The following article is a repost from the Workers’ United Front website. We strongly urge our reader to read through this article. The original can be found here.
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
Introduction
The collapse of social-democracy in Canada and what approach the WUF should take to a potential new labour party were major points of discussion at our founding congress. While our Strategy and Tactics,1 our Report,2 and several articles on The People’s Hammer3 deal with these issues in part. We believe it is necessary to expand on the role of social-democracy and labour parties in Canada and on how we should prepare for the next stage in their evolution.
This is of importance because as our Report states:
“Social-democracy, often with support of certain liberal principles, is the dominant ideological line found among the working-class. When class politics are first brought to the proletariat, many workers will very quickly articulate social-democratic principles such as nationalisation of industry, a large social safety net, free healthcare and education, mediating class conflicts through existing institutions, and even workers ownership and control of the means of production.”4
In many imperialist countries, social-democracy has experienced a similar collapse. Yet, the opportunists have managed to re-invent themselves and regain some traction among the proletariat. We can see this in the USA with Zohran Mamdani or in the UK with Jeremy Corbyn’s Your Party. The class conscious proletariat need to recognise that Canadian social-democracy is collapsing and have a plan of action to combat its re-emergence as a political force among the proletariat.
What is Social-Democracy
Before World War One, social-democracy meant something very different from what it means today. Social-democracy was basically synonymous with Marxism or communism. It described the “doctrine of the conditions of liberation of the working-class”.5 The international communist movement of the time was united organisationally under the International Socialist Bureau. This organisation grouped many of the organisations of this movement from Lenin’s Bolsheviks to the reformist British Labour Party
However, in World War One, the international communist movement split first over the issue of whether to support the imperialist war. Secondly over the strategy and tactics of the Russian Revolution. Out of this situation, the left united into the Communist International and the right united into the Labour and Socialist International. From this split onward, the term communism was embraced by the left, while the right embraced the term social-democracy.
The Communist International had a very clear basis of unity on Bolshevism and later Marxism-Leninism. The social-democrats on the other hand were united simply on the basis of their rejection of the strategy and tactics of the communists and a bourgeois understanding of the state as being above class. Social-democracy has remained a very broad and contradictory movement. It has always been divided into a left and a right. The left has generally supported the unity of the workers, at least case-by-case unity with communists, and a workers’ republic. On its right, social-democracy aims to bind the workers movement into the capitalist state through corporations to prevent revolution. Right-wing social-democracy is better described as social-fascism.6
Today, the social-democratic movement has further liquidated since Lenin’s time. Most social-democrats no longer claim to be Marxist. It has increasingly broken from a basis on the workers movement into an attempt to pander to different social movements (student, pensioners, environmental, feminist, “queer”, etc.). This liquidation is the result of the salarisation of much of the petite-bourgeoisie in the 1960s-1980s allowing deeper penetration of bourgeois ideology among the proletariat. In this movement we find those who call for socialism such as those who identify today as socialists, eco-socialists, and democratic socialists. Those who are likely to refer to themselves as social-democrats often limit themselves to fighting to expand the social safety net.
As Canadian social-democracy has distanced itself from the workers movement toward the flavour of the week social movement, socialism has lost more and more of its meaning even among those who refer to themselves as socialists. This has reached a point where to many socialism just means a state that plays a very open and active role in society and provides services for free. This liquidated understanding has even found its way into the far-right of the communist movement with the “(New) Communist Party of Canada”. This counterfeit party describes a socialist state as one focused on healthcare, education and culture instead of the construction of communism.7
Today, social-democracy in Canada refers to a broad social-movement that calls for broader social safety, nationalisation of key industries, mediation of class conflict through existing institutions, higher unionisation rates, and opposition to communist strategy and tactics. Modern social-democracy is the descendent of Eduard Bernstein who said “the movement, the series of processes, is everything, whilst every aim fixed beforehand in its details is immaterial to it.”8
What is a Labour Party?
