The People's Hammer

On Prostitution Part 1: “Sex work is not work” – By Bessy

, ,


The past few decades have been dominated by discussion about “sex work” collapsing all types of prostitution into one category. This is first of all not true, and as Marxists we should take time to assess the make up of this industry. This first part will argue against the dominant slogan “sex work is work.”

To accomplish this I will paint a picture of the landscape of the industry’s economy in order to establish a class-based understanding of different jobs within the industry. In the second part, I will go over a recent “sex strike” of strippers in Montreal during the Formula 1 races. From there, the last segment will move to break apart the discourse of “decriminalization” in Canada using China in the 1950’s as a counter example of a socialist approach to the resolution of sexual exploitation.

In 2014 under the Harper government, the state enacted Bill C-36, the Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act which made massive changes to laws around prostitution in the country by treating prostitution as a type of sexual exploitation. What this means is that anyone selling sexual services is protected from criminal liability, but the person obtaining or communicating for the purpose of obtaining sex is subject to criminal liability. The act also allows some flexibility to prostitutes to advertise their own sexual services, but prohibits any advertisement that is promotion of another person. The last part of the act criminalizes profiting off prostitution (for example pimping). This was a major change to the previous Canadian law which generally outlawed everything.i

Accessing numbers on prostitution is difficult in Canada because it is an illegal economy. However, there are general statistics based on police arrests and some research papers. A federal government initiative identified that 94% were women and girls, 67% had been coerced into providing sexual services. 81% of these clients expressed wanting to exit the sex trade, and half of them have previously attempted to leave at least once. ii Those who returned to the sex trade did so because of poverty, drug addiction, or homelessness.

Impoverishment is one of the main motivators for women to enter into prostitution.iii

There is very little data on stripping in Canada, but British data shows that at least one-third of strippers are students who are using the money to pay for their education.iv Stripping is also not completely separated from escorting, because many strippers will offer an escort service.v

The dominant argument today of “sex work is work” argues for a differentiation between “sex work” and “sex trafficking.” This idea is to do with the view of consent or “choice” to enter into prostitution as a “sex worker” versus being trafficked or pimped into the sex trade. The main opposition to this is that while individual decisions can be made (ranging from “what would I like to eat for dinner today?” to “do I want sex with this person?”), and not all sex is rape, we must focus on the social conditions that make the sex industry exist in the first place. That is, under imperialism there exists social alienation, homelessness, bills that need to be paid, alongside social expectations, and sexualization and oppression of women. It is necessary to address these presuppositions before starting to discuss what is possibly sexual exploitation.

The other half of the “sex work is work” argument that I’ve heard is that proletarian work is exploitative, and so is prostitution therefore both are work. However, there is a difference between exploitation and “exploitative” with regard to proletarian labour. Marx describes the relationship:

“The capitalist buys labour-power in order to use it; and labour-power in use is labour itself. The purchaser of labour-power consumes it by setting the seller of it to work.”vi

Labour power here means the capacity to do work, which is what is actually sold for a wage. Marx then continues to describe the relationship of use value in the process of production:

“Though a use-value, in the form of a product, issues from the labour-process, yet other use-values, products of previous labour, enter into it as means of production. The same use-value is both the product of a previous process, and a means of production in a later process. Products are therefore not only results, but also essential conditions of labour.”

A very important condition here is the production of commodities. Marx later details that there can be proletarians who do not produce themselves, but are involved in the selling or valorization of commodity. But a relationship to production or valorization of commodity is integral to proletarian labour. Prostitutes do not produce a physical commodity, and describing the prostitute’s body as a commodity that can be exchanged is not a valid argument towards the prostitute being a proletarian. If the person themselves is a commodity, then they exist as a slave in relationship to someone else who sells them for a price. In cases where prostitutes are pimped out they can definitely be considered as slaves.

