We are pleased to present this interview with Fred Engst on his experience during the Great Proletarian Cultural Revolution and the lessons for us today.
We will release this interview in three parts over the next few weeks.
– Editorial Board of The People’s Hammer
Q: Do you want to introduce yourself?
A: My parents came to China after WWII. My father came first because he met my uncle – my mother’s brother in Cornell through my aunt Jean who was a CPUSA [Communist Party of the United States of America] member who would talk a lot about what was going on in the world and introduced them to Red Star over China.
My father went to Cornell because he wanted to learn how to be a dairy farmer. He didn’t finish college, he just went farming. Then WWII was going on, so he finally decided to join the army. So, he sold his farm. He wanted to join the army to fight fascists. When he sold his farm, the war was over, so he wasn’t ready to go back to farming again. He read Red Star over China and wanted to go to China to take a look. He got a job with the United Nations relief programme and came to China in Spring 1946.
My mother was a nuclear physicist, she was all into science. When she found out what she was working on turned out to be a [weapon of] mass destruction. They were under the impression that they were making a bomb before Hitler could, so it would be used as a deterrent. They never though it would be used in reality. That was devastating for her.
She was not ready to come to China when my father came. My father had a crush on her, but she was not interested in romance in those days. Before they split, they made a deal. My father’s version was that “after a few years, I’ll come back and we can get married.” My mother’s version was that “well, when you come back in a few years, let’s talk about it.” My mother was not eager in going to China anyway. Instead she went to the University of Chicago to continue her education. After a year or second year, she discovered her scholarship had come from the navy. That was most devastating for her. She realized you can’t pretend you are doing just science and don’t have to think about what you are doing to humanity. Her conscience wouldn’t let her to continue those studies. She decided to leave and come to China. She came here the summer of ‘48, but it took her a whole year before she was able to meet up with my dad. They got married in Yan’an, that’s how I was raised in China.
My birth caused trouble for her. The US didn’t know where she was until I was born when she was at a peace conference in Beijing. She happened to have lunch with a group from Japan. She told the people at the table about her experience. They said “that’s an amazing story, you need to talk about it at the conference.” So, they scheduled a part of the conference for her to talk about her experience. She asked the scientists around the world to think about how the science is going to be applied. Is it going to serve humanity or the war machine? After that the news went back to the US. People said “wow, this nuclear physicist went to China.” All kinds of rumors. Less respected journals made up stories about how my mother was part of the Chinese nuclear programme, took Mao’s private plane, flew from Inner Mongolia to Beijing. Just a laughable story. As a consequence, when my uncle decided to go back to China in ‘53, all his notes were confiscated. They knew where he was coming in, they followed all the mail they even had a subpoena for my mother to appear before the Un-American Affairs Committees during the McCarthy period. There was a lot of stuff in the ‘50s and ‘60s.
I was born in Beijing, but raised on a state farm in Xi’an. Our family was asked to leave in ‘66 and come to Beijing just before the Cultural Revolution started. I came to Beijing and became part of the Red Guards and traveled around the country by foot. Actually, I took the train to the place where my cousin and her classmates walked from Beijing to this coal mining town in Yangquan (阳泉) We stayed there for a few months. Then in spring of ‘67 after Chinese New Year, the Party asked us to go back to school and make revolution. I wasn’t satisfied and ready to go straight back, so I worked with my cousin and some other college students. We took the train most of the way to Beijing and got out at a town that took us a week to walk back from.
Then, the Cultural Revolution continued, most of my classmates went to the countryside after ‘68. I wanted to go with them, but turns out my nose is too big, so instead I was assigned a job in the city in a woodworking factory in Beijing. I stayed there for five years. Of course, in ‘71, the US-China relationship became more normal. First Kissinger visited, then Nixon visited. I got an intense curiosity, so I decided to visit the US and see what it’s like. In China, they always say I’m American. In America, I blend in until I open my mouth and they say “where are you from?” No escape.
I stayed about thirty some years in the US. Half the time I worked in the factories and various jobs. In the early ‘80s, I found I wasn’t prepared to address all kinds of questions with the the turmoil in China – the reform. I decided I wanted to go to college, but I was working. So, I worked full-time and studied part-time. It took me seven years to finish. I took every course I could find on economics. It was funny, one professor said “If you’re so interested in economics, why don’t you go to graduate school.” I had never thought about that. So, I went to graduate school and spent another nine years. College and graduate school were not able to fully resolve the confusion I had.
The ‘80s and ‘90s were pretty tough around the world. It was the low-point of the communist movement. The saying was that it was the end of history. I needed to figure out what happened and how it happened. It took me many years. In the ‘90s, things started slowly to make sense. One thing is that a lot of the state-owned industry workers got laid off, US war in Iraq the first wave, in 2000 there was the second war. Imperialism did not change. Everything the Cultural Revolution tried to prevent turned out to be true. The Cultural Revolution was being validated.
So, I decided I needed to figure out what happened in China and why things happened this way. By 2006, my kids were grown and I was free to decide where to stay. I decided to go back to China in 2007. It has been the greatest experience of my life.