The labour party is often the first form that independent political action takes for the workers. It is usually confined to fighting for workers rights at the ballot box and within the confines of capitalism.
The communist party is highly disciplined, has defined membership based adherence to its programme, and is based on the unity of communism with the most advanced workers. The labour party membership is much broader encompassing as much of the class as possible. As social-democracy is the main ideological line among the proletariat, it is generally this line that is represented in the party line and programme.
Organisationally, labour parties are an outgrowth of the unions. They are formed by the labour movement and have a large number of unions affiliated to the party. While membership is not confined to the unions, union bureaucrats are usually granted a guaranteed and outsized representation on the party’s leadership bodies. Because of this, labour parties represent mainly the interest of the union bureaucrats and labour aristocracy, not the interests of the class as a whole.
Labour Parties and Social-Democracy in Canada
Historical
In Canada, labour parties, permanent trade unions, and labour journals all began to emerge at the same time.
The Workingmen’s Progressive Political Party was formed in London, Ontario in 1872.9 Its demands were limited to the reform and increased democratisation of Canada through measures such as the abolition of property qualification in elections and the election of senators.10 Independent proletarian parties in this period were all formed on a regional basis with fully reformist programmes. By the turn of the century, many would also adopt racist positions calling for the exclusion of all “oriental labour”.
In 1873, the first national trade union centre was founded – the Canadian Labour Union. At its first convention, it called for independent political action by the proletariat by running independent labour candidates.11
By 1895, the new national centre the Trades and Labour Congress (TLC) broke their formal pact with the Liberals.12 Instead, they called for the formation of an “Independent Labour Party”.13 It was also around this time, that the class conscious workers began to organise for a communist party based on Marxism. This movement eventually culminated in the formation of the the Socialist Party of Canada (SPC) in 1904.
The TLC again called for a Canadian Labour Party at its 1906 convention with a federated structure based on provincial divisions.14 This effort for a labour party was more successful than the previous one, leading to the formation of labour parties in many provinces. Earlier attempts reflected the rising class consciousness of the workers in their rejection of the big bourgeois party (the Liberals) and the middle bourgeois party (the Conservatives) in favour of political independence. However, the 1906 effort was in reaction to the rising communist movement in the west led by the SPC. This is obvious from the fact that at this very convention, the delegates were presented with the opportunity to endorse the SPC’s principles and programme and opted for a labour party as a third path between communism and liberalism.15
From October 29-30 1906, a meeting was held in BC to found the provincial labour party.16 This meeting became a debate on the creation of a labour party versus support for the SPC.17 24 delegates left for another room to found a stillborn labour party rather than discuss the possibility of supporting the SPC.18 It is important to note that the delegates that left had been elected mainly from the craft unions.19 That is, they were mainly the representative of the labour aristocracy. Those that remained voted to support the SPC programme and to study the principles of communism in all constituent unions.20 In December 1907, the Alberta TLC executive held a similar convention to found a labour party. The convention resulted in the endorsement of the SPC programme and the founding of new SPC locals rather than a new separate labour party.21 In both of these cases, the SPC intervened in the movement to set up a right-wing labour party, took leadership, and led it to instead build greater unity around communism.
From 1907 until the end of World War One, several more provincial labour parties would be founded and dissolved. These were often supported by the right-opportunist Social-Democratic Party of Canada and opposed by the SPC.
