The People's Hammer

We must Recapture Control of the IBEW – by CWIO

,


A common anti-union talking point we hear from less informed workers is that a union means you are “just paying to work.” The fact that the vast majority of negotiations take place behind closed doors between the bureaucrats and the bosses contributes to this belief, but there are also unions that engage in class-collaborationist behaviour to the point of putting arrows in the quiver of the enemies of unions. One such union is the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers(IBEW).1 We are against the domination of the Canadian labour movement by international American unions such as this one who boast 901 thousand members (only 70 thousand of whom are in Canada: 7.8%). This union has been known to be particularly dismissive of the effectiveness of strikes. This article will be focused on their use of Market Recovery Funds and their place in the class struggle in the constuction industry.

An article posted to the IBEW website explains in detail what an MRF is and what purpose it serves in IBEW’s organizing.2 After not being able to organize Thompson Electric after 30 years of effort, Jason Kish, the Business Manager for Local 115 in Kingston, Ontario made a deal with the contractor directly to organize the workers through a “top-down strategy.” The fact that the employer could be convinced that it would be beneficial for his profit-seeking enterprise to go along with this speaks volumes about what this means for the workers of Thompson Electric. Kish said specifically: “I’m not sure we could have done this without a healthy market recovery fund.”

MRFs are a type of job-targeting program that are more common in the American labour movement where they have official legal status in several states.3 They can be defined as initiatives typically established by labour unions to increase their share of the labour market. They do this by having their members contribute part of their union dues to a fund that will go back to the employer in order to remain competitive with non-union contractors. In the construction industry, most projects are offered to the company that promises to fulfill the job contract for the lowest price offered during the bidding process. So these Market Recovery Funds in construction help the union employers bid lower than would otherwise be profitable when hiring union labour. Jason Kish notes that: “It’s not always an easy sell to our members to give up some of their increase, but they do it.”4

Simple math would suggest that if the workers were contributing part of the extra wages they receive from having a union contract, and that pay goes directly back to their employers, and another part to dues, they probably aren’t making much more money than their non-union counterparts on average. In fact they could make less than the non-union workers who are able to negotiate better pay for themselves individually. In terms of wages then, the union is shooting itself in the foot by making itself less enticing to workers, and shooting themselves in the arm so that the employers know they won’t fight for better conditions for the whole working class.

This problem isn’t confined to Kingston either. In Vancouver, IBEW local 213 was found in court to have given 40% of its MRF collected from 1992 to 2002 to just 4 contractors. This was only revealed after the IBEW attempted to sue the ICBA (an association of the construction bourgeoisie) for defamation for pointing that out and losing the case.5 It must be acknowledged that the bourgeoisie also targets MRFs as they want to prioritise non-union labour and this is not our reason for opposing MRFs. In standing against MRFs we must point out that it would not be necessary to compete with non-union labour if there WAS NO non-union labour to compete against. That is why the CWIO demands the unionisation of all construction workers in the country.6

The IBEW is one of many unions that pursue class-collaboration, but this method of using MRFs to supplement employer profits and as a means to have employers install the IBEW as the representatives of their workers (where these workers were not convinced to organise with them before) is showing a dangerous trajectory of the IBEW’s overt domination by the bourgeoisie. They appear to be embracing company unionism, which is explained in greater detail in the WUF-FUO’s report on imperialism.7 The IBEW currently dominates union electrician labour in all parts of Canada outside Quebec, and represent a sizeable portion of the electricians in Quebec as well. This represents a larger dominance of the construction industry in Canada by USA-based unions such as SMART, whose local 280 in Vancouver has been the topic of a Metro Vancouver Workers United article.8 Construction worker members of the WUF-Vancouver have been involved in the CWIO’s work and continue to share their experiences with the class-collaboration of the union bureaucracy in their unions.

The CWIO has been calling out the disintegration of Canada’s construction unions since our founding at the beginning of this year.9 The unions are falling apart less from overt attacks by the bourgeoisie on the right to organise, but instead by the union bureaucracy putting their salaries above the workers they represent time and time again and proving themselves to be just interested in taking a cut from workers’ wages. Craft unionism, “No-Strike” clauses, tentative agreements that remain unratified, and Market Recovery Funds are what the union bureaucracy and the social-democrats that tie the hands of the labour movement are promising. The bourgeoisie who want open shops, “right-to work” laws or corporatism will never be opposed effectively by these flightless birds. We must build a Construction Workers’ Industrial Union that will not seek to help employers become more competitive but to seize control of production for the workers. It must organise all of the construction workers, the ones in trades not typically included in the conversation; the ones who are in Canada on precarious temporary status; the ones who are being injured and dying in droves.

We are aiming to produce more articles targeting the IBEW’s opportunism. This means we need to hear from the workers who are organised in these unions. We have heard many claims of what goes on in these union meetings, but only those who participate in these meetings and have been represented by their bureaucrats can give us the full picture. If you are a member of the IBEW please contact the CWIO by email at cwio-wuf@proton.me to take part in our upcoming online meeting that will be open to all construction workers so that we can move beyond the limits of our isolated craft union structure!

1 https://ibew.org/about-ibew/

2 https://ibew.org/electrical_worker/ontario-local-signs-longtime-organizing-target/

3 https://legal-resources.uslegalforms.com/m/market-recovery-program

4 https://ibew.org/electrical_worker/ontario-local-signs-longtime-organizing-target/

5 https://vancouversun.com/news/community-blogs/job-targeting-funds-from-ibew-213-disproportionately-allocated

6 https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/10/31/draft-programme-of-the-construction-workers-industrial-organisation/

7https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/25/report-on-the-condition-of-imperialism-and-the-workers-movement-in-canada/

8. https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/05/17/smart-local-280-a-union-for-who/

9 https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2026/01/12/a-shattered-mirror-the-disintegration-of-canadas-construction-unions-and-the-need-for-industrial-organisation/