The People's Hammer

Interview with a Supply Teacher – by Alice S.

, ,


Alice: What do you do for a living?

Teacher: I work as a high school supply teacher for the Toronto District School Board (TDSB). I have been working for the TDSB since September of 2025. This school year (2025-2026) has been my first full school year with the board and I intend to work with them into the next year and future years.

Alice: What is your average workday like?

Teacher: I will usually get a call either the night before or the morning of and be informed by the automated dispatch service that a supply position is available at a particular school. If I like the school or the subject I’m expected to teach, I accept it and based on when I accept it I will go to bed immediately or get ready immediately that morning and go to that location to teach. As you make yourself known to teachers and admin staff, they will reach out to you personally and book you well in advance which is much easier. In either case, my lesson plan usually will be made available to me either via email when I’m on my way, or the office staff will give it to me when I arrive. I will teach as it is explained to me in the lesson plan that the teacher left behind. I teach three classes a day, every day. If I am working a half-day I teach only two.

Occasionally I will have to fulfill what is known as on-call coverage, where during the prep period (the time in which the full-time teacher has a class-length amount of time dedicated to preparing the materials for other classes) I will have to fill in for a half-period somewhere else in the building. This coverage happens every now and again. During that time if I don’t get an on-call, because I am a supply teacher and I’m not responsible for producing any materials, it is essentially like a second break. Outside of these three classes and the occasional on-call, I go home and that is it. Most TDSB high schools run from 9 in the morning to 3:15pm, with a lunch break running from 11:40am to 12:40pm. There are exceptions. I try to arrive at 8:30 and leave by 3:30.

Alice: How are your hours and wages, and how do they compare to full-time teachers?

Teacher: In terms of my wage, I make roughly $212 per day after taxes and deductions, which includes union dues and money which is put into the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan as well as the CPP. If I work a half day this is cut in half. I don’t get paid more or less depending on if I have on-calls to do. In terms of my weekly hours, because I am a supply teacher, if I don’t get a shift or I don’t take a shift I’m not penalised for it. I work basically as an on-call, which means I just take shifts as they’re either made available to me or as I want to take them. In terms of my conditions compared to other supply teachers who work in the private sector, I would say in general public sector supply teaching is better. Your employer is a lot more reliable and the pay is equivalent but generally a bit higher. I make a daily rate. I’m not paid by the hour. In terms of my pay as it relates to a contract teacher, it honestly depends. The way that the payment structure works for full-time teachers in the TDSB, or LTOs, which are long-term occasional teachers (these are the people who cover for a set or unset amount of time when the contracted teacher is injured, is on maternity leave, or an equivalent absence) those teachers are paid on a payment grid which increases over a ten year period. As I understand it, my daily rate right now would be higher than what a year 1 or a year 2 contract or LTO teacher makes based on the grid, but very soon after, once you start hitting year 3 and onward the pay for full-time or LTO becomes much greater than what you make as a supply.

Alice: What is the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan?

Teacher: The Ontario Teachers Pension Plan is a pension plan dedicated for public Ontario teachers. It’s something that you pay into. I believe you can opt out of it, but I don’t know what the procedure looks like for that. Everybody pays into it, whether you’re a supply or a full-timer. The pension plan is quite lucrative. I believe it pays out upwards of $40,000 a year or more once you hit your necessary years for it. It takes a long time to max it out; well over thirty years usually. It falls under some scrutiny from various political poles. In terms of what it actually is, though, it’s just a pension plan like any other. It just happens to be a very lucrative one. The Plan basically functions as a hedge fund and has billions of dollars in capital; the Plan is quite well off and is run like any stock holdings company.

Alice: What kind of criticism do they receive?

Teacher: I remember I attended a political event last fall and there was a group there which focused on divesting. They were a critical pension plan group made up of Ontario teachers. They called for the OTTP to divest from companies which supported the exploitation of Palestinians and the Palestinian genocide, but I thought that they were very near-sighted because they didn’t recognise that any company that the pension plan is going to back financially in terms of holding stock, or something like that, will support imperialism and the oppression of workers anywhere, so I thought it was a pretty dumb initative to be honest with you. It was total economism and would do nothing to help anyone let alone Palestinians. That’s one specific example that comes to mind.

Alice: If you wanted to become a contract teacher, would that opportunity be available for you?

Teacher: Yes, in general. For any supply teacher who’s looking to move into more full-time teaching, there are job postings that are made available online. Through word-of-mouth, however, if you have a good relationship with a school, they will let you know if you would be eligible for it and seek you out for it. From there you go through a standard interview process. Even though you’re hired by the TDSB, you do need to interview again for the position, whether that’s a short-term contract, like an LTO, or a full-time contract. These full-time positions are quite competitive. Principals, I think, have the final say on whether or not a person is hired. They conduct the interviews.