In 1917, 1918, and 1920, the TLC again attempted to form a federal labour party.22 At the 1917 TLC congress, a resolution passed to form a labour party based on the British Labour Party-model made up of trade unionists, socialists, Fabians, co-operators, and farmers.23 This was partially a win for the right-wing based in the Ontario labour movement who opposed mobilising the masses’ anger against the state that had grown to a fever-pitch in the war. Instead, they supported organising for parliamentary intervention.24 The left, which was centred in BC, supported a combination of mass mobilisation and parliamentary action.25
Despite being founded by the TLC, the TLC stepped back from the CLP after its creation in order to maintain political independence.26 This was a confusion of the idea of political independence from independent action by the working-class into total independence even from the supposed party of the class. The CLP operated in a decentralised way on a provincial basis until mid-1921 when the CLP was founded nationally.27
It was in this context that a major two-line struggle emerged in the communist movement between Bolshevism (Marxism-Lenin Thought), and opportunism. The opportunists had an open form in possibilism which was basically social-democracy and an ultra-“left” form in impossibilism or dogmatism. The possibilists largely liquidated into the labour parties. The Bolsheviks combined into the communist party founded in 1919, refounded in 1921, or the Workers’ Party of Canada which acted was their legal front. The impossibilists largely joined the Bolsheviks, although a small set became modern social-democrats alongside the possibilists.
Initially all Bolsheviks denounced the CLP as reactionary and refused participation. This was in line with the generally “left-”opportunist attitude of the early Canadian Bolsheviks, who also largely rejected participation in elections or reactionary unions. It was this general line that led outgoing president of the Ontario CLP and communist leader Jack MacDonald to call for the dissolution of the CLP at the 1921 provincial convention.28
On December 22 1921, the Workers Party of Canada held a provisional conference where they declared against the CLP and labour parties generally.29 Over the next several months, the communist movement began to correct its opportunist approach to other worker organisations including the labour parties. In the May 1922 Manitoba elections, the WPC proposed a joint list of candidates among the labour parties, the SPC, and the WPC, however this was rejected.30 In July 1922, the WPC resolved that the party could affiliate to the CLP as long as independence and freedom of criticism were maintained.31
While adopting this position of unity in action among the working-class, the communists regularly exposed how the labour parties in government ended up tailing the larger farmer parties.32
Jack MacDonald addressed the Nova Scotia ILP convention in July 1922 as a representative of the WPC.33 The convention resolved to advise all member branches to become WPC branches while keeping ties to the ILP.34
The 1922 CLP convention was held just after the WPC founding convention.35 Jack MacDonald presented the WPC programme to the CLP convention which said it would discuss affiliation.36 Affiliation of the WPC/CPC to the provincial parties of the CLP was complete by 1924.37
On September 25 1922, the WPC central executive committee issued a letter to the membership explaining they were pushing forward with affiliation to the CLP as part of the overall effort to build the workers united front.38 By boring within the CLP, the CPC/WPC were able to win the CLP to several positions and neutralise the right in others.39
By the time affiliation was completed, the right of the CLP began a campaign to purge the CPC.40 In November 1925, the Quebec branch purged the communists.41 Communists rallied the other branches to call for the Quebec branch to reverse the motion.42 At the September 1926 Quebec CLP convention, pro-communists called for the expulsion of the CPC to be reversed, but this was rejected.43 The Ontario provincial convention in April 1926 considered a motion to ban the communists which also failed.44
The right found themselves unable to purge the communists from the party, leading to the right of the Ontario CLP calling for the formation of a new Independent Labour Party (ILP).45 The TLC left the CLP and joined the new ILP.46 This split was in part due to the returning influence of Gomperism in the TLC post-WW1 which was opposed to independent political action generally, but especially communism.47 The CLP resolved to dissolve as following the split, the remaining membership had been won to communism and could be directly integrated into the party.48
Labour parties diminished in importance following the split in the CLP. This changed in 1932 with the launch of the Canadian Commonwealth Federation (CCF). This new party was social-democratic and founded by the unification of right-wing social-democratic organisations, labour parties, farmer organisations, Trotskyists, among others. It emerged in the middle of the great depression in response to the economic conditions and to counter the successful mass work of the CPC. The CCF was part of the general rise of fascism in Canada at the time alongside the Mackenzie-King’s faction of the Liberal Party, the social-credit movement, and especially Union nationale in Quebec.
