The struggle over housing is real, urgent, and capable of drawing broad masses into action. But tenants do not constitute a class of their own, and the housing struggle cannot abolish the conditions that continually reproduce the housing crisis. If the tenant movement is to advance beyond scattered defensive battles, it must be joined to the workers’ movement and led by the proletariat.
Across Canada, the cost of housing has become an open wound. Workers surrender an ever-greater portion of their wages simply to keep a roof over their heads. A change of address can mean a crushing increase in rent. In 2022, one-third of renter households spent at least 30% of their income on shelter, more than twice the proportion of homeowners. New renters paid an average of $1,590 per month, 27% more than tenants who had remained in place.1 By 2024, residential landlords reported $63.9 billion in operating revenue.2 The contradiction is visible every payday: wages earned at work pass rapidly into the hands of landlords, banks, utilities, and other owners of property.
These conditions have produced a renewed tenant movement. Tenant associations have resisted evictions, fought renovictions, demanded repairs, exposed corporate landlords, and taught neighbours to act collectively. Such struggles deserve the support of communists and the workers’ movement. They can defend families, train new organizers, and reveal the state’s daily service to property. Yet urgency does not relieve us of the obligation to understand what kind of struggle this is, which classes participate in it, and which class must lead it.
The decisive question is therefore not whether tenants should organize. They should. The question is whether tenant organizing can substitute for organizing workers at the point of production, and whether the politics presently influential in the tenant movement can lead it beyond local and temporary concessions. On each point, the answer advanced by fashionable legalist and anarchist currents is wrong.
The Housing Question is a Working-class question
Tenants are not a class, but the housing crisis is profoundly a working-class question. This is not a contradiction. Workers form a large and particularly burdened part of the tenant population. The rent bill determines how much of a wage remains for food, transportation, children, health, and rest. Eviction can separate a worker from a job, a union local, a school, and a community. Overcrowding and distant commutes intensify the exhaustion already imposed by the working day. Housing insecurity weakens workers’ ability to strike or resist a boss, while secure and affordable housing improves their capacity to fight.
The working class therefore has every reason to struggle over rent, repairs, displacement, public housing, and homelessness. The error begins only when the location of a struggle is confused with the source of class power. Workers can fight in a building, neighbourhood, school, courtroom, or legislature, but they possess their distinctive power as a class because social production depends upon their labour. Organized workers can stop production, transportation, construction, maintenance, and distribution. They can interrupt the reproduction of capitalist society at its foundation. No collection of consumers, however numerous, occupies the same position.
Engels made this point in The Housing Question. The housing shortage is not an accidental defect that can be permanently cured while leaving capitalist production intact. Capital repeatedly produces overcrowding, displacement, speculation, and scarcity in new forms. Therefore, “the solution of the housing question” depends ultimately upon resolving the social question, abolishing the capitalist mode of production itself.3 Reforms may be fought for and won, but reformism begins when immediate demands are presented as a complete road out of the crisis. The tenant struggle should consequently be understood as one field of the broader class struggle, not as an alternative centre around which a revolutionary strategy can be built. Tenant organizing can protect workers and other oppressed people; it can expose the dictatorship of private property; and it can bring sections of the masses into collective action. But it cannot replace the central task of organizing the proletariat where it is brought together, disciplined, and exploited: at work.
The Small Capitalists and the Struggle for Leadership
The draft politics of much contemporary tenant organizing reflects the social position of the people most able to sustain activist organizations: students, academics, nonprofit employees, lower professionals, and other intermediate strata with flexible time, specialized education, or access to institutional networks. This observation must be made concretely and without turning occupation into a mechanical class label. A salaried worker does not own “the intellect” as a means of production in any useful Marxist sense. Skills are not factories, machinery, land, or capital, and highly trained employees can still be compelled to sell their labour-power and be exploited by an employer.
