The People's Hammer

The Popular Democracy Movement is a New Bottle filled with Old Revisionism – by Ivan D.



The Popular Democracy Movement founded in 2024 in response to what it describes as the failures of Canada’s political institutions and the “so-called leftist parties”. PDM argues that the advance of the far right requires a new “competent and unifying mass organization.”1 It surrounds this project with an unmistakably communist political culture. Its members speak as comrades, organise Marxist educational events, celebrate the October Revolution, recommend Lenin, Stalin, Marx and Engels to their membership, and denounce NATO and cultivate international relations with organisations calling themselves communist.2

First of note, the organisation is considerably less new than it appears. PDM’s General Secretary, Tyson Strandlund, was until only a few years ago a significant figure in the Communist Party of Canada. Strandlund himself states that he sat on both the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Canada and the Central Executive Committee of the Young Communist League.3 Earlier public material identifies him as an organiser of the Communist Party’s Victoria club and a member of the YCL Central Executive Committee, while he repeatedly stood as a Communist candidate on Vancouver Island.4

This fact is not itself an accusation. A communist can emerge from a revisionist organisation by breaking with its political line. What matters is whether such a rupture occurred. Strandlund says that his departure involved “political, personal, and other differences,” but does not identify the parliamentary road, the CPC’s conception of the capitalist state or its anti-monopoly transitional strategy as the basis of his break.5 When we turn from his biography to PDM’s programme, the reason becomes obvious: the essential revisionist conception of the state has not been rejected. It has been carried into the new organisation.

“Transform This Capitalist State”

PDM provides the most concise possible summary of its politics in one of its six founding principles. Under the heading “Democratise the Economy,” it declares:

“Transform this capitalist state so that it serves people, not the rich.”

It then tells its readers where to begin:

“START by building a comprehensive and truly progressive tax system.”6

There is scarcely any need for communists to caricature such a position. PDM has stated the reformist conception of the state in its purest form. The Canadian state, according to this formulation, is something that presently serves the rich but can be transformed until it serves the people. The problem is therefore not the class character of the state itself but the policies pursued through it and the social interests presently exerting control over it. Change taxation, reconstruct democracy, constrain monopoly capital, and a state constructed upon capitalist social relations can apparently be converted progressively into an instrument of popular rule. This is precisely the question upon which Marxism and revisionism have historically divided. In State and Revolution, Lenin returned repeatedly to Marx’s conclusion from the Paris Commune that the working class cannot simply take possession of the existing machinery of the bourgeois state and wield it for different purposes. Lenin stressed that Marx’s position meant exactly the opposite of gradual transformation: the working class must break up and smash the ready-made state machinery, substituting new organs of proletarian political power for the institutions through which the bourgeoisie exercises its dictatorship.7

What makes PDM’s position especially revealing is that ignorance cannot plausibly explain the contradiction. PDM’s own recommended reading list places Lenin’s State and Revolution in its section on “Marxist Philosophy and Fundamentals,” alongside What Is To Be Done?, The Communist Manifesto, Stalin’s Foundations of Leninism and Rosa Luxemburg’s Reform or Revolution?8 This produces an almost absurd contradiction between PDM’s educational work and PDM’s programme. It recommends that its members study a book whose central argument is that the working class cannot transform the existing bourgeois state machinery into its own instrument, and then instructs those same members to “transform this capitalist state so that it serves people.” This contradiction captures the essence of revisionism more clearly than any accusation could. Marxism is retained as study material while its revolutionary conclusions disappear from political practice.

Communists do not oppose progressive taxation. We struggle for every concession that improves the material position of the working class and shifts the burden of the capitalist crisis toward the bourgeoisie. But a progressive tax system does not alter which class owns the means of production, nor does it transform the police, military, courts, bureaucracy and parliamentary machinery of capitalist rule into organs of proletarian power. Reform is one terrain of class struggle. It is not a method by which the bourgeois state gradually ceases to be bourgeois. PDM erases that distinction.

From Justin Trudeau to “People’s Power”

The same political line appears in PDM’s principle “Renew Democracy.” It declares that Canada’s established parties “serve the elite,” that “people’s power” must rejuvenate democracy, and that Canada’s political rules must be reconfigured. What is the first concrete step toward this alleged people’s power?