The response of the CPC to the CCF was initially one of sectarianism where the party treated everyone from top leadership down to the rank-and-file as a committed social-fascist. The CPC corrected this position to one where it fought for a united front from below with CCF locals while struggling against the CCF as a whole. The CPC would often call on the CCF to join in a communist initiative that whether they declined or accepted was used to build the united front from below. The CPC would either make known to the workers that the CCF refused cooperation or if they accepted cooperation they would use it as an opportunity to struggle toward higher unity. In either case the party always used the united front from above to support its construction from below.
In the late 1930s onward, the CPC became nothing more than a tail of the CCF.
Contemporary
The CCF had a very close relationship with the labour movement. Many major leaders in the labour movement were big wigs in the CCF and vice versa. However, it was never a labour party. The CCF was principally a farmers’ party. In the early 1960s, the CLC and the CCF resolved to unite to form a new labour party which became the New Democratic Party. On paper, the NDP like the CCF was a socialist party, in reality it was a right-wing social-democratic party. The NDP platform was also a further liquidation from the original CCF platform. Following this merger, the NDP, labour party, and social-democracy effectively became synonyms in all electoral politics outside Quebec.
The CPC ran a left wing caucus in the CCF and NDP for many years. It was out of the security club the CPC formed in the CCF/NDP, that Jack Scott’s red fraction first emerged. Following its purge, the red fraction united into the Progressive Workers Movement (PWM). The PWM maintained activity in the NDP at this time as it was party with genuine mass participation of workers. However, many of its members were quickly expelled.
At the same time, the PWM ran a single candidate in the 1966 election against an NDP incumbent. The PWM used the election to highlight increasingly reactionary role of the NDP.49
The NDP has only moved more and more away from the working-class in order to succeed in parliament by courting the bourgeoisie. In a modern NDP election programme you can find almost as much meant to appeal to the small business owner as the worker and poor farmer. This decay of the NDP culminated in their 2013 convention where socialism was officially dropped from the constitution.50
This decay of the NDP has seen many among the progressive petite-bourgeoisie form new organisations with the intention to either unite the left of the NDP to correct its course or to establish a new social-democratic party. In almost every single case, these organisations have not done so by trying to rebuild a labour party or reconstitute the communist party. Instead they have latched on to some social-issue and tried to create a pan-class social-democratic party.
In the 1960s and early 1970s, the demand for a labour party became especially loud in Quebec where the NDP never took off. It was in this context that Charles Gagnon and the Newspaper Team published For the Proletarian Party. In this document, they demarcated the communist party from all other forms of “worker party” being proposed at the time. Instead, they put forward a clear line on the necessity of a communist party and socialist revolution. It was on the basis of what was laid out in this book that the Newspaper team would found In Struggle. Since the liquidation of the Communist Party of Canada in 1943, no other communist organisation has contributed as much to the application of Marxism to Canada.
In Quebec, the Parti Quebecois was formed through the co-option of the majority of the the progressive nationalist movement in Quebec. The PQ was established on the basis of a more petite-bourgeois social-democracy than the NDP although still with large support from the labour movement. However, on election the PQ immediately dropped social-democracy in practice and initiated a large-scale austerity campaign. Its unofficial federal wing, the BQ remains more committed to social-democracy than the provincial wing. However, for both the PQ and the PQ they aim to form a broad tent for secular nationalists with a wide variety of ideological and political lines present inside. Today, the “left” of the nationalist movement is mainly represented by QS which is very similar to the NDP even if it is superficially more “radical”.
Collapse
Social-democracy is collapsing in English Canada, but not yet in Quebec. In Quebec the state itself is structured in a social-democratic way. There has been very little change to the structure of the Quebecois state following Duplessis. Secularism was introduced, but the state took on the corprativsist role previously mediated through the church.
In English Canada, this collapse has been characterised by an increasingly tense relationship between the NDP and the labour movement. A secondary important contradiction informing this relationship is the relationship between the petite-bourgeoisie and the NDP.
