Q: You were a worker in China for five years and you were a worker for 20 years in America
A: Not quite, I went to US in ‘74 and the factory I was working in went bankrupt so I got laid off in ‘86. In ‘86 the factory closed and I took another year to finish my college course. So you can say 12 years, ‘74 to ‘86. Then I went to graduate school and became white collar. While I was going to graduate school the first two years I had TA and then I was working part time in an AT&T for six years. Then I spent two years finishing my dissertation, I do everything slow. Everything took me a long time to figure out anyway. So I’m a slow learner and just have to work harder.
Q: How would you compare your experience working in China versus the US?
A: Unlike a lot of people in China who describe it as a frog in a pot and the heat is getting hotter and hotter, by the time you can’t stand it, it’s too late. For me, I just jumped into the hottest pot right away. The contrast can’t be any more startling. I came back [to China] in ‘77 and I was telling my colleagues and friends about my experience working in the US, all they cared about those days was how much you made. And of course I made so much more than when I was in China. In China for the five years, the first year I got 16 yuan per month, next year I got 18 yuan, then I got promoted to the first grade which was 33, and then 4th and 5th year I was getting second grade, which was 38 yuan and 61 cents. I don’t know how they compute it. That was equivalent to one hour of work when I was working in the steel mill in the US nominally. It was six dollars an hour, that was a lot of money those days.
In ‘76 I was earning 6 dollars an hour then I found out they took one third taxes so net only of four dollars, but even then there’s no comparison to the standard of living. China was really a backward and barely moved out of agricultural society, 80% of people were working in the field to feed the rest of the 20% of the population. It was in early stages of industrialization, however by the time I left in ‘74 almost every province could make trucks. Well, the quality might not be the best, little bit exaggerating, every truck they sold, they had to send a person to fix it on the away. But they had something they can fix, they can improve on.
So those five years working in China contrast to the years I worked in the US. At the beginning, most people would just think about how much you make, which it was just at a very different stage of development. What strikes me is the atmosphere. All these five years working in Beijing in a factory I never had a fear of people in management. Really you were equal. The relationship among the workers, I mean it was my best time, most memorable. In fact in ‘77 when I came back when I got laid off from the steel mill so I decided to come back to China and of course the living standard was very different, working 8 months in the steel mill I was able to buy a ticket to China and I had bought my first car. You cannot do that in China.
I came back and I missed that life so much. I spent four months in China and I spent three months just back at the factory working with my colleagues every day. I don’t remember if they gave me a wage or not. I didn’t care much about that wage. But I loved that atmosphere, the people were joking and working, talking, and very much relaxed. You know, humans like to move. If you find somebody who’s so called lazy, they are not motivated. You’ve got to find out why they are not motivated. People love to be active, people are not like pigs just eat and sleep, eat and sleep. There were some unenthusiastic workers but they were far and few between. Most workers, in my experience, would finish their job and go help somebody else. Because, once you finish your job, when you work with other people on your job you can talk and joke around then when you finish and some other people are still working you go there and help them and talk to them. The nature of the job is not assembly, you do a batch and a batch and then you have time in between, 10 minutes, 20 minutes, so some people go to the smoke room, because we were a wood working factory so you were not allowed to smoke in the shop. So you can go to the smoke room, and I had second hand smoking experience for 5 years, and the people how do you say it in the US, shoot the shit, and just talking and a lot of great experience there I remember.
I can’t remember a moment some big shot comes in and people get nervous. Instead the workers, quite often, they teased these people in leadership. If our upper manager walked though the shop “Ooh you are coming here to be part of the masses! I have not seen you for a long time!” People always gave leadership a hard time.
In fact that’s how I learned to tease other people so when I came to the US and I teased one of my friends he said “you learned that from the Red Guards right!” It was like teasing but not picking at people it was critique, it was sort of a bad habit because not everyone enjoyed that, being teased right. But teasing the leadership was common. That’s not imaginable [in the US] how could- could you imagine in the US teasing the foreman? Teasing! You’re out of your mind! You’re suicidal! But that’s what we’d do.
So if you were unhappy with factory management of various levels you could just speak to their face and things you can resolve, and write big character posters, or you can form a meeting and raise that issue up. So it all depends on if your grievance is only personal, individual, and doesn’t really have support of a lot of other workers then maybe the manager says “well, you’re wrong.” But if a lot of people consent and agree with you then the leadership has to do something about it. Worst comes to worst you have some complaint of leadership and they’re treating you badly or doing something wrong, you live in the same neighborhood. I curse you in the factory and you don’t do anything about it, I go home, I go to the front of your house and I curse you right in the front of your house in front of your kids. I mean that is the power of the supervision by the masses.