PDM answers:

“START by realizing the prime minister’s 2015 promise to create a truly representative democratic system.”9

The “prime minister” in question is Justin Trudeau.

Here the gulf between revolutionary language and reformist substance becomes almost comical. A movement that organises October Revolution banquets and recommends Lenin’s writings to its membership begins its programme for “people’s power” with the fulfillment of an abandoned Liberal Party campaign promise. Again, communists have no principled objection to struggling for electoral reform. Proportional representation can expand democratic space and weaken certain mechanisms through which bourgeois parties monopolise parliamentary representation. Communists struggle to defend and expand democratic rights because these rights make it easier for the working class to organise. Democratic reform within a bourgeois state and proletarian political power are not the same thing. PDM’s formulation obscures this distinction by speaking of democracy without establishing its class content. The Canadian state is treated as a political structure whose rules can be made sufficiently representative that “people’s power” develops through their reform. Marxism begins from the opposite direction. It asks which class holds political power, which class controls the decisive means of production, which class commands the organised apparatus of coercion, and what institutions must replace that apparatus when one ruling class is overthrown by another. Without those questions, “people’s power” becomes an empty phrase into which nearly any progressive reform can be poured.

The CPC Programme With the Serial Numbers Filed Off

The continuity between PDM and Strandlund’s former organisation becomes even clearer when PDM’s principles are compared with the programme of the Communist Party of Canada. The CPC advocates the construction of a broad “democratic, anti-monopoly, anti-imperialist alliance.” This alliance is supposed to pursue electoral advances and ultimately establish an anti-monopoly government based on a parliamentary majority, acting alongside extra-parliamentary movements. The CPC says such a government would restrict finance capital, redistribute wealth, extend public ownership and introduce democratic reforms to increase “popular control and administration of the Canadian state.” Its programme specifically proposes sweeping taxation of corporate profits and individual wealth as part of this process.10

Compare this with PDM’s programme: a broad popular movement; renewed democracy; progressive taxation; restraints upon the rich; peace and national independence; and the transformation of the capitalist state so that it serves the people. The resemblance is not incidental. It is the same political logic compressed into six attractive infographics. Indeed, on the immediate question of the state PDM’s public programme is in one respect less revolutionary even on paper than the current CPC programme. The CPC formally maintains that eventually the “old capitalist state” must be replaced by a “new socialist state” and even continues to describe working-class rule as the dictatorship of the proletariat.11 This does not rescue its anti-monopoly parliamentary road from revisionism; it merely means that the CPC formally postpones the revolutionary rupture to a future stage. PDM does not even clearly make that distinction. Its founding programme simply proposes to transform “this capitalist state.” Thus the emergence of PDM should not be understood merely as a younger group breaking organisationally with an old and stagnant Communist Party. Politically, it appears much closer to an attempt to renovate the same general line: remove the institutional baggage, stale electoral image and declining apparatus while retaining the basic conception of popular democratic transformation. The bottle is new. The political contents are remarkably familiar.

A Mass Organisation Under the Leadership of Which Class?

PDM’s founding statement says that the successes of the far right demand a “competent and unifying mass organization.”12 Communists certainly require broad mass organisations. The proletariat cannot make revolution as an isolated minority preaching only to itself. It must unite around itself every section of the masses whose conditions bring them into struggle against monopoly capital, imperialism and reaction. But Marxism never speaks merely of unity. It asks: unity of whom, under whose leadership, around what programme, and toward what political objective? PDM’s language of “the people” repeatedly obscures this problem. Its programme does not establish the independent organisation of the proletariat as the foundation upon which wider popular unity must be constructed. Instead, workers appear as one constituency within a broad democratic movement whose common political denominator is opposition to the elite, war, discrimination and the far right.

This is particularly dangerous when antifascism becomes the principal strategic justification for popular unity. If the distinction between proletarian politics and bourgeois democracy is already blurred, antifascism can easily become the defence and rejuvenation of the “democratic” institutions of capitalist rule against their reactionary degeneration. The working class then becomes the most militant foot soldier of progressive bourgeois democracy rather than an independent class preparing itself to rule. The communist method is different. Broad alliances are necessary, but the proletariat must retain ideological, political and organisational independence within them. It must struggle to become the leading force of the wider masses rather than disappear politically inside them.

