Q: What are the general working conditions within the animation industry?
A: Unlike a lot of other industries, the industry works on a contract basis. The employer is basing themselves on if a client would sign a contract and fund a project for the studio and then the studio will hire necessary labour. It is fairly unstable because even though some people can get put into another project immediately you are never 100% secure that this will happen and you might have to start searching for another job. It’s quite usual for people to start searching for another job a couple months before their current project finishes.
Q: Are you familiar with the current rate of wages across the animation industry?
A: I think there is some sort of agreement across studios of what each position pays but it’s definitely not standardized, especially because majority of studios are not unionized. So they can put the price down on what it’s actually worth. I don’t have an idea of exact numbers.
Q: Can you give us some insight as to what the current state of the industry is?
A: It has been a rough couple of years. Because it’s a very project based industry, when things are rough, like if we are in a recession and investment is not there, there is very little job security. We currently have a high number of unemployed, people with a lot more experience than me struggling to find any work.
Q: What other factors would you say have led to this state of affairs besides just a general recession?
A: I can only speculate. There is the rise of genAI which has been used as an excuse to hire less people and try to integrate that as a cost cutting mechanism. I also think it’s a consequence of the pandemic. During the pandemic the film industry suffered because you couldn’t do anything in person. So the animation industry took the load and got a lot of investment and projects going on. A lot of people even with no prior experience got hired. There was this bubble with no infrastructure to maintain this growth. So when film came back and investment got cut there was nowhere left for these new workers to go.
Q: Are you familiar with the general work conditions of animation jobs specifically pertaining to health of the workers and potential for repetitive strain in the industry?
A: Carpal tunnel syndrome is something most people have to prevent or it will become a problem even by the time you start working. The thing about animation or any art based thing where you have to use your wrists and arms a lot in repetitive motions is you have been doing this before you were a professional. It is a real problem that there’s not necessarily a lot to prevent such a thing. You have to take care of yourself before it happens.
Q: Given what you mentioned about the high proportion of animation workers compared to a very low proportion of available work, are you familiar with a general industry that these workers have turned to in particular? Or have a lot of these workers branched out to any industry they can find?
A: It comes down to the individual and whatever they deem worthwhile. Some of them will try to get some art adjacent job like graphic design or marketing. I know some of them that will just completely have to change gears, I know someone doing animal conservation. Some of them will do that out of necessity still trying to go back to animation, but some of them are too burned out by the whole process and give up.
Q: Is there a high rate of animation workers who are not permanent residents? Has this increased the severity of these difficulties?
A: Yes, there are a lot of immigrants that come specifically for the pursuit of this career. At least in the past couple of years it’s been much more difficult with the closure or restrictions on the streams that the government previously made available for people. Studios will benefit from tax credit incentives if you hire locally. If you hire a Canadian or permanent resident you will get some tax break. There is a lot of advertisement for how good you can make a life here in Canada and the pathways for it. Then when you come you have to spend a lot of money and the job security is nothing like they tell you. Hiring an immigrant that doesn’t have permanent residency yet is a little bit more expensive for a studio, it’s kind of logical that they will avoid hiring immigrants because of it. It makes the life of the person who came here that much harder.
Q: Based on all of these difficulties, can you enlighten us on the general wave of unionization efforts that are going through the animation industry? What are the general feelings of animation workers towards these efforts? How successful has it been?
A: Specifically the Canadian Animation Union is a pretty recent thing. The first unionized studio was in 2020 in the middle of the pandemic. There have been great strides, they unionized two big studios in the past year and a half and are currently doing the last steps of their contract. They are still fairly small by comparison to many other unions but they are growing rapidly.
Q: Is there much of a divide among animation workers between those who are anti union and those who are pro union?
A: The majority are welcoming to the idea. The main issue right now is the fear that if you are outwardly pro union you might not be as hireable as if you just didn’t say anything about it. The industry by the artists nature is a bit more reserved because a lot of the work is still being done remotely in some fashion. It is more a lack of communication between workers and a lack of understanding of exactly what a union is and how it can help them have better working conditions.
Q: What have been some of the principal demands that these workers have put on the table? Whether or not these have been met.
A: Outside of better wages, there are four main components: job security and guaranteed right of recall, benefits like a pension plan, proper tracking of time and overtime against ghost hours, and protection around the artist’s work around AI.
Q: Can you clarify what you mean by ghost hours?
A: Ghost hours are basically when you are working for free. You are working beyond the scope of 40 hours per week to meet the deadline without overtime pay.
Q: To close off, are there any gaps in demands that you see?
A: It’s less that I’m optimistic and more that I’m seeing the trend of people being fed up with their current conditions. This industry is like a passion industry because people love doing it, but this passion gets exploited. I think the current union efforts are doing a good job. Currently each studio is unionizing individually and they have their own bargaining contracts. I believe the objective for any industry is to have a master contract for every worker under the union to have the same rights and protections, or as close to that as possible for them.