Union Bureaucracy – NDP
There is an increasing break between the bureaucracy of the unions and the NDP. The most severe break here was followed the Unifor-CLC split. Unifor, who represented NDP staffers, refused to give unconditional support to the NDP. In response the CLC raided these union shops.51
The NDP has been unable to confine this split to Unifor. A key example of this was the aftermath of the BC Federation of Labour convention in 2022 when the convention resolved to demand for fifteen paid sick days in the province.52 The NDP government refused to carry out this demand despite 1) on paper being the political arm of the CLC and 2) the the large degree of overlap between the bureaucracy and leadership of those making the demands and those in the leadership of the NDP.
It is clear that the union bureaucracy are increasingly seeing that the NDP’s main concern is courting the salaried petite-bourgeoisie and even the small business owner.
In response to this, a trend has emerged seen in both the Alberta NDP and the federal NDP leadership races of senior union bureaucrats fighting to retake the party as a labour party. In Alberta this was seen in Gil McGowan.53 Federally, this has been seen with Rob Ashton.54 It is worth noting that in both cases, their campaigns have regularly acknowledged they are on the back foot trying to retake control.
Labour Aristocracy – NDP
While there is considerable public tension between union bureaucrats and the NDP, there has yet to be a final break. The same is not true among the labour aristocracy. This section of the class is made up of those workers who are 1) highly skilled, 2) mainly work in monopolies, and 3) have a lower rate of exploitation than the social-average. Unions that represent the labour aristocracy have largely broken with the NDP at election time. Instead of automatically supporting the NDP, they have taken an independent position where they bargain with each party to see which will promise the most to their specific trade. One of the best examples of this was in the recent Ontario provincial election in which a large number of unions defected from the NDP to full support of the Progressive Conservatives.55
The Proletariat – NDP
The class as a whole has been increasingly disenchanted with the NDP. The dramatic split of the labour aristocracy and the petty fighting of party and union bureaucrats is following the split that the majority of the class has long since made with the NDP. This is because the NDP has never represented the class interests of the NDP, only the upper crust. Now that it is breaking with even this upper crust, they are following the lower strata in looking for alternatives.
Petite-bourgeoisie – NDP
In the NDP’s electoral appeal, they have moved from a basis among the working-class to a new social base among the petite-bourgeoisie, especially the salaried public sector petite-bourgeoisie. This is a result of 1) the salarisation of much of the lower petite-bourgeoisie bringing petite-bourgeois ideas into the workers movement; 2) the transformation of social-democracy from a movement based in the workers movement to one based in vaguely progressive movements; and 3) the opportunism of the NDP who in seeking to broaden their electability have embraced more more liberal positions. Today, when you ask a worker their opinion on the NDP, you will struggle to find a supporter. When you ask the petite-bourgeoisie, they will often shame anyone who would think of any action other than support.
Next Steps
The appeal of social-democracy has dropped both in the unions and at the polls. Unless some major change occurs, the NDP will continue to lose its influence among the proletariat. This crisis of social-democracy presents an opportunity to fill this vacuum and raise the workers from their natural social-democratic outlook toward class consciousness.
Especially with the tension between the union bureaucracy and the NDP, there is a chance that a new labour party could form. Already many unions have broken with the NDP and taken up a barter-approach with the bourgeois parties where they pledge to support whatever party pledges to support workers in that union. The Alberta Federation of Labour is currently at the forefront of this movement. They recently launched a new initiative – Worker Agenda, which aims to organise workers for independent political action through the new reforms to provincial referendum law. This initiative explains:
“Albertans need their elected leaders — UCP, NDP and independents — to focus on things that matter to ordinary working people.”56
While the AFL and other unions are organising outside of the NDP, we cannot idealise this movement. At the moment, this movement which would naturally conclude with a new party is coming entirely from above. There is no rank-and-file movement for a new labour party. Unless this changes, communists should oppose the push for a new labour party as simply a movement by the union bureaucracy to serve their own ends.
