The following article is a repost from the Workers’ United Front website. The original can be found here. We encourage our readers to also submit their criticisms on articles published on the People’s Hammer.
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
The following is a criticism sent to the Central Committee of the Construction Workers Industrial Organisation by a member of the Workers United Front. CWIO members reviewed it and agreed with it. It is now being published to further the debate on this question.
Please send responses to: peopleshammer-editors@proton.me
Criticism of the Report on Conditions in the Construction Industry1
In Section 4: “Systemic Issues in Construction”, you have correctly identified homophobia and transphobia as two forms of oppression that exist in the construction industry. However, I disagree with your use of the term “LGBT+” to describe workers who are oppressed by homophobia and transphobia.
Although widespread and officially recognised, the term “LGBT” and its many derivatives are unscientific and bourgeois. This is because they attempt to unite various eclectic sexual and gender identities, regardless of whether or not they are oppressed by the state. This kind of identitarian terminology is usually adopted by the petit-bourgeois, because they are isolated from the class struggle and are thus only exposed to identity struggles. Because identity does not have a material basis in social relations of production, the number of subjective identities people adopt continues to grow. To adapt to this, the term “LGBT” is endlessly amended to include new identities ad nauseam (“LGBTQIAP2S+”). Within the gay and trans movement, many liberal activists busy themselves debating which identites should be included, what the new abbreviation should look like, or how to cram more symbols into the Pride flag to make it even more “inclusive”. Because you can adopt whatever identity you want, you could be a de facto cisgender heterosexual person and call yourself a member of the “LGBT” community, because you have so-and-so sexual and/or gender identity. This confusion serves to distract the masses from the class struggle by keeping them busy with petty identity struggles. It also takes the agency away from actually-oppressed gay and trans workers by watering down their movement with non-oppressed people who just chose to adopt a particular identity. At this point, the term “LGBT” has no concrete meaning, and anyone can interpret it however they want. We must use specific terminology to delineate our position on the gay and trans question, and ensure it cannot be interpreted in any other subjective way.
There are infinitely many groups of people in society. For the purposes of Marxist analysis of society, we should only concern ourselves with groups that emerge as a result of material social relations of production, and not with identity labels that were imagined out of subjective feelings of individuals. How should we then refer to people who are opressed by the very material homophobia and transphobia? People who are affected by homophobia are, simply, gay (this includes homosexual men and women), whereas people affected by transphobia are trans (not “transgender”) . So, if I were to suggest a new term to use in your article, I would use “gay and trans workers”. Why not lesbian? There is no qualitative difference between the oppression faced by homosexual men and homosexual women, so why would homosexual women require a distinct name? Many homosexual women already call themselves “gay women”. Why not bisexual? Bisexuals have a dual character where they can chose between entering homosexual and heterosexual relationships. When bisexuals are oppressed, it is because of their homosexual character, and not because they face a unique form of oppression. If there were no homophobia, bisexuals would not be oppressed. Any other sexual or gender identity that may claim to be part of the “LGBT” does not have a material basis in social relations of production, and only exists as long as there are enough people willing to adopt that identity. They do not face unique forms of oppression, and thus do not need to be recognised on the same level as gay and trans people. Your choice to include the “plus” symbol in “LGBT” implies that you are extending the same recognition to every single sexual and gender identity that may want to jump on the bandwagon.