Introduction
Workers control means different things to different people. The slogan is used by communists, anarchists, and even some liberals and fascists each to refer to very different ideas. It is very rare that workers tend to have the communist understanding of workers’ control in mind. More likely, they are thinking of a cooperative. The sole commonality between all forms workers’ control takes is that they all involve some degree of worker participation in management.
Forms of Workers’ Control
Codetermination
In a regular capitalist enterprise, a company’s management is wholly selected by the body above it up to the ownership. In the late 1800s-mid 1900s, some European states introduced codetermination as a form of limited workers’ control. It requires companies of a given size to allocate a portion of their management to workers’ representatives. For example, a country may require any factory employing 500 people or more to allocate half of its senior management to workers’ representatives. Codetermination is a liberal means of mitigating class struggle. While the workers gain a say in how they are exploited under this system, it does nothing to change the productive relations. The bourgeoisie still own the means of production and the profits generated still only accumulate individually. While the occupation of an entreprise and its management by the workers prior to its full capture is useful in developing the class consciousness of the workers, codetermination does not even do this as the worker representatives work alongside the bourgeois representatives rather than replacing them. In the example of an occupation or other forms of workers control, the workforce is brought into the management of the enterprise through general assemblies, votes, and other means. In the example of codetermination, a small set of workers may be elected or appointed as management, but the workforce as a whole remains outside of the running of the entreprise.
Cooperatives1
A worker cooperative is a company owned and run by the workers. Each worker owns a portion that is non-transferable and cannot be taken with them when they leave the company. Cooperatives are generally the go-to when workers begin to discuss workers’ control. This is because they are the most elementary form of collective ownership and are fully able to operate under capitalism making it a lot simpler to imagine.
Under capitalism, worker cooperatives are forced to act as any other capitalist entreprise in order to survive. Capitalist markets are chaotic leading to cyclical, worsening, and more frequent crises. Worker cooperatives do nothing to calm this anarchy. Worker cooperatives are forced into competition with the bourgeoisie who have much more capital and connections than the workers. The result of this competition is either the introduction of capitalist measures in the cooperative (ex. progressively transferring capital assigned to labour-power toward means of production causing lay-offs), de-mutualisation, or elimination and centralisation of the cooperative’s capital by the larger bourgeois cartel in the industry. In either case, the worker cooperative under capitalism must abide by the laws of capitalism.
The cooperative is seen as the basis of the socialist economy by syndicalists. While the capitalist cooperatives of today are forced into competition with a better equipped bourgeoisie, in the syndicalist view this obstacle is removed by the seizure of the entirety of the bourgeoisie’ capital by the workers who operate their factories across the whole of society. While this resolves the contradiction between bourgeois and proletarian entreprises, anarchy of production remains as the proletarian entreprises are set into competition with one another.
Most syndicalists aim to resolve this by organising the cooperatives into their respective industrial union. As cooperatives are the most elementary form of collective ownership, they remain marked by capitalist relations such as a division of mental and manual labour, separation of management (elected or not) from the mass of workers, material incentives, etc. This provides a fertile base for the restoration of capitalism as can be seen in Yugoslavia which was similarly organised on the basis of cooperatives. What would become of this syndicalist structure in the case of capitalist restoration? It would form ready-made corporations for a social-fascist regime.
The communist form of cooperatives are saved from the limitations of cooperatives formed under capitalism as well as in the syndicalist model. They are not placed into competition with other private entreprises, instead they are integrated into the economic planning of the state. Cooperatives additionally form a crucial means of winning the small bourgeoisie to the revolution by gradually abolishing their bourgeois right rather than doing so overnight. The cooperative’s property may be collectively owned, but it is still private property. This is in contrast to the state sector which under socialism should be both the leading and main form of ownership. Cooperatives act as a means to move from the fully private property of the small bourgeoisie toward unity with state-ownership in the property of the people as a whole which will characterise the higher stage of communism.2
Employee-Ownership3
Employee ownership comes in two main forms. The first and most common makes shares of the company available to the workers on a one-off or regular basis. We can see this with Starbucks which is not mainly owned by the workers, but all workers receive shares on a regular basis once they pass probation.
The second form is sole ownership by the workers. In this system, all owners must be employees of the company. We can see this with a company like EllisDon.
Unlike a cooperative, shares in the company are transferable. There may be restrictions on who can purchase them as in the case of sole ownership. Another difference is that there can be workers without ownership such as those that sold their shares or who never bought in.
Employee ownership does nothing to advance the fight for communism. Like codetermination, employee ownership masks class struggle by hiding the worker-capitalist contradiction behind a screen of cooperation between partners. Even where the company as a whole is owned by workers, it only creates a new bourgeoisie made up of former workers who have specialised their work into managerial positions similar to what happens under codetermination.
Corporatism
A corporation is an organisation whose aim is the resolution of class contradictions in a given industry. It aims to unite the employer cartels and the unions into a single organisation. While they are presented to the workers as above class struggle, in reality they are just another tool of the bourgeoisie to carry out class struggle against the workers.
