Preface by the WUF
The following document was drafted shortly after the WUF became aware of the Anti-Imperialist League (AIL). It was circulated among the membership for criticism before being sent to the AIL in March. Since, AIL has agreed to respond to the document, but has failed to follow through. The WUF has also attempted to engage with the AIL in joint action through their campaign against the G7, of which Canada is a member. However, the WUF did not receive a response to this request until after the campaign had concluded.
AIL was informed of our intention to publish this criticism in early August in order to bring Canadian workers into this debate and clarify our view of the AIL. We will continue trying to engage in two-line struggle and joint action with the AIL going forward.
Introduction
In making contact with a number in international organisations such as those in Norway, USA, and Germany, the Anti-Imperialist League (AIL) has been raised as an organisation that we should make contact with. Because of this, our central committee has studied the basic public documents of the AIL and have put together the following set of questions and criticisms. We agree with much of what has been put forward, but we are not prepared to rally to the AIL while there are many disagreements between our organisations.
We believe there is no international centre for the united front and support the effort to create one, although we disagree with the way it is being built by the AIL.
Our organisation believes that wherever it is not a matter of security, it is useful to carry out two-line struggle among the masses. For this reason, we would like to suggest carrying out further debate through papers like The People’s Hammer in Canada as well as any other medium you may suggest.
We also want to offer our organisation’s founding documents for you to review. Please let us know what criticisms you have of them.
– Programme: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/about/
– Strategy and Tactics: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/2025/09/20/strategy-and-tactics-of-the-workers-united-front/
– Constitution: https://wuffuo.wordpress.com/constitution/
General Points
The basic AIL documents contain no analysis of the International League of People’s Struggles (ILPS). We believe this is an error as it is the most prominent international organisation claiming to fulfill the same role that the AIL aims to fulfill. For our part, we are opposed to the revisionism of the “Communist Party of the Philippines” and the organisations it provides ideological-political leadership to such as ILPS. In Canada, these organisations have worked to harbor rapists, collaborate actively with domestic revisionist parties, and even the social-fascist New Democratic Party! How does the AIL understand the role of the ILPS? If you believe they are united under a systematised right-opportunist line, as we do, than this should be openly stated in these documents. If you believe ILPS still plays a progressive role, why is AIL forming a separate international centre for the united front?
Why has AIL sought to build the international united front beginning from its broadest class basis of unity, rather than begin with an international centre for the left of the workers movement? We believe it is incorrect to form the united front mechanically step-by-step and recognise that all levels of the united front can be built together. However, the emphasis must be placed somewhere. In Canada, it would be fully possible to organise at the broadest scale a united front of workers, farmers, and urban petite-bourgeoisie. In fact, many revisionist organisations in Canada do just this. We believe though that in order to ensure the hegemony of the proletarian line in the united front it is a necessity to place the emphasis on the construction of the united front of workers first, unite with the small farmers, and finally rally the progressive petite-bourgeoisie around this workers front and worker-farmer alliance. All attempts in Canada to begin with a broad pan-progressive class united front have rapidly decayed into opportunism as there has been no way of ensuring proletarian hegemony.
Following from this last point, how is proletarian leadership being built within the AIL?
Has the AIL grown beyond its original signatories in Turkey, Ecuador, Brazil, and Mexico? If so, what other countries does AIL now have a presence within?
The English translations of the AIL documents available on your website are very poor. They often use acronyms from other languages such as OTAN to refer to NATO and often say what is presumably the opposite of what you intend to say as will be seen below.
What are the short term objectives of the AIL?
How is AIL preparing for its first congress?
You refer to the labour aristocracy as opportunist. We agree that the labour aristocracy are one of the main sources of opportunism along with the labour bureaucracy and at least in Canada the salaried petite-bourgeoisie. Can you elaborate on this position?
Are you able to explain what exactly the AIL means by the slogan “Unity-Struggle-Victory”?
The writing style used in the majority of your documents is highly stereotyped with the constant use of terms like lackeys, Yankees, paper tigers, and scrapheap/dustbin of history.
We believe the slogan used on many of AIL’s documents “Anti-Imperialists of the World, Unite” is a poor slogan. We should not call for unity between a globally small set of activists. Instead we should call for the unity of the two main movements of world revolution that will put down imperialism. Therefore we suggest adopting the slogan: “Workers and Oppressed Nations Unite”.
