The People's Hammer

Criticism of “Mistakes to Avoid Starting Communist Work by Matt F.” – by The People’s Hammer Editorial Board

,


We received an article that we republished on May 29th, 2026 at https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/05/29/mistakes-to-avoid-starting-communist-work-by-matt-f/

When we reposted this article it came with the promise of a criticism of the last section of the article, now we are able to fulfill this promise to our readership. We at the People’s Hammer have worked tirelessly to promote the two-line struggle within the communist movement in Canada and that involves posting articles on our site that we disagree with or believe are lacking in some aspects. There are some errors that warrant bringing our disagreements with into focus so as to prevent our work from going completely off-track should the error become more widespread than it already is. In struggling with the author we hope to cure the sickness of doomerism in order to save the communist spirit of newcomers from the stagnation induced by hopelessness.

The article serves a very important point of trying to point out common mistakes when starting communist work. Many newcomers could learn a lot from the experience of the author and this type of advice-giving is an important task of the more experienced communist organizers. Unfortunately, the author, “Matt F.”, has done a bad job of summing up his experience in his final paragraph and will undoubtedly convince many readers never to get involved with communist work at all, which we hope was not the point of his article. Let’s talk about it.

We would have to disagree with the idea that “Communist work largely sucks”. Connecting with the masses and fighting collectively for your liberation with them has much to be enjoyed and is extremely rewarding. Perhaps from a petite-bourgeois point of view this kind of work takes away from the time you spend partying, playing video games or otherwise distracting yourself from the class struggle, but the class conscious worker will choose to let go of their dependence on distractions in order to achieve what is necessary. It is possible that this is what the author is talking about when he says: “The sacrifices suck, but consider making them so we can all see the future.” It is true we face an immensely difficult challenge in organizing a revolution and will face the entire repressive might of the class enemy. Luckily we are not doing this blindly but we can study Marxism-Leninism-Maoism-Gonzalo Thought for the practical lessons our forefathers in the struggle have already learned.

Do we really think that Lenin or Mao would consider the masses they wished to organize as “lonely, mentally ill weirdos”? Would that have been a helpful attitude to propagate among the People’s Army as they liberated territory and began to govern the workers and peasants? The masses are the lifeblood of the communists and when they are lonely and mentally ill it reflects the conditions of the exploitation in society and part of our task is to fix that in each other. As for “weirdos” I think most communists will be considered weird by many for wanting to get involved in what is for now a subculture and for as long as we stay alienated from the masses we will remain seen that way. The attitude that this paragraph promotes will see to it that communists continue to be alienated from the masses.

Where the author really does a disservice to readers of his article would be in his description of the necessity of communist revolution. While we agree that communist revolution is necessary from a historical perspective to advance our species’ development, he promotes a fear of apocalypse caused by capitalism as the motivation for communism. This is the tactic of climate activists who have not proven to be very motivating for the working-class when the harm of exploitation is so acute on an individual level. If workers are struggling just to feed their children it will be hard to convince them to act in service of stopping the hypothetical death of the species as a whole. It is therefore better to focus on the workers’ bread and butter before committing them to an existential struggle against the apocalypse.

Getting the new communists ready for struggle does not mean telling them they are going to have a terrible time but they just need to do it to save the world. This last paragraph reeks of Stoic philosophy and even Christian asceticism where suffering is made into a virtue unto itself. In learning to struggle and fight people’s war we will go through hard times but we must find all the possible joy along the way or we will not build a movement at all. We must create culture that expresses our philosophy and draws others towards it. The kind of society we seek to build will be hard to achieve but the brave do not cower from such difficulty. Many will follow when they see our accomplishments, they will be proud of us and we will celebrate every victory against the class enemy and take lessons from every defeat. There is nothing to fear if we study well and stay committed to our goals.


Response to “Criticism of “Mistakes to Avoid Starting Communist Work by Matt F.” – by The People’s Hammer Editorial Board”

  1. Optimism: The Correct Perspective – by Matt F. – The People's Hammer

    […] This article is a response to our criticism of the author’s original article, which can be found here. […]

    Like