Alice: You mentioned being eligible: are there any criteria that are unique to becoming a contract teacher?

Teacher: Yes and no. It’s not very much different from when you apply to the TDSB. Of course, you need to be licenced by the Ontario College of Teachers (OCT) to teach publicly in the province. You need to have the required teachables or different qualifications that the position warrants. Beyond that you just need to be a good candidate. You should be able to successfully explain how your teaching vision works to bolster student knowledge acquisition and self-efficacy, how it connects to provincial educational policy documents, etc. If you can do that and articulate this in a meaningful way, and you have the qualifications for the role, chances are you’ll proabably get hired. It’s really not that different from being employed anywhere else, it’s just like an extra step. You are already hired by the board at that point but to get a contract position you functionally need to be hired again.

Alice: Do you have to be a supply teacher first before becoming a contract teacher?

Teacher: Not necessarily, though in practice that is how it works. In terms of the TDSB’s structure, and I am fairly sure it’s like this for other boards, there is what’s known as the OT list and the ETH list. I’m on both lists. The OT list, the occasional teaching list, means you are eligible to receive shifts as a supply teacher with the board. The other list is what’s known as the eligible to hire list. That basically means that you are eligible to apply and be hired for LTO and full-time positions. In terms of being hired on one or the other, I’ll put it very simply: to be on the eligible to hire list you must be on the OT list, but you don’t need to be on the eligible to hire list to be on the OT list.

It’s very rare to get a full-time contract position straight out of college. Normally you have to work as a supply teacher for a couple of years to build up your resume and use that time to become more qualified, but it’s not impossible. When the school board is in crisis and they don’t have as many full-time teachers in their system as they need they might hire someone out of the gate. That’s rare, but it’s happening more frequently now. I know several people I graduated with that already have full contracts.

Alice: Aside from having a permanent position, are there any benefits to being a contract teacher as opposed to a supply teacher?

Teacher: Permanent teachers get extensive benefits all year round which include dental, health, massage, all kinds of stuff. OTs can opt into the OT plan but it is fairly expensive for pretty poor coverage. As a full-time teacher you get the security of working only in one building. As a supply teacher you may never know where you’re going to work on a day-to-day basis; it’s working in flux.

Alice: You mentioned paying union dues. What union are you in, and what is it like?

Teacher: So the union structure is a little bit confusing. The broad teaching union in Ontario is known as the Ontario Teacher’s Federation (OTF); it unionises all teachers in the public sector in the province. In terms of the structure within that, they have a couple of distinct sections. The section that I am in is the OSSTF, the Ontario Secondary School Teachers Federation. That’s the section which works specifically with high school teachers. Within that there is a specific subsection for supply teachers. The other three are the ETFO, OECTA, and AEFO, which oversee elementary, Catholic, and Francophone teachers respectively. They all fall under the umbrella of the Ontario Teachers Federation. In terms of the union overall, it’s a very petit-bourgeois [P.B.] union. It does an effective job of advocating economically on the behalf of teachers. In terms of political, in general I would say it’s negative: they don’t make any attempts to try and unionise teachers who aren’t in the public sector, they don’t have any dialogue as I’m aware with other unions to unionise non-education workers who work in schools such as janitors and other relevant staff. This is something that they absolutely should be doing. In that sense they are quite backwards, like most other unions in Canada.

Alice: Why do you think there is a necessity for these teachers unions to organise other non-teaching staff in schools?

Teacher: The OTF likes to pride itself as being a progressive union. I’m sure many people in the union believe that the OTF is doing its best to “advocate for workers’ rights.” Of course we have to recognise that teachers occupy a unique class position that is distinct from workers: they are petit-bourgeoisie. In general they own their own means of production, another aspect to this is that teachers generally only engage with mental labour, rather than manual labour. We could say that the teachers who work in tech, construction or auto, might not meet this specific criterion, but then again their role in production is entirely contained within the school rather than the general productive forces in Canada. Teachers don’t need to engage in socialised labour; they don’t have to work with other teachers to produce their lesson plans and to execute what they need to in the classroom. A lot of people are under the impression that because the teacher are unionised, because some are technically paid a wage, they’re workers like everybody else. This is not the case. They do occupy a distinct class position and the union centers itself around this highly specific P.B. work. In Canada what we need is a united front between all the progressive classes so that we can launch a front against imperialism. The unions may say in their words that they want to do this, but in action they are not moving forward. We ought to be very critical against the union and even some teachers. If we are not organizing everyone in the industry, we are making costly mistakes.

