The People's Hammer

Optimism: The Correct Perspective – by Matt F.



This article is a response to our criticism of the author’s original article, which can be found here.

-People’s Hammer Editorial Board

I want to start this article with a sincere thank you to the People’s Hammer Editorial Board for writing a thoughtful and positive criticism of my previous article. I will admit, a pit formed in my stomach the moment I sent it in for submission with regards to the last paragraph, but ultimately I think the dialogue that has been created here is incredibly positive for young communists. Certainly, the intention was not to dissuade anyone from communist work. There is very little to address from the criticisms presented as I agree with all of the points, so this article is instead meant to follow up and correct the poor rhetoric and ideas from my initial conclusion. I hope readers will be able to take these broad ideas and use them creatively to inspire optimism among their coworkers.

We have all met someone who says “I’m not a pessimist or an optimist, I’m a realist.” As people who understand dialectics, we understand that A) pessimism and optimism are attitudes, not crystal ball future predictions and B) in a dialectic, at any given point, one aspect of the contradiction will be principal. Equilibrium is an exception, not the norm. Thus we have to understand that optimism and pessimism are an internal struggle for positive and negative outlook and we will exhibit more of one side at times and its opposite at others.

In the conclusion of my article, despite the fact I correctly addressed maintaining a positive attitude in the section titled “Prepare for Failure” I got lost in the negative aspects of my experience and failed to look at things in an all sided manner. The Editorial Board has wonderfully coloured in the positive side of communist work, but I believe it needs further expansion.

Communist work holds many rewarding aspects generally as was outlined in the criticism, but it is important to illustrate these things specifically too. One of the most rewarding parts is the bonds formed through struggle. A shared sorrow is a sorrow halved and a shared joy is a joy doubled. Communist work involves many spectacular ups and downs with absurd, fun and interesting new ideas, places and people along the way. To form these bonds, enjoy these experiences and do it all while contributing to something that is improving the world bit by bit is really like nothing else. To get bogged down by the unpleasantness of certain aspects is to focus on the pebble in your shoe when you’ve got a mountain range standing before you. These unpleasant sides to the work have solutions both internally and externally and no communist should be alone when struggling through these challenges, no matter how small. Communist work necessitates challenge because the development of the proletariat requires us to expand ourselves, develop and rise above difficult conditions so that the future we build will be one that lasts. Every challenge is itself a joy in this sense because without challenge there is no growth.

An important disclaimer here: the social side to communist work must not be the principal motivator for starting the work. Politics must remain in command among the relationships you will form. If you are not interested in communist work for improving your own conditions, those of others and building a lasting, proletarian future, you need to reassess things and reflect on what has been influencing these decisions. With proper reflection and struggle, your goals should become more clear and you will find a place to meaningfully contribute.

From this analysis it becomes clear which is correct between optimism and pessimism. To ignore the positive sides of things and the usefulness this perspective presents us is to become detached from material reality. Pessimism is tempting and sometimes we want to take the easy way out. Pessimism promotes passivity where optimism promotes activity. When we feel especially drained, overworked, and alone, pessimism pretends it has all the answers. But idealism holds no answers. Your pessimism will only defeat you. Optimism takes more effort and time but is invigorating. Just as stated before, without challenge we will see no growth. The beauty of optimism is the habit you can make of it. When you start looking for the positive in things, you become more aware of these things generally and it becomes less challenging to maintain this outlook. For those struggling with pessimism in their work I would like to recommend an exercise. Every time you conduct agitation or meet to struggle with other communists, reflect afterwards on all of the things you think went well. Even if it felt like a complete disaster, try to think of one thing that was funny or strange or useful that stood out in the interaction. From that you can craft yourself an anchor with which you can keep your boat of optimism steady.


Response to “Optimism: The Correct Perspective – by Matt F.”

  1. Write for the People’s Hammer! – by the People’s Hammer Editorial board – The People's Hammer

    […] Optimism: The Correct Perspective – by Matt F. […]

    Like