The small capitalist is rooted above all in small ownership and small-scale production: small proprietors, independent producers, and others whose economic position stands between proletarian labour and developed capitalist ownership. Marxist analysis has also historically examined students, lower intellectuals, clerks, and professionals as strata whose conditions and aspirations can pull them toward small capitalist politics. Mao emphasized that the small capitalist class was internally divided: its upper layers looked upward toward enrichment, its middle layers struggled to preserve an unstable independence, and its declining layers could become an important revolutionary ally.4 The category must therefore be established through concrete economic and political analysis, not assigned by insult.
Because the small capitalist is squeezed by monopoly capital, banks, large landlords, and the state, substantial sections can be won to struggle alongside the proletariat. Other sections seek individual escape through ownership, credentials, entrepreneurship, or entry into the middle-capitalist class. This produces its familiar political instability. Under proletarian leadership, its democratic anger, knowledge, and organizational capacities can strengthen a united front. Without such leadership, its outlook tends to transform material antagonisms into questions of policy expertise, moral witness, lifestyle, or organizational form.
This is visible in the tenant movement. Legalism reduces tenants to clients who must be represented by specialists before boards, courts, and city councils. Its horizon is a more balanced administration of the rental market. Anarchist horizontalism, meanwhile, treats the absence of formal leadership as liberation, even though informal leadership inevitably persists in the hands of those with the most time, confidence, contacts, and education. One current concentrates authority in lawyers and nonprofit staff; the other conceals authority inside friendship circles and unaccountable activist networks. Neither creates conscious, elected, disciplined proletarian leadership.
This criticism must not be distorted into hostility toward students, intellectuals, professionals, or small proprietors. Mao began his class analysis by asking: “Who are our enemies? Who are our friends?”5 The purpose of class analysis is to unite reliable friends against definite enemies, not to shrink the movement into a social club. Progressive small capitalist activists should be welcomed into common struggle. Their skills can make real contributions. But no allied stratum should determine the strategic orientation of a movement whose emancipation ultimately depends upon proletarian power.
What Proletarian Leadership Actually Means
Proletarian leadership is often invoked abstractly, as though it were guaranteed by placing a worker at a microphone or excluding everyone with a university degree. Neither produces a proletarian line. Leadership is a political and organizational relationship. It must be measured by which class’ interests set the movement’s objectives, which forces form its durable base, what methods it uses, and toward what larger struggle it directs its members. In the tenant movement, proletarian leadership would mean beginning with concentrations of workers rather than treating the most available activists as a substitute for them. Organizers would investigate where tenants work, which employers and industries shape a neighbourhood, where union members live, and how rent increases, evictions, and unsafe housing affect workplace organization. Building committees would remain essential, but they would be linked through accountable structures capable of adopting a common plan and concentrating forces against major landlords and the state.
The Vancouver Tenants Union illustrates both the value and the limits of present practice. It has organized building-level fights, eviction defence, and neighbourhood chapters well beyond UBC; its own published material lists active formations on the East Side, in Fairview, Mount Pleasant, the West End, Marpole, Joyce-Collingwood, the Downtown Eastside, the North Shore, and UBC.6 Any serious criticism should acknowledge these facts rather than dismiss the organization through an unsupported caricature. At the same time, its “snowflake model” gives considerable autonomy to chapters and working groups coordinated through a steering committee. As an earlier People’s Hammer criticism argued, tactical decentralization can permit local initiative, but strategic decentralization fragments campaigns and makes city-wide action dependent upon voluntary alignment.7
The answer is democratic centralism: full discussion, elected and recallable leadership, unity in carrying out decisions, systematic summation of experience, and a clear division of responsibility. A tenants’ organization needs local initiative because every building presents different conditions. It also needs central direction because corporate landlords, courts, police, banks, and municipal governments do not confront tenants one building at a time. Local committees should be the foundation of a wider organization, not isolated islands.