Alice: What are the means of production that the teachers own?

Teacher: Given that public education emerged in Canada alongside market capitalism, the division between mental and manual labour that existed in the workplace has been grafted in some ways onto education. In particular, I would say that specifically mental labour was relegated to education to promote higher study for academics, in line with the time that post-secondary institutions began to emerge in the country; the early 1800s. It is not in the interests of the education system to meaningfully develop class-consciousness in its students, nor to give them a fundamental understanding of how to produce and how to do so socially, because that impedes the extraction of surplus value the capitalists will receive from many students as they enter the workforce. So what you have is a contradiction in which students are not learning anything about the productive forces or their relations despite being, generally, amalgamated right into it following the completion (or dropping out) of school. This is deliberate. Because of this development there created a vacuum in which professionals needed to be developed on the basis of their mental labour only, to serve the public school system, itself divorced from production; hence the modern teacher. The teacher owns their capacity to perform mental labour. I might be wrong, and would be willing to be criticized, but this is how I understand it at this time. This would make teachers explicitly petite-bourgeois.

Any petit-bourgeois person owns their own means of production. What that means is they own more than their labour-power and they don’t have to sell their labour power for a wage. Teachers don’t need to sell their labour-power to the marketplace. While they are getting employed by a larger body, which pays them a wage or salary depending on if they’re supply or contract, any of these teachers are well within their capacity to work as private tutors and make a living that way. Many people do, and lots of people make more money this way than you would supplying, to say the very least. And this is because they own their own means. A worker can’t open, unless they have the capital for it, a private retail store. If they could, they would be at least P.B. if not more. Based on this characteristic, it’s quite evident to me that teachers occupy a class position that is different than that of workers. The particulars are just weird because it is relegated to principally mental labour. That doesn’t necessarily mean though that teachers are innately anti-worker or will undermine the workers struggle. But for us to be successful in toppling imperialism in Canada we need to align our interests as teachers with that of workers. We need workers to lead our struggle, and we need to assist that in whatever way we can.

Alice: Are there material benefits to going to a private school, tutoring, or even moving to another country to teach? Is this something that your coworkers discuss a lot?

Teacher: I wouldn’t know if my coworkers discuss it a lot. As a supply teacher sometimes you aren’t able to build excellent working relationships with teachers in the schools you go to simply because you’re in a different school often. As for when I was in teachers college, this was something that was raised very frequently with my colleagues. For teaching abroad the pay usually isn’t fantastic, but for many of these foreign teaching programs they give major stipends towards rent or provide free accomodations outright. The living conditions aren’t fantastic; you’re living out of a studio or shared accomodations usually. These programs target young people who are fresh out of university, so that’s really all that they would need. Though the pay isn’t great, far less than half of their paycheque is actually going towards for their living expenses. I believe in certain instances teachers also get some stipends for food, though I’m not sure of that.

In terms of going the private school route, pay is usually better at the high-high end; it takes a lot of careerism to get there. That’s appealing for some people, and so you might want to pursue private school for that. Private schools aren’t involved in the Ontario Teachers Pension Plan. That discourages a lot of people from going the private school route. There is also no union protection. In terms of their actual working conditions: classroom sizes are usually smaller, you aren’t subject to the curriculum requirements of the provincial government as you would be in the public board – that’s appealing to some people who really want to control the intellectual aspect of their teaching. The fact that it is deregulated can also be seen as a negative.

As for the private tutoring sector, you can set the rate at which you charge for your services. Some people charge as much as $100 an hour for tutoring at any level. You also are completely in charge of your own schedule, which is appealing for some people. This allows many people who tutor privately to also be hired by public boards to pursue other work. In terms of why someone might want to work in a public board, you do have fundamental union protection which is very important (the private and foreign sectors are scarcely unionized) you do have the pension plan, and in terms of a “moral aspect” I would say many teachers consider it to be the most honourable line of teaching work, whatever that’s worth to them.

Alice: What would you say are the demands of teachers? Would there be any difference between the demands of supply teachers and contract teachers?

Teacher: I’ll focus my answer specifically on how the working conditions between each may makes demands different. One of the things that makes it appealing for supply teachers to not go into a contract position right away is that you don’t take any work home. As a contracted teacher you are fully expected to have prepared all of your daily lesson plans, all of the grading, all of the conversations between parents and guardians – these are explicit responsibilities of a contract teacher. As a supply teacher you are there for the day and your job is to help execute lesson plans that the teachers have left behind in their absence and to do that to the best of your ability. Once the bell rings at the end of the day, you go home and you have nothing to do. It’s this aspect which makes teaching full-time seem very unappealing, because you’re not on the clock after 3:15 and yet you’re preparing lesson plans and materials for your students, sometimes for several hours when you get home. And so that’s a big problem. A lot of new full-time hires get burnt out, and it’s not unusual for someone to pursue an entirely different line of work after five years of contract teaching because the volume of work that you do is so immense.