Corporatism in Canada exists in a very limited form. We can see it in organisations like Canadian Work Strategies.4 It has also been institutionalised in the form of joint labour-management committees which by law must exist in all union workplaces. This does not mean all unions in Canada are in reality corporations, but the seeds of this transformation exist and all unions participate in corporatist bodies.
Corporations often allow for some degree of workers control as members of the corporation. However, this participation in decision making is often symbolic and superficial. As members of the corporation participating at a lower level, the workers may have greater input. However, with each level of management, this participation would die out until at the top of the company the workers’ voice is drowned out completely.
Under the Italian Social Republic, there was a push to further entrench corporations by transferring ownership from individual capitalists to the corporation as a whole. This was meant to further erode class contradictions as all would be working toward the same goal not only politically but economically. This late form of Italian corporatism is essentially the same as the social-fascist regime in Yugoslavia or what would occur under a syndicalist form of socialism.
Nationalisation
Nationalisation is the process by which the state takes ownership of an enterprise or industry. Under capitalism, nationalisation often benefits the workers relative to purely private ownership by putting it under some degree of public scrutiny and increasing the ability of the workers to access the nationalised industry. Public healthcare, education, and transportation are all examples of this. The main beneficiaries of capitalist nationalisation are the big bourgeoisie embedded in the state bureaucracy. The bourgeoisie as a whole benefit as well from the relative stabilisation to capitalism nationalisation provides by reeling in some of the anarchy of production. On its own, nationalisation can improve the lives of the workers but it is the bourgeoisie who benefit the most.
The Guiding Thought and Workers Control
When communists talk about workers control, we are referring to the formation of worker councils and factory committees, the application of the Angang constitution, and socialist nationalisation.
The basic unit of the socialist state is the workers council. From the lowest to the highest state body, the workers council is characterised by its basis on industrial units, the recallability of its delegates, democratic centralism, and the unity of legislative and executive power.5 The basic form of the workers council is the factory committee – a body elected and accountable to a general assembly of workers.
The bourgeoisie and bureaucracy will attempt to stifle workers’ control over production by transferring power to managers and experts. Following the restoration of capitalism, a return to one-man rule in the workplace is always one of the first steps taken. The workers in China’s Anshan Iron and Steel Company developed a management system that ensured the preservation of workers’ control and the subordination of the bourgeoisie to the proletariat. It was developed in opposition to the Magang constitution of Magnitogorsk Iron and Steel Works which emphasised control by experts and one-person rule. This system is commonly referred to as the Angang Constitution involving the participation of cadres in labour and workers in management, reform of unreasonable regulations, and three-in-one combinations of workers, technicians, and cadres. This system ensures politics remains in command of production, maintains unity between the workers and the party, and preserves workers’ control.
The Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) has applied the Angang constitution to Canada with its call for “Participation of workers in management and participation of managers, officials, and technicians in production. Overturning of all unnecessary regulations. Management of all worksites by the elected workers’ committees.”6
Each workplace and workplace committee cannot operate independent of the broader economy. This would result in a return to anarchic production and the crises that come with it. Every workplace in Canada is reliant on the rest of the economy for inputs to production and for circulation of commodities produced. The workers cannot only seize power in each individual factory. They must seize power country-wide. With the seizure of power by the proletariat must come the nationalisation of those sectors of the economy formerly held by the big and middle bourgeoisie and overall economic planning.
Under capitalism, we should still fight for more limited forms of workers control through the formation of workers councils and their taking on of tasks held by the bourgeoisie. The Workers United Front of Canada has explained in their Strategy and Tactics the relation between the fight for limited forms of workers control and the final form outlined above:
“The WUF will fight to take ever increasing control of industry from the bourgeoisie. The final goal of this is the total nationalisation of the property of the big and middle bourgeoisie’s in a workers’ republic.
“In all organising drives, strikes, negotiations, and other fights, the WUF will push for more and more control to be taken by the workers through their shop committees. This includes the election of managers by the workers, management by shop committees, abolition of dues check-off, auditing of the company books, etc.
“Outside of the workplace, the WUF will organise the workers to provide their own relief against the capitalist offensive. The workers will be organised to accept and distribute the aid they receive from the state and its non-profit arm. The WUF will further organise the workers to provide their own relief.
“These limited forms of workers’ control should only be seen as a base to agitate for total nationalisation under a workers’ republic.”7
1 A longer criticism of cooperatives can be found in the article Centralisation of Credit Unions in Manitoba and Dead-End of Cooperatives
2 This process is described in the Programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction): “Abolition of private property, transformation of state and collective property into the property of all of society, administration of the economy by and in the interests of the whole of society”
3 This form is discussed more in the article Canadian Work Strategies: A Fascist Front in the Labour Movement
4 Ibid.
5 https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
6 Ibid.
7 Strategy and Tactics of the Workers United Front of Canada
Responses to “Forms of Workers Control – by Daniel H.”
[…] 25https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/10/02/forms-of-workers-control-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike
[…] 12https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/10/02/forms-of-workers-control-by-daniel-h/ […]
LikeLike