The People's Hammer

Prostitution Part 2: The F1 Race and the Stripper Strike – By Bessy

, , ,


This article came about as a reflection on the “sex strike” called upon by strippers in Montreal.i The “sex strike” was timed to coincide with the F1 racing weekend. The action was aimed at getting as many strippers as possible to not come to their clubs. The principal call by the organizers was to improve the working conditions being that strippers are considered “independent contractors” and therefore do not have a steady schedule, have to pay cover fees to a club, not being paid for dances on stage, and having to face sexual harassment at work. The secondary call by the organizers was regarding total decriminalization in order to receive labour protections.

The class position of escorts can vary, depending on if they are being pimped out or if they work for themselves. For strippers, it is predominantly a petit-bourgeois occupation because other than the cover they need to pay to a club, which is a one time fee to perform, they receive the full payment amount. A similar but different example is artists who vend at craft markets have to pay a cover for the table but essentially set the prices and receive the full amount of the selling value to themselves. The article expresses the complaint of strippers having to pay out the club and bouncers, but this is not the same as being exploited for a wage but rather a system of having to pay expenses. Any business owner has to pay expenses whether that’s rent for their brick and mortar store, online domain fees, advertizing, labour costs, etc before they can collect the profits. Complaining about not receiving the full amount for dances in this case is complaining about the cost of business, not about class exploitation.

Regarding regularization of strippers work, in any other industry it would be a legitimate demand of the petite bourgeoisie who have non-steady work, or work that is not guaranteed all the time. For strip clubs as was mentioned with prostitution in general it is a vestige of patriarchy where women are sexualized and degraded. If most of the strippers and escorts are women, and most of the customers for this are men, these women become sexual objects to cater to sexual desires of men rather than being seen as a social being in equal position to them. Strippers or escorts sometimes say that “this customer is really nice” or that they don’t accept a kink or violent customers. However, this doesn’t erase the fact that by nature of the industry the women’s body is still up for being sexualized and objectified. This is not something to support because strengthening these institutions does not lead to the reduction of oppression of women.

Regarding decriminalization and labour protections. The legal system as mentioned in the first part of this article decriminalized prostitutes and allows them to sell and advertize their services individually. The concern that the strippers raised in the article on the “sex strike” being that they face sexual harassment during their shifts is legitimate. There is a pathway to report this harassment to police at this time. However, incorporating strippers and escorts into the labour code through decriminalization will not resolve the issue itself. The nature of prostitution and stripping is manifested through some of the last vestiges of patriarchy. Incorporating strippers into the labour code will provide them with an added level of bureaucracy, where strippers will be able to appeal to a human resources person or department, or file a labour board complaint. But in actuality proletarian women who experience sexual harassment at work often do not see these as useful resources, and are often left to their own to address workplace harassment anyway. It is no secret to anyone that HR exists to defend the company, and despite the sexual harassment training that some workplaces receive this is not to protect individual workers from harassment, but rather an insurance clause for the company. In past discussions with women workers on experiences of sexual harassment most chose to either leave their job, stand up for each other against individual harassers, or bear the experience and continue working there. This is not to be brushed off either and must be an active task of communists in combatting.

The decriminalization call extends beyond the realm of the “sex strike” to other non-profits and groups calling for this demand. I will focus on one group in Vancouver as an example of this line. For groups like SWAN, much of the work they do is promote the sexual health of prostitutes in massage parlours which is good in that it limits the spread of infectious diseases like HIV. On the other hand, nonprofits have a political wing that does some lobbying. Here is SWAN in their own words:

“SWAN supports the full decriminalization of sex work.

SWAN advocates for the sex work sector to have the labour rights and protections as other sectors.

Canada’s Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act (PCEPA) criminalizes the sex industry(1). PCEPA increases sex work stigma and creates unsafe working conditions by impeding im/migrant sex workers from reporting violence, violating their basic human rights, and preventing them from accessing labour and legal protections.

Migrant sex workers experience multi-layered criminalization. The Immigration and Refugee Protection (IRPR) Regulations prohibit temporary residents in Canada from engaging in sex work(2). In combination with PCEPA, IRPR creates disproportionate vulnerabilities to systemic violence and barriers to reporting violence for migrant sex workers.

SWAN advocates for the full decriminalization of sex work, i.e. decriminalization that includes migrant sex workers. [my emphasis]”ii

The call for decriminalization here starts with the intent of protecting or providing freedoms for control and agency by prostitutes. From a different argument explaining why to decriminalize:

“The third approach is decriminalization, which removes all laws and regulations that criminalize or penalize sex work, including its sale, purchase, advertisement and involvement of third parties such as managers and brothel keepers. This framework allows sex workers to retain agency and control over their work.”iii

However good as the intent is we have to ask what are the consequences and material implications of decriminalization under imperialism?

Full decriminalization would allow for pimps and brothels to be run. Prostitution right now is legal in Canada which means that you can’t be arrested as a prostitute for advertizing your services or doing your services. Advocates for decriminalization attempt to shoehorn increased oppression of women by allowing the illegal bourgeoisie to flourish. The prostitution industry exists as an illegal industry with a bourgeoisie that profits off of prostitution, among other things like the drug trade. Decriminalizing pimps and brothels would make it possible for this industry to expand without backlash from the state bourgeoisie as it is right now with the police being able to arrest pimps and sex traffickers.

While there is truth to SWAN claiming that the laws around immigration and refugee protections leave people vulnerable, it is a whole other claim to demand for sex trafficking to be decriminalized for migrant women who are already in a vulnerable position. Rather than demanding to decriminalize migrant prostitution we should be addressing the conditions (employment, language, economic security) of our immigration system that leave women vulnerable enough to enter into prostitution in the first place.

China as an example

Article 6 of the common programme of the CPC stated the aim to abolish the feudal system that keeps women in slavery.iv The practical approach was uneven across the country. On January 1949 all brothels were ordered to shut down. Some cities followed orders quicker, and others did not take abolition orders until a few years later. In Shanghai, the government registered all prostitutes and brothels, and continued compulsory medical examinations.v The government banned soliciting in the streets and conducted a survey on prostitution.vi The government took on a policy of discouraging prostitutes and encouraged measures for them to learn a productive craft. Secret societies, teahouses, and other bars could no longer hire prostitutes and dancers.vii The local courts adopted a regulation that forbade brothel owners and madams from demanding money as compensation.viii

The culture also changed as a response, and the men who procured prostitutes before were diminishing. There were active education programs taught by women to encourage literacy and learning a trade, and the government followed up with the prostitutes to make sure that they were maintaining their trade and not backsliding.

All of these measures were taken alongside the construction of socialism in China, so it is hard to compare. However, prostitution in China was widespread and the government managed to diminish it not by decriminalizing and encouraging prostitutes to continue, but by redirecting women towards productive trades and education. If unemployment and homelessness are the main factors driving women to prostitution as mentioned in the first article, then the answer should be to increase training programs and pathways to full and stable employment. The issue of resolving patriarchy under capitalism may not be fully abolished until a socialist revolution, but the outcomes of disparity among women leading to prostitution can be reduced by involving women in production.

ihttps://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/montreal-f1-sex-worker-stripper-strike-9.7202840

iihttps://swanvancouver.ca/who-we-are/#team

iiihttps://theconversation.com/sex-work-on-trial-what-the-recently-dismissed-constitutional-challenge-means-267163

iv Henriot, Christian. “ ‘La Fermeture’: The Abolition of Prostitution in Shanghai, 1949-58.” The China Quarterly, no. 142, 1995, pp. 467-486.

vIbid.

viIbid.

viiIbid.

viiiIbid.