Hank: What do you do for work?
Crossing Guard: I’m a crossing guard with Synergy. They’re under contact to the City of Toronto.
Hank: Is there any particular reason you pursued this line of work?
CG: Not really. I quit my last job because it was just really stressful. This came up and seemed less stressful. For the most part it was better than the last job but there’s a lot here that could be better.
Hank: Could you describe the last job a bit?
CG: I was working at a furniture store. We were short staffed for over a year. We should have had six people staffed; we only had three. Pretty regularly there were only two of us in the store. Often we wouldn’t even have time to go to the bathroom. I would be going nine hours straight moving heavy furniture a lot of the time.
Hank: What was more appealing about this job compared to the last one?
CG: The hours. At the last job I was never working the same days. My hours were very erratic day-to-day. My co-workers and I were all stressed out and on each other’s nerves. It caused a lot of problems. It got to the point where I was having panic attacks everyday, so I said fuck it and quit without anything else lined up. At this job the hours are much more consistent.
Hank: How long have you been working for this company now?
CG: I got the job in May of last year. Because it only runs during the school year I would have stopped in June, so they just had me start officially in September. I was at home for a couple of months recovering mentally from the last job.
Hank: What’s your average workday like now?
CG: I get down to my intersection at about 7:00am. I like being early. I work from 7:40am-9:00am. Then I go on break for two hours and work 11:00am-1:00pm. Then I have another break and work from 2:30pm-4:30pm to cover when kids finish school for the day. After 4:30pm I’m off and go home.
Hank: Are there any distinctions between part-time and full-time workers at your company?
CG: The part-timers are called casual employees. They work when they want to and they don’t have a permanent intersection. Today they’re here, tomorrow maybe they don’t work. They’re also used as coverage for when a full-timer can’t make it into work. Casuals need to work a minimum of four shifts a month.
Hank: As a full-timer, what expectation does the company have in terms of your schedule?
CG: My schedule’s the same everyday. I don’t even need to think about it which I really like. Same hours, same days, same intersection. I don’t work weekends which is a benefit. I’ve got holidays off.
Hank: How much do you make in a wage as a crossing guard?
CG: It’s about $18.20 an hour. I’m still living with my parents and they don’t charge me rent. I’m lucky they’re cool about it. If I was living on my own and paying rent I wouldn’t be able to survive on what I make. We’re not paid during our breaks even though we can’t go home. They have a system where they round you up. I work for five and a half hours between all of my shifts, but I’m paid as if I worked six hours. It doesn’t matter very much because I have to be outside of home for almost nine hours, and that’s not including my commute.
Hank: Are wages tied to seniority at all?
CG: I don’t know because I’ve only been doing this a year. Some of the crossing guards who have been around longer told me that the last time they got a raise it was less than a dollar. I think it was a twenty to thirty cent raise, they said.
Hank: Why do you think that is?
CG: The company is just cheap. Breaking news, they all are.
Hank: Are there any opportunities for you to interact with other co-workers?
CG: Usually we’re all clustered around schools. We only know if someone’s a crossing guard if we see their sign or whistle or vest. If you want you can say hi but for the most part you’re working by yourself, which has its benefits, but it’s hard. When you start out you might need help. Sometimes new hires have questions and they don’t know who to talk to. You’re not allowed to leave your post, so even if you’re close to someone or working the same intersection it’s best you don’t talk to them.
Hank: And there is no central area where the crossing guards can go during one of their breaks to gather and talk amongst themselves?
CG: Nothing official. You’ll end up around the same coffee shop or McDonald’s which is what happens in this area, but there’s nothing official.
Hank: What does the management structure look like as you understand it?
CG: There are field supervisors which are your direct superior. There’s four supervisors divided among the city. Then there’s quality assurance managers who come in and check in on you. The only reason why I know two of the quality assurance managers is because they just introduced themselves but they don’t wear any uniform. They might just walk by you to try and catch you not working or using the washroom and you have no idea they’re your manager.
Hank: What roles do they fulfill for the company? What jobs do they do?
CG: Besides monitoring us the quality assurance managers fill in for us if there’s no one else to do it, as an example. The field supervisors are like the actual bosses. They deal with reports and more serious matters.