I remember when I was in teacher’s college during my practicum block (that’s when you go into the school that you’re training at for several weeks straight) I would go and would teach all day which was unpaid. I would go home, I would lesson plan for the next day for about five to six hours, I would eat dinner, and then I would go to bed. That was my routine for over five weeks. It was exhausting. It created physical and mental problems, health problems, and this is not unusual for new teachers. It does get better, because you develop and reuse materials that stay with you years down the line. But when you’re a new teacher you don’t have that advantage, and it can be very difficult. Because most supply teachers do that work with the intent of moving into a contract position, I would say demands are generally similar: better pay, better facilities, lower classroom sizes, etc. Supply teachers due to their work are probably less adamant about struggling for these things.

This said, there are some demands which would be unique to supply teachers. I alluded earlier to the fact that when you develop positive relationships with staff and admin at a school they will book you in advance. They do this through a preffered list, where they keep the contact info of supply staff they really like and give them priority to the school with the automated dispatch service. The manner in which schools do this is highly secretive and there is no publicly available preffered list anywhere at any school, even internally. That’s a huge problem. Supply teachers do not receive parking passess for TDSB lots, and so may be refused parking in certain instances. If they commute by car, which many have to do because of how massive the range of the TDSB is, that can seriously ruin a morning and make a teacher late for no good reason. Teachers should also be reimbursed if no parking is available on-site. One demand I have seen the union put forward is what’s known as an Assigned Long Term Occasional Teacher. They describe this as “an LTO attached full-time to a school for daily coverages of teacher absences and paid at the LTO rate of pay.” This would be very proactive. Supply work does basically nothing to elevate your rate of pay; I think it moves you up the grid at 1/10th the rate of contract work. This raise course would only come into effect if you were to secure a contract: supply teachers again make a flat rate. Supply teachers do not get the opportunity for paid professional or training days. These are some examples that come to mind of supply demands that contract teachers wouldn’t have.

Alice: Would you say the unpaid training is an example of super-exploitation?

Teacher: Under capitalism I would say yes. You’re expected to go in to this building full-time and teach as you would if you were a full-time contracted teacher. Speaking from second-hand experience, there are many people who enter that program later in life who have already done a career and are interested in making a change. These are people who live on their own, sometimes who have families, and they’re expected to work unpaid for weeks at a time. Mind you, because they’re at the school for six hours or more a day, they’re not able to go into their jobs, their normal jobs outside of university. You also don’t get any tuition breaks even though you are putting in work functionally as an employee for a large body. I think that’s a problem. I don’t know what the solution is to this because you do need practical experience. I’m not saying that overall this is something that should be discontinued. But I think if the people were to own the means of education, so to speak, and education were more directly tied with production in general, that would work to solve a lot of these problems. In that situation I’m sure rent would be cheaper because housing would be collectively owned and administered by the masses. Food would be done the same and would be much cheaper. Therefore, even if weren’t able to work or you weren’t making any income during that period, at the very least you wouldn’t be so behind that month because stuff would be cheaper in general.

Alice: How do you think the taking work home aspect could be resolved?

Teacher: Because education is so divorced from production, that creates a lot of these problems where teachers have to produce a lot of material that generally is of little impact, or is isolated from what students will be doing in their day-to-day lives. Because of that, there is a lot of material that gets produced or that is needed to be produced to meet curriculum requirements that is of generally little impact on a student’s ability to articulate and develop their intelligence. That’s not to say that what we teach in Ontario isn’t important full stop, much of it is, but I think a lot of the things that we teach should be reconsidered. If we were to amalgamate education more with production, a lot of what students do in-house would be more directly related to the productive forces and their social relations in the country. Let’s say schools had partnerships with automotive factories or with a lumber mill, and students were safely able to contribute to that and be paid for it, and the schools kind of function as a channel into these industries, all of which would be under control of workers directly. Right there you solve two problems: the students aren’t alienated from production through school, which as we know happens generally in education in the province, in the country, and the world over; and as for the teachers it makes less work for them outside of their hours because a lot of what they’re doing is in line with what the industries are doing within their hours of operations. Of course it needs to be flushed out in more detail.