When Marx talks about exploitation he means specifically the undermining of the proletariat’s labour-power, because they do not receive the full-value of the commodities produced at the price that they are sold. That is, the wage a proletarian receives is a piece of the value of the commodity to compensate for the labour-power exchanged, but is not the full value of a commodity despite the proletariat producing it. Fundamentally, the profit is not shared with the worker.

Exploitation for Marxists means a very specific thing. The proletariat is exploited because they work for a wage that is paid to them in exchange for their labour-power, or the capacity to do work. When the proletarian is hired they are producing or valorizing a commodity. The capitalist receives the full selling amount of the commodity and keeps the profits for himself. The proletarian receives in wages only what is enough to keep the proletarian ready and able to continue working.

That prostitution is degrading is undeniable. But these degrading conditions are not comparable to the quality of the work of the proletariat. Returning to the statistics listed earlier, we can see how violent and cruel of an industry it is composed mostly of women who are experiencing homelessness, unemployment, or drug addiction. The average proletarian is not coerced with violence to work, does not face sexual harassment (penetrative sex, oral, otherwise exhibiting their bodies) as an average standard of work. Customers at a retail store, or coworkers on a production line are not entitled to touching workers in unwanted ways. Additionally, workers do suffer injury at work as has been documented extensively.vii However the quality of injury is very different when you look at prostitution. Prostitutes can catch STI’s, experience rape, assault, vaginal and anal tearing, as well as addictions. The PTSD rate among prostitutes is at 67%, and suicide is at 40 times higher than the rest of the population because of the mental impact.viii This aspect of prostitution points at how it is a violent vestige of patriarchy and not an average condition.

Final argument I will address, which is also the easiest to rebuke, is the claim of “prostitution being the oldest trade.” This claim attempts to make prostitution appear trans-historical, as if it has always existed and will always continue to. This quote is sourced from Kipling’s On the City Wall (January 1889) where he discusses an Indian girl and her family resorting to prostitution and claims it is “hereditary” in the East. Aside from the obvious racism, this is also just not true. In Origin of the Family, Engels explains how prostitution emerged with the development of private property:

“With the rise of the inequality of property – already at the upper stage of barbarism, therefore – wage-labor appears sporadically side by side with slave labor, and at the same time, as its necessary correlate, the professional prostitution of free women side by side with the forced surrender of the slave. Thus the heritage which group marriage has bequeathed to civilization is double-edged, just as everything civilization brings forth is double-edged, double-tongued, divided against itself, contradictory: here monogamy, there hetaerism, with its most extreme form, prostitution. For hetaerism is as much a social institution as any other; it continues the old sexual freedom – to the advantage of the men. Actually not merely tolerated, but gaily practiced, by the ruling classes particularly, it is condemned in words. But in reality this condemnation never falls on the men concerned, but only on the women; they are despised and outcast, in order that the unconditional supremacy of men over the female sex may be once more proclaimed as a fundamental law of society.”ix

To sum up this first part, prostitution is cruel and violent and communists do not promote prostitutes to remain as such. Instead, communists must combat the conditions that lead women to prostitution: homelessness, unemployment, and addiction. Simultaneously, the realities of prostitution must be exposed so as to help women escape it and not to promote some valiant idea that prostitution is respectable.

ihttps://www.justice.gc.ca/eng/rp-pr/other-autre/c36fs_fi/

iihttps://justice.canada.ca/eng/rp-pr/jr/rmapi-epmlcp/p1.html

iiihttps://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0096300324004910

ivhttps://www.independent.co.uk/student/news/as-many-as-a-third-of-women-strippers-are-students-trying-to-pay-for-their-education-9158808.html

vhttps://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-f1-sex-worker-stripper-strike-9.7202840

vihttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/ch07.htm

viihttps://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2026/03/13/report-on-conditions-in-the-construction-industry-by-cwio/

viiihttps://www.psychnews.org/pnews/98-10-02/ptsd.html

ixhttps://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/download/pdf/origin_family.pdf