The past two years has seen a resurgence of extra-parliamentary fascism. The movement is still significantly less militant, organised, and widespread compared to the late 2010s. However, it has set up a few large organisations: Nationalist-13, Second Sons (SS), Dominion Society of Canada (DSC), and few exclusively Quebecois organisations like New Alliance.
In the late 2010s, this movement was organised on the basis of largely uninfluential political organisations, but mainly on a military basis. This military component was made up of militias like Soldiers of Odin – broad organisations that drew out a large amount of people with less specialised training to do social services and military actions such as intimidation, organising security for reactionary speakers, and clearing anarchists out of places like Vancouver’s Blood Alley.
The other part was a more specialised and offensive group that would carry out high-profile agitation actions, military drills, and in some cases propaganda-of-the-deed type terrorist actions. Groups that made up this wing included Proud Boys, Atomwaffen Division, and the earlier Heritage Front.
The fascists of today are more isolated. They are militarily organised with groups like SS. However, they do not carry out large public campaigns and are not currently able to organise on a broad scale. Their military wing tends to be more narrow and specialised than it was at the end of the last decade. They had died down as a result of Covid, the federal crack-down on the Ottawa protests, and the ban on Atomwaffen Division and the Proud Boys, but they have begun to carry out public actions again. These actions have been one-off instances of agitation like a march, a flash rally, etc. Where they hold conferences that are publicly announced, they are largely still underground. To attend you need to contact them and be vetted before being invited.
Dominion Society of Canada (DSC) is an organisation whose purpose is to popularise fascism through liberal-democratic means. Through its work, it attempts to move fascism from its present state of semi-openness and narrowness back to its position in the 2010s and beyond that into a force that can form government.
DSC is not a political party. It is a registered non-profit that advocates mass deportations or “remigration”.1 It was founded and is presently-led by ex-People’s Party of Canada executive director Daniel Tyrie.2 It has been noted as having close ties to Jeremy Mackenzie’s former organisation Diagolon and his present organisation – SS.3 The exact nature of these ties is unclear.
It is a common claim among anti-fascists that DSC is a political face or a front for SS. This does not seem likely. There is certainly confirmed overlap in membership.4 DSC has also been noted for providing a SS leader with the membership number 88 (Heil Hitler).5 However, this overlap does not appear to be one-to-one and not all SS members appear to be DSC members.
What is true is that DSC and SS are two organisations with different tasks within the same broad movement. There is mutual support and an unofficial alliance between the two. Many fascist organisations and unaffiliated fascists likely operate within DSC alongside SS. DSC on the other hand advertises actions of the SS while providing minor criticisms. In Tyrie’s most recent episode of Long Live Canada, he talks in a supportive way about the actions of SS on National Truth and Reconciliation Day in Kamloops while criticising their wearing of masks.6
Whether conscious of it or not, SS represents a “truer” integralist faction of the fascist movement while DSC represents a revisionist line.7 The role of a group like DSC is to lay the groundwork for a group like SS should the imperialists need assistance putting down the workers or should they need to reorganise the state under a fascist system of government. DSC itself is not opposed to the way Canada is currently organised on principle while SS is. Tyrie has regularly praised Carney and calls for working through the existing parties.8
While DSC advocates for mass deportations they are much softer than SS. At their convention, a speaker put forward a plan of voluntary deportations over the course of many years. Mackenzie on the other hand has never minced-words about what mass deportations will look like:
“Give me some guys and some weapons and we’ll fucking get rid of them. We’ll take them up. Get in the truck, you’re going to the airport. ‘Make me.’ Okay, bang. Anybody else? Anybody else not want to go to the airport? Who wants to go to the airport? Show of hands, who wants to go to the airport? I only had to shoot one, see? Easy.”9
Or,
“We’re at war with India. We should be bombing India. We should be arresting and quarantining and putting all Indians in fucking camps and then putting them on buses and boats back to India at gunpoint starting yesterday. That’s what should be happening.”10
There is definite overlap between these two organisations in terms of broad aims and membership. In terms of tactics and strategy they are quite different. This does not mean that there is no coordination between them especially at the local level.