Call for Public
This document states that:
“US imperialism has been the hegemonic power since the Second World War, the imperialist redivision of the world, it is the main actor of all kinds of exploitation, plunder, unjust wars and occupations in the world.”
Can you clarify your organisation’s understanding of the USSR in the years from 1956-1991? We believe that in this period there was no hegemonic superpower, rather we had two superpowers competing for hegemony.
The document states there is a commodification of people not just labour-power under capitalism which would mean slavery, but in the next paragraph you state slavery is on the rise:
“For the capitalist system, everything serves as a commodity in order to make a profit and utilise it for the expanded reproduction of capital. People, communities, other living beings and nature itself have no other meaning for the capitalist system than to be a commodity with which profit can be made. These relations of production and distribution are the cause of all humanity’s problems. This system is not limited to realising itself only through economic exploitation, or in other words, these relations of production and distribution create forms of man and society that are suitable for this. With the ideological and cultural hegemony that it creates, it creates human and social forms that obey it and accept the existing as a necessity. Although it is the source of the problems, it forces the problems to occur outside itself. It aims to ensure that the solution to the problems is to turn in on oneself and hope for help from oneself. Therefore, we must fight against the capitalist system, we must fight on different fronts in order to centralise all these areas of resistance and struggle as much as possible so as not to break the link between them and direct them towards the main source that creates the problems.
“Poverty, unemployment, labour conditions under slavery, access to the most basic human rights is becoming more difficult every day, unjust wars are increasing, tens of millions of people are leaving their land and becoming refugees. The displacement of millions of peasant masses and indigenous peoples from their land through the appropriation of agricultural land in the interests of international monopolies and large landowners, the spread of racist, fascist and religious organisations, the unimaginable destruction of nature are the visible results of the imperialist order of plunder and pillage in which we live.”
Does the AIL believe that the worker himself is a commodity or was this just a poetic way to describe the situation?
Programme and Process
The basis of unity given by the AIL is a laundry list of “anti-”s. You state that:
“The Anti-imperialist League is an anti-imperialist, anti-capitalist, anti-fascist, anti-feudal and anti-bureaucratic-capitalist formation. It stands against imperialism, fascism, racism, discrimination and all kinds of reaction.”
Much of this seems redundant and can be boiled down to saying that the AIL is anti-imperialist. If you are anti-imperialist, then you are anti-capitalist and anti-bureaucrat capitalist as imperialism is capitalism today and bureaucrat capitalism can only exist under conditions of imperialism. Anti-feudalism is also unnecessary to add to this list as feudalism is maintained in countries today through an alliance of landlords with the imperialists.
Fascism is a system of government that only exists in the context of imperialism.
We do not believe that these additional points of unity are incorrect, but rather that listing them out weakens the programme. For example, there are still states today with a slave-holding economy. Why is anti-slavery not listed if anti-feudalism and anti-bureaucrat capitalism are? Another example would be how you declare yourself anti-fascist, but not anti-liberal or anti-postmodern? We believe that a programme should be as succinct as possible with all unnecessary additions removed.
We disagree with the idea that an organisation of this type should be opposed to discrimination broadly, as it should discriminate to the fullest on the basis of class toward the big bourgeoisie, landlords, and other reactionary classes such as the middle bourgeoisie in Canada.
How does the AIL understand democratic centralism? The document states that:
“The Anti-imperialist League is open to the participation of all organizations and individuals who define themselves as anti-imperialist and accept the program and principles of the AIL. The AIL accepts as members all individuals and organizations that accept the principle of democratic centralism and the program of the AIL.”
This implies that the AIL has a federal structure allowing both individual and organisational affiliation. We believe that an organisation of this type cannot be formed by the conglomeration of individuals and organisations. Rather, it should be built from the highest body, the congress, down to the lowest body whatever this may be. Organisations that chose to affiliate should rally to the AIL where they can be reorganised as part of a single organisation. The federal structure outlined is incompatible with democratic centralism. If this contradiction is not resolved early on, it will easily lead to factionalism within the organisation. This situation is similar to that of the Communist Party of Canada in the 1920s which was similarly established with a federal structure and commitment to democratic centralism.
