- What were your responsibilities at work?
I watched two children under the age of four in a private home, which included feeding them, cleaning up after them, getting them dressed, organizing their whole day and taking them to activities, making lunch and dinner, keeping on top of house management, doing bedtime and wake-ups, driving them around, running errands for the family, grocery shopping. This type of job usually spills over, because once a rich person realizes you’re good at something, they want you to do it for them, even if it’s not why they hired you.
- What are the working conditions like as a childcare worker?
I would say, it’s a hard relationship to explain. It’s very intimate because you work at the family’s home for huge stretches of the day, so they treat you kind of like family, but also very disposable. Usually your boss doesn’t treat you like family. I would think ‘maybe I am a bit like family’, but then you realize that nobody would ever treat their family like this. It’s just something they say, like any other company.
In terms of schedule, I am basically always on call. The family will call me whenever I was home or off work to ask about things, and text me to pick things up or prepare activities before work. So I was basically at their whim 24/7, including the mental load of handling all of that, without getting paid until I walked in their door.
- Do you have any examples of this type of ‘family treatment’?
They would be like “our home is your home, eat when and whatever you want,” but in reality, if they’re eating anywhere, or the kids are eating, I don’t have time to eat because I’m doing a million things at once to make that possible. So actually you have to eat in secret when you’re done all your work, which really never stops.
I also found out I was pregnant, and they told me they would take care of everything I needed, but instead they let me go a month later. That’s what I mean by ‘family but disposable’.
I also had to work on every holiday, and although they would get me a gift on holidays, then they wouldn’t pay me enough, or holiday pay, or overtime, or anything.
- On that topic, what are the wages like for a childcare worker?
They were not bad, it was alright pay ($25/hour by the end of my last job), but I was a contract/grey area worker, so I got no benefits or vacations, no overtime. And then I have to put money away for taxes because they always try to pay you under the table, but I wanted parental benefits, so I paid my taxes on it anyways. This ate away at any benefit for me that under the table work normally would give.
- What was your relationship like with the family you worked for?
The kids really think you are family, because you’re with them all the time. But managing all the tasks, plus the kids and the parents, that really strains the relationship. So I would often park the kids in front of the TV to get stuff done for the parents. The father I hardly talked to, it was mostly the mother. They were constantly demanding. It’s crazy how much stuff they need you to do for them.
- Your industry is notorious for using immigrant labour. Did your workplace have any immigrant workers, and how did their conditions differ from yours?
There was a Filipino housekeeper who actually lived in the family’s home, in a basement room with no window. She was supposed to only work something like 35-40 hours/week, based on her work visa, but she never got to clock out, or finish everything in a day, so she worked basically from 6 am to 9 pm, six days a week. They also deducted room and board from her wages, without ever paying her overtime. She would basically do anything for them, no matter what they asked. Her status in Canada depended on keeping the family happy, so this made her especially vulnerable to exploitation, so she didn’t lose her job, and then her visa. This meant she would spoil the kids, feeding them candy just so they didn’t cry. It’s not that she was bad at her job, but she was forced to do these things based on the circumstances, which worked out badly for everyone. She spent her life raising these two kids, but she had a seven year old daughter of her own, who lived in Hong Kong (where she previously worked as a live-in housekeeper) that she never got to see, let alone raise. I never even heard them FaceTime, because I don’t think she had time. She also didn’t know how to navigate any of the social systems here, English was her second language and she spoke no French, so she couldn’t just call a doctor. She would ask me to pick stuff up for her like food and medicine, because she couldn’t drive, and the walk from the house to anywhere was so long. The family said they could eat what she wanted, but they would never actually account for her, so there was never enough for her. And they deducted money for food, but she never got to go the grocery store, unless I took her with us. She also had to take out a loan for a lawyer to get her visa to come to Canada, and she was still paying that off while working here. So nothing she even made was hers, it was going to a lawyer in Hong Kong. One of her friends here had her own place, and most of her days off she would go to her house and just sleep. She never wanted time off because she needed the money to get out of debt.
- I imagine there were many other nannies in the neighbourhood, with other kids. What was your relationship with them like?
I got along well with them to have play dates, go to the park, but they were also almost all Filipino as well. I met one other White nanny out of like 20, so even though some were permanent residents, they were still exploited at least as bad as me. One worked for two doctors, so she could get called in at any time of night. They were always complaining about ridiculous things that their bosses needed, like having to stay up all night because one of the kids needed all pink things for their birthday party. In the sort of house hierarchy, nannies are better off than housekeepers. When the day starts, you only see Filipino nannies and housekeepers in these neighbourhoods, where none of the other residents are Filipino, walking dogs, taking kids to school, coming to clean houses.
- How do you find work and what’s the process of switching jobs like?
I find jobs online, on websites where people are looking for nannies. I make profiles, kind of like a dating profile, and you get matched with these families. Then you meet them in person, interviews, meet the kids, then go to their house, to get an idea of how you are with kids. I have to do a background check, they want to make sure I know First Aid and CPR, but I have no formal education in this. I’ve just been doing it for about 10 years. I imagine someone with a real education is more expensive. Plus my French is bad, so I have trouble finding work in the field I trained in (carpentry), which really limits my job options in Montreal. Switching jobs usually takes a few months to find the right family, but then I also can’t go on EI between jobs, because of the under the table pay, so it can be stressful between jobs.
- What happens when there’s an accident or injury at your workplace?
It’s all on you, there’s no workplace safety or anything, it’s basically like if you got injured at home. If you’re so hurt you can’t work, it will just annoy them, but there’s no legal recourse or anything. Probably the CNESST would help if there was a serious injury, but generally like if you hurt your back carrying kids all day, you have to suck it up. The housekeeper hurt her leg and just had a funny limp for a month, but didn’t see a doctor or anything.
- Did you travel with the family?
Yes I did they would pay for everything but I had to share a room with the kids, and when you’re traveling, you get no break, maybe an hour alone. So this was like three weeks straight of 16 hour days with one day off, when I went to Europe with them. And I got a lower rate because they took off my food anyways, and you’re in a foreign country so what are you going to do? They talk nice before you go, but once you’re there, it’s always more work, promises are broken, and there’s nothing you can do about it. I was actually valuable to the family because of my Canadian passport because I could travel internationally. Other nannies on work visas couldn’t travel to third countries, so it was easier with me, but that’s another way that legal status is used to divide people who work in my industry. The family would tell me to say I was going on the trip for pleasure while applying for a visa, even though I was working, but I was always worried I’d get in trouble with foreign border services.
- Are there any unions or other labour organizations for your industry?
I really don’t know. Not that I’ve heard of. I know there are some immigrant labour rights organizations, but I’m not an immigrant so that was no help to me. I could go to the CNESST, but that was all on my own will, nobody else was ever really there to support me. Especially because everyone works in their own situation, nobody in my specific work actually works together, we’re all in different private homes all alone. That make it tough, and basically impossible to organize for those who live in the houses. They’re trapped.
- What immediate improvements would you make to the industry if you had the power?
Regulate it more, so the workers had more rights and guidelines to be treated like employees rather than the weird ‘like family but workers’ relationship
It’s hard to say because also it feels like this job shouldn’t exists; families can care for their own kids or clean their own houses, but we need work and they can pay, so we’ll do it.
Response to “Childcare Worker Interview – by WUF-MTL”
[…] This article in English […]
LikeLike