Another thing, because education has a fundamentally bourgeois character in the province, a major problem is that we prescribe an unhealthy amount of authority towards teachers, and generally treat the students as secondary. It emerges in the classroom that way: you could speak to any student in the province, and they would tell you they feel that way, whether or not their teachers are great. This is just a natural phenomenon that occurs due to the class character of education. One way we could eliminate this is if we involve students more directly in the development of lessons, the development of unit plans, the development of the general education schema in their schools. Of course, high schools will say the student councils that they have solve this. In my mind, they’re as politically effective as the big political parties of the country are for workers, you know, but that’s just my opinion. It is like an activity. It should be fun, but it should be of greater value too. Including students how I mentioned earlier not only reduces the amount of work that teachers have to do, but also allows the students to be the principal force of their learning. Of course teachers should be the leaders in the classrooms and they would need to scaffold this heavily, but who is to say students can’t be a driving force in their learning. Isn’t that what schools say they’re for? You eliminate the amount of intellectual work that the teacher has to do, and at the same time you are elevating the type of work that the student does, which directly promotes their self-efficacy as a learner. I think this is something that we should consider very seriously in the province and in the country. The fact that we don’t do this speaks to the fact that the state would see this as an affront to their public education, the flaws of which we have outlined in part. It would take a very long time to develop this and to make it sound, but I think the benefits would be immense.

Alice: You mentioned that education has a bourgeois character. What do you mean by this?

Teacher: I will reiterate on what I spoke about earlier. Western pedagogy has developed very little since the times of the industrial revolution in the mid-1800s. You go in at a specific time, have a break at a certain time, you leave at a certain time, you receive direct instruction from your educator who generally functions as your boss. You are simultaneously divorced from production and yet at the same time through this education system students are generally being funnelled into the workforce at the lowest rungs. Sure there are co-ops, but they are not mandatory. The content of learning has changed, but the essence of learning not so much. Maybe you could say rote learning is a thing of the past, or something. Graduation rates in the province are stagnating, usually. If not they’re going down. Literacy rates are not improving. We’re seeing the increased digitisation of learning in the classroom, which coinsides with this massive centralisation of capital in major tech and AI companies. I don’t think that that’s a coincidence. Of course, that’s a particular manifestation of a general problem. We are at a very, very, very antagonistic time in education in this province, which I think reflects broad world antagonisms between imperialist powers. I don’t think that that’s coincidence. What goes on in the classroom generally reflects the class character of society and its ensuing antagonisms in the same way it would on a jobsite. There is another aspect to this problem that I think should be mentioned in this interview: that is the increase of post-modernist thought in education, which I think is a huge problem, and is creating a pocket in education that is expanding.

Alice: Is there room for authority in education?

Teacher: Absolutely there is. I think authority emerges from two-line struggle. If we were to equate authority to centralism, which for the context of this interview we ought to, centralism is fundamental to education. Centralism exists regardless of who’s in power, whether that’s the bourgeoisie or the workers. Each side will struggle for their centralism. In education, we need to struggle principally for workers’ centralism in education. This can be channelled through the students as they become more amalgamated with the productive forces and their ensuing relations in the country based on what we have discussed. At the same time, this isn’t to say that I think teachers should play no role in classroom authority. Again, we are working with young people who will at times, given their age, struggle with behaviour management skills, socialising skills, cognitive ability – this is normal, improving this is how we develop as people, as a class. And so, you need to have someone who is able to exchange leadership simultaneously with the students as is appropriate, so as to elevate them to the point where they’re able to do it on their own – that’s what education is. You need a teacher in the room who is not restricted by the bourgeois post-modern tendencies in education, in an environment where they’re more directly amalgamated with production so that they can do their best work in elevating the students. Authority has a role in the classroom, and I think this is how it can best emerge.

Alice: How does post-modernist thought manifest itself in the curriculum and the teaching strategies in the school board?

Teacher: I’ll use one particular example in Ontario. There has been a major shift in the last ten years, though principally the last five since COVID, towards Indigenous Knowledge in classrooms in the board and education broadly in Ontario. I don’t think that we should alienate Indigineity from the classroom by any means. However, I think some of the decisions that have been made around Indigeneity in the classroom are questionable at best. We have fundamentally removed the English course at the grade 11 level for what’s known as the NBE course. This is the Indigenous course that has replaced it. It functions very similarly to an English course. You are still developing your foundational skills in terms of being able to read and interpret text, but it’s channelled through an Indigenous lens where you are reading Indigenous scholars, Indigenous authors, Indigenous poets, etc. I think it’s no coincidence that the Ontario Secondary School Literacy Test (OSSLT) rates have plummeted in the province as we have seen this wave of Indigenous thinking emerge in the classroom. And that specific course comes after that test is taken, so there is no serious intervention happening for struggling students. If literacy rates are plummeting, foundational literacy skills must be developed rather than replaced. By that I’m not trying to suggest that Indigenous Knowledge is making people stupid, I don’t think that at all, but I think by replacing integral courses such as English for something which hasn’t been developed for nearly as long, still functions broadly as an experiment, I think is very misguided. The texts students read for these courses are very trauma dense and lack narrative variation, which makes it difficult for students to develop understanding of theme and reading varied subtexts.

