Over the past several months, we have run up against a number of opportunist positions in the communist movement on the national question. Two of those which will be discussed have been encountered domestically among supporters of our paper. The third has been encountered in discussions with overseas organisations, but is also prominent today among the petite-bourgeoisie and some revisionists. The aim of this document is to outline these three errors and why they break with guiding thought of the Canadian revolution.
The erroneous lines are characterised as “left” or right opportunism. It is important to recall that these descriptions refer to the form the error takes. In essence, both “left” and right errors are on the right in that both serve imperialism.
“Left” Opportunist Position
A “left” opportunist error was recently raised in western Canada in a discussion on the right of national self-determination. The comrade held that the right should be conditional on the separating state’s continued construction of communism. If for example the Inuit chose to secede, form a capitalist state, and carry out an anti-communist campaign, it would be the responsibility of a socialist Canada to block their secession and forcibly reintegrate them.
By selectively allowing the right to national self-determination, we are effectively denying the right altogether. The inclusion of the right to national self-determination in the communist programme is essential to building the unity between the workers and oppressed nations of Canada.1 If we remove this point or only apply it selectively, we will not be able to rally the masses of the oppressed nations toward socialist revolution. Why would they fight for socialism if it only meant the replacement of imperialism with social-imperialism?
The policies that constitute national liberation: the abolition of national oppression, removal of language restrictions, the right to national self-determination, the development of the national economy, etc. – these are all concessions to the national bourgeoisie of the oppressed nation. However, the nation itself is a bourgeois phenomenon. It emerges with the development of capitalism and will be abolished with the final abolition of capitalism and emergence of the higher stage of communism. If we aim to establish unity between the proletariat and the oppressed nations, these concessions must be made. This does not mean abandoning the workers of the seceding nation which will be discussed more below.
Right Deviation #1
The first of the right opportunist positions on the national question discussed here was raised recently in a discussion in Ontario. The position was that fighting for the right to national self-determination while opposing self-determination itself is still colonial and chauvinist. Instead, we must fight for self-determination. Secession itself must be the endgoal of the revolution.
This position is similar to that of the PCR-RCP when it began to liquidate. It would often talk of support for “full self-determination” over simply the right. We see this in their Canada Day statement from 2017:
“To indigenous peoples, who have struggled so long against Canadian colonialism: keep up the struggle for legitimate national self-determination! Do not settle for ‘reconciliation’ or whatever other traps the Canadian state has set for us on our path to liberation. Nothing short of full control over our lands, resources, and people –in short, complete control over our futures as nations – will be able to overturn the effects of centuries of colonialism. And know that in the struggle for national self-determination, the Revolutionary Communist Party will be right alongside us, fighting to dismantle the prison-house of nations known as Canada.”2
It is true that self-determination, especially in a case where a nation not only makes a formal separation, but is able to develop its economy would be a blow against the imperialist bourgeoisie. However, this would not necessarily advance the cause of the proletariat of that nation. Particularly in the case of a Canadian revolution where the workers have seized power, the only beneficiary of separation in this instance would be the national bourgeoisie.
Communists must fight for a united workers’ republic of Canada. This unity cannot be based on coercion and oppression as Canada is today. Instead, each nation must have the right to self-determine and must have the ability to do so which is why Communists in Canada have emphasised the need to develop the economy in these nations, particularly their heavy industry.3
Right Deviation #2
In a recent conversation with some overseas organisations in oppressed nations, they raised the position that communists should not only fight for self-determination in their context, ally with progressive nationalists, and carry out development of the national economy. Communists in these nations must go further and become nationalist themselves. A similar position is often raised in Canada by those from the oppressed nations who just beginning to get organised. It is often the justification used for the heavy use of nationalist imagery by the Quebecois “communists” who believe they are nationally oppressed. Outside of aesthetics, the most common area this is seen is in the promotion of a moribund language that has since been replaced as the national language by English or French.
This idea is often based on a very superficial reading of the new democratic revolutions of the third world. These revolutions develop the conditions for national formation through the overthrow of imperialism and the conditions for capitalism through the overthrow of feudalism. Just as the struggle against fedualism does not mean communists must become capitalists, the struggle against imperialism does not require communists to adopt nationalism. However, allies can be made with both capitalists and nationalists in in the oppressed nations in specific instances. The communists must maintain a proletarian outlook which is in all cases internationalist not nationalist.
How this manifests in Canada has been outlined by the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) in their document Mass Line:
“Oppressed nations. Canada oppresses many nations inside its own borders. We aim to win over the oppressed nations through our fight against Canadian imperialism and a guarantee of the right to national self-determination. We will give special attention to the actions of imperialism against these oppressed nations in our agitation. We do not seek to take leadership of the national movements of the oppressed nations as they are fundamentally bourgeois movements. We aim to lead the people’s movement not the national movements. We will rally the workers and allied classes of all nations in Canada to the red flag and not to any bourgeois flag. We will not form or compete for leadership of an Inuit national organisation for example. Instead we will aim to lead the Inuit workers according to their class interests. We must educate the masses of all nations in Canada on proletarian internationalism and against bourgeoise nationalism. We must struggle against all forms of nationalism, aiming mainly at Canadian and Quebecois nationalism.”4
The Guiding Thought of the Canadian Revolution and the National Question
Rather than allowing circumstantial self-determination, a workers’ republic must allow any nation to leave and set up its own sovereign state. Whether this nation chooses to maintain socialism or go down a capitalist road, it is up to that nation. While communists must campaign against separation in any referendum on the question, if the nation votes to leave we must respect the decision.