Q: You mentioned you were in Beijing from 1966-
A: 1974, eight years.
Q: Could you briefly go over what you did as a Red Guard and as a factory worker?
A: When the Cultural Revolution started, I was only fourteen. I didn’t finish my seventh grade. I was in school in Xi’an for my seventh grade. The Cultural Revolution began in summer of ‘66, so we didn’t even have our final exam. Then, my family moved to Beijing in the Spring of ‘66. I didn’t want to go to Beijing because I had spent my first years of elementary school in Beijing. So, I had lost all my curiosity about big cities. I had been there in big cities, but I love farms. I didn’t want to go to Beijing, I stayed in Xi’an.
When the Cultural Revolution began, the school stopped. All my classmates went around different places and I went back to the farm. Because I was staying in a dorm in the boarding school in Xi’an. I went back to the farm and did nothing. All my friends they were busy doing stuff like taking care of family or doing some work to earn some money or something. No one was playing with me, so I decided to go to the farm’s team leader and said “give me a job.” That was after two weeks of doing nothing I decided that’s too boring I need to do something. The guy assigned me to do some work with old ladies and old men husking the corn in the corn field. It was really hot. It’s work in the hot summer. The sun is beating on you and you’re going through this cornfield. There’s no wind and if you wear short sleeves the leaves will cut you – it’s terrible! You have to wear long sleeves. However, I was really happy because I was with these people and they argue and discuss things. I was part of the life in the village.
When I look back, it was horrendous what was going on there because this work team sent by the party upper level was terrible. They came to the farm and had this idea that you are guilty until you prove your innocence. Embezzlement that was part of the movement before the Cultural Revolution – the Socialist Education Movement. What they were doing was following the line by Liu Shaoqi’s wife who made this Taoyuan Experience. Have you heard of the Taoyuan Experience? Its terrible! It’s not relying at all on the masses, believing in the masses. It was rather very much top-down. It was very ultra-left. It was a very left cover but was not dealing with how the farm was running: is it going on a capitalist road or a socialist road? Instead they focused on embezzlement.
I went to a big meeting it was scary. The meeting was condemning, denouncing the accountant of the farm accusing him of embezzling money. And how they accuse you of embezzlement was if you raise watermelon, then each acre or field how many watermelon plants can you plant normally? For each watermelon plant, how many should they normally grow? For each one that grows normally they should be of what size? Then they estimate the yield, but the actual yield is so different. So that must be embezzlement! Just based on that.
Its pretty much what we call “white terror.” The workers and farm managers were under this terror by the work teams. The farm workers had to send notes to the city twice a day. The head work team was from a factory in the city. So they all went to the factory with all kinds of big-character posters denouncing this guy as a capitalist roader. So, they copied down and came back to the farm and secretly wrote down these big-character posters and put them up on the front door of the cafeteria. The next day in the morning everybody on the farm went to the cafeteria to get their food. Some people cook on their own, but a lot of young people went to the cafeteria. All hell broke loose with all the high pressure on the farm workers. They just went “Wait, you are the capitalist roaders!” So the work team had to withdraw and left the farm. So, the Cultural Revolution was a liberating experience for the farm workers and management teams. I went through that experience and it was just incredible.
My parents went to Beijing city. They didn’t want to go to Beijing city, they wanted to stay in agriculture. But, the leadership was trying to convince them to move to Beijing. They resisted and resisted. But ultimately, you have to obey the directive of the leadership, so they said “Okay, we will do it, but on one condition. We don’t want to live in the Friendship Hotel where all the foreigners live.” So, they went to Beijing. Instead of living in the Friendship Hotel, they were living in an even fancier hotel. Since my parents came to China in the ‘40s, they had always been with the ordinary farmers, ordinary workers and cadres. They were used to that kind of life. So in Beijing there is this hierarchical privilege and they had a hard time getting used to it. First, your day is very different now that you have the shower, the bath, the toilet and everything. You don’t have to go to the outhouse. But after a few days, it’s just like what are we doing here?
It was worse for my brother and sister. They went to elementary school on the farm. On the farm, you go home every day. You go to school in the same village. In school you learn and after school you play. When they went to this city, privileged, boarding school, you were only allowed to go home once per week. You also have to study morning and night. They couldn’t stand it. My sister in fact was mentally disturbed, she was throwing things, hitting things, spitting at things – just uncontrollable. That was in April and May of ‘66.
My parents were just so frustrated and said “we’ve got to move out of this place.” So, they moved out to live with my uncle’s ex-wife and my cousin’s family there. Then, the Cultural Revolution started. With all kinds of big-character posters around the city denouncing this, denouncing that. My mother said “we need to write a big-character poster denouncing the way foreigners are being treated!” So, she mobilized my dad and my cousin’s mother – my uncle’s ex-wife and another woman from the US named Ann Tompkins. The four of them wrote a big-character poster. Actually, they just wrote a letter sent to the central committee of the party and the foreign experts bureau. The foreign experts bureau also had rebels and they had conservatives. They broke up into two factions, so the people there copied the letters and posted them in front of the Friendship Hotel where the foreign experts bureau is located. North of the Friendship Hotel is the People’s University – one of the elite universities of Beijing. South of the Friendship hotel is the industrial college.