We want to ask clarification on this point:
“8) The Anti-imperialist League recognizes the current and historical task of the working class. It opposes policies that exacerbate the exploitation of the working class and aim to disperse it and render it powerless against capital by forcing disorganization. It supports the class unions in which the economic and democratic rights and demands of the working class are expressed and in which the struggle for these demands is organized jointly. It endeavors to realize the unity and class solidarity of the class trade unions at national and international level. It involves the struggle to make class unity dominant within unions that capitulate and agree with the bourgeoisie.”
We understand power to exclusively mean political power. In this sense, the proletariat have no power anywhere in the world. This is not a result of policies, but by virtue of living under a dictatorship of the bourgeoisie. AIL seems to fall into the view that organisation by itself constitutes power in some way. We also would like clarification on what is meant by a “class union”? What is its relation to what syndicalists refer to varyingly as “class struggle unions”, “militant unions”, “fighting unions”, etc.?
How does AIL aim to build these class unions? Do its national sections bore from within the existing unions, do you form separate revolutionary ones, or do you conduct entryism. We are asking generally as obviously differences will arise country to country.
How is AIL working to unite these class unions internationally?
The document states:
“The crisis-producing character of the imperialist system inevitably develops the tendency of society to become militarized and fascist.”
Can you elaborate, does AIL believe that under imperialism all capitalist states will end up under a fascist government unless they are overthrown?
Can you clarify your position on the right to national self-determination? We recognise this right exclusively among nations, but not national minorities. However, the AIL states that this right must be recognised for both:
“10) The Anti-imperialist League fights against discrimination, racism and national oppression by the imperialists and the submissive, collaborating ruling classes. It unconditionally defends the right to self-determination of national minorities and oppressed nations.”
We disagree with your position on child labour:
“17) The Anti-imperialist League defines the fight for the prohibition of child labor as one of its most important tasks.”
We believe this is a bourgeois outlook. We fight instead for poly-technical education where children are formed through both productive labour and intellectual study. In a broad sense, we may agree to an end to the super-exploitation of children and youth under capitalism, but we oppose a prohibition of child labour altogether.
Point 21 states:
“The Anti-imperialist League directly represents the anti-imperialist goals of the environmental movement. The Anti-imperialist League fights against the destruction of nature and the habitats of all living beings, including humans, for the purpose of profit maximization. When it comes to environmental issues, the well-being of people and the protection of their habitats come first.
“It fights against the destruction of the natural environment, against imperialist mega-projects that destroy the traditional habitats of farmers and indigenous peoples, and against all forms of oppression of indigenous peoples.”
Where does the AIL draw the line on opposing mega-projects where no oppressed nation is found? Do you oppose railways, bridges, and nuclear plants? Many of these projects can improve the lives of the people and improve the environment in the long-run, but may be “mega-projects” with an immediate negative environmental impact. How do you determine what is a mega-project that can be supported against one that should be fought against?
Our final question on this document relates to the following point:
“11) The Anti-imperialist League opposes the suppression and disregard of religious and sectarian beliefs and sees this as part of the struggle for democracy.”
What is meant by disregard? We assume this is a translation error as this implies that the AIL stands for the promotion of religion if it opposed both suppression and simple disregard.
We also believe that there is a need for some degree of suppression. In Canada, many provinces operate confessional education systems. This needs to be outright abolished in favour of secular education. The catholic church also holds a number of privileges in society that need to be stripped away. We agree that religious beliefs among the proletariat and masses should not be treated antagonistically. However, we must take a firm stance in favour of atheistic education and the removal of the church from public life.
Ideological Political
This document confuses the main force and leading force in the struggle against imperialism when it states:
“The proletariat is the main force of the anti-imperialist struggle.”
We do not believe this is true. The proletariat lead the struggle, but the main force in the world today is most likely the peasantry who vastly outnumber the proletariat.
Can you clarify your position here, there seems to have been a translation error:
“therefore, all anti-people economic, political, military, cultural and ideological reaction originating from and produced by the ruling system will be possible only with the ideological hegemony of the proletariat. The real liberation of all oppressed classes and strata and oppressed peoples and nations will be possible only through the leadership of the proletariat.”