I also think identity politics have pervaded education in a way in which students are discouraged from developing and struggling with opinions of inquiry, or reaction, against race, “queerness,” class, what have you. Students don’t feel comfortable about sharing their opinions on a matter because they do not identify with the group of people that is being spoken about. Or maybe they aren’t being given meaningful opportunities to do that. That’s a huge problem. Of course, this does not mean that we should not be extremely critical of racism, homophobia, transphobia, classism, etc. It’s not to say that we shouldn’t be extremely critical of these things, and that we shouldn’t teach our students how to struggle against these ideas, but when superficial, immaterial ideas towards “inclusion” replace line struggle in the classroom, I think that creates a new issue. It’s an issue that I think doesn’t need to exist but it does right now.

Alice: If post-modernism, in essence, is about rejecting the idea that there can be a singular truth, it makes sense to me why they would introduce all of this Indigenous Knowing and other alternative thoughts into the curriculum: because it falls into this “there is no singular truth” paradigm, and so from their perspective, they are promoting alternative “truths.” I think in education this is very dangerous because it’s a rejection of what education is about at its core.

Alice: Does the school board support proletarian children?

Teacher: Can you elaborate?

Alice: You have mentioned previously that a function of the school board is to funnel children into the workforce, and I think what you meant by this is that the school board reinforces the existing class relations. Something that came to my mind is how in Ontario you have a separation into university-level courses, college-level, workplace-level courses. Do you think students in schools who intend to go on into proletarian employment after high schools, or maybe into colleges where they will get an education that leads to a proletarian job, that the education system supports them enough in doing so?

Teacher: No, I don’t think that schools support proletarian childern at all. You spoke about streaming, I’d like to elaborate for readers the following point. In the TDSB, and I presume in Ontario broadly, historically there were different streams of education which qualified students to be eligible for certain things. The primary two were what’s known as academic and applied level courses. Academic level courses guaranteed, with appropriate grades, that a student would be able to pursue higher education in the name of universities. Whereas, if a student were to take applied level courses this would qualify them for most colleges, trade schools, etc., but not for the universities. This created an overwhelming, overwhelming amount of stigma and reaction between academic and applied level streaming. This has disproportionately affected proletarian families in keeping them stratified in their class position, and also acutely affected visible minorities within the TDSB, most of which also are coming from proletarian backgrounds. This also supports the idea of bourgeios ownership informing education. Now there is a major pushback, good pushback, against streaming, which should be completely eliminated. Anyone who is against this is an idiot. Streaming is negative. There is no doubt about it. But what the Ontario government is doing is under the guide of destreaming is terrible. They have said: okay, at the grades 9 and 10 level, there are no streamed classes. What was once academic or applied is now destreamed and all students are now in the same classroom. What this actually is is a very convenient way for the provincial government to save money through cuts. You can now, where you would once have two 20-student classrooms, one academic 20-student classroom, one applied 20-student classroom, now instead you have one 35+ student destreamed classroom! Sure, it is now “destreamed” where students of varying levels are all in the same classroom receiving the same material. But the teachers are overworked. They have absolutely zero support. They have to manage so many more students than they would have previously. Students have less time with their teacher for personalized support. This negatively affects the teacher’s ability to work, it negatively affects the students’ ability to learn. It is completely negative and it is a total sham by the provincial government of Ontario. What’s funny is that the streaming levels still exist at the grade 11 and 12 level anyway! So, in terms of their overall impact students who are now in these “progressive” destreamed, classrooms in the early years of high school will be funnelled into academic and applied type classrooms anyway, and will still be segregated on the basis of what the board perceives as their intellectual capability. No, I do not think that the province effectively supports proletarian students whatsoever. They are sabotaging their ability to learn and develop by cutting teachers, funding, etc., and saying it is for the students’ benefit.

Alice: Would you say that the way the public education is designed creates extra barriers for students who have to work in their free time, as well as for adults who want to obtain a high school education?