Hank: In what other ways does your employer monitor the crossing guards?
CG: We have an app on our phone: TrackTik, that we use to clock in and out. It also has a GPS.
Hank: Can you elaborate?
CG: So we have to have GPS and location data enabled for the app to work and that’s how we clock in and out and it also tracks where we are. My understanding is as long as we’re logged in even before you clock in it tracks you. If you log in at home it starts tracking you not just when you clock in and out. Then there’s the higher ups driving around checking in on us. Also the City of Toronto has inspectors going around checking on us. We don’t know who they are. They’ll be in a random City of Toronto car and they’ll just drive by, look, and drive off. They won’t come talk to you.
Hank: When you were hired did the company explain to you that this app would monitor you when you were logged into it or did you find that out while working the job?
CG: They mentioned in the ad that you had to have a smartphone that has GPS and all that sort of stuff.
Hank: What was your training like?
CG: When I was there my first thought was: it’s work as a crossing guard, how complicated could it be? Even still, the training is laughable. They give us a slideshow. You sit in a big room and someone explains it to you. I remember one slide where they had text saying green light means go and a red light means stop. Five year olds learn that. Do you really have to go over that during training, you know? Then they take us outside in front of the office to a street with barely any traffic. One at a time we walk out into the middle of the street, hold the sign up and walk back for them to say, “Okay, you passed!” There’s also a written test. You need an an eighty percent score or higher to pass. The test is a joke, too. I’ve heard from co-workers that sometimes answers will get fed to trainees so they pass. They need to pass everyone because the turnover rate is so high. They don’t train you at all. What do you do in a busy area where there’s a back up because a car is blocking an intersection? They don’t tell you what the process for that is. They don’t tell you how to deal with aggressive drivers. They just say blow your whistle. Anyone who lives here knows drivers around here are nuts—what’s a whistle going to do? They don’t teach you much of anything besides when to walk out and how to hold your sign. You can learn that in five seconds.
Hank: Does the company give specific directions for where a crossing guards needs to position themselves?
CG: They have an expectation for you to be at a specific spot. When they assign you a spot they don’t tell you where that is. If they expect you on the northeast corner they will just give you the intersection and not say that. They want you to be closest to the school so the highest amount of kids will naturally cross by you. But they don’t tell you where that is, it’s not always accurate, and if you have multiple schools in that area where do you stand? You don’t know.
Hank: It sounds pretty subjective.
CG: Yes.
Hank: There also seems to be no training for different intersection types. Do they go over that in training at all?
CG: No. They treat every intersection as the same, whether you’re at a major intersection or some side street.
Hank: Zero specialized training?
CG: Nope none whatsoever. They treat it like its one size fits all.
Hank: What protocols are in place for inclement weather or weather emergencies?
CG: They tell us to dress for the weather. During the two snow days that happened since I was hired we were emailed ahead of time that the schools might call a snow day, so check online and check with the school board and we’ll send you an email to confirm whenever the school board made the decision. Around 5:00 or 6:00am or so. But on the first snow day I hadn’t got an email. I was getting ready and I was pretty sure they were going to call a snow day but I wanted to be ready in case school was on. I saw online that the public and catholic board had both called snow days but I hadn’t gotten an email or anything official. I called the central help line to check to ask what’s going on. I was told I’ll get an email in a minute. I got the email at 9:00am.
Hank: What did that mean for you?
CG: It was a snow day, so nothing happened. But it was nerve-wracking having somebody telling me on the phone randomly that I didn’t have to go to work, but I didn’t have any confirmation until 9:00am which would have been after my shift finishes.
Hank: Assuming that you stayed home because the person said stay home, but then it ended up not being a snow day, would you have been disciplined for that?
CG: Probably been charged with a missed day or a call from my supervisor. I don’t recall exactly that in training if they mentioned it or not. They didn’t go into too much detail for what disciplinary action looked like, but I’m sure I would have gotten a call from the supervisor.1
Hank: Assuming there’s no snow day but it’s extremely cold: hail is coming down and it is forty below, let’s say, do you still have to report to work if the schools are open?
CG: As long as schools are open we have to be at work. Basically they told us it’s our responsibility to dress for the weather whatever it might be.