Dominion Convention
On August 29, DSC held a convention initially planned for Hamilton.11 After having their venue pull out multiple times, it was moved to Burlington, Ontario.12 The event was the first in what is meant to be an annual convention. The speakers included Restore Britain’s Charlie Downes, Quebec separatist Alexandre Cormier-Denis, White Papers Policy Institute’s Lucy White, DSC leaders Ken Jones and Tyrie, American Renaissance editor Jared Taylor, Fortissax, Generation Identity’s Martin Sellner, and John Carter.13
The federal state attempted to prevent Sellner and Downes from speaking in-person at the convention by delaying their paperwork.14 Downes was able to get through by flying to the USA and entering through Niagara as the paperwork they were waiting on was not required for land travel. This same trick was not possible for Sellner as he had previously been banned from the USA.
Hamilton is the centre of Canada’s fascist movement. Beyond the most visible agitation actions occurring in the city,15 the city police have recorded 332 hate and bias incidents in 2025, 138 of which were criminal.16 It should come as no surprise that it was planned for Hamilton as it allowed for large participation and DSC could rely on the local military groups for protection if necessary.
Anti-Fascist Tactics from the Middle Bourgeoisie and the People
While the big bourgeoisie attempted to interfere with the event, their interference was very minor. It consisted of holding up paperwork and holding Downes at the border for several hours. The middle bourgeoisie of Hamilton were much more involved in trying to shut down the convention.
If fascism serves the bourgeoisie why were they attempting to shut down the conference? First, fascism is a movement required to defend imperialism in times of high-levels of class struggle. There is a rise in struggles at the workplace currently, but these struggles rarely tie into the broader struggle against imperialism remaining economic fights. Fascism is not needed by the bourgeoisie at this moment.
Second, fascism is a movement directed by finance capital – the big bourgeoisie. This explains the split among the bourgeoisie in dealing with the convention. To the big bourgeoisie, represented by the federal state, fascism is more an inconvenience at the moment reflected in their hands-off approach. While the middle bourgeoisie will rally to fascism at times of high class struggle, they will often oppose it when class struggle is at an ebb. This is why they took a much more hands-on approach.
The middle bourgeoisie mounted a public campaign to de-platform the DSC with support from politicians, business and venue owners, and even the police.17 Mayor Horwath sent local businesses a letter encouraging them to research the DSC before accepting a booking.18
While opposing fascism in this instance, the middle bourgeoisie did not want to bring the mass of workers into the struggle. This could risk the workers getting carried away and peeking behind the curtain of “a struggle against racism” and transforming it into a struggle against imperialism broadly. For this reason, they aimed to restrict the campaign to the bourgeoisie. The Hamilton Police were reported as stating:
“Even if officers learn the location, the service does not intend to release it because doing so could attract crowds and increase the risk of a confrontation.”19
This has been a common tactic throughout the history of fascism. Where the masses have aligned with an at least temporarily anti-fascist wing of the bourgeoisie, that wing will aim to prevent the struggle from breaking out among the masses in order to preserve their rule. The most famous example of this is the palace coup against Mussolini in Italy.
Hollow Victory
The inability of DSC to book a venue in Hamilton was portrayed as a victory by the middle bourgeoisie and activists of the city.20 Was it a victory? The event was moved to Burlington, a city just across the bridge from Hamilton. Would we regard it as a victory if an event was forced out of New Westminster to Whalley? Would it be a victory to force an event out of Ottawa into Gatineau? The only thing that was won was a slightly longer commute time for attendees.
Protests were held to coincide with the convention. At the actual venue a small protest of twenty people was held while at Hamilton City Hall a 200-person “victory rally” was held.21 Spring Magazine has noted that activists from Toronto were bused down, past the actual DSC convention protest in Burlington, to the “Victory rally” in Hamilton.22
For A Workers’ Militia!
The minimal programme of the Communist Party of Canada (Red Fraction) calls for:
“Abolition of the bourgeois military and police, formation of a workers’ militia with elected leadership”23
Communists in Canada cannot take a spontaneous attitude towards this question, it must be consciously organised towards. Already, union bureaucrats such as those in BC’s IATSE have issued similar calls to defend IATSE members following anti-trans protests a couple summers back. If we sit back and wait for the workers’ militia to pop into existence, it will be brought under the leadership of the union bureaucracy and social-democrats. Or when the fascists grow to the point that they can launch their own militias again, we will be on the backfoot.
