Across the BC building trades, workers are constantly told the same story: strikes don’t work anymore. We are told that strikes drag on forever, that members lose more money than they ever gain back, and that the safest path is to accept whatever deal the contractors put forward. In some unions, this line has been repeated so many times that workers have begun to see striking itself as the problem.
SMART 280 members have heard this for years. Older members and union officials frequently point to a long strike the union went through in the 1980s as proof that strikes are a disaster. The lesson workers are expected to take away is simple: do not fight, fighting is too dangerous. But this turns history upside down. The issue was never that workers fought . The issue always was how the strike was led, organized, and strategized.
A recent dispute involving SMART Local 280 workers at Ecco Heating Products Ltd. demonstrates this clearly, when in March 2026 the company rejected a proposed collective agreement time and time again. As a result the union had to break a long-standing bragging point of theirs that labour relations have been so “good” that they have not had to strike since the ‘80s, as workers at Ecco voted in favour of a strike. Several dozen workers walked off the job, putting down their tools for sheet metal and picking up the tool of the strike. Yet instead of dragging on for months, the strike only lasted a single day after the workers gathered strong and students from local trade schools joined the picket lines in solidarity. Ecco quickly moved to settle once it became clear the dispute risked expanding beyond a small isolated workplace issue between boss and employer.
This is the exact opposite of the lesson many workers are taught. The strike succeeded precisely because workers moved aggressively, mobilized solidarity, and created immediate pressure. The issue was not striking itself, but strategy. A strike that disrupts production rapidly and threatens broader solidarity can force employers to retreat quickly. A weakly organized strike that is isolated and demobilized will naturally drag on.
As the workers at Ecco have shown, the weapon of the strike is far from outdated. Yet this is effectively the logic workers are constantly fed regarding strikes. When a strike fails due to poor leadership, weak preparation, or passive strategy, workers are often told by various unions that the problem was militancy itself rather than the people directing it. That the union doesn’t want to lose the “positive relationship” it has with the boss. However, it is important workers continue to understand the importance of the strike. A strike is the main weapon workers possess against their boss in this period because it attacks the source of capitalist profit directly: labour power. Contractors make money from workers producing value. The moment workers collectively withhold that labour, the flow of profit is interrupted. It is also worth pointing out that if strikes were truly useless, governments and employers would not spend so much time trying to restrict them. The existence of anti-strike laws alone proves their effectiveness.
In BC and across Canada, the right to strike is constantly being narrowed through legislation, court injunctions, back-to-work laws, and “essential service” designations. Under the BC Labour Relations Code, there is a whole section dedicated to “no-strike and no-lockout” clauses during the term of collective agreements given how prevelent they are.[1] In construction, entire unions write off the tactic with such clauses, such as the United Association who has this promised in their industry wide collective agreements.[2] The entire labour relations framework in Canada is built around controlling and containing worker militancy, not empowering it.
The construction industry has become a laboratory for “labour stability.” The BC Infrastructure Benefits system openly advertises its “no-strike, no-lockout clause” as a selling point for contractors and major projects.[3] Think about what this means. Employers and the state celebrate the removal of workers’ strike power as an economic advantage. That alone should expose the lie that strikes are useless. The bosses clearly understand the power of strikes better than many union officials do. What workers are really being taught is not that strikes fail, but that workers should fear exercising power independently. This view leads directly to concessionary bargaining. Workers are pressured into accepting weak contracts because they are told any real struggle would be worse. Over time, this creates increasingly passive unions whose primary function becomes managing labour peace for contractors rather than organizing class struggle.
As workers from SMART 280 recently pointed out, many problems in the BC Building Trades stem from a growing disconnect between union leadership and rank-and-file workers.[4] A union bureaucracy that fears disruption will always frame militancy as irresponsible, even while contractors aggressively pursue their own interests. But history shows something different. Workers have repeatedly won major gains through decisive strike action. Short, aggressive, well-organized strikes have often succeeded precisely because they created maximum disruption quickly. Employers settle when the cost of continued disruption outweighs the cost of conceding.
The issue is not striking itself. The issue is strike strategy. Too often, strikes are treated as symbolic pressure tactics rather than real economic warfare. Union leaders enter disputes planning to minimize disruption instead of maximizing worker leverage. They limit picketing, discourage solidarity actions, isolate bargaining units, and rely entirely on mediators and labour boards. Then, when the strike produces limited gains, they claim the lesson is that strikes do not work. But workers cannot negotiate effectively without the credible threat of shutting production down.
The World United Front has repeatedly argued that labour militancy is inseparable from rebuilding the unions as genuine defense organisations of the working-class. Likewise, People’s Hammer has emphasized that the labour movement declines when unions abandon class struggle in favour of bureaucratic management and partnership with employers.[5] The reality is simple: every major gain workers possess today exists because workers fought for them. Not because employers were generous. Not because labour boards intervened. And certainly not because workers accepted sell-out agreements in the name of “stability.”
Construction workers especially hold enormous potential leverage. Entire projects worth billions depend on labour being performed continuously and on schedule. Delays cost contractors and developers massive amounts of money. The problem is not that workers lack will, nor that strikes inherently will lead workers to lose. The problem is that the strongest tactics workers currently have are often deliberately underused. Workers should reject the idea that strikes are outdated. The question is not whether strikes are bad for workers. The question is whether unions are prepared to organize strikes capable of winning.
At the same time, workers should understand that the strike is not an end in itself. Even the most successful strike leaves workers returning to workplaces still owned and controlled by employers. The importance of strike action extends beyond immediate economic gains. Every strike teaches workers lessons that cannot be learned through speeches or labour board hearings. Workers learn who stands with them and who stands against them. They learn the value of solidarity, collective discipline, democratic organization, and their own capacity to challenge the power of employers. In this sense, strike struggles become a school of class struggle, transforming workers from isolated individuals negotiating over wages into a conscious force capable of fighting for broader social change. The struggle for better contracts remains necessary, but workers must understand the deeper significance of these battles lies in preparing the working class to organize itself as an independent political force capable of challenging the system that exploits them, otherwise leave themselves in a losing battle of fighting for scraps. The strike is therefore not the final goal of the workers’ movement, but one of its most important training grounds for the future of a socialist Canada.
Footnotes
[1] British Columbia Labour Relations Code, RSBC 1996, c. 244, sections governing no-strike and no-lockout provisions during collective agreements.
https://www.bclaws.gov.bc.ca/civix/document/id/complete/statreg/96244_01
[3] BC Infrastructure Benefits Inc., union and labour relations framework outlining project labour agreements containing no-strike and no-lockout provisions.
https://bcib.ca/unions/
[4] Workers United Front, “SMART Local 280: A Union for Who?”
https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/05/17/smart-local-280-a-union-for-who/
[5] People’s Hammer, various labour movement and class struggle articles emphasizing militancy, anti-concessionary bargaining, and strike action as central working-class tactics.
https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/01/16/a-shattered-mirror-the-disintegration-of-canadas-construction-unions-and-the-need-for-industrial-organisation-by-workers-united-front/