On the Picket Line With What Strategy?

PDM’s second newsletter reports enthusiastically on the 2025 BCGEU strike. It notes that PDM members joined workers on Victoria picket lines and concludes that the settlement demonstrated “the effectiveness of union organising and a militant labour movement.”13 Communists are not simply the most enthusiastic outside supporters of trade-union struggles. Their distinctive task is to organise inside the working class: to help workers build independent rank-and-file organisation, struggle against class collaboration, connect economic struggles across workplaces and industries, develop workplace committees and militant opposition where necessary, and transform the proletariat from a class fighting over the conditions of its exploitation into a class conscious of its ability to govern society.

PDM’s public programme offers virtually nothing on this question. Its newsletter demonstrates solidarity with organised workers, but solidarity is not the same thing as a strategy for working-class organisation. The proletariat remains largely one component of “the people” rather than the class whose organisation and political leadership must constitute the backbone of revolutionary transformation. For communists, this is not a secondary organisational disagreement. It flows directly from the question of state power. If socialism is conceived principally as the transformation and democratisation of existing political institutions, then workers need mainly to provide sufficient social force behind progressive political change. If socialism requires the overthrow of bourgeois rule and construction of another class power, workers must develop their own independent organisations capable eventually of exercising authority themselves.

Marxism in the Study Hall and Reformism in Practice

PDM’s newsletter makes much of its regular seminars on Marxist theory. It reports educational work on dialectical and historical materialism, the national question and Marxist feminism.14 Its October Revolution banquet featured communist symbolism, the singing of the Internationale and recorded greetings from representatives of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation and its youth organisation, who congratulated PDM as “communists in Canada” and spoke of struggling for a “shared socialist future.”15 This produces the central contradiction of the organisation in concentrated form. PDM teaches Marxism, celebrates revolutionary history, recommends State and Revolution, etc. But when PDM formulates its own political programme, the revolutionary theory of the state disappears. There is no clear statement of the dictatorship of the proletariat. Instead there is a progressive tax system, electoral reform, environmental policy, peace diplomacy and the transformation of “this capitalist state.” The revolutionary classics are turned into objects of study while the political line remains revisionist.

A New Organisation Is Not Necessarily a New Line

Communists should not respond to PDM with childish sectarianism. Where its members stand with striking workers, communists can struggle beside them. Where PDM opposes NATO aggression, or attacks upon democratic rights, practical unity is entirely possible. No serious communist believes that every mass action must first be ideologically homogeneous. But unity in struggle requires independence in politics. The WUF must therefore be clear about what separates revolutionary communism from the politics being advanced by PDM. We struggle for reforms, but we do not turn reform into a strategy for gradually changing the class character of the state. We defend democratic rights, but we do not confuse a more representative bourgeois parliament with people’s power. We participate in broad mass movements, but we do not dissolve the proletariat into an undifferentiated “people.” We support workers’ struggles, but we seek to build workers’ independent organisation within production itself. We oppose imperialism, but our internationalism begins from the independent interests of the proletariat rather than diplomatic alignment between states. Above all, communists tell the working class the truth about political power.

The Canadian state does not serve the bourgeoisie accidentally. It does not serve capital because the wrong party won an election, because corporations evade too much tax or because Canada’s voting system is insufficiently representative. It is a bourgeois state because Canadian society is capitalist and the bourgeoisie is the ruling class. Its institutions have developed historically as the political machinery through which capitalist property and capitalist class rule are reproduced and defended. It cannot simply be transformed until it serves the proletariat, but must ultimately be replaced by the organised political power of another class.

PDM’s General Secretary has left the Communist Party of Canada. The PDM has adopted a new name, new organisational structures and a fresher public image. Its members may well be more energetic than the moribund organisations from which some of them emerged. But new organisation is not ideological rupture. When a movement led by a former member of the CPC Central Committee tells workers to “transform this capitalist state so that it serves people,” begins the road to “people’s power” with the fulfillment of Justin Trudeau’s abandoned electoral-reform promise, and reproduces the basic democratic, anti-monopoly logic of the revisionist organisation from which its leading cadre came, communists should say plainly what has occurred. It is an old and moribund line being repackaged in a new bottle.