In the Communist International’s military manual Armed Insurrection, they issue a call for all parties to organise semi-military organisations in the period prior to the formation of militias as one of the main ways to confront fascism and the bourgeoisie broadly:
“In a general way, the communist parties must demand the dissolution of these volunteer associations. But while waging a political campaign on these lines, they must simultaneously seek to subvert them from within. Experience shows that a very powerful weapon for this purpose, i.e. a good means of separating out the proletarian elements, consists in creating semi-military proletarian organizations, like the Red Front in Germany. Thus wherever possible communist parties must strive to create organizations of this kind; they must give high priority to work (both political and organizational) designed to subvert the military associations of the bourgeoisie.
“The Red Front in Germany, a mass organization of mixed character (i.e. working class but not purely communist) with over 100,000 members, and containing communist cells within its ranks) is one of the main centres for revolutionary mobilization of the proletarian masses. It serves to detach the latter from the bourgeois reformist National Flag association, influenced by the Social Democrat Party and the Centre. But not only does it seek to inject a revolutionary spirit into the National Flag by creating a left opposition inside it; it also wages a political struggle against reaction in general, particularly as manifested in the activity of the bourgeois-monarchist military associations (Steel Helmets, etc.). The Red Front also carries out propaganda against new imperialist wars, and against the idea of a war against the USSR.”24
These organisations are not only useful for preventing the growth of fascist militias. They also function as organisations through which the workers can be organised to defend pickets and marches, prevent evictions, among other actions. They educate the workers on a broad scale on their military doctrine – people’s war, questions of strategy like street fighting, and on practical issues. Finally, they can broaden our ability to conduct agitation and propaganda among the workers. When they are not concentrated for an action, they can be dispersed among the various factories, warehouses, and other worksites.
These organisations were widespread in the late 2010s – the Peacebearers, the IWW General Defence Committees, the Against Fascism collectives, and the PCR-RCP’s direct work in Montreal and Vancouver. A summation of this period must be made so that new communist-led organisations of this type can be formed on the basis of what was best in the anti-fascist movement’s last wave.
1https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/what-is-the-dominion-society-9.7315829
2Ibid.
3Ibid.
4Ibid.
5Ibid.
6https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ai22Ngk8ELY
7More on this diistinction can be found in the article Social-Fascism and the “American Communist Party”
8https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ai22Ngk8ELY
9https://www.antihate.ca/white_nationalism_in_canada_organized_emboldened_and_growing
10https://www.sudbury.com/local-news/group-tagged-far-right-by-officials-sees-wahnapitae-event-cancelled-9231262
11https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/what-is-the-dominion-society-9.7315829
12https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/rally-hope-not-hate-dominion-society-9.7325522
13https://www.youtube.com/@DominionSoc
14https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/rally-hope-not-hate-dominion-society-9.7325522
15https://www.antihate.ca/mass_deportations_protest_remarkably_similar_australian_neo_nazi_protests
16https://nowtoronto.com/news/domcon-hamilton-nationalist-conference-police-mayor-speak-out/
17https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/what-is-the-dominion-society-9.7315829
18https://nowtoronto.com/news/domcon-hamilton-nationalist-conference-police-mayor-speak-out/
19Ibid.
20https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/hamilton/rally-hope-not-hate-dominion-society-9.7325522
21https://www.thespec.com/news/hamilton-region/domcon-met-with-protests-in-burlington-hamilton/article_08cda7a3-9f38-56e5-88a5-2daab794d32f.html
22https://springmag.ca/hope-not-hate-hamiltons-community-response-to-white-supremacist-violence
23https://peopleshammer.wordpress.com/2024/08/24/announcement-of-the-founding-of-the-communist-party-of-canada-red-fraction/
24https://files.libcom.org/files/A.%20Neuberg%20-%20Armed%20Insurrection%20(1926).pdf