Hank: How do you feel about that?
CG: I get this is a job that you’re working outside, that you’re expected to deal with the weather, but there are certain conditions that are not safe to work in. If you’re outside for two hours and it’s thirty below, no matter what you’re wearing you’re gonna get cold very fast. One of the crossing guards here has those electric heating gloves. They told me that about an hour in their hands were freezing. I have about $150 worth of gloves with heating packs inside and my hands still get cold.
Hank: Has your physical health ever been at risk because of the weather?
CG: One day it was twenty-five below with wind chill. After my first shift I was getting a mild case of hypothermia: shaking, dizzy, felt like I was gonna be sick. I was shivering for a half an hour inside a restaurant. I called into the company and said I’m not going back out I can’t do it. I was told it’s hard to get someone last minute and was asked to come back out. I told them it wasn’t happening. They don’t have a process for dealing with someone leaving last minute. They need to send someone else out but it seems like they don’t have enough people.
Hank: Is that specifically because there’s no protocol for weather and people can’t handle being out there?
CG: Sure. I noticed afterwards that people just quit during the winter. I heard a story of one crossing guard that had to quit because he couldn’t afford to buy the weather gear (coats, gloves, etc.) to deal with the weather. Not being able to afford to do your own job is a ridiculous concept.
Hank: The company doesn’t provide you any equipment upon being hired?
CG: Nothing. They give us the sign, the safety vest, and the whistle. We have to pay a deposit on that which is over 100 dollars. That’s it. They don’t even give us a rain coat. No spending account, nothing. A spending account for some weather gear would be great. Even a discount with Mark’s or an outdoor shop would be helpful.2
Hank: So the money you spend on winter gear to keep yourself warm that was entirely at your expense?
CG: Yes.
Hank: How much have you spent on equipment to do your job?
CG: I’ve spent over $150 on gloves. 4 pairs of hunting socks that were 40 or 50 bucks each. 80 bucks on a pair of boots. I bought electric hand warmers that were about 20 bucks. So many disposable hand warmers.
Hank: We’re talking over $500 in equipment here.
CG: Yes. And that’s just for winter.
Hank: Does the same thing apply in the summer? If its forty degrees out with a high UV rating, you’re expected to be out there?
CG: Yep. On extreme weather days they should really have shortened shifts. It should be an hour. To go back to the winter days for a second, at a lot of the intersections when it is terrible winter weather most of the kids show up in a fifteen minute burst right before the bell. Otherwise you are standing around in the freezing cold doing nothing. Most adults drive in this kind of weather and so we don’t have anyone else to help cross. This doesn’t happen so much with my intersection because it’s very busy, but this is common.
Hank: You’re outside all this time. There’s no common area for you to go to between shifts. How do bathroom breaks work?
CG: There’s big problems around bathroom breaks. By the company rule book the idea is that if you need to go to the bathroom we were told to hold it as long as you can.
Hank: That’s what they said?
CG: Yeah. If you can’t hold it you have to call your supervisor and tell them you need to go to the bathroom. They need to send someone over to replace you while you’re away. The one time I actually called my boss it was the last fifteen minutes of my shift and I was told it’s going to take twenty minutes for someone to get there. And then also we have no dedicated bathroom. It depends entirely on where you are. Coffee shops, whatever washrooms are around you are what you can use. That’s not great because sometimes there’s a line, sometimes they’re gross, and sometimes you’re told you need to pay for something first which is another expense.
Hank: For crossing guard workers who are in areas that are more residential without washrooms nearby, do they just have to deal with it?
CG: Basically. They didn’t explain this during the training but I heard afterwards if you’re by a school you can use the school. Then again you gotta show ID, you gotta deal with the admin buzzing you in, all of that stuff. I heard from one crossing guard who told me he went to the school one day to use the bathroom. The next day the door was locked and they wouldn’t let him in. If you’re in an area without washrooms available you really are screwed.
Hank: I’ve heard stories in which crossing guards have been subject to harassment and assault from the public. Have you been witness to or involved in a situation like this before?