Teacher: Very simply, yes, I do. I’ll try to think of a specific example. Teachers are somewhat unforgiving when it comes to students who have to work as well as going to high school. I would say you would have to look at what each teacher does on a case-by-case basis in their classroom, which would require an immense amount of investigation to discern what was actually going on. I’ll say very simply, though, students are not supported in the ways that they should. Many of these students go to school sleep deprived, many of these students look for extracurricular outlets to socialise, because they feel alienated from their classrooms, because they don’t have time for their studies. Usually this emerges as students neglecting their learning to focus only on athletics. This I have noticed very often with working students, usually males. It’s a huge problem for sure. Schools also do not have the resources to deal with this, so it persists. As for adult learners, I would say these problems are a little less acute because a lot of the adult programs have very small classroom sizes. The hours and the workload is usually a bit more flexible. But I’m sure problems persist there as well. I don’t have a lot of experience working with adult learners personally, but this is what I can speak to now.

Alice: What do you have to say about the state of special education in Ontario?

Teacher: One thing I will say is as a supply teacher whether or not you are qualified to work with special needs children and adolescents is irrelevant. If there is an opening on a day you’re covering in which a special education classroom needs coverage, you will be put in that room regardless of whether or not you’re qualified to do so. I think that while any good teacher is able to effectively manage the behaviours of any situation, I still don’t think this is something that should be happening, regardless of whether or not there are supports in the room. Focusing on your question, there’s a lot of debate on if students with major cognitive impairments, social disorders, etc., should be amalgamated with the general student body or isolated from them. I haven’t personally developed a specific and concrete opinion on this. I would need to do more work in education for a couple of years to come to a conclusion on that and more work with special education students in general. I don’t think Spec Ed students are getting the best shake so to speak.

Alice: How do the budget cuts manifest themselves?

Teacher: Well right now at the elementary level the Elementary Teachers Federation of Ontario is predicting that over 400 permanent jobs are set to be cut going into next school year, which is very high and very concerning. As the public board enters crisis, as less money is put into education, conditions deteriorate and teachers leave the board. The teachers that stay have to take on more work and the situation continues to get worse. You have, in effect, massive pockets where the board needs to create a surplus for itself in order to stay afloat, which manifests in laying off teachers. This is one way in which budget shortfalls try to correct themselves. I believe that entering this school year the TDSB was operating on a shortfall of 45 million dollars. That’s crazy.

Alice: Are the unions capable of countering these cuts, specifically the layoffs in any meaningful way?

Teacher: Theoretically, yeah, of course, any union is capable. But will the union meaningfully apply pressure? That remains to be seen. We go on very tedious strikes every few years over collective bargaining disputes. I haven’t experienced any myself as a new hire. Most the demands center around economic concerns rather than political ones. I’m personally not confident that the union will be able to apply any meaningful pressure as it relates to layoffs.

Alice: Why is there a trend grade inflation in the province? Is this part of a bigger pattern of degeneration of the students’ skills, them not being able to keep up with the standards, and the solution being proposed is to just lower those standards?

Teacher: Yes, I agree with that assessment. We have to make sure we connect this with production first, as well as the economic conditions of the board to come to an answer as to why this is happening. We have already adressed that the TDSB and the other boards are currently facing major budget deficits. I am not sure of the specifics, but I know that the amount of funding a school receives is dependent on how many students are enrolled at that school. If a student is failed this creates two possibilities which are not mutually exclusive. The first is that the failed student is more likely to drop out of school entirely for various reasons (needing to work, perceived self-inability, shame) and the second is that students which are retained for failing grades usually go through some sort of targeted education plan, sometimes as simple as retaking the course but other times it is much more involved with guidance councilors, multiple teachers, admin, and other stakeholders becoming involved in getting the student at the provincial standard. If the student leaves the school the school loses money. If the student stays on and needs to be struggled with through all of these people, that is a major expenditure of money, resources, and time. We have already addressed that schools in the province increasingly have less and less at their disposal in the general. So, when resources are increasingly stretched thin, what is more financially advantageous: failing the student and risk having them leave and/or having to create a rigorous plan for that student involving several people, or just brushing it aside and moving the student through anyway? Think about it.

It is interesting to note that this phenomenon, which I have observed directly in my time supplying so far, is that this grade inflation becomes increasingly common in proletarian neighborhoods and neighborhoods with higher rates of first or second generation Canadians. At these schools in the general I see grade ten and eleven students routinely demonstrate oral and written skill levels in line with curriculum expectations for students at a grade five or six level. That is ridiculous. And yet they are being given passing grades for their final marks? Why? Because the schools do not have the funding the develop the resources necessary for getting the students where they need to be, and it is much easier to just pass them and be done with it. It becomes more problematic when many teachers, and this I have also observed at times, write off this generation of students as stupid or lazy or backwards when this is not the full picture. Who faces the brunt of a lack of funding? The teachers have it pretty bad, no doubt, but if you stop to think about it there’s only one right answer to this question. Of course we are talking about economic solutions now rather than political ones, which we touched on earlier, but even at the economic level it is obvious that the state’s disinterest in funding public education is creating antagonisms between the student and teacher body which is directly advantageous to our common enemy: the bourgeioise. We know that the state is the organ of class rule. The erosion of public education is being slowly carried out by the state for the benefit of its class. There are many more aspects to this problem that I have not touched on, but in a word this is how I understand why the trend of grade inflation is emerging. I will also say briefly that COVID-19 did exacerbate this issue, but this trend is not prinicipally dependent on COVID-19.