This was in August when all these Red Guard movements broke out. Red Guards were traveling all over the country to different cities and a lot of them came to Beijing. They just took over classrooms and office buildings. They put straws on the floor and slept on the floor.
Renmindaxue – the People’s University was filled with students from around the country. All people did in those days was read big-character posters, write big-character posters, copy them. News spread from one to another. So, everyone was interested into the big-character poster my parents – the four of them wrote. So, very soon “four foreigners wrote a big-character poster” spread all over China. What’s amazing is that was more than a half century ago without internet. It was a form of social network, it’s a social media – its spontaneous. So, everyone can read, everyone can write, everyone can forward. How they could forward was the Red Guards copied it then went back to their hometown in Shanghai and Guangzhou, and Chongqing and Xi’an. So everyone copied each other’s.
I was still on the farm. One day the worker who sent milk to the city came back and said “Fred, your parents wrote a big-character poster.” I was so proud, but I didn’t know what they wrote. The posters then reached to Mao’s desk. Mao read it on September 8th and he was so excited. Of course, I wasn’t there – how did I know he was excited? He wrote “I agree with this big-character poster. All revolutionary foreigners and their children should be treated absolutely like the Chinese. Not permitted to be different.” (完全一样,不许两样). That was the directive given to Zhou Enlai and Chen Yi and a few other central committee members in charge of foreign affairs. Then, I don’t know if five seconds, five minutes, five hours later, he decided maybe this is too absolute. He changed the period to a comma: “all those who want to be treated like this should be treated like this.” First it was no difference – absolutely the same, then it was only if they want to be. So, you can see he was processing – thinking about it. After that, of course all the foreigners were allowed to be part of the Cultural Revolution.
Later on, the Cultural Revolution became more and more factional fighting among the workers and peasants. So, factional fighting broke out across the country. In the beginning it was mostly between conservatives and rebels about factory leadership, city leadership, provincial leadership, school leadership. Then, pretty soon the conservatives folded because the Cultural Revolution’s target was the people in leadership on the capitalist road. Criticizing people in leadership is totally justified. So, criticizing leadership is not anti-socialism, it’s not anti-party. So, the conservatives just folded. So, then it became arguments between the rebels and what they were fighting over was who should be the leadership.
Shanghai was the first one where they took over leadership of the city – the workers took over, but that was in a very interesting circumstance because the leadership of the city basically just abandoned their job. So, the workers just walked into the office and took over. There was no fight over there. But in other cities and provinces and factories and schools and farms…
So, they argued about who should take over. So, factional fighting was getting stronger and stronger and lasted quite a few years. That’s where all the chaos came from. Some of these fights became quite violent.
I came to Beijing in late – I can’t remember if it was before October 1st or after October 1st. Anyways it was around then and those days it was still mostly a struggle between the conservatives and the rebels. By the time I went to the coal mining town then soon the rebels won over the masses. When people are allowed to speak up all kind of crazy things happen. You can see that with today’s social media when people argue, people curse, and people do all kinds of things, right, so factionalism is very pervasive. I came back to the city in the spring of ‘67 and then went to the factory ‘69. In that year and a half my school was also students broken up into factions with people arguing and debating, but at least there was no violence in the school, and not too much violence actually in Beijing. The coal mining town that we left, later on they did break out into a lot of violent fights and the factional clash lasted quite long in Shanxi province and didn’t stop until almost the fall of ‘69 after the 9th Party Congress.
In many other places the violent clash between the working class in the ranks, factories, or farms were quite chaotic actually. That was a part of the experience of the Cultural Revolution and what you hear today all they talk about is this chaos and violent struggle and denounce the Cultural Revolution. My answer is well, do you forbid people to speak up or not? If you want people to speak up you’ve got to face the question of factionalism. So you cannot throw the baby out with the bath water, you have to find a solution of how to defend people’s right to speak up and how to prevent that escalating into factional fighting and violent struggle.
That’s the thing, you can’t just say because of all these violent fights the Cultural Revolution was terrible. But actually in retrospect it’s the first time in human history you have millions of people participating in trying to figure out how to be masters of society. It was the most long lasting, most thorough going, most comprehensive. There is no parallel in human history. I just find it so weird, it took me a long time to think through all this because in the 80’s and 90’s there were all these condemnations of the Cultural Revolution and I didn’t understand why. They had all kinds of horror stories and those horror stories don’t change my view of the Cultural Revolution because I saw how people feel and how people act and how people conduct themselves in the Cultural Revolution and its a liberating experience for the workers, for students, for the peasants.
In the West they always talk about we’re struggling for democracy but here, that is real democracy! So when I went to the US in ‘74 I went to a steel factory and the boss told me “You want democracy? You go outside of the factory floor. I’m the boss here. I hire you for your muscle, not for your brain, so don’t tell me how to run the factory.”