution not because of it. He liked the results but not the methods of the Cultural Revolution.
- Was there organised resistance to the liquidation of the party and restoration of capitalism? If so, what are some organisations and figures that were involved in this fight up to the present?
None that we know of. Resistance did exist within the RCP from the former leadership, Chivu Stoica, Gheorghe Apostol and Constantin Pârvulescu had some form of opposition towards Ceaușescu’s plan, but in their case it was never an organized resistance as they still had hopes that the party can be salvaged and so upheld the ban on factionalism. Even so, the revisionists still tried to reduce them to silence by terror or isolate them by bureaucratic means. In the case of Chivu Stoica, it is very likely he was assassinated.
At regional levels, there are signs of existing discontent and resistance, if it took an organized form it was most likely censored and suppressed because since 1972 a very extensive oppressive apparatus took form, the Security or “Securitatea” as you might know it. Most forms of oppositions were suppressed. In any case, we are very sure that it is unlikely that resistance took a Maoist form, as the works of Mao Tsetung weren’t really available beyond the 4th volume of Selected Works and the Cultural Revolution was never mentioned in the press. Generally, not much was presented in the press about other parties except a sanitized version, which didn’t contradict the revisionists’ narrative.
Whatever survived of the disorganized and partially organized resistance begun to organize only in the ’90s. The organizations that formed during this later period such as the Socialist Labor Party, the Romanian Workers’ Party were always plagued by revisionist elements which ran them into the ground. The best people involved with these were still old party members like Apostol, but their involvement was limited and didn’t have a lasting impact, although they outlined a more correct political line than what these organizations upheld after they were no longer involved or died. The result is that we had a period of about 10-20 years when there was no organization that wasn’t revisionist nor had at least a partially correct line.
Red Flag and the Contemporary Communist Movement
1. How was Red Flag founded?
Red Flag started off as a group of like-minded individuals inspired by the examples of the ongoing People’s Wars in India, Peru and Philippines and the ICM more generally. At the time, 2021, materials to do with Maoism, the previously mentioned People’s Wars or even the writings of Mao Tsetung weren’t that accessible in the Romanian language. Through the Red Flag we sought, on one hand, to make these materials more accessible to the Romanian public and, on the other hand, offer a basis for unity under Maoism for the Romanian communists.
2. How does Red Flag understand Maoism?
Maoism is the third and highest stage of Marxism, the scientific ideology of the proletariat. Today this ideology is Marxism-Leninism-Maoism. This higher stage has been based on the developments of Chairman Mao in all the three branches of Marxism and has been defined as such by Chairman Gonzalo. And further we would like to emphasize that to be communist today means to be Maoist, since it’s the natural development of Marxism to a higher stage, since all other so-called Marxist trends have proven their revisionism and since all authentic Marxist-Leninist parties of the past were already moving toward this development, which is what happened to our party before the liquidation of the party and the counterrevolution.
3. What role does Red Flag play in the struggle to reconstitute the party?
Mainly, we publish and make accessible a wide range of materials, including fundamental texts on Maoism, both Romanian and international historical documents of the communist movement, materials from the International Communist League and other parties involved in the ICM, and more recently, as the Maoist movement in Romania has grown more and more, we also publish materials from the organizations and individuals actively involved in the reconstitution of the Party.
So, to answer your question, in a sense Red Flag is supposed to make easily available the documents of this struggle for reconstitution and to aid in it by making more people aware of it and involved in it.
4. Is the Romanian communist movement divided or united? If divided, how does Red Flag aim to overcome this? If it is today united, how was this achieved?
At present, the communists are largely scattered; this is not due to some ideological split but just because Maoism is not that old in our country. But among Maoists there is a great degree of unity and our ranks are growing rapidly as the line of reconstituting the Romanian Workers’ Party is made aware to more and more people. Of course in Romania too we have some revisionist groups which have been active for a while and they have been perpetuating a state of confusion, but their reach is limited and fortunately they don’t exert influence over the communists nor over the masses.
5. Aside from Red Flag and the Romanian Workers Party (Red Fraction), are there other organisations in Romania currently struggling to reconstitute the party?
None that we are aware of; if there are other communist organizations struggling for reconstitution, they haven’t made themselves visible yet. There are, on the other hand, a number of revisionist groups that we know of, but these groups don’t intend on reconstituting the Communist Party, and in most cases not even a party of the proletariat, instead being interested in other “revolutionary subjects.” A good example for this is the Romanian Socialist Party (PSR). Although they already consider themselves to be a party despite their numbers not being too different from other groups, and their links with the masses are non-existent. They focus on “working people” as a general term, which includes anyone who works, in some of their materials this being capitalists, and the “already existing socialist countries” such as China, Cuba and so on.
6. To what degree have the advanced workers been won to communism?
To a high degree. It can be said that most of the advanced workers know that a communist party is their party and would be willing to work with it when it will be reconstituted. In a sense, the issue for us is probably the opposite of what comrades in other countries might face, the advanced workers associate themselves with communism so much that presenting ourselves as communists doesn’t mean a lot and so we have to prove practically that we are communists, as even though they remember the dictatorship of the proletariat and the old RWP, they also remember the old revisionists and that they also called themselves communists.
Sympathies toward communists are common even among the intermediary and backwards workers or even among broader masses. And this is seen as a problem by the ruling classes, they have tried to make campaigns trying to “educate” the masses on “the evils of communism” but with little results. The best they could do is trying to associate communism with the revisionist Ceaușescu through some ambiguous polling in which the majority seemingly express favorable views towards Ceaușescu. In reality, anyone with a nuanced opinion would have been forced to give favorable answers there, as most of the masses see something like universal employment, state housing and a developed industry, which were maintained under the rule of the revisionists, as the saving grace of the regime and without it, there would be nothing good to say about it.
Conclusion
- How can the workers and communists of Canada support the struggle to reconstitute the Romanian Workers Party?
The most important support comes through exchange of experience and joint participation in building international organizations no matter if we talk about a Communist International, an anti-imperialist international, a new international of trade-unions or any such organization; all of them are important for the communists of all countries to learn from each other. Of course, actions to show solidarity or support are always welcomed as well and always raise our spirit.
Development of these international links between communists is of great importance to us. Of particular importance to us are international links between communists of Europe, of Eastern Europe and the Balkans, as they are our neighbors and, geographically speaking, collaboration with them is easier. So, by supporting them and helping them or the communist movement in any country in their struggles in the end helps us as well.
- Do you have any other concluding remarks?
Since a significant part of our interview was dedicated to Party history, we would like to encourage communists from all countries to make serious studies of their parties’ history since it’s an important question what party we have to reconstitute, and if there is a party to be reconstituted or the problem is of constitution. For the Romanian communists as well, the issue was nebulous for a long time. Many of us used to think that we didn’t have much of a party to reconstitute and you can imagine how great our surprise was when, taking historical events one by one, we discovered how different they were from what we expected.
In such an investigation we would also advise that things should start from the particular to the general and not the other way around, such that facts might not be overlooked or misrepresented, to not reconsider previous wrong assessments. Such was the case with Hoxhaist groups in Romania who would mold historical reality just to uphold Hoxha’s biased recollections on Gheorghiu-Dej.
In the end, we would like to thank our Canadian Comrades for the occasion to make the struggles of the Romanian masses, workers and communists known to more people.
Response to “Interview with Red Flag (Romania)”
[…] The following document is a translation of On Class Analysis produced by The Red Flag (Romania). We have previously published an interview with them which can be found here. […]
LikeLike