CG: I’ve been assaulted once. I called my supervisor to report it. She didn’t write it down. She told me to call the cops and when you get the report to let her know. Trying to get a report from the cops was pathetic. They bounced me around between different police divisions and officers. In over a week they couldn’t even send out one officer to meet with me to get a statement so I said forget it. I heard a story from a supervisor that a crossing guard had someone step out of their car, yank her stop sign out of her hand to try and hit her with the sign. Nothing came of it. There’s tons of stories of us being assaulted. Second hand, third hand, directly from guys that have been assaulted. The same day that I got assaulted someone else had it happen too, or that same week.
Hank: So the company has no specific procedure in place for these situations?
CG: No, You report it to your supervisor and then if you want to go any further with it it’s on your own time. I have no faith in the cops at all. There’s really nothing you can do.
Hank: Is this something that the company goes over during training?
CG: Not really, no.3
Hank: What happens in the summer when schools are closed?
CG: We get laid off. You can apply for EI, get another job, but there’s no work when schools are closed.
Hank: Does the company have any procedures in place to redirect off-season crossing guards into other positions in or outside of the company?
CG: No. There’s a couple of spots that will cover for intersections near summer schools, but it’s not as many positions. I’m not sure the exact numbers but it’s not many.
Hank: So they have positions in the company but they are severely reduced?
CG: Exactly. And it goes by where you work. If my corner was one that required a crossing guard for summer school I would get first dibs. If I don’t want it they just go down the list. It’s based on area and then who applies for it first if the full-timer working there doesn’t want it.
Hank: What would you say the main reason the turnover rate is so high? Everyone you have described has rarely worked over a year or two years.
CG: It’s a hard job. You’re outside in the weather dealing with all the drivers. And you don’t get paid enough. It’s not worth risking getting hit by a car, all the weather, for what we’re paid. 18.20 an hour is just not worth it. And like I said before we’re outside from before 8:00am till past 4:00pm. In that span of time we only work about five and a half hours, but we’re expected to be present to work for almost nine hours. There’s no flexibility for us to get a second job.
Hank: The role of Synergy, which is your company, is to be around schools so that kids can cross intersections near their schools safely. Is Synergy at all affiliated with the TDSB or other school boards?
CG: I’m not sure about affiliations. I do not believe we are affiliated with any school board.
Hank: Does Synergy require any previous experience or level of education?
CG: No. We do a police check, VSC, and if you can pass that that’s about it.
Hank: So a high school dropout could get hired?
CG: From what I remember on the job application, yeah. I don’t remember any minimum requirement for education.
Hank: What about benefits? Does the company that you work for provide any benefits at all?
CG: No, nothing. They used to but I believe that was a couple of months before I started. That would have been at the end of that school year that they cut the benefits.
Hank: Do you know why that happened?
CG: Not sure.
Hank: In the past crossing guards in Toronto were unionized but had their contracts flipped and were kicked out and de-certified. Could you explain to the best of your understanding what happened?
CG: One guy has been doing it since the company used to have that contract when it was unionized. He mentioned they used to be unionized, that they used to have benefits. I asked what the hell happened and he said the contract was up and the City gave it to someone else and we lost out. I’m sure the fact that it was unionized, that they had benefits, that it was costing more it was a huge factor as to why they gave it to Synergy which, as I see it, is trying to do it as bare bones as possible.4
Hank: Are you in favour or against of unionization of crossing guards in Toronto.
CG: 100% in favour.
Hank: Why?
CG: My dad works in a factory. He’s unionized. My whole life he’s been in a union. I got my asthma medication as a kid because the union paid for it. To me all jobs should be unionized. Especially ones where the companies are screwing people over and taking advantage like this. The old saying is you get the union you deserve, right?
Hank: Is there a common set of demands amongst your co-workers for improving the job that you know of? If not, what would you raise personally.
CG: I’ve heard a lot regarding a spending account, discounts for weather gear, reduced hours on extreme weather days. Of course, better pay. That’s always a big one. I don’t know how they would do this because we’re out in the middle of nowhere, sometimes by ourselves, and really spread out, but some sort of support process that the company gives us for assault. Have some sort of liaison or something. Build some sort of process to report these situations easier.
Hank: Could you describe the corporate culture the company promotes amongst the employees?