However, if the movement for a labour party becomes a mass demand, then we must join the fight for this labour party. This is for the exact same reason that we fight in the union movement. It is where the masses are actively involved in class struggle. In such a labour party, our approach must be the same as that in the unions. We must expose those misleading our movement, social democracy, the limitations of the labour party, and explain the need for a communist party.
In the movement for a labour party, we must learn from the way the SPC engaged in the Alberta and BC efforts to establish a labour party and the WPC/CPC’s engagement with the ILP and CLP. We will act within these parties as a red fraction to unite the most advanced and militarise it as a communist party.
Labour parties cannot be seen as an end. They are a means through which communists can agitate and organise workers.
- https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/20/strategy-and-tactics-of-the-workers-united-front/ ↩︎
- https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/25/report-on-the-condition-of-imperialism-and-the-workers-movement-in-canada/ ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/tag/ndp/ ↩︎
- https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/25/report-on-the-condition-of-imperialism-and-the-workers-movement-in-canada/ ↩︎
- https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1847/11/prin-com.htm ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/04/25/social-fascism-and-the-american-communist-party-by-daniel-h/ ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/02/14/repost-questions-regarding-the-ncpcs-programme/ ↩︎
- https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/bernstein/works/1899/evsoc/ch04-conc.htm ↩︎
- Lipton, Charles The Trade Union Movement of Canada 1827 – 1959 ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Communist Party of Canada Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Morden, Lazarus Years of Hard Labour ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- The Marxian Socialist Tradition in British Columbia – Ross Alfred Johnson ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- Ibid. ↩︎
- The Marxian Socialist Tradition in British Columbia – Ross Alfred Johnson and Martime Radical – Nicholas Filmore ↩︎
- McCormack, A. Ross Reformers, Rebels, and Revolutionaries and Canadian Socialism and the Origin of the Communist Party of Canada, 1900-1922 – Adam Tadeusz Kawecki ↩︎
- Soldiers of the International – Rodney ↩︎
- Lazarus Morden, Years of Hard Labour, Canadian Bolsheviks – Ian Angus and Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Lazarus Morden, Years of Hard Labour ↩︎
- Canadian Bolsheviks – Ian Angus and Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Canadian Socialism and the Origin of the Communist Party of Canada, 1900-1922 – Adam Tadeusz Kawecki ↩︎
- Canadian Bolsheviks – Ian Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Canadian Socialism and the Origin of the Communist Party of Canada, 1900-1922 – Adam Tadeusz Kawecki ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Angus ↩︎
- Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Angus, Buck, and The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic ↩︎
- The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic ↩︎
- The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic and Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Buck and The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic ↩︎
- The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic ↩︎
- The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic ↩︎
- The Communist Party of Canada – Ivan Avakumovic and Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- Canadian Socialism and the Origin of the Communist Party of Canada, 1900-1922 – Adam Tadeusz Kawecki ↩︎
- Canada’s Party of Socialism: History of the Communist Party of Canada 1921-1976 ↩︎
- https://www.marxists.org/history//erol/ca.firstwave/fedelection.htm ↩︎
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/ndp-votes-to-take-socialism-out-of-party-constitution-1.1385171 ↩︎
- https://www.cbc.ca/news/politics/federal-ndp-staffers-split-with-union-that-urged-strategic-voting-in-ontario-1.2695202 ↩︎
- https://thetyee.ca/News/2022/12/02/Labour-Paid-Sick-Leave-15-Days-Province-Hesitant ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/06/15/ndp-alberta-leadership-election-daniel-h/ ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/12/05/ilwu-canada-president-enters-ndp-leadership-race-by-daniel-h/ ↩︎
- https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/03/21/the-ontario-election-and-growing-division-in-the-labour-movement-by-daniel-h/ ↩︎
- https://workeragenda.ca/about-us/ ↩︎