I had one quite telling experience in the early 70’s there were some workers who were in the second grade or third grade for a long time and have not had a promotion. I forgot maybe its 45% maybe 25%, maybe 30% can have a promotion and a raise up one grade. Who’s on the list who needs to be promoted needs to be discussed among the workers. In our department we had maybe 5 or 10, I can’t remember how many were qualified. Of that 5 or 10 only 3 or 4 can be promoted. We had a meeting and people had discussion. I was not qualified for promotion because I had just been promoted to my second grade. In our meeting we had most people are not part of this qualifying group, maybe 1 or 2 were qualified. So we had discussions and I found it so fascinating that the workers decide about who is qualified. Basically your performance and your behaviour from the last few years is how people judge. If we have 2 out of 5 need to be promoted, and if all these years you’ve been very active, energetic and uplifting type of person then you most likely will get promoted. If you were being always passive, demoralized, unenthusiastic, and complain then people might say “well, why promote you?”
However, some of these people who are not good workers and who didn’t get a promotion last time, but they have many kids and the family is in a bad economic position, then the workers will say “well I mean you are not a good worker but your children should not be punished.” So they are so reasonable, so reasonable. It was so moving.
The list that we discussed will need to be approved by the leadership. So leadership will make some adjustments and if that adjustment is so different than what workers approved, the leadership cannot lead anything. It lost ability to lead. Because if workers think somebody deserve and you don’t promote them, and instead you promote someone who the workers feel doesn’t deserve it, well what happens? You ask some workers to do some job and they say “don’t ask me, that guy he was the good worker you promoted let him do it.” I mean they will just have spontaneous slow downs. So you can complain workers are being lazy, its not if what’s been happening is unjust, its unfair. So the least they can do is just doing a slowdown, not quite strike. That’s the power of the Iron Rice Bowl. Job guaranteed. When you have a guaranteed job you’re not afraid of people in leadership. That is such a powerful tool that workers can use. Of course the experience of the Cultural Revolution provides something even more powerful which is the organizations that workers can form themselves.
The people in factory leadership of course they have to keep in the back of their mind “When I do this and walk around the shop what are the workers going to say?” Individual worker complaint is one level of concern, when organized workers are complaining that will be a different story.
That’s why the spontaneous, semi-autonomous workers organizations are the most powerful check on the leadership. The issue is how to prevent these workers spontaneous organizations with others that have different opinion and escalating the arguments into violent fights. That’s something that needs to be learned in future working class movements. How to prevent factionalism that splits and destroys working class power. When I talk to Trotskyists they say “Just arm the working class.” I say “yeah, the Chinese working class was armed fighting each other killing each other in some places.” Don’t think about these simple solutions, they say democracy, well yeah what happens when workers in factories they’re fighting each other and you can’t come to a consensus.
The experience working in the US was so so different and I don’t need to tell you too much about it, because people in the West know what it’s like to work in the factory. In Chinese they say after reform (大锅饭养懒汉) – Iron rice bowl breeds lazy workers – I was so offended by that because that’s just the opposite to my experience working in China and working in the US. All my years working in China I don’t remember of people thinking of ways of slacking off. They will do slowdowns because they’re protesting against the leadership. But slacking off is when you pretend you’re working but you’re not. I don’t recall instances of that kind in China. I never learned that kind of stuff. That’s a skill, I learned that in the US. I learned that at my job at the steel mill on the first day. I fooled them I told them I was an electrician in China for five years because they can’t find out. But I do know something about electricity because during the Cultural Revolution I actually made an electrical motor with scrap and everything. So I knew something about electricity and they hired me. On the first day on the job the foreman assigned me and other coworkers to fix this big motor hoist. I was so eager to show the boss that I’m a good worker and before he finished his sentence I pulled out my wrench and started taking the motor apart and then the foreman walked away and another worker grabbed me and said “What’s the hurry? Take it easy.” He told me “you know what? You were the last person hired and on this job we have a union and the union can’t decide who gets hired but for who gets laid off goes by seniority. And if you work so hard the foreman will find out they don’t need that many workers and you will be the first one they let go.” Later on I was working in a rail car company making these subway cars and Amtrack trains and I met colleagues who showed me all kinds of tricks of how to pretend you’re working really hard and nothing gets done.