Proletarian leadership also means connecting tenant demands with the organized labour movement. Unions should establish housing committees, support tenant defence, mobilize members against evictions, and identify common corporate targets. Tenant organizers should help workers carry housing grievances into union meetings and should encourage employed members to organize at work. A large landlord renovating occupied buildings may employ unionized construction labour; a property manager may contract cleaners, maintenance staff, and security guards; a public campaign may involve municipal workers who administer or enforce housing policy. These links turn two separated defensive struggles into coordinated pressure upon capital. Such unity cannot mean subordinating every tenant dispute to the timetable of existing union bureaucracies. Many official labour bodies are passive, legalistic, and bound to the same electoral machinery as housing nonprofits. Rank-and-file workers must fight inside their unions to make housing a labour issue, just as they must fight to make their unions instruments of class struggle rather than grievance-processing agencies. The alliance required is between organized tenants and the workers’ movement from below, not merely between tenant executives and labour officials above.
One Movement Against Capital
The housing crisis draws many classes and strata into motion because capitalist development subjects them to the concentrated power of finance, real-estate capital, and the state in different ways. This breadth is a source of strength only if the movement distinguishes its forces instead of dissolving them into an imaginary “tenant class.” Workers, the unemployed, students, lower professionals, small proprietors, and others can fight side by side without pretending that their positions and long-term interests are identical. The proletariat must lead because it alone is collectively positioned to seize and reorganize large-scale social production. This is not a moral claim that workers are purer or suffer more than everyone else. It is a material claim about power. Housing can be removed from the market only if land, construction, finance, transportation, energy, and the production of building materials are brought under social control. The class that collectively operates these systems is the class capable of reorganizing them to meet human need.
The small capitalists cannot independently carry out this transformation. Its conditions reproduce dispersed ownership, competition, and the hope of individual advancement. Even where its left wing sincerely opposes monopoly capital, it lacks a common position in socialized production from which to reconstruct the economy as a whole. It therefore vacillates between the middle capitalists and proletariat. The progressive sections can become close allies, but the alliance advances only under a proletarian programme.
For communists, the practical conclusion is concentration rather than abstention. The main forces must be rooted among workers and in the labour movement, especially in the decisive sectors of production, construction, transportation, and logistics. Tenant work should supplement this orientation, not compete with it. Where communists intervene in housing struggles, they should organize proletarian tenants, develop mass leaders, connect buildings to workplaces, combat dependence upon professionals, and direct the struggle toward the organized power of the working class.
Tenant organizations have already demonstrated that neighbours can resist when isolation is broken. Their next advance will not come from declaring a new class into existence or multiplying autonomous committees without a common direction. It will come from building disciplined organization, distinguishing allies from enemies, and joining the fight over housing to the fight against capitalist production itself. The choice is not between tenant struggle and labour struggle. It is between a tenant movement confined to the administration of misery and a tenant movement incorporated into the struggle for workers’ power. Under capitalist leadership, the housing crisis is managed. Under small capitalist leadership, it is endlessly protested or litigated. Under proletarian leadership, every defensive battle can become a school for the larger struggle to abolish the system that makes housing a commodity and homelessness a permanent threat.
1Statistics Canada, “Housing affordability in Canada, 2022,” September 10, 2024, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/240910/dq240910b-eng.htm.
2Statistics Canada, “Real estate rental and leasing and property management industries, 2024,” March 25, 2026, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/260325/dq260325e-eng.htm.
3Frederick Engels, The Housing Question (1872–73), https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1872/housing-question/.
4Mao Tse-tung, “Analysis of the Classes in Chinese Society” (1926), https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-1/mswv1_1.htm.
5Mao Tse-tung, “Analysis of the Classes in Chinese Society” (1926), https://www.marxists.org/reference/archive/mao/selected-works/volume-1/mswv1_1.htm.
6Vancouver Tenants Union, “Get Involved,” accessed September 4, 2026, https://www.vancouvertenantsunion.ca/get_involved.
7Ivan D., “Against the Snowflake Model, for Democratic Centralism,” The People’s Hammer, April 3, 2026, https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/04/03/against-the-snowflake-model-for-democratic-centralism-ivan-d/.