Socialist revolution will create the conditions for the absolute equality of nations and their languages. While this will likely see a consolidation of many formerly oppressed nations, with the continued construction of communism these national distinctions will be abolished. We can see this from Stalin’s The National Question and Leninism from 1929 which showed how the liberation of the oppressed nations did not immediately lead to the abolition of national distinctions, but their development:
“It would be a mistake to think that the first stage of the period of the world dictatorship of the proletariat will mark the beginning of the dying away of nations and national languages, the beginning of the formation of one common language. On the contrary, the first stage, during which national oppression will be completely abolished, will be a stage marked by the growth and flourishing of the formerly oppressed nations and national languages, the consolidation of equality among nations, the elimination of mutual national distrust, and the establishment and strengthening of international ties among nations.
“Only in the second stage of the period of the world dictatorship of the proletariat, to the extent that a single world socialist economy is built up in place of the world capitalist economy—only in that stage will something in the nature of a common language begin to take shape; for only in that stage will the nations feel the need to have, in addition to their own national languages, a common international language—for convenience of intercourse and of economic, cultural and political cooperation. Consequently, in this stage, national languages and a common international language will exist side by side. It is possible that, at first, not one world economic centre will be formed, common to all nations and with one common language, but several zonal economic centres for separate groups of nations, with a separate common language for each group of nations, and that only later will these centres combine into one common world socialist economic centre, with one language common to all the nations.
“In the next stage of the period of world dictatorship of the proletariat—when the world socialist system of economy becomes sufficiently consolidated and socialism becomes part and parcel of the life of the peoples, and when practice convinces the nations of the advantages of a common language over national languages—national differences and languages will begin to die away and make room for a world language, common to all nations.”5
A workers’ republic must establish the economic basis of national liberation – the development of a national economy mainly through the development of heavy industry. Whether a nation remains or leaves Canada, this must be pursued. If a nation remains in Canada, the development of the formerly oppressed nation will be a function of economic planning for the country as a whole with a special emphasis on catching the more backward areas up to the rest of the country.6 If a nation leaves Canada, aiding the development of the departed nation will allow this nation to develop a national economy, weaken the grip of imperialism over this nation, and hasten the conditions for socialist revolution in the case of the nation returning to capitalism
The international relations of a socialist Canada, especially as it relates to any separated nations must adhere to the five points of peaceful coexistence. This elaboration of peaceful coexistence was originally developed in the 1954 Sino-Indian Agreement:
“1. Mutual respect for each other’s territorial integrity and sovereignty, 2. mutual non aggression, 3. mutual non-interference in each other’s internal affairs, 4. equality and co-operation for mutual benefit, and 5. peaceful co-existence.”7
While a socialist state must not deviate from these principles in state-to-state relations, the communist party must continue its support for the proletariat in all nations. Should any nation separate from Canada, the communist party will split as well along these political boundaries and assist this separated party in leading socialist revolution whether through the construction of communism or the seizure of power depending on the path the departed state chooses. We can look to the Russian Communist Party (Bolsheviks)’ support of socialist revolution in Estonia and Finland following these nations separation and continuation of capitalism.
A socialist state must develop a means for the constituent nations to make their voice heard and prevent their re-submission to national oppression by the numerically superior Quebecois and Canadian nations. It is pointless to put forward a specific proposal while we are only still fighting to rebuild our party. However, we can look to the example of the Council of Nationalities in the USSR.8
More important to communists today, how should we address the national question today? We understand the united front to be built concentrically beginning with a united proletariat, an alliance between the workers and small farmers, followed by a broader unity with the urban petite-bourgeoisie and oppressed nations. The construction of the united front in this way ensures proletarian hegemony in the united front and the future state. Within the Workers United Front, we must develop unity between the proletariat of all nations in Canada. Within the broader united front we can unite with progressive nationalists from the oppressed nations on specific positions and struggles that advance the liberation of their nations and socialist revolution. However, we must also struggle against their bourgeois outlook, particular against the line that advocates for the formation of nation-specific organisations rather than class-based organisations. Communists must go beyond declarations in support of the right to national self-determination and actively support these nations when they carry out land occupations, protests, and armed actions.
1. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
2. An Appeal on the 150th Anniversary of a Prison House of Nations – PCR-RCP
3. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
4. https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/07/25/repost-mass-line-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-by-cpcrf/
5. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1929/03/18.htm
6. This outlined further in the following document by the CPC(RF) which breaks down how the workers’ republic will allocate the social product: https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2025/04/18/repost-commentaries-on-the-programme-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction-by-cpcrf/
7. https://www.tpprc.org/documents/agreements/1954.pdf
8. ARTICLE 35. The Soviet of Nationalities is elected by the citizens of the U.S.S.R. according to Union and Autonomous Republics, Autonomous Regions and national areas on the basis of twenty-five deputies from each Union Republic, eleven deputies from each Autonomous Republic, five deputies from each Autonomous Region and one deputy from each national area. https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/stalin/works/1936/12/05.htm