1Popular Democracy Movement, “About.” PDM states that it was founded in 2024 in response to the failures of Canadian political institutions and “so-called leftist parties,” and says the advance of the far right requires a “competent and unifying mass organization.”

2Popular Democracy Movement, Newsletter, Issue #2, May 14, 2026, especially pp. 8–11. The newsletter documents the October Revolution banquet, Marxist educational seminars and participation in the BCGEU strike.

3Popular Democracy Movement, “An Interview with Salam Hamdan,” March 27, 2026. Strandlund states: “I actually used to be a member of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Canada, and on the Central Executive Committee of the Young Communist League until a couple years ago,” adding that the departure involved “political, personal, and other differences.”

4VoteMate, “Tyson Riel Strandlund, Communist for Langford-Juan de Fuca,” 2020, identifies Strandlund as organiser of the CPC’s Victoria club and a member of the YCL Central Executive Committee. Communist Party and election records also document repeated Communist candidacies on Vancouver Island.

5Popular Democracy Movement, “An Interview with Salam Hamdan,” March 27, 2026. Strandlund states: “I actually used to be a member of the Central Committee of the Communist Party of Canada, and on the Central Executive Committee of the Young Communist League until a couple years ago,” adding that the departure involved “political, personal, and other differences.”

6Popular Democracy Movement, “Democratise the Economy,” one of PDM’s six basic principles. The graphic states: “Transform this capitalist state so that it serves people, not the rich” and proposes beginning with “a comprehensive and truly progressive tax system.”

7V. I. Lenin, The State and Revolution, Chapter III. Lenin stresses Marx and Engels’ conclusion from the Paris Commune that “the working class cannot simply lay hold of the ready-made state machinery and wield it for its own purposes,” explaining that Marx meant the working class must break up or smash the existing state machinery.

8Popular Democracy Movement, “Reading & Viewing List,” Section 2, “Marxist Philosophy and Fundamentals.” The list includes Lenin’s The State and Revolution and What Is To Be Done?, Marx and Engels’ Communist Manifesto, Luxemburg’s Reform or Revolution?, and Stalin’s Foundations of Leninism.

9Popular Democracy Movement, “Renew Democracy.” PDM calls for “people’s power” to rejuvenate Canadian democracy and says to begin by “realizing the prime minister’s 2015 promise to create a truly representative democratic system.”

10Communist Party of Canada, Canada’s Future Is Socialism: Program of the Communist Party of Canada, Chapter 6, “For a People’s Government,” paras. 314–320, pp. 47–48. The CPC advocates a “democratic, anti-monopoly, anti-imperialist alliance,” electoral advances, an anti-monopoly government “based on a parliamentary majority,” expanded public ownership, redistribution, tax reform and increased “popular control and administration of the Canadian state.”

11Communist Party of Canada, Canada’s Future Is Socialism, paras. 364–373, p. 55. The CPC formally describes socialist political power as working-class rule, retains the term “dictatorship of the proletariat,” and states that a socialist government must “replace the old capitalist state by a new socialist state.”

12Popular Democracy Movement, “About.” PDM states that it was founded in 2024 in response to the failures of Canadian political institutions and “so-called leftist parties,” and says the advance of the far right requires a “competent and unifying mass organization.”

13Popular Democracy Movement, Newsletter, Issue #2, p. 11. PDM reports members joining BCGEU picket lines in Victoria and describes the settlement as demonstrating “the effectiveness of union organising and a militant labour movement.”

14Popular Democracy Movement, Newsletter, Issue #2, p. 9. PDM reports regular seminars in dialectical and historical materialism, the national question and Marxist feminism.

15Popular Democracy Movement, Newsletter, Issue #2, p. 8. The newsletter reports its annual October Revolution banquet, including recorded greetings from representatives of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation and Communist Youth Union of the Russian Federation, who congratulated PDM members “as communists in Canada” and spoke of a “shared socialist future.”