The People's Hammer

Tenants Are Not a Class – by Daniel H



The division of Gonzalo Thought from the proletarian vanguard is the principal contradiction in the communist movement today. Until this contradiction is resolved in the form of a militarised communist party, there will remain a large organised set of communists engaged in spontaneous actions, tailism of the labour bureaucrats, and focusing on secondary sites of struggle. Often this is done in the name of resolving this contradiction.

One of the main ways this manifests is the move toward tenant organising among communists. Often this is justified on the grounds of de-industrialisation, lack of unions, etc. These are nothing more than excuses to participate only on the margins of class struggle rather than at its centre. Canada remains an industrialised country. If there are less workers in industry today than in the past, this is not because of “de-industrialisation”.1 It is due to the development of industry in Canada to the point where fewer and fewer hands are needed. Still, industry can be found in every city coast-to-coast-to-coast.

It is undeniable that unions in Canada have shrunk and today much of their membership is pulled from the petite-bourgeoisie. Regardless, the workers being on the back foot is not an excuse to abstain from fighting in the labour movement. In fact, the retreat of union membership presents a great opportunity for communists to intervene in union drives to show the shortcomings of trade unions and demarcate communism from trade unionism.

There is a set of more principled communists who recognise these excuses have no merit, yet still focus on the tenants movement. The reasons given by this set of communists is that tenant organising provides a way to make contact with workers where they live which can later lead to intervention at the point of production. To these communists, tenant organising is a road to organising in the workplace. This set is generally composed of petite-bourgeois communists who do not see a direct path to communist agitation at the workplace due their separation from socialised production.

Since the beginning of the 2020s, the idea of a “tenant class” has risen to prominence among the “left’. This idea is usually put forward by communists and anarchists attempting to legitimise their work in the tenants movement and present it as a key site of class struggle. This concept acts to justify this petite-bourgeois approach to tenant organising by giving it a shiny coat of Marxist paint. One of the main books circulating in the Canadian tenants’ movement detailing this concept is The Tenant Class by Ricardo Tranjan. Tranjan elaborates the two most common explanations of how tenants and landlords are classes which this article will deal with.

Feudal Versus Modern Tenants and Landlords

Several times in his book, Tranjan portrays the agricultural tenant-landlord contradiction as the same as the housing question.2 Tranjan is far from the only one to make this comparison. Communist housing activists love to make jokes like “what’s more Maoist than fighting landlords?”

It is a shame that the same words “tenant”, “landlord”, “rent” are all used to describe two very different relationships – one productive and one distributive. When used in an agricultural setting, these words refer to the exploitation of a class of tenants by a class of landlords through the collection of surplus-value in the form of rent. This develops and takes different forms including labour-rent, rent-in-kind, and finally money-rent.3

These three terms in their contemporary usage refers to the owner of a commodity (the landlord) selling access to the commodity to a consumer (the tenant) on an ongoing basis in the form of rent or a periodical payment. The productive nature of the relationship between the feudal landlord and tenant is what allows us to define these as classes.

While these three terms read and sound identical, they need to be treated as homophones not synonyms as the relationships they describe could not be further apart.

Exploitation

Tranjan attempts to show that tenants are exploited by their landlords. Here, he draws a comparison to the capitalist who wants to leverage the exchange of labour-power for a wage most heavily in their favour. When it comes to housing, Tranjan defines the exploitation of the tenant as the tenant overspending on rent relative to the actual value contained due to having no other options.

If overspending due to the leverage of scarcity can form the basis of exploitation, why stop at landlords? Are shoppers exploited by the big grocery oligarchy because they can fix the price of bread? Are we exploited by the financial oligarchy given that there are only a handful of banks to choose from allowing them to leverage higher fees? Are we exploited by Microsoft for having to purchase a subscription to Office rather than a one-time purchase of the app itself? Does the labour aristocrat exploit the bourgeoisie by leveraging their skilled labour for a higher rate?

Ownership and sale of a scarce commodity does not mean exploitation. Exploitation does not exist outside of a productive relationship. An exploited class is one that labours for the private accumulation of another. In this labour there is both necessary and surplus labour. While the member of the exploited class is reimbursed for their necessary labour, the value produced by their surplus-labour goes to the pockets of the exploiting class. For the slave, the necessary labour is reimbursed directly in the form of food and shelter provided by their owner. For the peasant, it is in the form of the portion of their crop not taken by the landlord as rent. For the worker, it is in the form of their wage.

Their is no equivalent relationship between the landlord and tenant today. Tranjan even recognises this to be the case. In his book he explains that he is liquidating the idea of class in order to make it fit the landlord-tenant relationship.

Conclusion

Tenants are not a class. They form a broad social group similar to a sex, a nationality, or a sexuality. They do not become a class simply because they are named one. Like these other cross-class groups, they are not united by their productive relations. Instead, they are united by some set of social relations. While related, these categories are distinct. The only characteristic that all tenants share is that they do not own their home and pay on a continuing basis for housing. What unites landlords is their ownership of excess real estate which they let out on a continuing basis. We can say that workers tend to be tenants and landlords tend to be bourgeois, however, even this is far from exact.

The tenant-landlord relationship takes place in consumption not production. While tenant unions may take up a number of union tactics, they are in essence consumer rights organisations. This should not be interpreted as a dismissal of the importance of work in the tenants’ movement. It is instead to lift the vague veil of class struggle that it has been dressed in. By doing so, we can properly understand its place. We must keep in mind what the Communist Party of Peru stated, “Mass work is done within the class struggle and not on its margins.”4. Our struggle to reconstitute the Communist Party of Canada cannot take place mainly in the point of consumption even in as vital an area of consumption as housing. It must take place in the point of production where class struggle is currently sharpest.

Important interventions can be made at the point of consumption, but we must be honest with the forces we have. They are very very very small. We do not have a party of tens of thousands that can be dispersed across many different classes and strata of society. We must plan carefully beginning from the concrete reality of a tiny set of organised communists in Canada. This means concentrating our forces where they will be most important for resolving the principal contradiction in the contemporary communist movement: the isolation of the communist movement from the advanced workers. This can only be done in the workplace.

Within the labour movement we must prioritise industry (especially heavy industry) over other workplaces. These workers are the most openly robbed, the most disciplined, and are formed in the most advanced form of capitalist production – the assembly line. Logistics, retail, agriculture, construction, and restaurants must all act as secondary sites for our mass work.

There is no substitution or secret path to resolving the proletarian vanguard-communism contradiction. Only by intervening in the workers’ daily struggles at the point of production will we be able to rally the advanced workers to communism and forge our party. The jump to this style of work is often difficult and will lead to a communist group losing many of its petite bourgeois-minded elements along the way. But what they will gain are proletarian communists and a genuine advance toward the party.

1. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/05/09/oshawa-general-motors-layoffs-and-the-myth-of-deindustrialization-by-cliff-z/

2. Tranjan, Ricardo. The Tenant Class. Pg.67-70

3. https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1894-c3/ch47.htm

4. https://gplpcp.wordpress.com/mass-line/


Response to “Tenants Are Not a Class – by Daniel H”

  1. Myron Manor Flash Rally October 3rd – By Bessy – The People's Hammer

    […] iihttps://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/06/12/tenants-are-not-a-class-by-daniel-h / […]

    Like