As for degeneration of student skill, there is truth to that too. Students today are completely inundated with distractions and stimuli because of their cellphones. It is not healthy. I don’t want to be a loser and say get off your damn phone, because the problem we have discussed is much broader than that, but this is certainly of great concern. I think this particularly affects literacy skills: now there is less of a material need to read and write text. There are machines that do that for them, and in the mind of the student it is only logical that these devices “do the work for me,” and in some respects I don’t blame them. The school boards reinforce this; every student has a personal laptop that they use very often and is not heavily monitored. These are given to them by the board. Sure, some websites are banned, but kids are crafty. If they are given a device that can be exploited so as to not do work, they will exploit that device. This is not to say that electronics have no place in the classroom, but with each passing year the electronics are replacing learning. This becomes intensified when teachers, as we have said, face a lack of money and resources. This incentivises the increased use of personal devices from the teacher’s perspective, and the problem will only continue to get worse. I will finish with an example to illustrate this.

For my last placement in teacher’s college I worked in a 7/8 split classroom. I remember they were doing a project for Black History Month where they needed to do a research paragraph on a Black Canadian, explaining who they are, how they contributed to the development of Canadian society, etc. My mentor teacher, their teacher, explained that if they were to capitalize their person’s name they would be given a Level 4 (the highest in Ontario) for the communication portion of the rubric! That is insane. What’s worse is that maybe half of them could not even do that!! While I was helping them develop their paragraphs I would scan the room and check in with the students to ensure they were on task and understood what they needed to be doing. One young man was having a lot of trouble with his work so I asked him what he needed. He said he wanted to find sources but didn’t know where to look, which on the surface is a fine question. I tried to intiate a line of questioning that would prompt an understanding in him of what he should be looking up: what is fascinating about your person, what did they do, what do you like about them? Multiple I don’t knows ensued. Then I said if you want to look for sources the best place to start is to type your person in the search bar and see what websites look reliable or more academic and try to find a quote or two that speaks to you or effectively demonstrates that person’s contributions to Canadian society. What’s a search bar? He did not understand it as a concept despite knowing to type stuff in it and was unable to channel his thoughts into typed text on the laptop. In his document the name of his person was, apparently acceptably, uncapitalized. I explained he needed to use the shift key to go and capitalize that name as it’s a proper noun. What’s the shift key? Of course this is just one student, but it is this kind of thing that is happening shockingly on the regular.

Alice: Do you want to say anything about confessional education?

Teacher: It’s a total holdover from a more religious fundamentalist position that the bourgeoisie would have been incentivised to have occupied fifty or one hundred years ago. The confessional education system is increasingly more and more similar with the secular boards, to the point in which there’s almost no distinction outside of occasional mass and prayer. It should not exist.

Alice: What are the non-teaching staff in schools?

Teacher: It’s primarily custodial: janitors. There are also IT people that are on standby and technicians. There are maintenance staff and warehouse staff that come in and are available to do repairs and move equipment. What their working conditions are like I have no idea. Those people make up a major portion of the TDSB. I am not sure if they are hired by the TDSB directly or if they work with the TDSB through a private employer that is contracted with the TDSB and sends them out.

Alice: Are there cooks in schools?

Teacher: That’s another example. Yeah there are cooks, lunch staff. They’re not really common anymore; budget cuts. There are also hall monitors but I don’t really think they are workers, they’re like security. Crossing guards also come to mind. I would say they are workers.

Alice: How do you think teachers can take control of their workplace?

Teacher: I’ll reiterate. I think it goes back to struggling for the amalgamation of education with production, struggling to incorporate education with work. I think this is absolutely key. I think from there teachers can work to democratise their workplace by joining workplace committees with the various non-education workers present in the building and the industry. I think that the administrative aspect of schools needs to be completely overhauled in terms of the roles of office staff, of principals, of vice-principals, etc. I think students should be directly incorporated in these broader changes and decisions in education in the region at a much higher rate than they are now. A committee in this case might be constitued of 1/3 teachers, 1/3 non-education workers, 1/3 students.