CG: It’s hard to say because I’ve been to the office one for training. I talk to the supervisor. That’s about it. I talk to a quality assurance manager every once in a while. From what I hear, though, they have a high turnover rate in the office as well which is causing some problems. I don’t know much of what’s going on in the office.
Hank: When they send out emails or anything like that, is there specific message that they try to push amongst employees to try and retain people? Is there anything they do to make people feel good about coming to work.
CG: The emails always have something along the lines of, “We appreciate the hard work through the hard conditions, keeping everyone safe. We appreciate it—the community appreciates it,” the standard bullshit that company always say, you know. The first or second week of June was Crossing Guard Appreciation Week. They gave us a “gift.” It was a key chain that you could add your ID card to. We have our ID cards in a little pocket in our vest. I have no need for a key chain with the company name on it. If they had given us a Tim Hortons with 5 dollars on it it would have been more useful.5
Hank: A slap in the face?
CG: Yeah. At Christmas they gave us a toque with the company name on it and a candy cane. The toque I had was better.
Hank: The one you bought yourself to do the job?
CG: Yeah, yeah.
Hank: Why do you think crossing guards are so disrespected even by the public? It seems like that’s been a common theme.
CG: I don’t know man. You see interviews and news stories about crossing guards and it’s always something about how this person dances and this person sings. They’re always on some quiet street or right in front of the school. If you’re on a busy street people just have no patience they don’t wanna take those two seconds drivers and pedestrians to just check if it’s safe to go. I’ve had drivers yell at me, pedestrians yell at me. One person was about to cross against the light in front of a car that was turning. I tell her to wait she looks up at the car and I say that there’s a car about to turn. She told me to fuck off and kept going. Even the driver looked at me and said what the hell was that? People just have no patience. I get it. Sometimes you’re in a hurry. But that extra minute is not gonna make a difference. If you’re late you’re late. That extra minute is not gonna make a difference. I think overall people overall not having the patience to wait. It’s not worth injury. There’s a trial going on in Ottawa because someone ran through a crossing guard, hit him and killed him. Going back to what I said earlier, there actually was a dancing crossing guard somewhere in the city. She was hit by a car and can’t work anymore. People just treat us like we’re in the way.
Hank: Do you have any other statements you’d like to make to fellow crossing guards and other workers in the country who might be reading this interview.
CG: Always go for that union. For the crossing guards, I honestly do believe it’s an important job. We need to have crossing guards around to protect young children and the elderly. It needs to be done. We need to be treated better. It’s a useful job. An important job.
Endnotes
1. We later learned that disciplinary measures are in the contract and are not made clear to new hires. This would have resulted in a verbal warning before being escalated further.
2. It is worth noting that charging uniform deposits is illegal in Ontario.
3. Crossing guards have zero power when it comes to law enforcement. If a crossing guard had a body camera which captured footage of commuters not obeying traffic, the crossing guard’s directions, attempts at assault, etc., it would not receive any special attention. It would be equivalent to a random person sending an anonymous tip. Even though legislation allows for fines, even demerit points for failing to stop at a crossing guard’s instructions, this cannot be enforced by the crossing guard. Of course, this does not mean we advocate for crossing guards to amalgamate with the police force. We would simply like to demonstrate how laws which relate directly to crossing guard protection do nothing to protect them while they are at work.
4. Some crossing guards in Toronto were previously organized by CUPE Local 5519 and were employed to a different company. When the contract expired, the City of Toronto flipped their contract and sought to employ crossing guards through a different company; Synergy Protection Group, and laid off every single crossing guard from the previous company to employ non-unionized crossing guards to this one. There were nearly 400 unionized crossing guards who were fired. The City of Toronto was able to do this because they contracted out the service, allowing them the opportunity to choose a new contractor when the contract with this body expired. There are unique barriers for crossing guard unionization in the city: crossing guards are separated into four zones, all of which are contracted to different, changing companies. Synergy’s domain is just one of the four and was the only one previously unionized; there is nothing in place in the labour code to force new contractors into accepting the previous one’s union contract. This is called succession.
5. The announcement by the city to inaugurate Crossing Guard Appreciation Week came less than one week after they voted to change contractors and fire 300+ crossing guards.